10 ms·
Dynamism in Retreat: Consequences for Regions, Markets and Workers
- randcraw 9y agoI'm guessing much of this "failure to thrive" among startups is driven by the inability of a small US company to deliver services that are commercially sustainable. Most startups don't make a product; they resell or provide a service. So their profitability devolves to the margin between their hourly service charge rate and their hourly labor cost. And that profit margin has continued to shrink due to continuing optimizations by large/foreign players in our hyper-optimized global marketplace. Though the article doesn't propose specific causes, since 2008 I suspect the causal changes in small US business to be: 1) domination of product sales and distribution by a handful of on-line mega-retailers (Amazon, Alibaba, Walmart) due to their high efficiency and ever broader and deeper market penetration and hyper-efficient distribution networks, and 2) increased mobility and adaptability to quickly fill newly created market niches from low labor cost foreign firms (still 2X-5X cheaper), and 3) the rising cost of US employees (esp. healthcare). As such, the ability of the traditional ma and pa startup company to eke out a positive cash flow has become more difficult than than it was in 2008.
- sparkling 9y agoHow exactly is the number of people employed by startups related to the economy as a whole?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoDisclaimer: I am not an economist. But as I understand the theory, job growth mainly comes from smaller companies. Of those, startups are the fast-growth ones. (Mom-and-pop businesses aren't where the growth is.) The number of people employed by startups can therefore be regarded as an approximation of the first derivative of the economy (or, perhaps, of employment).
- pm90 9y agoIts related to the dynamism of the economy. More startups/new businesses == more jobs, more competition, more creativity etc.
- justicezyx 9y agoThe startup scene now is more capital dominant, than innovation. Therefore regulation is more important than other things. IMHO, this is a reflection of the stagnant of fundamental new technology breakthrough since the internet era started. Internet itself hardly brings anything new, it merely make things marginally more efficient. Maybe AI is the true innovation we have been waiting for. But I doubt it plays nice with startups either.
- ygfvvhygvn 9y agoI have been trying to start my own business for years now. The hoops you have to jump through in every industry I have looked at are not insignificant. It makes a huge barrier to entry which makes the risk vs. reward ratio a little more skewed towards risk than I can handle. We really need to do something about unnecessary overregulation. We can protect our environment without needing a team of lawyers to open a lemonade stand (hyperbole).
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoI think we have to be really specific about regulation, and, because of scope, it's hard to do that. The system we currently have is not quite, but similar to, the worst of both worlds. We have regulators who let major corporations get away with murder - because the regulators are either beholden to corporations or beholden to politicians who are beholden to corporations; at the same time, they make life unnecessarily difficult for small businesses, which helps the larger corporations by eliminating much of the competition for them. I don't agree with everything William Sanjour says on this, but he makes a lot of good points, and it's very possible that my points of disagreement stem from me not knowing/understanding as much as Sanjour, which I clearly don't. In this piece, he even gives you the TL;DR. To summarize, this is what I believe needs to be done : 1) Agencies which enforce regulations should not write the regulations. 2) The revolving door should be shut. 3) Whistle blowers should be protected, encouraged and rewarded. 4) To the greatest extent feasible, those who the regulations are intended to protect should participate in writing and enforcing the regulations. https://www.independentsciencenews.org/health/designed-to-fail-why-regulatory-agencies-dont-work/ https://www.independentsciencenews.org/health/designed-to-fa...
- deelowe 9y agoUnfortunately, in an attempt to do something about this, the people got conned.
- komali2 9y agoRespectfully, I find this a vague response to a vague post. I don't know what you mean by "this" in "something about this" because I don't understand what sort of regulations the OP is talking about, and I don't know what you mean by "the people got conned."
- redm 9y agoI heard about this on NPR. My thought is that most new businesses never go beyond a couple of people. I think many of them are related to local services, such as realtors, small shops, and services. The Internet's allows a relatively small team to reach and impact a lot of people. We see new industries disrupted all the time. These industries have real small businesses that are impacted. Just as Walmart put small retailers in a bind, Amazon is going to put Walmart in a difficult spot. IMHO.
- sharemywin 9y agoWal-Mart earnings top Street estimates as retailer's digital sales jump 63% Here's what the company reported vs. what the Street was expecting: Earnings per share: $1.00, excluding items, vs. expectations for 96 cents, according to Thomson Reuters analysts. Revenue: $117.5 billion vs. a forecast for $117.74 billion, analysts said. Same-store sales: 1.4 percent growth at U.S. stores http://www.cnbc.com/2017/05/18/walmart-reports-first-quarter-earnings.html http://www.cnbc.com/2017/05/18/walmart-reports-first-quarter... What does Amazon have that Walmart can't buy?
