2 ms·
Well I am disappointed but not surprised that SCOTUS didn't throw out software patents. The patent system has been the foundation of the business processes in
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Well I am disappointed but not surprised that SCOTUS didn't throw out software patents.
The patent system has been the foundation of the business processes in many industries. It's natural that a lot of powerful stakeholders expect this to continue into the information age. Despite this, when production in general is going towards information, patents are doomed to become more pathological and more a rent-seeking activity as information processing expands.
There is simply no even slightly objective measure for determining whether X algorithm and Y distinct algorithm are "the same". The existence of such a measure is essentially a mathematical impossibility. Among other challenge, a sameness measure would probably have to solve the halting problem (otherwise you substitute an algorithm with the same results for any given patented algorithm). More generally, any "sameness" criteria must really be based on a "close enough" measure and closeness itself is a characteristic of the three dimensional metric space we humans live in. Closeness doesn't exist and can't meaningfully exist in an infinite dimensional space of abstract algorithms.
So "sameness" is going based entirely on subjective and arbitrary judgments of juries and judges, who naturally know little of the situation (indeed, ignorance is something of a necessary condition for having an honest opinion on the similarity of algorithms). Thus, software patents give any given patent holder of any algorithm an unlimited terrain to sue people on.