12 ms·
These companies are going to get absolutely destroyed when the big supermarkets come on tap. Several are working on identical services where you pick up, curbs
by Someone1234 9y ago
These companies are going to get absolutely destroyed when the big supermarkets come on tap.
Several are working on identical services where you pick up, curbside, the ingredients and instructions in a bag, and pay significantly less for doing so.
Why have your ingredients mailed to you when a supermarket on your way home will offer the same thing for 50% cheaper?
- handedness 9y agoWhile I don't disagree, people said the same thing about Amazon. The supermarkets have changed very little about the way they've done business in the last half-century, and as such I have a difficult time imagining them doing a good job executing on something like this. I've also tested the majority of the meal and food delivery services out there, and my experience meshes well with the above: the local supermarket chain in some ways provides a better offering than anyone (as they should–you're absolutely right about that), but for a few years now they've persisted in making sure the actual execution is the worst I've experienced of any service. I can't see that changing until they completely overhaul their hiring practices and put sufficient processes in place to ensure good execution. (For the record, Blue Apron strikes me as a pretty mediocre product at a pretty uninteresting price, executed in a pretty bad manner.)
- sharkmerry 9y ago>> While I don't disagree, people said the same thing about Amazon. just to play devil's avocado, Amazon's advantage was not having the overhead of stores, now they just purchased whole foods. Seems as if they are moving towards being a supermarket
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- handedness 9y agoSorry, I was referring to how it was obvious to so many that Barnes & Noble and Borders would crush this fledgling website founded by the kook who set out in a van to compete with them.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y ago> Sorry, I was referring to how it was obvious to so many that Barnes & Noble and Borders would crush this fledgling website founded by the kook who set out in a van to compete with them. I remember Amazon's launch quite well, and I don't remember any of that sentiment. The first time I used Amazon I remember thinking "Wow, books are the perfect thing to sell online." I feel like it's become part of a standard origin mythology to play up the founder as "some kook with a crazy dream" that everyone else thought was insane. I think that's rarely the case, and is instead played up in an effort of founder worship.
- code_duck 9y agoThere was some of that... generally, skepticism that internet startups would become large enough to challenge businesses like Walmart, ever. https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericjackson/2015/09/24/revisiting-amazon-dot-bomb-16-years-later/#6b40b816b08f https://www.forbes.com/sites/ericjackson/2015/09/24/revisiti... And also people saying things like tiny businesses of people with bookstores in their spare time will make Amazon obsolete... https://mobile.nytimes.com/1999/02/26/opinion/foreign-affairs-amazonyou.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/1999/02/26/opinion/foreign-affair... Ah, Thomas Friedman. Thanks for the advice to not buy amazon stock in 1999.
- imron 9y agoOut of curiosity, I went to have a look at AMZN's stock price at the date the article was published, to see how the stock price during the heady heights of the dotcom bubble compared to today. Interestingly, if you view the entire stock history price chart, the dotcom bubble is barely a blip.
- sokoloff 9y agoIMO, the right way to look at long-term performance of an investment is on a semi-log chart. (Day or week charts, I prefer linear; anything 3 month or longer, I prefer semi-log.) Semi-log (where constant percentage changes are constant-sized), it's more than a blip. Linear (where constant dollar changes are constant-sized) charting hides past market moves if the overall bias has been up and exaggerates past market moves if the overall bias has been down. This can lead investors to improperly discount the pain/gain cycle that happened over that time period. Linear charting: http://bit.ly/2tk5Ulj http://bit.ly/2tk5Ulj Semi log: http://bit.ly/2sJs7ec http://bit.ly/2sJs7ec
- Gaelan 9y ago> devil's avocado I can imagine the headlines. “AVOCADO TOAST FAD MAY BE LINKED TO DEVIL WORSHIP”
- dilemma 9y agoAmazon's digital/technological backend lets them put WF retail spaces to more productive use, so it's still an asset and not a liability.
