7 ms·
Finance sites erroneously show Amazon, Apple, other stocks crashing
- kwelstr 9y agoWow, that's crazy! What algorithm did this, or maybe it's some scheme manipulation for profit? You can never be sure when something like this happens, flash stock crashes have a history that's muddy at best. :/
- ams6110 9y agoAnd we trust that software can drive our cars for us?
- Flammy 9y agoStock tracking websites don't need to be perfect, just need to be better than the humans they replaced. Faster, free, and less errors doesn't mean they must be error free. Self driving cars just need to be better than humans, and given the number of teens and senior citizens on the road...
- Nition 9y agoStatistically that's true but realistically I wouldn't want to use a self-driving car that's only a little better than the average driver. It's one thing to have a friend that's a bad driver and another thing to ride in their car.
- jfoutz 9y agoBut they are still on the road. They're still a hazard to everyone around them. Pedestrians, cyclists, and other drivers are all at risk.
- Nition 9y agoYes but they'll continue to be on the road until they can get in a self-driving car that they can trust.
- notahacker 9y agoNever mind trust: teens and seniors generally don't have the disposable income to spend on high end brand new cars (or expensive retrofits of sensor devices). The first buyers, apart from the wealthy, would be people and corporations that spend the most time on the road: generally tending towards being better than average drivers. And even if self-driving cars were exactly as good as the drivers they replaced, half the purpose of buying them is to spend more time on the road...
- Tepix 9y agoElon Musk said that he is aiming for his self-driving cars to be 10x safer than the average driver (without LIDAR btw).
- dogecoinbase 9y agoThis is true from a pure-risk perspective, but I suspect we will find that humans are far more forgiving of the errors of other humans than they are of the errors (or worse, harm-minimizing calculations) of machines.
- ams6110 9y agoAs someone contemplating the purchase of one, a self-driving car needs to be better than me. That's a higher bar than better than average even if it's not objectively correct.
- krallja 9y agoThis is only true if you are on an otherwise empty road.
- tybit 9y agoOn the other hand, as a passenger on public transport, taxis and ride shares it only has to be better than (often over worked and over tired) average human drivers.
- stale2002 9y agoDo you ever use a taxi? Because if you do, you are putting your life into the hands of someone who could be a much worse driver than you. Instead of putting your life in the hands of a terrible taxi driver, would you put it in the hands of software that is on average better than a taxi driver? You are in a taxi, so you don't get to choose to drive it yourself.
- goodplay 9y agoNot gp, but I would personally expect a taxi driver to be better than me seeing the amount of time the diver spends on the road. The driver wouldn't be profitable otherwise. That said, I also mirror gp in that any self-driving car must be at least better than myself for me to trust it. I imagine that's a sentiment shared by many people.
- yellow_postit 9y agoI agree this is the natural bar, but don't know how to reconcile it with the average person believing they are a better driver than average (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_superiority)
- 9y ago
- simonsarris 9y agoWe are all running software to drive our cars. Sometimes the software gets drunk, or has a stroke or a diabetic fit or just drops hot coffee all over the hardware.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoYes. If this is indicative of the failure rate of computers in general, then cars will be PHENOMENALLY safe. Humans are doing a garbage job, killing people left and right. So what's your solution that isn't human or computer? I'd also hazard a guess that having humans update tens of thousands of stock prices every few seconds would result in more than one mistake in a decade.
- stale2002 9y agoSoftware ALREADY drives your car. You press the gas pedal, and a computer reads that signal and puts gas into the engine.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoWe trust software to fly our planes and run our nuclear power stations... So what's the problem?
- brohee 9y agoThose are simpler problems. There is more at stakes, but they don't have to contend with a kid running after a football.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- grondilu 9y agoSometimes I wonder if it would make sense to place long-term buy orders at a ridiculously low bids. Just in case.
- comboy 9y agoOn Bitcoin exchanges, sure. But here I think there's too much liquidity and automated trading.
- MichaelDickens 9y agoI believe the recent Ethereum flash crash demonstrated that this strategy wouldn't work for cryptocurrency either. Ethereum price dropped to $0.10, but it rebounded in about 5 seconds because trading algorithms put in lots of bids at the really cheap price.
- j_s 9y agoIt did work, but not for many. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14611653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14611653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14690908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14690908
- wcummings 9y agoToo much liquidity?
- ams6110 9y agoExcept these weren't real prices. Buy orders would not have been triggered.
- pishpash 9y agoIt seems like the price was trying to be set to 123.45 -- there are some discrepancies on different sites; not really clear whether any trades took place in little or no volume after hours, or purely feed error.
- cbanek 9y agoI've actually seen a number of times where Google Finance has a daily low that was never reached or a high that wasn't shown on the graph (sometimes many percentage points away). It's also notoriously bad when there's a gap up or down, and will sometimes cut out various parts of the graph. But still, seems to be one of the better ones out there, as I still use it. Just don't treat it as authority. Another interesting example of questionable data is the premarket CNN feed at (http://money.cnn.com/data/premarket/ http://money.cnn.com/data/premarket/). I have sometimes seen a stock trading premarket down 99%, which almost always looks like an off by some factor of ten of the price.
- pishpash 9y agoGoogle Finance does not even have a working price plotter, that's pretty awful in a basic way.
- vpribish 9y agoand their financial news is flooded to uselessness with bot-written "stories" from sites like "The <placename> [register|tribune|bulletin|news|alert]". The service is pretty garbage now.
- coldcode 9y agoOf all of google's services Finance is the worst, it seems to be supported by cheap contractors in Elbonia. I mean Flash charts??? Sometimes stocks that were removed remain in the lists for months. The stock screener seems to be a student take home test where the student failed.
