7 ms·
I think that this is absolutely brilliant. I've been against the patent of generalistic ideas, and basic processes for a very long time. Anything in software
by tracker1 9y ago
I think that this is absolutely brilliant. I've been against the patent of generalistic ideas, and basic processes for a very long time. Anything in software should not really be patentable, unless there is a concrete implementation of an invention, it's not an invention, it's a set of instructions.
Let software work under trade secrets, but not patents. Anyone can implement something they think through. It's usually a clear example of a need. That said, I think the types of patent trolling law firms such as this deserve every bit of backlash against them that they get.
- mjevans 9y agoSoftware is already covered by /copyright/ law. It does not need patents.
- MatthewWilkes 9y agoCopyright covers implementations, not ideas. I have no moral objection to truly novel inventions in computer science being protected by patents. An innovative search algorithm, a compression scheme, etc. Its shit when MP3s and GIFs were encumbered, but they were genuine inventions whose sharing publicly genuinely advanced the public good. The kind the patent trolls use are not innovative in the same way. We need a stricter definition of obvious to one versed in the art, not a ban throughout the field.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Hermel 9y agoI'm pretty sure that if you rewrote Harry Potter from scratch with new names and wording (redoing the implementation) and published that, you would still get in trouble. So copyright is somewhat broader than you think.
- indolering 9y agoNope, it's not a violation of copyright.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoCopyright law apparently makes an explicit exception for translations. (i.e. translations are subject to copyright despite usually sharing literally no wording with the original.) It isn't clear to me whether that only covers works in a foreign language that claim to be translations of some other work, or whether it would apply to any foreign-language work that duplicates the plot of an earlier copyrighted work.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThe thing to remember with copyright is it covers copying. If you read a book and rewrite it in another language you didn't copy it, you copied the ideas, perhaps, but copyright covers expression and not ideas.
- shagie 9y agoCreating a translation of a work is a derivative work itself. This applies to porting software from C++ to Java as well as translating of Harry Potter to French.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoRe-writing a story and translation are different things entirely. If I describe at an abstracted level the working of a C++ program to you and you implement it in Java then you have not copied the work, nor even created a derivative, ergo clean-room implementation being a thing.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoLike I said, the copyright law makes an explicit exception for "translations". Copyright also covers translations, despite the fact that they share none of the "expression" of the original.
- mikekchar 9y agoPatents cover implementations, not ideas. Ideas are not patentable. Neither are algorithms. The implementation of an idea in a machine is patentable in most places in the world. The implementation of an algorithm on a machine is patentable in the U.S. We need better understanding of existing definitions so that we don't rehash the same arguments over and over again.
- dungle6 9y agoLol I'm not a lawyer and I am not really interested in the legal distinction between idea and implementation, because if a non practicing entity can buy a patent that amounts to a few flowcharts you're just arguing silly semantics as far as I'm concerned.
- URSpider94 9y agoI disagree with your characterization. Physical processes, expressed as "first x, then y, then z" are clearly and indisputably patentable. They can just be a series of steps performed by hand, no machine required. What is this but an algorithm? And, for anyone who believes that algorithms can't be patented, I have a collection of GIF's and MP3's to sell you.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoNope. Disagree. Look at claim construction in a patent "a fixing means", for example, isn't an implementation it's an element of an idea. A patent application has to include a concrete implementation but the claims - which define the patent legally - are always broader than the specific implementation and will cover multiple implementations that use the inventive concept. Thus, a new product that's never been made before can infringe an existing patent. The implementation is new but the _idea_ is not.
- riskable 9y agoProving that a patent's claims cover disparate implementations is how you successfully defend yourself against patent lawsuits. If a patent's claims are ambiguous enough to cover multiple, novel implementations it is by definition "overly broad" and will be ruled invalid. See: https://www.law360.com/articles/608579/overbroad-patent-claims-may-be-challenged-earlier https://www.law360.com/articles/608579/overbroad-patent-clai... So no, patents (and their claims) are not "ideas". They are disclosures of how the invention works and they're supposed to be damned specific!
- riskable 9y ago> Copyright covers implementations, not ideas. Patents cover implementations, not ideas. Copyright covers "artistic works" like text (files), audio, and video. To further clarify: The purpose of copyright is to grant control over who can copy it to the creator/owner so that it can't be reproduced or embellished/modified without their permission (which was a big problem at the time serious copyright laws started being written in the US). Exceptions such as fair use exist but that's the gist of it. Profit was a secondary concern to control believe it or not. The fear being someone would publish a copy of your work with a few damning sentences changed or added here and there with your name attached. Ruining your reputation/career which was much more important to the controlling elite (land owners) at the time than the pittance one might make from sales of their writings/art. The purpose of patents is disclosure. Don't let anyone state otherwise because the founding fathers were pretty damned clear about it. In exchange for disclosing your invention to the world you're granted a monopoly over who can use or manufacture it. Patents never have and never will be about something as ambiguous as, "ideas". Considering that software can only exist as ether it should never have been considered patent-eligible. Sure, you can implement software in an FPGA and claim, "it's hardware now!" Go ahead and patent that particular configuration of an FPGA... Which would be a tangible, physical thing. You should have no right whatsoever to claim a monopoly on the mere concept of such software which is exactly what software patents are.
- valuearb 9y agoAllowing novel software ideas to be patented ensures common software ideas will be. The incentives are for expanding patent coverage, it's a fallible system of people and it's why we are in this mess.
- greedy_buffer 9y agoInterestingly, Blackbird has a patent portfolio that is not exclusive to software, although Cloudflare intends to invalidate them all.
- protomyth 9y ago> although Cloudflare intends to invalidate them all. Scorched earth doesn’t allow for half measures, plus leaving them with any patents would leave them with hope and we can’t have that.
- chasd00 9y agoagreed. "I say we take off, nuke the entire site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure" - Aliens
- pas 9y agoSomeone comes up with a very amazing compression, chemical, medicine, foreign language learning trick? (Not like H.264, which is basically a patent on a lot of prior art [1], because they put the "video" word in the title instead of data.) Yeah, sure, you get a patent on that. But it has to be so outlandishly out of the box innovative, that it should be pretty much in the same league as Einstein's tensor equations compared to Newton's F= G (M1 M2) / r^2 . It shouldn't be the next iterative step in the field, that comes naturally in the context, after looking at the latest few interesting papers. It should be a leap, an invention to change the world. Innovation, research/development/engineering, the process of understanding problems and (partially) solving them itself become a lot better understood as we see fundamental sciences, theoretical limits, progress over time, as we have a better mental toolkit, full of amazingly powerful concepts (information, data, power consumption, space-time trade offs, threat model, probability/statistics/risk/incentives/microeconomics). Or, of course, make the term shorter and field based (based on the speed of adaptation and change of ideas/technologies/methods in fields), and/or mandate reasonable licencing fees (and licensing frameworks). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2349585 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2349585