4 ms·
From the article: "Scientists use a virus to make the genetic changes in the T cells, raising fears about possible long-term side effects" Is this a real r
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
From the article:
"Scientists use a virus to make the genetic changes in the T cells, raising fears about possible long-term side effects"
Is this a real risk? Is 'using a virus' in this way, still risky at all? or is it just the word 'virus' that makes writers put this line in every article about gene therapy?
{edit: real risk}
- Sir_Substance 9y agoA virus is a machine for replacing DNA in a cell with other DNA. Seems like the right tool for the job.
- gumby 9y agoIt's a standard tool. In fact a virus is not necessary a living device: there's a DNA delivery wrapper (looks like. Little lunar lander with a big spike coming out) and a payload (DNA). A virus can't reproduce but it can inject its payload into a cell and have the cell's DNA copy/execution capabilities copy the DNA for the virus, making new delivery machines until the cell explodes and emits a cloud of new dlivery agents into the organism. But if you remove the payload and replace it with your own, that payload presumably won't make more viruses
- eatbitseveryday 9y ago> It's a standard tool. In fact a virus is not necessary a living device: there's a DNA delivery wrapper (looks like. Little lunar lander with a big spike coming out) and a payload (DNA). Just a slight correction. Not all viruses look like what you describe. [0] Others, like the HIV, are circular. [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virus#Structure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virus#Structure [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_and_genome_of_HIV https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structure_and_genome_of_HIV
- aabaker99 9y agoThe virus is inactivated HIV. The risks about long-term side effects pertain more to gene editing than the use of a virus as a delivery mechanism.
- jfarlow 9y agoWhich are risks similar in nature to the risk of getting cancer after one has been infected with any other virus that integrates into one's genome.
- vibrio 9y agoThere is am ecosystem of many types viruses in all of us, healthy or not. Part of that ecosystem is HERVs or Human Endogenous Retroviruses (PERVs are the same in pigs--im not kidding). Understanding how they do or don't cause disease is an active area or research.
- wdbbdw 9y agoNot only are viruses a cool (if somewhat nefarious) DNA-delivery system (though, HIV being a retrovirus probably means that it delivered RNA instead of DNA), but it can be targeted. HIV viral particles attack human immune cells, which just happen to be the general cell type that needs to be treated in this case! Using something like hepatitis or HPV probably would do the trick here since those viruses wouldn't have the keys to unlock the doors to get inside of the T cells.
- nerdponx 9y agoNot to be flippant, but isn't a "virus that cures cancer" exactly how the Will Smith movie I Am Legend starts?
- HillaryBriss 9y agook, sure, the pessimistic among us can accentuate the negative aspects of this medical therapy, but it did solve the NYC subway crisis. and don't forget the wildlife habitat expansion. these things aren't all bad.
- philjohn 9y agoYes.
- agumonkey 9y agoVirus retroviral internal machinery has been used for ages.
- freeflight 9y ago> "Scientists use a virus to make the genetic changes in the T cells, raising fears about possible long-term side effects" Isn't that the plot of Resident Evil/Biohazard? ;)
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoA real risk compared to, say, dying from cancer that you already have? What, are they worried it might give you cancer in 10 years? If the cancer you have now is going to kill you, that still sounds like a good deal. (This is not hypothetical. My wife's grandfather had radiation treatment for cancer. 20 years later, he got cancer again, plausibly from the radiation. That's still a net win of 20 years.)