18 ms·
A Year After ‘Pokémon Go,’ Where Are the Augmented-Reality Hits?
- greenscale 9y agoI've played Pokémon Go quite a bit since it released, and I turned off AR mode within the first few weeks of playing. It's just a gimmick, and it gets old pretty fast, kinda like the '3D movies' fad.
- mtrpcic 9y agoI did the same thing. The interesting part of Pokemon Go was the geographical aspect of the game (which was really pioneered with Ingress, but became much more popular with the addition of the Pokemon IP). The AR was very gimmicky, and I honestly found it to be a distraction whenever it was turned on.
- vivekd 9y agoI still enjoy 3d movies.
- greenscale 9y agoGranted, sometimes gimmicks can be enjoyable. But in the case of AR in Pokemon Go (and IMO most 3D movies) they just distract from the actual content.
- nsxwolf 9y agoIn theaters, with the right treatment and the right film, 3D can be totally awesome. I haven't heard a lot of people talk about the 3D in Rogue One, but I'm very glad I saw it that way.
- fiatjaf 9y agoThat was very stupid. I thought it would actually let you see the world as if Pokémon were in it, but it was basically just a picture in a camera background.
- nitwit005 9y agoI don't see that as particularly unusual. With many video games the graphics can become a nuisance, particularly with mobile games or RPGs where you end up waiting for animations to complete over and over.
- awad 9y agoDidn't play the game at all, but saw my entire office be captivated by the phenomenon. Pretty much everyone turned off the AR within a day. Not sure that ever mattered as much as the location aspect...which I think really speaks to something that Dennis at Foursquare has been talking about for ~10 years now. Pokemon took that mainstream, for a hot second anyway, but in reality the value is in the convergence of social, local, and mobile...or what some might parody as SoLoMo on hit HBO TV shows. Also, 3D movies only seem to be getting better. Pretty sure it's not a fad at this point.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoAnd also the problem was that they made catching pokémon harder in AR mode. I quite liked the AR gimmick, but I turned it off because (1) it made my 3-year-old phone more prone to lag and sucked battery like crazy, and (2) I found out pokémon would stay much more still without AR.
- oDot 9y agoPokemon Go is a hit because of Pokemon and location tracking, not AR
- toxican 9y agoThe AR was a fun little gimmick and it was the subject of the early articles about the game (Pokemon IRL!!!). But I personally turned it off a few days in because of how much of an increased battery drain it was and having to position yourself in front of the Pokemon in order to catch it. Much less frustrating to do things without the AR.
- mjevans 9y agoI say 'was'. The more they try to make it a pointless grind-numbing micro-battle game over an actual hunt for completion (and pulling me towards places I /don't/ already go) game the less I want to play. I think they'd have to either add a tracking over time feature or restore the radar that used to exist for me to get back in to it.
- bsamuels 9y agothe "radar" is back. instead of using the old 1-3 steps system to gauge distance, it says which pokestop the pokemon is closest to
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sotojuan 9y agoThe AR of Pokémon GO is the same as the 3D of the 3DS - it was a big part of the promotional material and hype for it but a year after release everyone has it turned off.
- fiatjaf 9y agoReally? I always liked the 3D of 3DS! But since I've never played one for more than 30min I guess I can't speak on that.
- CM30 9y agoHeck, it's just like the 3DS AR functionality, which ended up being a fairly big part of the console's promotional material/hype but got thrown to the wayside about a year or so in. I mean, when was the last AR game you played on the 3DS after the built in stuff and maybe Spirit Camera? Just like with AR functionality on phones, the functionality on the 3DS just didn't turn out to be that useful or interesting for video games.
- bm5k 9y agoI still play my 3ds almost exclusively with 3D on. My uncorrected vision is bad enough that I have to turn it off if I'm not wearing my glasses. However the AR of pokémon go actually makes the game harder IMO, so it's only on in the rare instances I feel the need to take an in-game photo. Also, pokego is a significant battery drain on my primary device. I feel like leaving the camera on all the time would just kill the battery faster. OTOH I don't really care if the 3d effect kills my 3ds faster. My gaming sessions aren't as mission critical as my phone battery.
- voltagex_ 9y agoPokemon Go was the first time I saw "most" people walking around with an external battery for their phones. I was hoping it'd really take off and phone manufacturers might finally put decent sized batteries in flagship phones.