- dcroley 9y agoSo a group with Innovation in its name says that decreasing innovation is the "core economic problem America faces today." Hmmm. Color me skeptical.
- randomf1fan 9y agoThat's not really fair. The data should speak for itself, and I for one found the argument cogent. Did you find any errors or bias? Otherwise you might as well say the CDC saying something about Disease is invalid.
- bdcravens 9y agoThe CDC is a government entity, and "disease" is well-defined. "Innovation" is a bit more nebulous, and the EIG appears to be quasi-non-profit, but is a private company. Also, parent comment said "skeptical", not "invalid".
- redy 9y agoThe article is interesting because it gets a lot right but then it fails to clearly state the problem. It's not clear that this group groks it. It's funny because I just wrote this comment[0] this morning. To sort of repeat myself: - An extremely slack labor market which is causing a thousands of young men to drop out of the labor market and play video games. [2] - An extremely slack labor market which is causing unprecedented decreases in labor mobility and entrepreneurship. [3] - An extremely slack labor market which is causing enormous increases in household debt. (What the Great Financial Crisis was really about.) [4] - An extremely slack labor market which leads to corporate profits and inequality not seen since the Gilded Age.[5] - An extremely slack labor market which has led to what is probably negative wage growth as prices rise. [6] (That's just the UK but I'd say the US is probably 2-3 years behind the curve.) Add in the rise of China and you've got a perfect storm for a severe economic dislocation in the West as most of the population is tossed to the wolves of unemployment. The problem is that in America you can't simply say the labor market is the problem. People will call you communist or a socialist. So I guess you have to dress it up with terms like "innovation" and "dynamism." This confuses other people and instead of fixing the actual problem -- the labor market -- you get people arguing about cutting back environmental regulations. (Seriously, see elsewhere in the thread.) So, probably, words do matter. If this group called themselves the "Labor Innovation Group" it would be a sign they understand the issues. But as it is now it's probably a good idea to be a bit wary. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14751019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14751019 [1] https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21695385-profits-are-too-high-america-needs-giant-dose-competition-too-much-good-thing https://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21695385-profits-are... [2] http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/~nwilliam/Econ702_files/abch.pdf http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/~nwilliam/Econ702_files/abch.pdf [3] http://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Declining-Entrepreneurship-Labor-Mobility-and-Business-Dynamism-A-Demand-Side-Approach.pdf http://rooseveltinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Dec... [4] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/17/business/dealbook/household-debt-united-states.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/17/business/dealbook/househo... [5] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/06/opinion/wage-inequality-income-growth.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/06/opinion/wage-inequality-i... [6] https://www.ft.com/content/6d248d02-4885-37d6-b00d-c6117c0dcd73?mhq5j=e1 https://www.ft.com/content/6d248d02-4885-37d6-b00d-c6117c0dc...
- mtgx 9y agoProbably not the only factor, but I imagine inequality and the reduction in the middle class' purchasing power plays a big role in this, too. More money goes to a handful few = less money for everyone else to buy stuff = weaker economy = fewer companies that can be successful. http://www.oecd.org/newsroom/inequality-hurts-economic-growth.htm http://www.oecd.org/newsroom/inequality-hurts-economic-growt...
- solatic 9y agoNew businesses require capital to get started. That capital doesn't need to come from middle-class consumers - it can also come from large companies with hoards of cash to invest. Such hoards of corporate cash are easy to find, there's trillions of it collectively across American corporate accounts [1]. There just aren't many start-ups for them to invest in. From an access-to-capital point of view, there's never been a better time to start a company. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/24/magazine/why-are-corporations-hoarding-trillions.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/24/magazine/why-are-corporat...
- mtgx 9y agoThat's a false conclusion, in my opinion. There are plenty of startups in which money could be put in, but of course "smart investors" don't invest in all startups that may show-up at their doors. So they choose to save their billions and billions of dollars in Cayman Islands. That money goes largely unused in the economy. Also, the vast majority of startups aren't funded by VCs or angel investors, but through personal economies and loans - again, an issue that depends on the strength of the middle class.
- wnevets 9y agoWe just need to give more tax cuts to the mega rich, they're surely use it to create new jobs!
- downrightmike 9y agoBut make sure poor people don't get their services or they'll become dependent on the government!
- komali2 9y agoSmall businesses are important: Small businesses make up: 99.7 percent of U.S. employer firms, 64 percent of net new private-sector jobs, 49.2 percent of private-sector employment, 42.9 percent of private-sector payroll, 46 percent of private-sector output, 43 percent of high-tech employment, 98 percent of firms exporting goods, 33 percent of exporting value. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, SUSB, CPS; International Trade Administration; Bureau of Labor Statistics, BED; Advocacy-funded research, Small Business GDP: Update 2002- 2010, www.sba.gov/advocacy/7540/42371.
