10 ms·
Blogger discredits claim Amelia Earhart was taken prisoner by Japan
- lawless123 9y agoThere are always so many jokers making money speculating on things like this, it's nice to see some taken down a peg.
- flippyhead 9y agoBesides a couple national newspapers I pretty much don't read or watch anything online or on TV anymore that purports to be factual. This kind of thing is just too common, I've completely lost trust in a lot of the media available to me.
- JBReefer 9y agoIsn't that s very serious issue? I absolutely agree that journalistic/non-fiction integrity has collapsed in the post-print world, but what can we do about it? When your choice is Vox or Breitbart, that's kind of a turd sandwich.
- pluma 9y agoI thought the History Channel was already widely considered non-factual. Aren't half the documentaries about space aliens? "Source": http://www.cracked.com/funny-5720-the-history-channel/ http://www.cracked.com/funny-5720-the-history-channel/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lawless123 9y agoAnd the rest are mostly about Hitler, Hitlers dog, Hitlers secretary, Hitlers lunch.
- dboreham 9y agoHence "Hitler Channel".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- astrodust 9y ago"Hitlery Channel"
- dogma1138 9y agoThere's also the overlap with Hitler's flying saucers.
- thearn4 9y agoI almost miss the days when everything was about Hitler. At least then it had the veneer of being historical. Now it's about ice road truckers, pawn shops, and things hillbillies like.
- VLM 9y agoThey also went full on Jesus some years back. They're firmly in the blue collar reality TV camp now, its mostly truck drivers, pawn shops, and surprisingly, blacksmiths. Sorta like how the Sci Fi channel was all about pro wrestling, fantasy, action movies, pretty much anything but science fiction. When I was a little kid (a long time ago) the snarky wisdom was if a country had "democratic" in its name, it wasn't. The snarky wisdom today is a cable TV channel broadcasts everything except what its name would imply. So the History channel never broadcasts anything factually historical, the sci fi channel never broadcasts science fiction, or The Learning Channel only broadcasts fashion and style never anything educational. "Home and Garden" TV is endless real estate "FIRE sector" complimentary copy, containing no garden shows. Even the weather channel pretty much stopped weather forecasts and replaced it with agitprop documentaries that the faithful don't watch because they're already faithful and the unfaithful don't watch because they're nonbelievers.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aaron-lebo 9y agoWho doesn't like "ancient astronaut theorists"? http://chronicle.su/wp-content/uploads/tsoukalosaliens1.jpg http://chronicle.su/wp-content/uploads/tsoukalosaliens1.jpg
- pluma 9y agoThat's pretty much what I think of as a non-American when I hear "History channel".
- criddell 9y agoIs the European version pretty much the same?
- toxican 9y agoI think the ancient aliens theories are fun little 'what if' dips into scifi, but treating them seriously like History does is just stupid. And people who buy into that are equally stupid, if not more so.
- wil421 9y agoIt used to be a decent channel. Modern marvels was great. Discovery, NatGeo, Animal and History Channel used to be good a times. They all sold out for cheaper to produce reality shows. PBS and BBC docs are still hanging on and pretty good. NOVA and Planet Earth series are great.
- throwaway7645 9y agoNova is one series I've been continually excited about since being a small child. Fantastic stuff.
- versteegen 9y agoThank goodness. It's really unpleasant to see such history-rewriting claims made in the global press based on such flimsy evidence.
- dpark 9y agoNot just flimsy. Complete trash. There is more resolution in the typical forum emoji than in the face of the man claimed to be Noonan. And the person claimed to be Earhart has their back turned. It's not even clear that it's a woman. All the people involved in this should be ashamed.
- criddell 9y agoI wonder if History Channel will update their website with this information? It seems like if they actually give a damn about history, they should.
- toxican 9y agospoiler alert: They have not given a damn about history in a looong time.
- qbrass 9y agoIt was never about giving a damn about history. It was about turning a cheap source of content into a channel when cable service providers were looking for new channels to air.
- dkarl 9y agoYeah, I wonder if they'll say aliens aren't real and it's embarrassing for grown men to be endlessly fascinated with Hitler when they don't know who their state representative is.
