4 ms·
I'm not talking about explicit transaction fees, I'm just talking about the energy use of the system on a per-transaction basis. Looking at the absolute energy
by mikeash 9y ago
I'm not talking about explicit transaction fees, I'm just talking about the energy use of the system on a per-transaction basis. Looking at the absolute energy consumed by Bitcoin isn't enough by itself, because you also need to account for how big Bitcoin is.
Pricing in externalities will absolutely stop people from wasting power pointlessly. People will only use power if the benefit is greater than the cost. This includes "waste" if the effort of stopping that waste is greater than the cost of the waste, but if externalities are priced in appropriately then that means there's actually a net benefit to that. It's only a problem if the cost to the world is higher but the person paying the bill doesn't see that.
In terms of bitcoin, if the electricity to mine one costs X on the miner's power bill, and that bitcoin can be sold for 2X, then the miner will keep on doing it even if the total cost of that electricity including damage to the planet and other such things is 3X. If you price in the externalities so that the power bill actually says 3X, then the miner will stop. You don't actually need to use the extra money to counteract the externalities.
- Dylan16807 9y agoBut as some miners stop, the efficiency of mining goes up again. In a general sense, the amount of money spent on mining will stay constant. If you make electricity 3x as expensive, then maybe 1/3 as much electricity will be wasted, but it's still fundamentally a waste. If you don't use that extra money to undo the externalities, then the world is still getting more polluted just so bitcoin can spin in place. This isn't something like a power plant where charging $X per ton of CO2 released will make them cut emissions to 0. You would need a per-bitcoin fee to stop waste. Charging per-kWh has a limited effect, because people will always buy [bitcoin price] * [bitcoins per day] worth of electricity.
- mikeash 9y agoIf pricing in externalities increases the price goes up by a factor of three and bitcoin mining continues at 1/3rd the energy usage then it's no longer a waste. As long as you've done it correctly so that the price is accurate, then people will only use that energy if the benefit it creates is greater. Using energy for some benefit is fine, and bitcoin clearly has some benefit. There's only a problem when the benefit is lower than the cost of the energy, and that only happens when the energy's price doesn't reflect its cost.
- Dylan16807 9y agoBut bitcoin could be sustained on a fraction of that much energy. There is no benefit to mining beyond the point that prevents 51% attacks. After that it's all tragedy of the commons waste.