- dozzie 9y ago> Small businesses make up: > 98 percent of firms exporting goods, > 33 percent of exporting value. In other words, 2 percent of firms exporting goods (the part that is not "small businesses") make the remaining 67 percent of exporting value.
- komali2 9y agoWell, I'd imagine Oil is a pretty huge chunk of that, which is pretty much impossible to export as a small business. I only suggest it because I used to work in Oil and the numbers I saw across my spreadsheets were truly absurd.
- turbobuckeye 9y agoRegulation is certainly a problem, but the unfettered growth and merging of many companies over the last decade has been nothing short of breathtaking. Amazon, Google, Facebook are all essentially monopolies in their space. Banks have combined to form behemoths (and good luck starting a bank these days with Dodd-Frank on the books). Until the government addresses unfair and anticompetitive behavior and concentration, this trend will continue.
- chapium 9y agoI'd be careful to include facebook in that group. Several mobile apps are very strongly keeping them in check.
- moomin 9y agoTell that to the editor of the New York Times.
- wil421 9y agoAgreed I keep Facebook for legacy support meaning older family and their friends. Snapchat is my go to for my friends or just plain group text. Snapchat is nice because I can post freely in my groups and not be worried about random people seeing the posts like FB. I doubted Snapchat for years. Trying to do more Instagram next...
- sharemywin 9y agoooops...moving back to a facebook product.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoHow is that? Everybody and their mother (and their grandmother!) has a facebook account. And instagram stories now boasts more users than Snapchat.
- turbobuckeye 9y agoDisagree. While there are certainly other social apps, there is no (significant) direct competitor to FaceBook's core product. When you buy a car (e.g.) you generally have plenty of very similar options. That's not the case here. If we use the car analogy, FaceBook could be a sedan, and if you don't want a sedan your options are...well...not much. Of course you can buy a motorcycle (Instagram), moped (Pinterest), or van (Snapchat), but none of these are really the same thing other than the fact that they're motorized transport devices.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- redm 9y agoPretty much every stat on small businesses in one place from the Small Business and Entrepreneur Council: http://sbecouncil.org/about-us/facts-and-data/ http://sbecouncil.org/about-us/facts-and-data/ "In 2012, according to U.S. Census Bureau data, there were 5.73 million employer firms in the U.S. Firms with fewer than 500 workers accounted for 99.7 percent of those businesses, and businesses with less than 20 workers made up 89.6 percent. Add in the number of nonemployer businesses – there were 23.0 million in 2013 – then the share of U.S. businesses with less than 20 workers increases to 97.9 percent." The majority was 23 Million sole proprietorships, or people working for themselves, in 2013.
- tabtab 9y agoThere are several unanswered questions, such as which kind of businesses are failing more, or starting less; and how do US trends compare to other countries? And, are they counting everybody? For example, volume Ebay sellers could be considered "entrepreneurs" but may not formally register as a business. Online and "big-box" stores have almost certainly reduced mom-and-pop retail, at least physical stores. Does this account for the entire drop, or just a part of it? As far as blaming "regulations", I'd like to see some specific examples. Many times they are state or local regulations. Don't focus only on Federal regs.
- ygfvvhygvn 9y agoI'm not sure if you were referring to my comment but if you were, they are state and local regulations. Federal regs that made roadblocks were usually tax related
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWell we're crushing the middle and lower class. Refusal to tax the rich and redistribute it downward, the constant weakening of unions, ineffectual antitrust enforcement, all of these contribute. Our economy depends on people who have a high marginal propensity to consume having enough money to spend it on discretionary goods.
- RodericDay 9y agoI agree with you and it's frustrating that this is sunk without a substantial response. A few months back, Matt Bruenig nailed it: "The unwritten story of the Juicero debacle is that high income inequality causes capital to be misallocated towards luxury production."
- justinzollars 9y agoOne small problem in California that needs to be fixed is the Franchise Tax on Corporations. This is a huge tax for a small startup. Its another example of taxing the small and poor rather than taxing the rich.
- tabtab 9y agoWhat kind of numbers are we looking at?
- justinzollars 9y ago$800/year.
- moomin 9y agoSomething that seems to have been happening for some time is people promoting "pro-business" policies when we should really be aiming for "pro-market" and "pro-competition". An extreme version of this is the recent championing of the coal industry, which is frankly already dead. Tax breaks for large multinationals fall into the same category. It seems to me that we've been constantly performing short-term hacks on the economy, and the bill is coming due.
- garethsprice 9y agoWhat's the correlation between rate of forming new businesses and the rising costs of healthcare? Quit your job to start a business and not only do you have to figure out your own insurance (at a vastly inflated rate), but you have to figure out how to play medical provider for anyone you hire. It's crazy that in the US, healthcare is so closely tied to employment. Single payer healthcare detached from the employer would vastly increase the opportunity for people to become entrepreneurs.
