4 ms·
Already the site has its first scoop! Question: What little-known non-convex optimization trick has been used in most Berkeley NLP papers since 2006? Answer:
by bravura 16y ago
Already the site has its first scoop!
Question: What little-known non-convex optimization trick has been used in most Berkeley NLP papers since 2006?
Answer: http://metaoptimize.com/qa/questions/14/what-are-the-state-of-the-art-optimization-algorithms-for-problems-with-numerous-local-minima#74 http://metaoptimize.com/qa/questions/14/what-are-the-state-o...
I am the person that built this site. I wasn't planning on announcing the site yet, until I disseminated it more widely in academic circles, because I wanted to establish a core highly technical user-base, but I guess this is fine. The quality of the users coming from HN has been great.
What people are saying about MetaOptimize Q+A:
Ryan McDonald (Google): "A tool like this will help disseminate and archive the tricks and best practices that are common in NLP/ML, but are rarely written about at length in papers."
Aria Haghighi (Berkeley): "Both NLP and ML have a lot of folk wisdom about what works and what doesn't. A site like this is crucial for facilitating the sharing and validation of this collective knowledge."
Bob Carpenter (Alias-I): "Par for the course, it’s a mix of wildly general (non-convex optimization) and reasonably specific (testing a random number generator) questions." (http://lingpipe-blog.com/2010/06/29/training-examples-a-stack-overflow-for-nlp-and-ml-and/ http://lingpipe-blog.com/2010/06/29/training-examples-a-stac...)
I'm targetting machine learning, natural language processing, vision, AI, statistics, data mining, neuroscience, etc. and other data-driven fields. As we've learned from StackOverflow, having a broad topic means that information cross-polinates between groups that don't normally communicate. This problem is particularly acute in academia.
It's a site for scientists to share knowledge and techniques, to document our ideas in an informal online setting, and to discuss details that don't always make it into publications.
Also, I've gotten a handful of job offers through answering questions on Quora. So hopefully this will connect people with gigs they like.
Why should you sign up and post a question or answer?
* Communicate with experts
* Crosspolinate information with experts in adjacent fields
* Answer a question once publicly, instead of potentially many times over email
* Share knowledge to create additional impact beyond conference or journal publication
* Find new collaborators
* Get job offers and gigs
The site is powered by OSQA. (http://osqa.net http://osqa.net) I think it's unfair to the core developers to call it a StackOverflow knockoff, given that StackOverflow is---like most software---itself derivative.
- timr 16y agoYour email validation links appear to be broken -- I keep getting a 404 when I click mine.
- bravura 16y agoSorry about that. I will contact the OSQA developers upstream. The software wasn't designed to work out of a subdir, so we're still ironing issues out on that front. [edit: This happens for reasons that neither I nor the core devs understand: http://jira.osqa.net/browse/OSQA-204 http://jira.osqa.net/browse/OSQA-204 ]
- a1k0n 16y agoYeah, there's an extra /qa/ in the URL. Removing that works.
- sundarurfriend 16y agoThanks a lot for that info. It worked for me too.
- alextp 16y agoReally thank you for that. I was trying to use quora for this purpose, but it's not specific enough. As a machine learning phd student from somewhere far from most good research centers (I'm in brazil, and how many brazillian ML papers have you seen in NIPS/ICML recently?), I struggle a lot with this folk wisdom. Most professors around here haven't really interacted enough with the international ML community to be up to date, and I often find myself recommending papers to my advisor and his peers. This can save me a lot of wasted time and effort; more than once I have spent a couple of months trying to solve a subproblem of an idea I had only to find out it is (a) trivial or (b) impossible with the current state of the art, and being able to find which of these is true in a couple of days does wonders. I'm trying to disseminate this site to my peers and professors, to see if it will help people around.
- epi0Bauqu 16y ago