8 ms·
Minitel: The Online World France Built Before the Web
- ForHackernews 9y agoSome previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14577881 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14577881
- mrkrab 9y agoDon't forget about Infovía in Spain, too, even though that was much later.
- gaius 9y agoAnd Prestel in the UK, but it was never as ubiquitous as le Minitel.
- tobltobs 9y agoAnd Bildschirmtext (BTX) in Germany.
- riccardo_gr 9y agoAnd the Videotel by SIP in Italy (a real failure): https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Videotel https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Videotel http://quartdepomme.fr/quartdepomme/VIDEOTEL_-_MINITEL_%28Updated%29.html http://quartdepomme.fr/quartdepomme/VIDEOTEL_-_MINITEL_%28Up...
- daemonza 9y agoAnd Beltel in South Africa
- fermigier 9y ago"and dudes (mecs in French) browsed the personal ads at 3615 MEC." <- Something was lost in the translation there.
- agumonkey 9y agoYou mean they weren't explicit enough in the article ? Funny the company behind is still here https://goo.gl/2YGfuq https://goo.gl/2YGfuq (SFW)
- raverbashing 9y agoWhat was lost exactly? The reference to MEC is explained
- dtech 9y agoYour sibling comment links the current website. Apparently it's a gay dating service. Wasn't clear to me from the article.
- raverbashing 9y agoAh that wasn't clear to me either.
- slau 9y agoA company I worked for used to host Minitel services. In particular, it was a system to handle driving test allotments, reservations and cancellations between the government ("Préfecture") and the driving schools. The service was provided for free to the government, the company organised free training sessions for government clerks, and it was the driving schools who paid for the service when dialling into our minitel servers. It technically wasn't a monopoly, because the driving schools could still go down to the préfecture, and do everything using the forms/pen/paper. The company tried on a number of occasions to get the driving schools to move from the Minitel service to the new web version. Every single time, there was a huge push-back from the driving school unions, about how expensive the new service was, and how "unusable" the website was, compared to the Minitel. We even had people calling in, saying that we were extortionists. "We've been using this for over 20 years, and never paid a cent; now you want us to pay xx€ a month?" I guess some of them really didn't look at their phone bill. I heard about 4 or 5 "planned terminations" of the Minitel service during my stint from 2010 to 2015. France Telecom/Orange even provides a "Minitel over IP" service these days, where a website can be enrolled into their payment service, and users pay per minute on the website. It's a superb scam tool (just have a hidden iframe open a pay-as-you-go page), and Orange is constantly fighting the fraudsters.
- agumonkey 9y agoTalking about migrations, I worked at two places (tax office, and large store) that were transitioning from AX400 minitel like interface to the web. Every time it was a disaster. I was much enamored by the old system that was hyper efficient, both at the low level (zero bandwidth, fixed layout) and at higher level too, all that wasn't spent on visuals and gimmicks was used for "smart" features, semantic suggestions, math auto correct on the fly. Also almost no learning phase. Sad.
- kartan 9y ago> that were transitioning from AX400 minitel like interface to the web. Every time it was a disaster. Usually the first service is build in an Agile manner. It starts small, and more and more features are added as years pass by. Then some one decides to create a complete new system from scratch, and they never realize all the hidden complexity that exists in the original solution. So this second waterfall project fails and needs years to become usable. Happened something like that in this case? :)
- srge 9y agoIt was great for "piracy". You had message board where people would swap floppies. You basically copied a game (Atari ST games of course) and would send the floppies hoping your counterpart would do the same. It was a great time and I learnt a lot about the geek community, the sharing and got access to many games which at age 15 I could not afford.
- digi_owl 9y agoElsewhere one made do with classified ads in computer magazines. I wish i could find the story i read once from a guy in GB that did so for the Amiga, and found himself so inundated with replies that he bought himself a second drive for his A500 and spend whole weekends swapping floppies.
- bigbugbag 9y agoThat's what I wanted to point out, classified had much more traction than minitel to swap disks.
- ekianjo 9y agoIs this just me or are we getting more and more articles about the Minitel on HN these days?
- agumonkey 9y agoNot only HN, I think it's been on reddit too. It's odd since the service has been removed entirely a few years ago and already got coverage at that time. Maybe the issues with net neutrality push people into history. Similarly there were Ethernet stories last week.
- fit2rule 9y agoYeah, I tend to think that we're all looking for an alternative to the looming destruction of the Internet that is inevitably going to happen when Net-neutrality dies. As an older user, I'd love it if we could figure out a way to resurrect Minitel/Teletext and use it as a way of routing around the damage that is coming from the political classes.
- zer0tonin 9y agoMinitel wasn't exactly net neutrality friendly.
- ekianjo 9y ago> for an alternative to the looming destruction of the Internet that is inevitably going to happen when Net-neutrality dies. The Minitel was the archetype of service centralization with a single hardware provider. Hardly a good case for Net neutrality.