- SurrealSoul 9y agoAR has been around for quite a while, but it won't kick off like VR will. I tried a few Hololens 'experiences' and the only thing I remotely enjoyed was leaving basically a notepad window on my cube wall. The "Games" really don't break the immersion levels like VR does. If I saw a bird fly at me in AR, I wouldn't flinch, but seeing a bird fly at my in VR may cause me head to weave a bit.
- Impossible 9y agoA rare internet comment that is the inverse of the now, cliche "VR is niche and AR will be (or is... if you consider pokemon go AR) mainstream" AR needs to get a lot better before its immersive, and there might be limits to displays that make true hard AR impossible or unlikely. I think most of the mainstream use cases that people imagine for AR are pretty basic, ie text and icon overlays over video, so immersion isn't viewed as an important aspect. In the context of games I think it's hard to design a good AR game because you don't have control over the environment the player is in. It does open up a lot of fun location based ideas though. I also kind of like the idea of hybrid physical digital games although those will always be niche due to costs and setup friction.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zimpenfish 9y agoIgnoring immersivity etc., the sheer number of people who can partake in AR vs VR means that AR will kick off hugely more than VR. AR can be used practically anywhere, by almost anyone, on a consumer-level phone. VR, by contrast, requires a fixed space, a certain amount of physical wellness, and expensive equipment.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jerf 9y agoOne could argue it wasn't "augmented reality" at all. I doubt cell phones have the power to take their camera feed in, do actual computer vision to analyze the (arbitrary) world [1], and then overlay anything with any interesting intelligence at all. (Even if you can scrape together the specs to say that high end phones might be able to do nontrivial work, I wouldn't be surprised you hit problems like internal hardware bandwidths and such. Even before we discuss battery, which Pokemon Go certainly chewed down pretty well even without complex analysis.) Pokemon Go was just a character laid over the camera with no intelligence. [1]: I have to qualify this because the 3DS can do some things with certain prepared cards, and cell phones nowadays outclass the 3DS quite handily. But doing any sort of analysis without such hints, which certainly have not taken off, is way harder. https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=3ds+augmented+reality+cards https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=3ds+augmented+r...
- karkisuni 9y agoI guess you haven't seen ARKit yet?
- CodeCube 9y agoheh, no kidding :) https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ARKit&page=&utm_source=opensearch https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ARKit&page=&utm... Even though, to his point, he's technically correct, it was just a "dumb" overlay. However, part of the excitement of the game was that you could see it in the world (both physically by having to walk around to catch it, and visually via the AR). I'm surprised you didn't see people posting pictures of pokemon in funny locations/situations back when it was really popular
- e0 9y agoThey did! For example, https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonGoSnap/top/?sort=top&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonGoSnap/top/?sort=top&t=all
- jerryr 9y agoThere was an app called Minecraft Reality back in 2012 that would seem to prove otherwise: https://mojang.com/2012/11/announcing-minecraft-reality-for-ios/ https://mojang.com/2012/11/announcing-minecraft-reality-for-... It placed a Minecraft creation into your environment in realtime. Though it seemed mostly like a tech demo without much of a point, it was pretty impressive when I played with it.
- fiatjaf 9y agoInstagram glasses floating around the person and other shitty stuff are more AR than Pokémon.
- habosa 9y agoIt's interesting that almost all of the comments here assume that the 'AR' in Pokemon Go was showing the Pokemon character in the camera viewfinder during the catching sequence. Is it not also AR to have many invisible creatures, gyms, and resources placed in the real world? I don't think there needs to be a visual component at all for it to be AR. When I used to play the game my reality was augmented because everywhere I went I thought "I wonder what Pokemon are around" and would check the app. A seamless visual integration would be nice (I want to see some Pokemon battle in my living room) but even just the Ingress-style map integration is AR in my opinion.
- greenscale 9y agoInteresting point. I'm not sure what the actual definition of AR is, but the article seems to assume the same definition that several others did, including myself: > "the nascent technology, which blends digital images with a person’s view of the real world."
- marcosdumay 9y agoThe specific term for this AR technique is "image overlay".
- simcop2387 9y agoI think this is part of the reason I've been seeing the phrase "mixed reality" be used to refer to what was previously AR. edit: correct mixed relative to mixed reality. brane fart.