- trimbo 9y ago> The supermarkets have changed very little about the way they've done business in the last half-century, and as such I have a difficult time imagining them doing a good job executing on something like this. I don't get what you mean by "ensure good execution" because it takes so little for grocers to successfully move into a market like Blue Apron's. 20 years ago, grocers destroyed the "fast casual roasted chicken" restaurants (Boston Market, Kenny Rogers Roasters) by simply buying chicken roaster machines and adding hot prepared food to the deli counter... and charging about a third the price. I'd hazard a guess that Safeway's chicken isn't as yummy[1] as Kenny Rogers' Roasters but that didn't stop anything. So what about their execution is required here beyond "cheap and available where you already shop"? No one can use Blue Apron without a regular grocer in their routine already. Grocers successfully tapping into this higher margin product line seems inevitable, even if done with lower quality (is that what you mean?) [1] - Or their neon sign as bright
- dragonwriter 9y ago> So what about their execution is required here beyond "cheap and available where you already shop"? It's not 20 years ago, and “online for home delivery” is increasingly where people already shop. And, it's easy to displace a business that requires a trip out with one that requires a trip out, but one you were likely taking already. Harder to do that with something that doesn't require a trip out at all. > No one can use Blue Apron without a regular grocer in their routine already. Yes, you can. Cooking oil, salt, and black pepper—the only ingredients BA doesn't usually supply—don't require a traditional grocery or even one of the limited-area perishable delivery services to acquire. If BA is your only home cooking, you literally never need to enter a traditional grocery store, or order from a similar full-grown online delivery service. Google Express or Amazon in one of the areas where they don't have grocery delivery will work fine.
- emodendroket 9y agoA life where Blue Apron is literally the only food you eat at home besides takeout seems dystopian.
- sheri 9y ago> While I don't disagree, people said the same thing about Amazon. The difference to me is that Amazon competed aggressively on price and selection. You could get books or items which you just couldn't get in a local Borders. You could also get the same item significantly cheaper than a Borders or Barnes and Noble. Blue Aprons value lies in the recipe and the convenience of having all the ingredients picked out for you, but charges a significant premium. I would like this as a way to try new recipes or expand my range (e.g. I don't stock ingredients/spices etc at home for Chinese food), but not as my go-to option for daily meals. It may not be as easy for someone like whole-foods or Safeway to generate recipes, efficiently package/put-together ingredients etc, but I also feel the value addition is much less than someone like Amazon's was: More items and much cheaper.
- emodendroket 9y agoAll they need to do is parter with/acquire something like AllRecipes and then they're pretty much set.
- leesalminen 9y agoDo you have any recommendations on similar services? We tried Blue Apron and found that their only shipping options were FedEx Home (consistently arrives after 10PM) and OnTrac (consistently isn't delivered at all).
- handedness 9y agoNone that we found good enough to stick with, unfortunately. The market still feels wide open. Aside: I've never heard a single good thing about OnTrac.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> The supermarkets have changed very little about the way they've done business in the last half-century... You really should visit a Wegmans.
- just4themoney 9y agoAnd pretty much every grocery store on the East Coast... they are all scrambling to play "follow the leader" with Wegmans.
- emodendroket 9y agoI've visited a few times and I'm not sure what's so special.
- pkulak 9y agoA store in my area (Fred Meyer) that sells about everything, recently started pushing this service where you shop online and then pull into this special parking space where someone brings you your stuff and loads it into your trunk. I thought it was a great idea, so at about 3 I loaded everything I needed for dinner into my online shopping cart and went to check out. Turns out the earliest they could have it ready for me was the next day. I wasn't even expecting to have to pick a time frame at all. I figured I would just see some message about it being ready in 30 minutes, or some other short time frame. You'd be amazed at how good entrenched companies are at completely failing to understand what their competitive advantage even is, let alone using it.
- ghaff 9y agoHannafords has a service like this too though I haven't looked into it. Seems sort of a limited use case for me. But at a minimum needs to be, if not ready in an hour, at least order at lunch and swing by on the way home.
- magic_beans 9y agoWow that's upsetting! Home Depot and Bloomingdale's are both really good about same-day pickup of online orders.
- arethuza 9y ago"The supermarkets have changed very little about the way they've done business in the last half-century" UK supermarkets seem to have made huge changes, online shopping and delivery is really common, self scanning (which I always use), loyalty points used across multiple vendors (e.g. getting points for paying utility bills), "metro" urban stores etc.
- tomw2005 9y agoWhile that is all true Amazon Fresh has completely blown that out of the water for me. Though it is only available in Greater London atm.
- arethuza 9y agoWhat are the benefits of Amazon Fresh? Edit: I'm not doubting that there are some - just wondering how it differentiates itself from other players in this market, particularly when Amazon isn't a brand I associate with product quality.
- ghaff 9y agoI'll add to what others have said that, for anyone vaguely interested in quality and variety of food, a grocery store of 50 years ago would be this ocean of poor quality produce, canned food, Wonder bread, etc. A lot of that is the transformation of US food supply chains but grocery stores are part of that.
- smaili 9y agoSpeaking of, whatever happened to Curbside? I saw them heavily around a few malls and now they're nowhere to be found...
- elgenie 9y agoA service with curbside pickup is not identical to one where the ingredients and instructions are waiting when one comes home. Consider, for instance, the logistics for someone who doesn't own a car.
- jhowell 9y agoHow do these folks get groceries from the store now?
- throwthisawayt 9y agoThey probably use delivery services for groceries or don't cook. The point of blue apron was it was an easy way for people intimidated by cooking to start doing it.
