4 ms·
> (Read the academic paper) I admire the effort, but: doesn't "academic" mean "scientific"? Can there possibly be any "science" in having a well-known VM reim
by Koshkin 9y ago
> (Read the academic paper)
I admire the effort, but: doesn't "academic" mean "scientific"? Can there possibly be any "science" in having a well-known VM reimplemented in a well-known programming language?
- bdcravens 9y agoYes, in the sense that it's called "computer science" with little scientific method involved.
- amelius 9y agoI got an error, so I falsified it according to the scientific method: Error extracting doppio_home.zip: Error: ENOENT: No such file or directory., '/persist/vendor/java_home/lib/images/cursors/cursors.properties'
- emeryberger 9y agoFile a bug report, please. Doppio is actively maintained, though our current focus is on Browsix (which incorporates and extends some of Doppio's functionality -- see browsix.org).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 9y ago> Academic: of, relating to, or characteristic of a school, especially one of higher learning. It appears as though this was a university project, the kind of project one completes for their masters even. Academic seems to be precisely the right term.
- nteon 9y agoPlease take a look at the contributions in the paper at the end of the introduction. The JVM uses operating system abstractions (like a file system, threads, and synchronous APIs) that were non-existent in the browser when the paper were published, and are still widely unavailable natively. Figuring out how to construct the functionality necessary not to just simply execute Java bytecode but to provide a full Java Virtual Machine, and then show how this could be generalized beyond a JVM, is a CS contribution. Disclosure: I'm a labmate of the author.
- munificent 9y ago> I admire the effort, but: doesn't "academic" mean "scientific"? No, it doesn't. Or did you forget about music, literature, engineering, business, finance, history, philosophy, dance, art, architecture, nursing, etc.?
- pgbovine 9y agorelevant paper: https://homes.cs.washington.edu/~jfogarty/publications/workshop-chi2017-codeandcontribution.pdf https://homes.cs.washington.edu/~jfogarty/publications/works... This is an example of research as illustrated by Figure 5 in that paper (known functionality, novel techniques)
- nerdponx 9y agoNo, it doesn't, and yes, there can.
- raddan 9y agoHere's one of the scientific questions, and FWIW, it's actually written right on the first page: can you implement a programming language that relies on synchronous primitives in a language that has only asynchronous primitives? The answer to that question is not obvious, but it turns out to be "yes". Doppio is existential proof that it can be done. Furthermore, that fact is falsifiable (see Karl Popper), which makes the process of learning the answer "science." You may not think this is an important question to answer--and that is your prerogative--but you can't argue that it isn't scientific. One of those other scientific questions is about threading (again, see page 1). BTW, did you know that System.out.println relies on synchronization primitives? You literally cannot write helloworld in Java without invoking a lot of machinery.