7 ms·
Signatures of extra dimensions in gravitational waves
- vardump 9y agoSame (?) paper (possibly a slightly different version), but without paywall: https://arxiv.org/abs/1704.07392 https://arxiv.org/abs/1704.07392
- mirimir 9y agotl;dr - There are two expected signatures: "breathing mode" (maybe like p-waves?) and high-frequency components. Seeing the first would require at least three independent detectors sensitive to polarization. Seeing the second would require at least several orders of magnitude increase in frequency response.
- chairmanwow 9y agoI originally thought this paper presented evidence for extra dimensions discovered in gravitational wave readings. This is certainly not the case, as this paper presents two potential effects from higher dimensional gravity waves and proposes methods to detect them. Namely, we would need an equivalent to LIGO that features detection arms in all three axes rather than just X and Z. The second predicted effect requires a GWave detector that is several orders of magnitude more sensitive than LIGO.
- mandarlimaye 9y agoPerhaps the LISA detector will be sensitive enough? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Ant...
- thechao 9y agoOP said "a few". The paper says LIGO et al. are sensitive up to an order of 3 or 4; planned interferometers are targeted at lower ranges. The needed device needs to be sensitive to modes of at least order 12---but preferably order 21 & higher (to cover all theories). So, realistically, they're about 18 orders of magnitude off. Conservatively.
- Already__Taken 9y agoThere's going to be multiple LIGO style detectors around the world, could their results be combined to account for the 3rd axis?
- tqkxzugoaupvwqr 9y agoFrom my understanding as a layperson, using other LIGO style detectors to substitute the z-axis won’t work. You need to shoot laser pulses continuously and in sync into two axes from the same detector to be able to detect ripples in spacetime. The sensitivity of two non-connected detectors working together is not high enough. See [1] for how the detection works. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10
- Already__Taken 9y agoGiven the size of the wavelength is multiples of the earth are they not able to sync up the section of the wave being measured and deduce further measurements from there? You couldn't add 1 axis of another detector as a 3rd leg but having 3 measurements on 3 planes from 3 pairs of beams due to their positions on earth should. Each stations 2 axis measure 1 plane, and you build the 3 plane from the positions on the earths surface. Wouldn't the relative velocities of the earths spin, orbit and the solar systems velocity from the gravity wave origin all make the above measurements... difficult. Or all things considered, the angular tiny velocity from the origin makes that irrelevant. Physics is hard.
- k__ 9y agoI have no idea about physics, but I thought the holographic principle said that it was the other way around?
- paulpauper 9y agomind-blowing how complicated these equations are each symbol with a superscript or subscript represents part of a system of differential equations each individual equation is a function of 10 or more variables wish I understood it better
- exabrial 9y agoI've had this crazy thought for awhile that the physical dimensions we see are the three dimensions of gravity, and that there are a similar number of dimensions for time.
- chadwittman 9y agoCare to elaborate? Sounds interesting.
- axlprose 9y agoNot the OP, but I know there is at least one guy who's delved quite deeply into the concept of multi-dimensional time: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSbZM83_FycPZNJqcFYzWG3DPmpIh41_I https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSbZM83_FycPZNJqcFYzW...
- logfromblammo 9y agoSo have I. I have an "everything moves at c" hypothesis, wherein everything has an inertia/velocity vector with 3 spatial (squares to 1) components and 3 temporal (squares to -1) components. The magnitude of every vector is c. We see three spatial dimensions, because the portion of our vector from the temporal components is almost c. Our inertia makes it very difficult to change our directional vector through the temporal dimensions, because we are almost at rest in the spatial dimensions. So we see time as a single dimension, because it is practically impossible for us to change the temporal-only components of our vector. Similarly, for an electron, when the spatial component of the vector is nearly c, it would perceive space as one dimensional, and would require less energy to change direction in the temporal dimensions. This results in spatial behavior that requires the use of probabilities. We perceive up-down, left-right, front-back, and before-after. Someone moving at near-c through space might perceive to-fro, entropy-order, likely-unlikely, because-causes, or similarly incomprehensible-to-us dimensions. This hypothesis is all thanks to the Back to the Future movies. Why does the DeLorean have to go 88 mph? Because the Doc could only generate 1.21 GW, and in order for that much energy to change your direction through time, you have to be moving at 88 mph. If you were going 120 mph, you would need less energy, but in 1985, 88 was about as much as you can expect from a commodity automobile. It also received significant contribution from quaternion-based mathematics, which is completely symmetric with respect to dimensional signatures of (3,1) and (1,3).
- dest 9y agoAt the end of the article (!): Our warmest thanks go to the Deutsche Bahn AG for providing us with comfortable office space in their conveniently delayed trains.
- nategri 9y agoCalling all HN physics cranks.
- jensenbox 9y agoSomewhere in my ancestral line I have a relative that can read and write the sort of math that is in this paper. I have given myself the OK that I will never be able to do a gosh darn thing even close to what I just saw. I just hope that somewhere in my life I am able to do something that is just as awe inspiring to someone else.
- olleromam91 9y agoWhat if dark matter is just mass that is moving faster than light?