3 ms·
What I would like to see is an informational analysis where you take something like a thousand common equations and look at how they would be expressed with pi
by joe_the_user 16y ago
What I would like to see is an informational analysis where you take something like a thousand common equations and look at how they would be expressed with pi versus with tau. If you can show they would take significantly fewer bits of information using tau, then tau would be objectively superior.
- timwiseman 16y agoI repectfully think you may be overlooking two things: 1. While storing fewer bits may be objectively superior in one sense, it is overlooking the far more significant question of which helps a human understand and work with the equestions. Math is encoded into the universe, but our expressions of it exist for our own understanding. 2. We get a lot of choice in how we encode information, and that choice can change the number of bits used substantially. For instance: c = 2 \pi r c = \pi d c = \tau r c = 1/2 \tau d All say the same thing, but their lengths vary considerably.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI'm sure this would overlook many things. It would just supply one objective measure, not the only thing to consider. Also, while there are indeed an infinity of representations of a given expression, there are a finite number of minimal representations, which can be found by exhaustive search if not some cleverer algorithm.
- orangecat 16y agoReally that reduces to looking at how often pi appears by itself (without being multiplied by a constant) versus how often 2pi appears. If there's a multiple other than 2 it's a wash; "4/3 pi r^3" isn't any better or worse than "2/3 tau r^3". And 2pi shows up all over the place, while the most common occurrence of a single pi is the area of a circle, which the proposal convincingly argues should have a 1/2 factor.