9 ms·
You seem to exist in a fictional universe where pulseaudio "got good" and doesn't suck. All these years later I have never seen that be the case. I think a much
by asveikau 9y ago
You seem to exist in a fictional universe where pulseaudio "got good" and doesn't suck. All these years later I have never seen that be the case. I think a much more likely explanation is that desktop Linux is less common since the rise of OS X in the "Unix-like developer machine" market so there are now fewer people noticing it sucks.
- pcr0 9y agoI was one of those developers with an OS X machine who decided to buy a Thinkpad and throw Ubuntu on it. pulseaudio worked out of the box for me and I definitely preferred it over the stunted OS X audio mixer that doesn't even let you define per-application audio.
- isatty 9y agoThe MacOS mixer is pretty much the epitome of "just works" even though I agree with you that it doesn't let you control levels per application. However I've been using the MacOS sound system (not just the mixer) for many years through many devices (mics, external dacs, HDMI transports, DP etc) and it has always worked without any problems.
- pfranz 9y agoI don't have much personal experience, but I /often/ hear about OSX users very wary of updating MacOS because of issues with sound equipment. This goes back to Classic. It may have gone away in the past 3-5 years, but the stigma is still there.
- Rjevski 9y agoWhat were your problems exactly? In my case I used Linux full time from late 2012 to early 2014 and during that time I haven't had a single problem related to it, all while running bleeding edge Archlinux. The only issue was with bluetooth headphones but I'm pretty sure it was more with BlueZ being a pile of garbage than Pulseaudio being bad, given that BlueZ was giving me problems with all sorts of other (non sound) peripherals as well.
- LukeShu 9y agoAre you actually using PulseAudio? Having run Arch (well, Parabola) since 2011, I haven't had any problems with PulseAudio... because I've never installed PulseAudio. Actually, I did have a problem with Wine and lib32-libpulse lagging slightly behind the video (where it's only a fraction of a second off, but enough that it doesn't feel like the words match the faces); and then I figured out how to get Wine to use ALSA, just like everything else.
- BeetleB 9y agoI tried installing it a few months ago, and... could not get any sound. Similar experience several years ago. I'm sure I could Google and fix, but for me, it did not "just work". Don't get me wrong. For years, ALSA was a pain. But in the last 10 years, ALSA has always "just worked" for me. I think the only time I had to fiddle with ALSA in the last decade was to get the mic on a headset to work.
- jhasse 9y agoFor me, "Just Works" includes me not having to install it at all, not it being easy to set-up on LFS. Pulseaudio is pre-installed on Fedora, Ubuntu, etc.
- boomboomsubban 9y agoALSA is part of the kernel, it's likely been pre-installed in every Linux you have ever run. It's not a mark against it that you choose to install distros developed to use pulseaudio.
- BeetleB 9y agoWell, that's almost what I had. It didn't come preinstalled, but it's in the package manager. I installed it, and, no sound.
- asveikau 9y agoMostly the same issues as BeetleB. It purports to pump audio samples. It does not. Another moving piece in between your app and ALSA, which seems to break down inexplicably when the crap that it's abstracting "just works" with zero configuration. Many times the solution to an audio problem on linux is to get rid of pulse. Still. Also had issues with bluetooth, as you seem to have. I will permit the idea that this is possibly unrelated (bluez is garbage, yes), but bluetooth audio was working for me previously, and only broke when pulse entered the picture. FWIW from an API perspective I still think OSS seems better than ALSA... Linux audio seems to be a repeated case of people confusing interface with implementation, and the interface only ever gets more complex.
- SwellJoe 9y agoI believe the universe I exist in is real, but how would I know for sure? Anyway, I haven't had to google about a pulseaudio problem in at least a few years. I've been using Linux as my primary desktop OS since 1995. I've hated Linux audio for most of that time, and I've broken it in every possible way. But, today, my Fedora system has sound that Just Works. I don't know how it Just Works (though I know it's pulseaudio), because I haven't had to learn...because it Just Works. It works for Steam games, it works for browser audio, it works for system notifications, it works for movies, it even works for audio and music software. It's pretty weird. Anyway, from what I can tell, the bugs, misfeatures, poorly thought out implementation, etc. all got worked out somewhere along the way. It took a long time. But, it did get fixed. Have you actually used it in the past couple of years?
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoI did try to use it and discovered that it's impossible to configure mpd to run as a system service and be able to play sound while also allowing desktop applications to play sound. I forget all the details, but the way I figured out how to get sound to do what I wanted was to enable alsa dmix and to pipe everything possible through dmix, using pulseaudio only for the one or two essential apps that insist on it.
- perakojotgenije 9y agoFunny, I just did that yesterday. I was reconfiguring my mpd server and I saw it was configured to use alsa (which, incidentally broke my sound occasionally). I set it up to use Pulseaudio and now I can listen to mpd server while listening to deezer.com that runs through browser while making a skype call on the same machine (not that I'd want to do it, anyway).