- XaspR8d 9y agoI think this is exactly what the media is trying to get at when they refer to Pokemon Go as an "AR" game, and I'm surprised most folks in this thread are missing the mark. Seeing as plenty of companies are wanting to cash in on the visual definition of AR, perhaps we need a differentiated term here? If you wanted to highlight the locational aspect, perhaps something like "augmented cartography" but I think the idea goes beyond harnessing position data... it's more generally about annotating reality, in a way.
- lwansbrough 9y agoShocker: the popularity of Pokemon Go wasn't that it was AR, it was that it was Pokemon. Anyone who thought they could capitalize on a new AR market after the release of Pokemon Go had absolutely no idea what the market wanted.
- yoodenvranx 9y agoAs someone who played a lot of Ingress: I _really_ wish a competent company would enter the AR market! Yes, Niantic had success with Ingress amd PoGo but literally everything they ever did they did in the most stupid and brain-dead way. I would still play Ingress today but after 3 years I am beyond frustrated with that company and lost any drive to invest any more time and energy. What makes me sad is the fact that Ingress still has so much untapped potential but at the same time I know that Niantic is unable to do anything with that potential.
- will_pseudonym 9y agoAnd the same could be said of PoGo.
- mort96 9y agoEvery since the last patch there has been a bug where if person A of one team takes down a gym and puts in a pokemon, person B of the same team has to wait half an hour before they can put in their pokemon, getting a "The gym is under attack!" error message before those ~30 minutes. The one core gameplay feature, taking down gyms together with one or more friends, has been broken for almost two weeks. The incompetence is staggering. There are workarounds (everyone have to insert their pokemon at the exact same time), but that's besides the point.
- croon 9y agoI agree that's very annoying, but it's: A) Only 5 or 10 minutes, definitely not 30 B) If both/all team members are present in the fight, they all have "claim" to the gym afterwards, and this works. I've tested both cases.
- mort96 9y agoI don't know about A, I just know it's far too long to just hang around and wait, but regarding B: I'm certain that when my brother and I have taken over a gym together, both present in the fight, and one have put in a pokemon before the other, the other can't insert a pokemon because "The gym is under attack".
- rabboRubble 9y agoI come from a country family with lots of family. I broke a different way, and I'm citified. They hunt. I don't. After playing Pokémon Go for a while, I finally realized that the act of playing PMG is like hunting & stalking for deer/elk/whatever, but without needing a weapon, ammo, training, safety gear, or bloodshed. So after factoring in all the extra exercise, a win for the city girl :-) I think to replicate PMG's success, the next game has to tickle that same hunter driver. What's the new new thing that people want to hunt and track down? If we identify this, we will have the next winning AR game.
- beezischillin 9y agoBringing up Pokemon GO and the AR games that didn't happen in this time and point in history is a bit weird - Apple's announcement kinda prepares to bring AR to the mainstream by giving everyone with their hardware a competent, stable platform for that, coming this September. When the market is provided for the taking and a platform behind it, in my opinion, developers will flock to create just those applications. But, I mean, a year from now? Maybe if adoption doesn't pick up by then let's ask the same question and see what conclusions we can draw.
- bitwize 9y agoAR is waiting for Apple to truly invent it.
- jeremynixon 9y agoPass the paywall: https://t.co/z5MeavGpkg https://t.co/z5MeavGpkg
- kronos29296 9y agoHow did you do that?
- aresant 9y agoWhere are the hits? - AR powers the world's #1 Photo App (#3 most popular app overall) in Snapchat's filters. - AR is getting its first commercially polished, OS level set of libraries in the next release from the world's most valuable consumer electronics company in iOS 11. - AR's killer form factor - wearable glasses - is being furiously developed by Google, Apple, SNAP, MSFT, etc, etc and it's going to be weird and fucking wonderful when AR has a truly suitable foundation to build on. So where are the hits? All around us, right in front of us.