- greglindahl 9y agoThat's one point of Blue Apron. For me, the point is that I can spend 100% of my cooking time cooking, instead of planning or shopping. As a result, I cook a lot more, and I like that.
- cakedoggie 9y agoOr use a bike and pick up stuff on the way home from work.
- ivanbakel 9y agoThat's a very narrow view of how people get around. Is it based on a rural experience? I've never been outside of walking distance of a small shop for food shopping.
- Osmium 9y ago> I've never been outside of walking distance of a small shop for food shopping I'd be interested to know whether a typical person's idea of what "walking distance" is has decreased or not over recent years.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Why have your ingredients mailed to you when a supermarket on your way home will offer the same thing for 50% cheaper? Because, based on supermarket prices for similarly sized packages, it won't be 50% of the cost, and because the additional time for a supermarket stop takes up enough time to basically make it a wash, considering the money value of time, for people in the target market even if it was 50%.
- verelo 9y ago> These companies are going to get absolutely destroyed when the big supermarkets come on tap. While I agree they're in trouble, i really don't think it'll be supermarkets that hurt them. Supermarkets are about as likely to rise up as Blackberry is about to destroy Apple.
- emodendroket 9y agoHave people quit buying groceries at grocery stores at some point in the past few years and I haven't noticed? I don't see the analogy.
- lobf 9y agoNot only that, but choosing one doesn't exclude the other when it comes to groceries / food delivery...
- vkou 9y agoAn iPhone is a fundamentally different device from a old-generation BlackBerry. As far as I can tell, these services sell you the same head of lettuce as the grocery, at a large markup. Just because you think that Safeway, QFC, and Costco won't figure out this business doesn't mean that some other grocery chain won't. Grocery stores have a fundamental advantage in this game - they have a location where people who don't want to pay for delivery can pick up. They can absolutely compete on price, without sacrificing any quality. On the other hand, it doesn't matter how much a BlackBerry costs - it was not an iPhone.
- jghn 9y agoThere are two reasons I like Blue Apron: 1) Here and there they have recipes involving ingredients not easily found in local stores 2) They deliver it to me If I have to go to the store anyways, and presumably using ingredients they have there already, it has no value to me.
- dndidieheb 9y agoAt least one big supermarket already has. Costco has a great selection of prepared, near-prepared (stick in oven), and frozen foods that are tastier and cheaper than Blue Apron. If meal kits become a huge market, I expect Costco will enter.
- russdill 9y agoPrepared, near-prepared, and frozen meals are a different product than Blue Apron. Blue Apron is raw ingredients that you have to prepare yourself.
- basejumping 9y agoWe have this already in the Netherlands. Albert Heijn is the biggest supermarket here, they have raw ingredients grouped in boxes for different recipes like soups, lasagnas, etc. I know I pay more than if I bought the ingredients one by one, but hey, sometimes you do it. They also do home deliveries, have express checkouts, and now they will experiment with something like Amazon Go.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanwilson 9y ago> Several are working on identical services where you pick up, curbside, the ingredients and instructions in a bag, and pay significantly less for doing so. Is there anything here that would get in the way of supermarkets usual model? All I can think of is that a package of ingredients would have to have a sell by date of the item that goes out of date the quickest and they would require staff for preparation (e.g. adding only one clove of garlic, packaging up a tablespoon of soy sauce).
- jonwachob91 9y agoPublix started offering this service a few weeks ago. I haven't tried it yet (probably never will, for the same reasons I'd never try Blue Apron), BUT they put it in plastic containers with a label for each of the individual items and the instructions. The contents appear to be in individual wrapped vacuum sealed bags. Not sure much beyond that.
- cgag 9y agoThere are so supermarkets on my way home.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOne of the differences is that Supermarkets don't have the freedom of operation that Blue Apron does. Years of tight margins and increasingly complex stocking and merchandising restrictions in exchange for incentives has created something of a quagmire there. You're locally owned small market, sure. But don't look at Safeway or Krogers to be able to jump onto this trend either quickly or cost effectively. Those constraints would seem to be the only reason another startup, curbside, continues to exist :-)
- jonwachob91 9y agoPublix, a regional chain that OWNS the South East and was recently ranked by Consumer Reports as the most loved grocery store in the US, is already doing this. They don't advertise it very well, but they started offering it a few weeks ago. EDIT: including some extra deets about their size (since that was your primary argument against it happening) -> $34B in Revenue (2016), Operating Income $2.94B (2016), Assets of $17.46B, and 200,000+ employees.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago... and privately owned. Which helps a lot in this case. That said, if they are successful at duplicating the Blue Apron model effectively then I expect that would be sufficient "proof" for the shareholder driven grocery chains.