- criddell 9y agoJust checked their Twitter feed and they are on it: https://twitter.com/HISTORY/status/884781394861469696 https://twitter.com/HISTORY/status/884781394861469696
- autokad 9y agoi remember watching ww II battle documentaries, and they would be talking about a battle, say battle of the budge. and I would be like 'wait a second, that stock video footage was a corsair shooting a drone. then it hit me that almost all of the video shown on these things is just for aesthetics / effect and not actual footage from the topic in question. then it hit me, the news was actually doing the same thing! like they would be talking about an event concerning the nimitz and would show stock video footage of the JFK
- arkitaip 9y agoIt's the equivalent of tech's hacker baddie wearing sunglasses and a hoodie in a dark room with menacing green letters on the monitor.
- T-zex 9y agoWhy waste time on finding a perfect colour scheme, when you can simply put sunglasses on? Same with shampooing, put on a hoodie. That's a true hacker mentality.
- EliRivers 9y agoIt certainly explains why we so often see the same inappropriate language or pattern applied to every other problem.
- ryandrake 9y agoThink about how much inaccuracy and nonsense you can point out (because you are an expert) any time you see/read mainstream reporting on technology. Now extrapolate that to other areas of reporting. It's hard to know what to believe or who's credible.
- ojilles 9y agoGell-Mann Amnesia effect? http://www.omsj.org/blogs/gell-mann-effect http://www.omsj.org/blogs/gell-mann-effect
- jorgec 9y agoThe proof was stupid. It shows the back of some person and the photo concludes that its Amelia. About this topic, its amazing how many people claim that its pro-science but never ask for proof, or scientific method.
- Bartweiss 9y agoMost depressing: "Kota Yamano, a military history blogger who unearthed the Japanese photograph, said it took him just 30 minutes to effectively debunk the documentary’s central claim." It was shoddy evidence, but it was also trivially disproven. Just... no one cared.
- jaclaz 9y agoWorse than that, the host wasn't a "common" investigator (and later executive assistant director) at the FBI, he was a specialist in computer crime, his bio: https://www.crowdstrike.com/shawn-henry/ https://www.crowdstrike.com/shawn-henry/ >... is credited with boosting the FBI’s computer crime and cybersecurity investigative capabilities. He oversaw computer crime investigations spanning the globe, including denial-of-service attacks, bank and corporate breaches, and state-sponsored intrusions. He posted FBI cyberexperts in police agencies around the world, including the Netherlands, Romania, Ukraine and Estonia.
- phkahler 9y agoThe best part is the photo credit: >> The woman said to resemble pilot Amelia Earhart is seen sitting on the dock in the centre of the picture. Photograph: Reuters So Reuters is falsely taking credit for a photo when they didn't know its origin. Journalistic integrity is long dead.
- phkahler 9y agoOh shit there's this: >> The documentary, hosted by former FBI executive assistant director Shawn Henry, also alleges a cover-up, claiming that the US government knew of her whereabouts but did nothing to rescue her. So (former) government officials are promoting false notions of government conspiracies. It's all theater folks. We are being manipulated by everyone.
- icebraining 9y agoReminds me of South Park's episode on the 9/11 conspiracy.
- Steko 9y agoInterestingly enough, Shawn Henry was the head of the FBI Cyber division and, after leaving, became President of Services at CrowdStrike which was involved in investigating the DNC hack by the Russians.
- eyeinthepyramid 9y agoIsn't that the Guardian misassigning credit to Reuters?
- e12e 9y agoI assume most of this story was written up by Reuters, picked up by the Guardian and regurgitated: http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-amelia-earhart-idUSKBN19R2YX http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-amelia-earhart-idUSKBN...
- thrillgore 9y agoNow there's a clickbaity title.
- gwern 9y agoAnother nifty example of how search engines and digitization are improving research. How would anyone have ever discovered that one super-obscure Japanese travel book happened to include one old black-white photo? This reminds me of another Japanese-related example of search-engine-driven historical research, the castaway Australian sailors: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/may/28/australian-convict-pirates-in-japan-evidence-of-1830-voyage-unearthed https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/may/28/austr... Or more literarily, the recently-discovered Walt Whitman novel https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/20/arts/in-a-walt-whitman-novel-lost-for-165-years-clues-to-leaves-of-grass.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/20/arts/in-a-walt-whitman-no...
