3 ms·
Using simplification to make predictions about reality ≠ "having a fantasy". The entire mode of operation of science involves being aware that one's approach i
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Using simplification to make predictions about reality ≠ "having a fantasy".
The entire mode of operation of science involves being aware that one's approach is less than absolutely accurate. The advance of science certainly debunked vitalist views of nature as some irreducible essence. It's a "common trope" to equate to such debunking into turning nature into a machine but nature itself remains as it is regardless of our ideas.
- beebmam 9y agoDisagree. A model is not reality, and is indeed a fantasy. Scientists should be (and usually are) well aware of this. Importantly, the documentary explores some historical examples of where these models were used to attempt to understand, predict, and shape human behavior. Some might find the use of models in these ways immoral, and in my opinion the documentary does a pretty good job of exploring it.
- joe_the_user 9y agoThe linguistic sense of the fantasy is of an idea of dubious value. But you (and the OP) seem to take position that one can use the term for any idea. If we're going to operate that way, I could just as well say that your claim that "A model is not reality, and is indeed a fantasy." is itself a "fantasy".