3 ms·
That's only true in the modern era where banks get unlimited dollars for free from the central bank. More typically in modern history, banks can deliver decent
by Spooky23 9y ago
That's only true in the modern era where banks get unlimited dollars for free from the central bank.
More typically in modern history, banks can deliver decent rates of return by capitalizing loans with deposits. Risk gets reduced by FDIC or other insurance.
As recently as 2006, savings accounts with zero risk for >80% of the US population paid 4-5% interest.
- euyyn 9y ago> As recently as 2006, savings accounts with zero risk for >80% of the US population paid 4-5% interest. I was gonna ask how was that "zero risk" possible, but I'm thinking the answer is "it wasn't actually possible as we all found out the following years."
- cesarb 9y agoDomestic government bonds of stable countries are usually treated as "zero risk", even though they still have a small risk. A savings account with "zero risk" would be one that has as much risk as a "zero risk" bond, usually by both being backed by these bonds, and having a government-backed insurance scheme (if the bank fails, the account holders are still paid). (It might help if you think of risk as a scale, and the "zero" as an arbitrary point in that scale. It's useful to set the "zero" to "the lowest risk you can actually get", even though there might be something with an even lower risk.)
- euyyn 9y agoSo US bonds were yielding 4-5% back then?
- Spooky23 9y agoNot at all. The problems we found out later were with banks packaging loans into more complex securities of and selling them to third parties. You have "zero risk" with bank deposits because FDIC insures deposits up $250k (today, $100k previously) with the full faith and credit of the US Treasury.
- euyyn 9y agoHow does that insurance work, though: If the bank promises to pay its clients some obscene interest, and goes belly up, will FDIC pay that? Or is it "the US Treasury will pay you up to the amount you initially deposited"?
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> That's only true in the modern era where banks get unlimited dollars for free from the central bank. That has always been true. Look, you can't save grain to eat in your old age unless you build a freaking grain silo, and even then the grain rots. Money is just little pieces of paper with value attached, they don't actually have value in itself (the same is true for gold). Whatever happened in the past, e.g. savings account with higher interest rates, was more related to the demand for capital rather than in the intrinsic property of the money itself.