- walshemj 9y agoyes it was the old central state controlled telephone system model a bit like OSI x.400 and x.500 where supposed to work.
- llsf 9y agoYes, very centralized, but in early 80's with telco companies having pretty much a monopoly on their own respective market, and practically no standard hardware, the Minitel was the best that could be done to get a large chunk of the population to go online, make safely online transactions, exchange messages, before the Web. Today, 35 years after with what we know, with a deregulated telco environment, with internet protocols and corresponding hardware, sure, the Minitel is not ideal for net neutrality. I think it was still a good step, and looking back, not a too shabby execution either. Now 35 years later, the market brought Android smartphone, which are the new commodity for people to go online.
- lloeki 9y agoA couple historical anecdotes: There was the equivalent of the hug of death multiple times every year when students were checking their results, overloading the servers as (tens/hundreds of) thousands of people tried to furiously dial in simultaneously to get results from various nationwide exams such as the infamous Baccalauréat. In 1981 for the presidential elections, the result was broadcasted live on the Minitel and showed up live on the news: (On TV) https://youtu.be/rJHUZNlO9ao https://youtu.be/rJHUZNlO9ao (Remastered Minitel output) https://youtu.be/JIZ_D34J3-I https://youtu.be/JIZ_D34J3-I The Minitel was such a national pride that the Internet had a hard time piercing through the habits and the collective mind, setting back France by a couple of years on that front. Said misplaced pride is also very visible on some other bad decision making such as forcefully applying national preference to technology such as Bull computers in the enterprise or Thomson TO7&MO5 in schools which were ripped apart by the competition nonetheless. This behavior is still visible today as the government tried to push for "the French Cloud" by heavily subsidizing software such as a poor alternative to Dropbox which became Orange Cloud or looking the other way when Deezer was clearly violating IP rights by padding its music catalogue as it was missing deals from the majors. Same goes with banks shunning Apple/Android Pay in favor of being hell-bent on that sad sad Paylib thing, and various other similar heavy cases of NIH. I'm tentatively hopeful but very cautions about that "French SV" thing. Wait&see.
- bengalister 9y agoThe solutions of the "baccalaureat", high school end of course exam were also available online just a few hours after the exam, if not immediately after. I still wonder who entered the them and how they got them so quickly. I guess some paid teachers who were able to get a copy of the exam tests or even illegal copies before the exam took place. I remember spending quite some time checking all online the solutions of the Math exam.
- makapuf 9y agoI think there indeed is national pride from the French Tech. I don't think USA is totally immune from it. How many non USA services do US people use ? Of course many were invented here but some were not and were reimplememted.
- djhworld 9y agoWas Minitel something only the middle and upper classes had, or was it a universal thing? I'm from the UK, I didn't get onto the web until 1999, before that we used Teletext. I think the advantage to it was most televisions supported Teletext by the 1980s and it was a free service - albeit you had to pay your annual TV license.
- chinathrow 9y agoI was also a heavy user of telext in my earlier years as a news junkie - I wouldn't compare it to Minitel or the web though, as it was unidirectional only.
- mjw1007 9y agoThe UK equivalent of Minitel was Prestel, which used the same display system as Teletext.
- djulius 9y agoIt was ubiquitous, everybody had a minitel at home since it was provided for free by France Télécom. The white/yellow page service (3611) was free for the first three minutes and was widely used. My parents never had the (huge) yearly book version at home. As mentioned in other comments it was also widely used to consult Baccalauréat (national exam like SAT) results.
- bigbugbag 9y agoAt peak in 2003 there were 9.1 millions minitels for 55 millions people so not ubiquitous but common. 3611 used to offer the first 3 minutes free for a few years then removed this.
- vbernat 9y ago3611 was free until 2007, when it became mostly irrelevant. 9.1 millions of minitels is about half the population (in number of households). I don't think that 2003 was a peak since Internet was already there for quite some time (people could get broadband at this time).
- tormeh 9y agoMinitel really illustrates my view on the tech business: Go global or go home. Scale is King.
- makapuf 9y agoWell Minitel tried to go global there was a Californian trial (and a country wide scale was unheard or for online services).
- revscat 9y agoIt was called USVideotel, and it was moderately successful. I worked for them in the late 80s. It was very popular amongst its users, but eventually lost to Prodigy and AOL.
- eli 9y agoOr maybe successful tech eventually becomes global. Tech history is littered with examples of good companies that failed because they expanded too fast
- genericacct 9y agoCredit where credit is due: the french invented fembots
- jim_lawless 9y agoAn effort to bring Minitel-based computing to the masses happened in Omaha, Nebraska in the early 1990's. The service was named CommunityLink. It was a joint venture between U.S. West ( then, a Regional Bell Operating Company ) and France Telecom. You can see the overview beginning at minute 16:00 in this episode of the old TV show The Computer Chronicles: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwNc1zQ0Fpg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwNc1zQ0Fpg The above episode begins with the Minitel story from France. CommunityLink didn't really seem to catch on, locally. We did have a thriving BBS community at this time and most techies that I knew had CompuServe accounts.