- badosu 9y agoIndeed. Moving to the opposite direction though I wonder when will we discover the first pseudo-historical artifacts generated by AI (speeches, art, photos, and even videos). This is the greatest weapon ever, the ministry of truth would never dream of something like this!
- badosu 9y agoNot on mobile anymore, some examples: - https://github.com/junyanz/CycleGAN https://github.com/junyanz/CycleGAN (drawings to photorealistic images and perhaps videos) - https://lyrebird.ai/demo https://lyrebird.ai/demo (inflamatory or incriminatory speeches) - https://deepart.io/ https://deepart.io/ (forgotten works of art)
- notadoc 9y agoIs this suggesting that the same TV network which airs a show called "ANCIENT ALIENS" would have some completely inaccurate and poorly researched easily debunked claim on one of their TV shows? What's next? Is some blogger going to reveal to the world that Seinfeld and Star Trek aren't real too??
- snickerbockers 9y ago>What's next? Is some blogger going to reveal to the world that Seinfeld and Star Trek aren't real too?? On the contrary, this means that the episode of Voyager where Amelia Earhart was revealed to be transported to the Delta Quadrant can still happen.
- roryisok 9y agoGive us the 37s!
- indulgent 9y agoNo one ever wants to remember that a couple years after she disappeared, pieces of a plane just like hers were found on an island a few 10's of miles short of her next stop. At the same spot the skeletal remains of a man and a woman were found with personal effects known to be hers. Someone (probably the family) wanted to keep that 'mystery' going with what was probably denial at first but became their own cash cow later.
- mcherm 9y ago>At the same spot the skeletal remains of a man and a woman were found with personal effects known to be hers. I hadn't heard that. Do you have any references?
- cag_ii 9y agoAssuming the OP is referencing the "Gardner Island hypothesis", there's a couple of references on the wikipedia page synopsis: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amelia_Earhart#Speculation_on_disappearance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amelia_Earhart#Speculation_on_... This one in particular is an interesting read: https://tighar.org/Publications/TTracks/14_2/14_2bones.pdf https://tighar.org/Publications/TTracks/14_2/14_2bones.pdf
- roryisok 9y agoNothing about that on Wikipedia. Have you a source please?
- WalterBright 9y agoThere's no particular mystery. Navigation in those days was rudimentary - not good enough to fly long distances across the Pacific and try to hit a tiny island at the limit of your fuel. She missed the island, ran out of fuel, and crashed into the Pacific. I saw a documentary on her long ago, and she was known to be sloppy in navigation, careless in handling the airplane, arrogant in dealing with her navigator, and would take unnecessary risks with the weather. It's all a recipe for disaster when taking a high risk flight. It's all too easy to die in an airplane if you don't have a mania for doing it perfectly every time. People also had a hard time believing JFK Jr died because of a perfectly mundane mistake on a routine flight.
- shawnbaden 9y agoThis reminded me of a passage on pilot checklists from The Checklist Manifesto by Atul Gawande: > Commercial pilots have been using checklists for decades. Gawande traces this back to a fly-off at Wright Field, Ohio, in 1935, when the Army Air Force was choosing its new bomber. Boeing's entry, the B-17, would later be built by the thousands, but on that first flight it took off, stalled, crashed and burned. The new airplane was complicated, and the pilot, who was highly experienced, had forgotten a routine step. > > From http://old.seattletimes.com/html/books/2010737113_br08checklist.html http://old.seattletimes.com/html/books/2010737113_br08checkl...
- WalterBright 9y agoLindbergh, on the other hand, was extremely careful and meticulous. He knew exactly where the risks were, and minimized them as much as possible. His only mistake was not taking some amphetamines along (he fell asleep and nearly crashed).
- nikdaheratik 9y agoIt's kind of funny how the "History" channel is turning into the "Unsolved Mysteries" channel. Maybe they'll buy up the rights to re-air that old show and go full retro with UFO conspiracies and the like.