3 ms·
Super misleading Economist headline and subheading: "Websites offering pirated papers are shaking up science: Musicians and moviemakers are not the only ones to
by Robotbeat 9y ago
Super misleading Economist headline and subheading:
"Websites offering pirated papers are shaking up science: Musicians and moviemakers are not the only ones to suffer from internet piracy"
If you come to this topic from an essentially blank slate, the headline and subheading would make you think that /science/ and /scientists/ are suffering from piracy (in analogy to the claim that musicians and moviemakers are).
Except very likely the opposite is true: this piracy offers much greater exposure to scientific literature and enables access to otherwise-inaccessible scientific knowledge for scientists in poorer nations.
Unlike musicians and moviemakers, scientists make ZERO money from publication royalties of journal articles but they (or their institutions) have to /pay/ for access to these journals. The only ones making money are the publishers.
- elif 9y agoWell, in deference to the dramatic title, there are also negative consequences and not only those positive ones. For instance: It seems logical that the average quality of science goes down when peer-reviewing is optional. Likewise, corrections and redactions are not guaranteed to take place. The real game change will be if/when pirate publishers force traditional publishers to drop their profit models, and the best of both worlds can be achieved.
- sitkack 9y ago> average quality of science goes down when peer-reviewing is optional where was this claim made?
- kbutler 9y agoYou also need to show that current peer review is happening and is effective at identifying bad science, and that corrections and redactions are currently guaranteed to take place. Both of those are questionable.