- sillysaurus3 9y ago- AR's killer form factor - wearable glasses Unlikely. I've elaborated on this in the past. Basically: You cannot make things dark. You can't use LCD type technology to block part of the lenses for the same reason you can't see scratches on your lenses: you're not focused on your lenses! You're focused in the distance. That means the ideal of having crisp, readable text overlays is mostly a fantasy. You can prove this yourself: get a piece of tape, write some text on it, and put it over your lenses. You can't read the text. You can even use clear tape to simulate what a real overlay would look like. The second problem is power. Oculus makes sense because you're tethered to a high-end workhorse. When you're using glasses, you have neither a video card nor a huge source of power at your disposal. That means battery technology would need to improve by a massive amount just to make the glasses not die within hours. The third issue is target recognition. The real world is instant. That means any overlay you use would need to attain 90FPS to appear seamless. If you're going to do the most basic thing with an AR device -- drawing an arrow on the ground, indicating where to walk, a'la Google Maps -- you'll need to recognize the ground + render the overlay within 11 milliseconds. This might work for a ground-based overlay, since you can assume it's a flat plane in a big city, as long as your gyroscope is accurate enough. But where would you even stick a gyroscope with that kind of precision inside a glasses form factor? The best form factor for this would probably be some kind of "bandana", where the meat of the device sits on the back of your head. That'd look dorky and it'd be uncomfortable, but you might be able to pull it off. The only way this might work is if you use LCD tech to dim the entirety of both lenses enough to then project light on top of them. But again, your focusing out in the distance, so trying to show anything readable (text messages) seems kind of a fantasy. Here's proof: Pull out your phone and hold it up to your eye where lenses of glasses would normally be. I'm not sure if you could even render it in a way that would account for the focus blur.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- extra88 9y agoSomewhat relevant, here's the researcher who made the Super Marios Bros. AR talking about what went into making it. The title references Unity3D but he spends very little time on the game engine. To me, the more interesting parts are about the challenges of using the Hololens outdoors over a relatively large area. https://youtu.be/Rcw7nB7_Los?t=732 https://youtu.be/Rcw7nB7_Los?t=732 original video: Super Mario Bros Recreated as Life Size Augmented Reality Game https://youtu.be/QN95nNDtxjo https://youtu.be/QN95nNDtxjo
- gozur88 9y agoI think industrial uses of AR will be bigger than games. Showing people where to find parts, bringing up additional data, comparing what you see with what you're supposed to be seeing... all that would be highly useful.
- hsod 9y agoI'd love a more passive version of Pokemon Go. I very quickly got tired of walking around with my face buried in my phone, or having to leave it open and unlocked when walking to hatch eggs. I'd love an AR game which gathered your real-life location data but allowed you to do the actual playing when you're back at home.
- kagamine 9y agoHaving to keep the phone unlocked while walking is a killer, the battery dies pretty fast. How is that I can go for a run and fitness apps can track me via geo-location, serving notifications as I go, but PG can't?
- dEnigma 9y agoIndeed, I always try to keep it in energy saving mode by having it bottom side up in my pocket. But when I want to listen to music too, I have to orient my phone the other way because of the headphone jack, which causes the screen to stay on. Since my smartphone is a few years old, the battery doesn't last very long that way. Quite annoying.
- paul7986 9y agoNever use a measuring tape again... http://armeasure.com/ http://armeasure.com/ Game changing apps like the one above (at least it is to me) are coming to the iPhone 8. Thanks in part to Apple's AR Kit and ingenious developers.
- transitorykris 9y agoSmall correction, ARKit works on as little as iPhone 6s with reasonable accuracy.
- nippples 9y agoAR won't be worthwhile until: 1) It has a window to the AR larger than a wallet 2) It doesn't hog one of my hands for holding said window into the AR 3) Actually takes into consideration the the environment it's supposed to augment Decent AR technology will probably be branched from current VR technologies, rather than mobile phones.
- weego 9y agoWhere were the genuine World of Warcraft alternatives a few years later? Sometimes a big hit is just a big hit in itself and not a genre creator.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIf you swap Everquest or Ultima Online for Warcraft in your question, then you have your hits that the were genre creators, and the alternatives that arrived a few years later (Warcraft, Eve Online, Club Penguin, Guild Wars, D&D Online, etc...) Or if you want to focus on Warcraft as the big hit that popularized the genre, then we can see that the secondary MMOs of today are over 10x size of the biggest MMO pre-Warcraft (Everquest peaked at around 600k subscriber, Elder Scrolls Online has over 8 million). No one game has been as big as WoW, but it did grow the overall market massively.
- davidmurdoch 9y agoTotally self-promoting here... But I'm making a new location-based game right now called Terra Mango. Instead of some buildings being pokestops or gyms, every building in the real world is intractable. We're not using the camera for AR at all though. It's only AR because where you are in the real world determines what you can interact with in the game.