- maxerickson 9y agoWith the ACA it isn't all that complicated, a small business doesn't have to offer health coverage, just pay enough to still have the job be interesting for people willing to buy a marketplace plan. I also wonder if actual premiums paid by end users in the individual marketplaces (that is, prices after subsidies) are really vastly inflated compared to group plans (it's just the group plans hide a lot of the cost from the insured).
- tabtab 9y agoI agree that healthcare and employment should be decoupled, but it would then increase individual taxes, which is poison to Republicans. All our significant competitor nations have nationalized healthcare/insurance (NHCI). Thus, the existence of NHCI alone doesn't give us a disadvantage over such nations. You could argue that HOW we do NHCI is no good, but that's a long and thorny side discussion.
- prostoalex 9y agoACA's goal was to de-couple insurance from employment by having exchanges that anyone can enroll, and in theory you gain some negotiating power by participating in a plan that thousands of others have chosen. I think one problem is perception - when you don't see the health insurance premiums on your pay stub, you tend to think of them as $0, so going from $0 a month to $800 a month does seem outrageously expensive. The other problem is the tax treatment of health insurance premiums - they're deductible for the employer, but not deductible for an individual. One of those inconsistencies needs to change, most likely deductibility on the corporate front, as that somewhat contributes to the rise of total costs ("who cares if it's 5% more expensive this year, it's a write-off") and is a corporate subsidy - the money that could've gone to the benefit of all citizens is funneled to large corporations to help those nice fellows cover their costs of doing business.
- agitator 9y agoI think a lot of people here are focused on tech startups, but I think what is really apparent is the domination of large corporations in many other aspects of our economy. So many mom/pop restaurants are being pushed out by corporations, same goes for all the small grocery stores and retail stores that existed in the past. Everything is being collected under massive corporations who have the lobbying power to maintain their positions. I'm not sure there is much you can do about that. The distribution of wealth is affected by this too. You don't have as many owners and entrepreneurs making a living running their businesses, instead its going to the top tier at these corporations.
- throwawayjava 9y agoFrom the article: > We don’t know why people stopped moving and became more settled in their work arrangements. We don’t know why the returns to incumbency have increased. What if the answer is the obvious one? What if the incumbents in the big cities are full of more efficient, better educated, richer, and smarter people? A lot of big companies suck. But the ones that have concentrated wealth in the past decade or two -- Google, Facebook, Apple, Amazon -- are remarkably good at what they do. And the people I know who work at those places are, on balance, remarkably smart/educated/efficient. There are equally good or even better people at smaller shops in smaller cities, to be sure, but the sheer number of great engineers at Microsoft and Google alone is mind-boggling. And even among small shops there's an enormous geographical concentration of talent. I don't know a lot about other industries, but maybe this is true elsewhere in the economy as well. If that's true -- that incumbents aren't just big but also better -- then I fear our only hope for increased dynamism is access to new markets or new technologies. Both of which are identified in the report as contributors to decreasing dynamism. Hm.
- maxerickson 9y agoThose companies don't really employ very many people. They won't explain widespread demographic trends. (In fact, I imagine they tend to counter the specific trend, attracting people to high paying jobs)
- throwawayjava 9y ago> They won't explain widespread demographic trends I know this, but I wonder if the same thing is happening in other industries. E.g. is Monsanto doing something similar to small seed distributors/providers? Are large banks doing something similar to small credit unions? Are large construction firms doing something similar to smaller ones? > In fact, I imagine they tend to counter the specific trend, attracting people to high paying jobs Maybe. But what if these firms are really so efficient that they're replacing 100 migrants to regional hubs with 10 or even 1 migrant to a national/global hub? Again, I'm just asking questions :)
- CryoLogic 9y agoInterestingly enough, starting a c-corp is actually quite difficult and expensive. You are probably looking at minimum 5k in legal fees to do it "right". You have incorporation paperwork, post-incorporation, trademarks, copyrights, patents, foreign qualifications, a lawyer to draft out founders agreement and employee agreements etc. That's not chump change. Maybe to some HN developers, but to the average joe starting a company is very expensive. Especially if you go by the new age motto of trying a bunch of shit and failing and trying again. After those legal costs you have to consider the costs of the average business, and the fact the financing is not avail. for the average joe. VC capital is not based off of merit, or much aside from connections and friendships. It's basically "bros funding bros". There are opps. to get govt. funding, but not enough to support almost any business today. A 20k grant means nothing when you can't even afford a 280sqft studio on that
- draw_down 9y agoCan't quit your job to start a business if you need health insurance. Which you do.