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoWhen you log out of your desktop session, does mpd continue playing? I have mpd setup to stream via icecast so I can listen to my music remotely and the issue I was having was that when I logged out of my desktop, the music would stop playing because the sound server was tied to my desktop session.
- shmerl 9y agoNever had issues with PulseAudio in the recent times. I use Linux for all my desktop needs, including gaming. Of course if you have specific audio needs that require more realtime processing, you can for example use Jack.
- gribbly 9y agoI haven't used PulseAudio until very recently when Firefox started requiring it for audio (chrome/chromium still support plain ALSA), that said I haven't come across any problem, what should I be looking out for ?
- petepete 9y agoNothing really, it's fine for nearly everything and just tends to get on with the job. The only bug that's affected me in the last couple of years was that the default volume on USB headsets was always set way too low. Pavucontrol helped sort it out https://freedesktop.org/software/pulseaudio/pavucontrol/ https://freedesktop.org/software/pulseaudio/pavucontrol/
- Crespyl 9y agoThe only problem I've had recently is that I can't seem to split up different ports on the same card (optical home theatre/soundbar for music, desktop stereo for everything else), but that's not something I was able to do with ALSA anyway. Something to do with opening the card in different profiles I think.
- aexaey 9y agoMostly minor things nowadays. I've seen so far: - a while ago pa got audio routing wrong on a new/obscure laptop, wrong audio routing as in - speakers would not turn off if you plug in headphones. That eventually got fixed with dnf upgrade and no effort on my part; - on ultrabook, pa sucks noticeable amount of battery by waking up 100 times a second (while no audio is being played). Something akin to what this poor chap is describing: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fedora/comments/6d7776/pulseaudio_battery_usage/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Fedora/comments/6d7776/pulseaudio_b...
- petre 9y agoOS X in incresingly less Unix-like with every new version. They even changed its name back to MacOS.
- eridius 9y agoYou mean "macOS". But I don't see the relevance. Is it because the name no longer contains an "x" character? The X in OS X had no relation to unix, it was because it was the successor to MacOS 9 (and in fact the full name was originally Mac OS X).
- petre 9y agoThey even advertised it as Unix-like. https://www.apple.com/media/us/osx/2012/docs/OSX_for_UNIX_Users_TB_July2011.pdf https://www.apple.com/media/us/osx/2012/docs/OSX_for_UNIX_Us... We are using it for develoment but it's considerably more work to setup the develoment environment than installing a Linux distribution with everything we need available by default or a command away. Also in El Capitan the root user is disabled by default. http://www.infoworld.com/article/2988096/mac-os-x/sorry-unix-fans-os-x-el-capitan-kills-root.html http://www.infoworld.com/article/2988096/mac-os-x/sorry-unix...
- lloeki 9y ago> installing a Linux distribution Linux != Unix. Darwin is much closer to BSD. > Also in El Capitan the root user is disabled by default. Lies. I never touched a thing and (on 10.13 ß): $ sudo su -l password: Galileo:~ root# ps -u root | wc -l 115 - You can't log into the UI as root (by default), and that is a good thing. - SEP prevents you (or any random script/software/installer you run) from meddling with system files and that is a good thing too, no different from sensible SELinux or AppArmor policies.
- acdha 9y agoWhat all are you lumping into dev environment setup? For many years most projects have only needed two steps (CLI toolchain install, Homebrew) plus the project specific setup.
- reitanqild 9y agoUser of desktop linux here (after 3 years of trying and failing with OS X). Also people at work are allowed to use desktop linux at work as long as we don't bother IT. (This with a serious company with even older more seriois roots.) I think desktop linux is still on the rise.
- aexaey 9y agoVery much this. The only big change with pa in last few years is - applications accepted and embraced it - to the point of dropping OSS & ALSA.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoI personally hope Linux application developers support PipeWire as it becomes available so that the usability issues around low-latency audio in Linux can be sorted out (i.e. it works out of the box): https://blogs.gnome.org/uraeus/2017/06/20/fedora-workstation-26-and-beyond/ https://blogs.gnome.org/uraeus/2017/06/20/fedora-workstation...
- digi_owl 9y agoI really hate seeing how Firefox on Linux is spiraling the drain in this regard. First GTK3, then PA. There really is a changing of the guard in Linux userspace, and the change is for the worse.
- mijoharas 9y agoTo be fair, pulseaudio has stopped causing me problems, which in my book is equivalent to "got good". Now if only the same could be said for bluez...
- jchw 9y agoMaybe you really do live in a different universe, because my audio sounds good and I legitimately can't remember the last time I had to worry about it. It's been years, and now for the first time on Desktop Linux I can connect a Bluetooth or USB audio device without wondering if I could actually coax my software into using it.