- paulddraper 9y agoHm. Publix has their stuff together then. They will make for tough competition. Quite solid in price/friendliness/quality.
- CincinnatiMan 9y agoKroger is currently running trials of meal kits in select Cincinnati-area stores (their home turf). They cost $14 for the same amount of food as a $20 Blue Apron 2-serving recipe, and most of the ingredients are pre-chopped. The recipes are less "exotic" than BA though. More details can be found here: https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanpearson/2017/05/17/krogers-meal-kits-could-make-a-meal-of-the-industry/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanpearson/2017/05/17/krogers...
- deepGem 9y agoI think there is a lot of consumer psychology at play here. What you said will work very well in a country such as Singapore where people predominantly stop at a mall/supermarket after work. Beyond 7 PM all the roast chicken from the supermarket shelves are gone. In the US, I don't see this as a practice. I mean you just drive home from work or these days use ride sharing. In either case stopping by is a hassle. Am assuming a supermarket can mimic BA's recipe and packaging. What bothers me about BA is not the supermarkets but the management's unacceptable ways of hiding actual customer acquisition costs.
- matwood 9y ago> Beyond 7 PM all the roast chicken from the supermarket shelves are gone. In the US, I don't see this as a practice Think it depends where you live. My nearby grocery store makes/serves fresh pizza, take out dinners (different each night), the usual rotisserie chickens (that are all gone by 7), in store made sushi (to order if you're there at the right time), has an asian and american hot bar, and provides a drive through grocery pick up service. I did BA some in the past, but now I have a bunch of recipes and just order the ingredients online and pick them up at a drive through on the way home. It's cheaper, and almost as convenient. The store will also deliver, but I'm okay saving the fee since it's so easy to pick up.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Think it depends where you live. My nearby grocery store makes/serves fresh pizza, take out dinners (different each night), the usual rotisserie chickens (that are all gone by 7), in store made sushi (to order if you're there at the right time), has an asian and american hot bar, and provides a drive through grocery pick up service. Is this Texas? Because it sounds like the most wonderful place known as HEB.
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't know but Whole Foods offers basically the same.
- 9y ago
- famousactress 9y agoAbsolutely. See: How Blockbuster Video Destroyed Netflix (sorry, having trouble digging up the link to that article) [Edit: But FWIW, I do buy that Blue Apron is fucked.. competition just isn't the reason]
- parennoob 9y agoBlockbuster and Netflix did not sell perishable goods. Now I could buy the argument that the supermarket chains just won't be able to attract the appropriate talent to deliver an experience rivaling that of Blue Apron (or Amazon, if they decided to get into this market tomorrow via Whole Foods).
- bdcravens 9y agoMaybe it's just Houston, but many of the ingredients are available in every supermarket. You can get higher quality recipes sent to your home whether you live in a Whole Foods neighborhood or a beer-and-weenies neighborhood. I would probably drive across town to find what I needed, but many people won't.
- kalleboo 9y agoIn other countries, supermarket chains are already doing this[0]. Wonder why the big actors in the US are so slow to compete. [0] https://www.ica.se/handla-online/ica-matkassen/ https://www.ica.se/handla-online/ica-matkassen/ https://www.coop.se/handla-online/matkasse/ https://www.coop.se/handla-online/matkasse/ https://www.citygross.se/mat/matkasse/klassisk-matkasse/ https://www.citygross.se/mat/matkasse/klassisk-matkasse/ https://www.hemkop.se/matkassar https://www.hemkop.se/matkassar
- Khol 9y agoI started using one of these services a couple of months ago and the biggest thing for me is simply having one less thing to have to think about. Both myself and my partner have struggled with depression, and one of the few things which reliably makes a difference for me is cooking. The issue is that when you feel like the world is crumbling around you and you struggle to make it out of bed, let alone out of the house, I'm simply unable to plan through what supplies I need, obtain them and cook. Obviously I'm incredibly privileged in the sense that I am in a comfortable financial position and can afford to use these services. Edit: I should probably also add that neither myself or my partner can drive, so getting groceries is a bus ride / hoping that the small shops in walking distance have what you need (reasonable for salt/pepper/cooking oil/pasta/rice, not so much for anything more 'exotic').
- siliconc0w 9y agoPart of the Blue Apron sell is you get to cook with 'fancy' ingredients that most grocers might not carry. Whole Foods 365, for example, is an attempt to move the industry in the opposite direction by carrying far less than a standard market. You can certainly make delicious meals from the 365 inventory but can't necessarily fulfill a given recipe with the inventory at 365 or even a standard grocer. This is a common problem when 'cooking to the recipe'. (though I'd agree this probably isn't enough on it's own to save blue apron)