3 ms·
The question that the title brings up, but the article fails to answer until the very end, is whose "due diligence" review Wikileaks failed. Well, here it is:
by jrockway 16y ago
The question that the title brings up, but the article fails to answer until the very end, is whose "due diligence" review Wikileaks failed. Well, here it is:
the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation considered and rejected an application from WikiLeaks for financial support
So that's the foundation of the article. An exciting and technically true "fact", a bunch of ranting about why the author doesn't like Wikileaks, and finally the source of the "fact" that the article is based on. Good whining, poor reading. Yawn.
- joe_the_user 16y agoIndeed, But calling WikiLeaks a whistleblower site does not accurately reflect the character of the project. It also does not explain why others who are engaged in open government, anti-corruption and whistleblower protection activities are wary of WikiLeaks or disdainful of it. And it does not provide any clue why the Knight Foundation, the preeminent foundation funder of innovative First Amendment and free press initiatives, might have rejected WikiLeaks’ request for financial support, as it recently did. Which of the fallacies from a few days ago are included here? Should "describing wikiLeaks as a whistle blower site" explain why the Knight foundation didn't give them funding?? Labels aren't intended to explain most of the time...
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoThe author also points out that WikiLeaks has published things that are not in the public interest to publish (e.g. the sorority ceremony), not theirs to publish (e.g. the copyrighted book), or that, the article argues, could have been handled much more effectively (the killcam video). I admit that the last point is not argued very persuasively, but there is more content in the article.