6 ms·
> the dinosaurs of finance adopting it 10 years too late The monoliths of finance will set the legislation that will determine everything about crypto-currenci
by adventured 9y ago
> the dinosaurs of finance adopting it 10 years too late
The monoliths of finance will set the legislation that will determine everything about crypto-currencies in all major economies. And if their extreme political power isn't enough, they already by far own the most patents relating to blockchain tech.
Bitcoin + Ethereum = $58 billion.
JP Morgan = $330 billion. That's one "dinosaur" with $25 billion per year in net income.
The notion that they're dinosaurs and they're ten years late, is laughable. Along with all the other banks and central banks, they'll dictate the terms by which crypto-currencies will exist (the only alternative to being controlled by the banksters that control everything related to finance, is to remain a niche that never goes big / mainstream).
- corporateslave2 9y agoWhy do you say they will dictate the terms? They will own the mining? The whole point of bitcoin is decentralization (unless some large entity owns mining majority).
- omarchowdhury 9y agoYou don't think they can create their own distributed ledger?
- corporateslave2 9y agoOh I see. Bank/corporation owned currency is a weird concept....
- omarchowdhury 9y agoWhat do you mean? Obviously if they can create their own blockchain they can issue their own currency, too. It's just a book of who has how much.
- campbelltown 9y agoBlockchains only improve the efficiency of permissionless system. If you're going to create an in-house currency, it would be idiotic to use something as un-scalable as a blockchain.
- omarchowdhury 9y agoWhat makes Bitcoin, not an in house currency, also not idiotic in your case?
- campbelltown 9y agoPermissionless ownership.
- omarchowdhury 9y agoInstead here your gatekeepers are speculators and miners and early adopters.
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoThe 'gatekeepers' are anyone who has bitcoin.
- campbelltown 9y agoEven further, there are no gatekeepers...
- c0nducktr 9y agoIt sounds like something you'd find in a cyberpunk novel.
- rtpg 9y agoThe cynical example: - People live in countries - countries levy taxes to be paid in "real money" - banks deal with the "real money" - BTC exchanges have to work with these banks + gov't
- kneel 9y agoThis assumes that future commerce will always revert back to 'real money'.
- palunon 9y agoCommerce is irrelevant. At the end of the day, you need to pay your taxes - presumably in your national currency. Suppose you had a commerce that only accepted bitcoins. How will you pay your taxes ?
- polyomino 9y agoa good thought experiment. I think it's likely that the government forms a symbiotic relationship with Bitcoin if things get that far. If the public does not want national currencies, then governments need to make them wanted. Physical force is an obvious approach, but probably impractical.
- Frogolocalypse 9y ago> (unless some large entity owns mining majority). Without control of the nodes, the mining hashpower is only a secondary concern. If the miners ever tried to enforce their will, the nodes would simply change the PoW algorithm, and the miners would effectively be out of work.
- Frogolocalypse 9y ago> The monoliths of finance will set the legislation that will determine everything about crypto-currencies in all major economies. As it turns, they won't. Or, more to the point, can't. Bitcoin didn't 'ask' for permission for anything, because permission isn't required to do math. There seems to be this unshakeable belief in some people that things that things that aren't given permission by a government aren't legal, where it is, in fact, the other way around.
- freeflight 9y ago> There seems to be this unshakeable belief in some people that things that things that aren't given permission by a government aren't legal, where it is, in fact, the other way around. It's got more to do with the knowledge that governments are the ones who decide what's legal and what's not. So if governments deem cryptocurrencies as "illegal", or something worth regulating, then there's literally nothing you can do against that. Wouldn't be the first time mere math has been heavily regulated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_th...
- Frogolocalypse 9y agoNo. Rights define what governments can and cannot do in democracies. It's amazing how many people from America of all places, that now fail to understand this.
- freeflight 9y agoAnd who defines those rights? Governments do. That's something only very few people from US America seem to understand. Even the mighty US constitution has had twenty seven amendments since it's original inception. We are not talking about some unchangeable "god given natural law" here, we are talking about human made contractual frameworks which have been evolving just as much as the societies they are meant to govern.
- 9y ago
- Bakary 9y agoGive it enough time and crypto-currencies will develop its own rapacious elite. It has already happened to some extent with Bitcoin, since the early adopters are kings and the peasants must fight for the scraps.
- module0000 9y ago> The notion that they're dinosaurs and they're ten years late, is laughable. Maybe I wasn't clear. They are ten years late because they missed the 100,000% return on investment. I promise you, before they sell their board members on the idea of "getting involved" with BTC, they will present a figure called "opportunity cost", which represents the gains they have not realized by not participating. That figure is incredibly high, hence they are ten years late. Also, I don't believe they can dictate terms with BTC's existance at all. They can depress or inflate the market, but since there is no central authority - all they can do to influence prices is determined by their market participation. An example of a real market that they can dictate terms with would be US debt(treasury bond futures). By participating in the bond auctions with the fed: they get to set the rate. There is no equivalent process by which they can influence BTC, much less dictate it's existence.