4 ms·
> same technology stack (HTML5 video+JS) for DRM-ful video as for DRM-free video this isn't a pro in my books - i want DRM to be a difficult and cumbersome sta
by chii 9y ago
> same technology stack (HTML5 video+JS) for DRM-ful video as for DRM-free video
this isn't a pro in my books - i want DRM to be a difficult and cumbersome stack to use. More specifically, i want the end user to go through hassle to obtain the proprietary plugins, so that the end user feels the hurt from DRM. This makes a non-DRM version much more simple to view (just click and play), so that users would vote with their wallet, and use the non-DRM version (and avoid the DRM version).
If making DRM video easy to play for end users is the goal, then yes, web-DRM is doing it. But it will make DRM more prevailent, as end users will have no reason to try avoid DRM, thus, making web less open.
- agentdrtran 9y ago> i want DRM to be a difficult and cumbersome stack to use. More specifically, i want the end user to go through hassle to obtain the proprietary plugins, so that the end user feels the hurt from DRM. so you want to make stuff like netflix as much of a PITA as possible? why? why be this vindictive?
- izacus 9y agoNo, we want to make Netflix pushing DRM as PITA as possible. Video streaming without DRM works just fine. (And please don't come back with "Netflix has no choice BS", they're happily doing all the nasty DRM crap for their own production as well.)
- hopeaboutthis 9y agoi agree with netflix, straight up. they invest quite a lot in infrastructure and production to provide these videos, and making it simpler for average folks to get their protected videos in a profitable manner is a win for everyone except idealistic pirates. i don't get why i'd care about the needs of the people who want to ruin a fertile ecosystem for some abstract principle.
- CuriousSkeptic 9y agoWith DRM+streaming as default the world will be relying on rights holders and streaming services to preserve an archive of cultural works. A situation that invariably will result in loss of a lot of those works once they stop caring or go out of business. Consider f.ex. the situation with the missing Dr. Who episodes. BBC is still hopping it can recover copies from the public. Had they'd been aired with DRM at the time they would be lost without hope, now at least there is hope.
- josteink 9y ago> you want to make stuff like netflix as much of a PITA as possible? Not op but yes, using DRM in a browser should be hard. Netflix should just make a native app, like everyone else who needs drm do. This clearly scopes what is open and webby and what is closed and DRMy. Nobody has issues installing Spotify to stream music. What makes Netflix special?
- icebraining 9y agoNobody has issues installing Spotify to stream music. Spotify does have a web player using web DRM (Widevine) and a lot of people use it exclusively.
- hsivonen 9y ago> Netflix should just make a native app, like everyone else who needs drm do. The native app security model on desktop (i.e. can do anything) doesn't make the notion of letting streaming services run native apps look so great. Do you really prefer giving streaming services (not just Netflix but others too) fully-privileged code execution instead of having an operating system or browser vendors exercise some oversight?
- librarian42 9y agoNetflix chooses to use DRM. That's completely on them.
- pvg 9y agoThat's a very principled position but it should not surprise you that any position with 'make things shittier for users' as a key component is unlikely to be well-received by any and all of: standards bodies, browser vendors, content providers, website developers, users, sane people and many others.
- izacus 9y agoContent providers have happily made experience utterly shitty by adding DRM with no regards to users. I don't think they care about your experience a lot.
- pvg 9y agoThey seem to care quite a bit. For instance, browser-based DRM and constrained devices have made the experience vastly better than it was just a few years ago. No plugins, you can download content for offline viewing, etc. So I'm not really seeing how they're making it utterly shitty.
- syshum 9y agoOnly if you use a Popular Platform like Android or Windows. If you use less popular platforms (Linux, Ubuntu Phone, etc) DRM makes it impossible to access content you paid for. Also if you Root Android, or modify the "approved" platforms in anyway... BAM the DRM kicks you out of your paid for content as well
- kelnos 9y agoSure, but for the vast majority of users, the experience is much better. You can certainly argue that they should care more about minority users such as yourself (and me, Linux desktop user here), but it's a hard sell when the cost of the development and maintenance effort exceeds the revenue brought in. I don't think there's a great solution here. Content producers believe that DRM reduces copyright infringement to a level that they're at least somewhat comfortable with. Whether that's true or not is irrelevant; it's how they feel about it that matters. Making playback harder for the average customer isn't in anyone's best interests.
- kelnos 9y agoThis already happened. We had Flash and Silverlight. This didn't make the Netflixes of the world drop DRM, and it didn't make customers flee for DRM-free solutions. All it did was decrease security for all of us. But yes, you do have a point that making DRM easier will likely make more content producers consider and implement DRM than before. I'm not sure there is a good solution to this right now, and yours is just vindictive and actively harmful.
- chii 9y ago> We had Flash and Silverlight. and when apple decides to drop flash support, what happened? Did netflix or any other video content producer suddenly decide to stop supporting those devices? No, they went with html5 video (and at that time, free of DRM). That was a great step forward for DRM free content for the web. By making the web standard include a mechnism to include DRM natively, this means content producers once again will have a hassle free way to include DRM. The end user won't care as long as they can get their content, but the slippery slope is there, and one day, the web will only contain content that is DRM'ed (and there would be no way of format shifting, or saving the video for offline viewing or sharing). That is not the web I want to see in 5/10 year's time, and the way to stop that is to prevent the cracks from appearing. It's actively harmful to consumers of content producing companies, but only if those companies do not move to DRM free platforms. But because companies ultimately have to make the user experience smooth, forcing them off DRM like this to make a smooth user experience is worth it in my books.
- Mindwipe 9y ago> and when apple decides to drop flash support, what happened? Did netflix or any other video content producer suddenly decide to stop supporting those devices? No, they went with html5 video (and at that time, free of DRM). That was a great step forward for DRM free content for the web. Unambiguously, no, they didn't. They used applications that had Playready or Adobe Access or Widevine built in, or a little bit later they used Apple FairPlay inside the browser. Some also used root level Apple certificates to limit streams to iOS devices only. Unambiguously, this argument is factually false.
- 9y ago
- om2 9y agoUnfortunately, "Get the browser that makes it harder to watch Netflix! On purpose!" is not a winning marketing message.
- chii 9y agoor, if DRM-free streaming is there, "get netflix on all your devices with a browser, no plugin or installation needed! Netflix everywhere, on your fridge, on your car's video player etc"
- librarian42 9y ago> i want DRM to be a difficult and cumbersome stack to use Exactly. Even flash plugins are too easy, really, so long as flash is ubiquitous. NOW would be the time to hit it, as flash is less common (almost completely absent on mobile) and silverlight is deprecated. Imagine if Apple and Microsoft and Real had agreed on an easy and ubiquitous plugin framework for music DRM. We would still be dealing with near-universal DRM for music today.