- thatguy0900 9y ago"Minitel enthusiasts cherished the network’s privacy and anonymity. In late 1984, Minitel engineers added a feature to the terminal that saved the last page visited and made it easier for the user to pick up an interrupted session—as a browser cookie does today. The public outcry was swift and brutal. Editorials in newspapers, which (rightly) saw Minitel as a competitor, warned that Big Brother had arrived. Some 3,000 terminals were returned in protest. The PTT soon dropped this feature." Pretty sad to see where we've come since then
- digi_owl 9y agoI think the basic problem is that while back then we had a low water mark of privacy, the Soviet Union, that the west wanted to stay above as a point of pride, these days we have none.
- kalleboo 9y agoWell we have China, but western leaders seem to be more prone to using the Chinese Great Firewall as a leading example than a bad example.
- digi_owl 9y agoFunnily China seems to be treated more like a capitalist oligarchy these days (and may well be operating like one as well). The last remaining communist nations to be "feared" seems to be Cuba and North Korea.
- walshemj 9y agoPrivacy lol I bet France telecom could look at every thing and as it was tied to the phone line it wasn't very anonymous.
- digi_owl 9y agoAs an aside, i recall running into something similar to a Minitel, only it was web based and used ISDN for connectivity. Basically it was a desk phone with a slide out keyboard and embedded web browser.
- kalleboo 9y agoThere were a bunch of devices kind of like that around the dot-com boom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3Com_Audrey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3Com_Audrey
- webreac 9y agoI remember having used minitel 1B (80 colomns) in 1992 to connect to my school from home (600km away) to send my updated (using vi) report (in latex) to my teacher. The main drawback of course was that the phone line was always busy. It was using a quite cheap (the equivalent of 0.02€ per minutes) connection (36 21).
- wolfgangK 9y agoFond memories of programming my Amiga to scrap pages from the Minitel to fill up up database instead of doing data entry by hand, as ha been expected of me during my first intership…
- MayeulC 9y agoFor what it's worth, I still have one around here. It makes for a great retro-terminal that can be plugged on a 1200 bauds serial connection. I agree that it isn't the most lightweight solution, but it at least works pretty well, and without hassle.
- gumby 9y agoThe article isn't kidding when it said that the old phone system was terrible, phones typically had a second earpiece so you could hear through both ears in the hope of making out what the other party said. And them in a huge jump foreward, the PTT switched to digital and by 1980 anybody could get digital service (isdn) cheaply at their house.
- drewmate 9y agoWhat was the significance of the '3615' in all the service codes? Was this just a common prefix like 'www' in web addresses?
- ebalit 9y agoIt was more than a common prefix. More like a portal.
- vbernat 9y agoIt's the short phone number to dial to get access to the portal where you enter the name of the service you want. There were different ones with different pricing. 3614 was cheaper (no revenue for the service I think), 3615 was regular and 3617 was expensive (you could buy stuff, like games by staying online). While most services were accessible through this portal (operated by the French telco), you could also dial a "regular number" to access some services à la BBS.
- Renaud 9y agoThe various services had different peicing tiers. 3615 was the most used and would cost a few francs per minutes. Some sites would force you to spend some time on their 3615 number so you could accumulate 'minutes' of use through the cheaper '3614' number. They used that scheme to modulate the cost of their service.
- bane 9y agoQuick question for those who remember the time. What was BBSing like back in the Minitel days? In the States and other places without an equivalent system, BBSs were pretty much the only way to connect in any kind of "on-line", but as soon as the Web became widespread BBSs died a very quick death. I would suppose that Minitel would have prevented an equivalent BBS scene from developing in France, but I have no idea. I know there were reasonably big scenes in other parts of Europe though.
- kawera 9y agoThere were plenty of BBSs in France at the time but mostly used by people who were "into computers". Oh, and Compuserve!
- grumblestumble 9y agoAlso, shoutout to BelTel in South Africa, my first foray into online world, including national chat, way back in 1985.
- jedisct1 9y agoAnyone with Minitels or compatible modems could run their own service, just like a BBS. There were quite a lot of these services, that anyone could connect to, for just the cost of a local communication. They had interesting features such as file transfers, real-time multiparty chatrooms, the ability to define macros (custom sequences of control code to display fancy images and animations in discussion boards and chatrooms), and more. At that time, local phone calls were not free, but they were cheap compared to longer-distance (but still in France) calls. So, these services were federating very local communities. Members frequently met in person. Think about Facebook just for your city, where most people in your friend list are people you actually know in person and often hang out with. That was pretty awesome. Internet being global is amazing, but these very local communities were also amazing in a different way.