- revmoo 9y agoWhat is a price plotter?
- tunetine 9y agoIf I had to guess, it looks like google and yahoo track by time. Each nth second it plots a point, so it's likely to miss graphing the actual high or low of the day.
- nopzor 9y agoThis story isn't emphasizing an important point: the stock price of many tech companies - amazon, google, Microsoft - were pegged to exactly $123.46 for multiple hours. This is likely 123.456 rounded to 2 decimals. To me this smells like a software testing bug or hack, rather than "stocks crashing"
- kakarot 9y agoGood eye. That was probably the case.
- AlBentley 9y agoTurns out they are scraping price data, the bots must have failed!
- dhbanes 9y agoI saw it pegged at 123.47
- karakot 9y agorounding
- radicality 9y agoRounding from what? 123.456 to 123.47?
- vpribish 9y agomaybe 2 passes? 123.45678... -> 123.4568 (4 decimal places is common in finance) then to 2 places for the retail muppets 123.46 :)
- beejiu 9y agoStocks have two prices. I guess this would be reflected in test data.
- doener 9y ago"Will Briganti, a spokesman for Nasdaq, was unable to immediately comment on the situation." https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/articles/2017-07-04/nasdaq-stocks-show-exaggerated-movements-in-after-hours-trading https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/articles/2017-07-04/nasda...
- rnprince 9y agoThis could be the beginning of a thriller movie. A nefarious hacker group demonstrates a powerful zero-day for a dangerous client by creating national panic over stock prices.
- hbcondo714 9y ago> The problem may have originated with data services providing Google and Yahoo their financial information I'm sure Google and Yahoo pay a small fortune for this data so I'm wondering if they are aware of the situation and holding these data services companies accountable or not.I'm also sure these data companies sell their data beyond information sites to investment firms & others that make buy/sell decisions based on this data. Yahoo does disclose[1] that they get some data 'direct from exchange' though. [1] https://help.yahoo.com/kb/finance-for-desktop/SLN2310.html?impressions=true https://help.yahoo.com/kb/finance-for-desktop/SLN2310.html?i...
- OskarS 9y agoI'm fairly certain they're aware of the problem :) And yes, I bet this is going to lead to some interesting meetings between them and the data providers.
- vpribish 9y agoThis was a market half-day: exercising some code-paths that haven't been used since the day after thanksgiving '16. I do find it surprising that google and yahoo are both affected, as they used to have very different patterns of stock data errors (yahoo was much higher quality).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- trothamel 9y agoOne nice thing about SEC-regulated markets - unlike the various cryptocurrency markets - is that it's possible for trades to be rolled back if they are "clearly erroneous". That isn't perfect - if the data is only a little off, it might not be possible to get a trade rolled back - but it tends to limit how much havoc is called. https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2009/2009-215.htm https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2009/2009-215.htm (My understanding is that trades can also be rolled back in the case of security breaches, at least at the exchange and broker levels.)
- beambot 9y agoDoes that SEC possibility apply to Google Finance stock data? It's not like they're a proper broker or official provider if data (i.e. most of the affected financial sites have ample "price inaccuacy" disclosures).
- jlarocco 9y agoI don't think the OP was trying to say it applies here, just that IF there had been some kind of hack or security problem, then the SEC has some tools for dealing with it. In this case, if it was only the data going to out to third party stock tickers, then it probably doesn't apply. Services like Google and Yahoo finance make it really clear on their sites that the data isn't necessarily accurate, can be delayed, and isn't for trading purposes, so nobody should have been making trading decisions based solely on this data anyway.
- nihonde 9y agoThe flip side of this is that no providers of pricing data are expected to stand behind their prices. It's basically arbitrary and at the whim of some people who very easily may not care about your situation.
- bendbro 9y agoWhy can't majority participants in a crypto currency agree to roll back?
- 9y ago
- gchokov 9y agoBlack Monday - fake news edition.
- bbgm 9y agoAs some have suggested, Nasdaq is confirming that this was test data that got propagated to third party aggregators. https://mobile.twitter.com/Nasdaq/status/882054148413325313 https://mobile.twitter.com/Nasdaq/status/882054148413325313 http://www.nasdaqtrader.com/TraderNews.aspx?id=utp2017-05 http://www.nasdaqtrader.com/TraderNews.aspx?id=utp2017-05
- cm2187 9y agoUsing production systems to run tests... What could go wrong?
- nickpeterson 9y agoNo test like production.
- humanrebar 9y agoIt's actually considered best practice in various categories of technology to run tests on the production systems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Built-in_self-test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Built-in_self-test
- noir_lord 9y agoWhen done intentionally. I've seen lots of tests 'escape' their environment for a bunch of reasons (tests got sent to production with a deploy, human was on the wrong machine and ran a manual test command etc etc). It's almost impossible not to screw up at some point, I try to focus on minimising the small mistakes (airline pilots have commented that it's not the first problem that kills you it's the second one).
- ethbro 9y agoThat's why artificially differentiated steps are critical. If the "deploy to test" procedure looks exactly like the "deploy to prod" procedure, except with different servers, then you're asking for human error. Ensure the test deploy procedure will always fail if run against prod targets when half-asleep. Whether it's something like requiring a different config setting or a reload or an account switch. Anything that breaks the process-as-usual.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoWhat if a multi-government coalation broke out of the lobbyism hypnotization and would split up amazon. Could such a drop be realistic?
- traviscj 9y agoOne of my grad school classmates spent some time in finance and always used to say something like "your best results are really just bad input data". This has proved a worthy maxim many times over.
- thomnific 9y agoThis is silly. Blame the third-party providers on this one, for using exchange prices during a holiday when the exchanges are closed ...