12 ms·
California's beaches belong to the public
- pulse7 9y agoAs much as I hate to say this - I must say it: this was one of the few good things (maybe the only one?) about communism - public beaches for all seas, lakes and rivers. Nobody could own first 4 meters from the water. And many tourist from non-communist countries came and enjoyed and marvelled this freedom they didn't have in their own countries. Western countries could copy this...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Tade0 9y agoComing from an ex-communist country I was amazed to see that privately owned beaches with an entrance fee are even a thing. Unfortunately from what I witnessed there's way too much money to be made in this business, so if somebody is going to adopt someone else's approach, then it's going to be the ex-communist countries.
- Swizec 9y agoThe trick they use in my ex-communist country is to make a really really nice beach, and charge exorbitant fees for services like chair and sunshade rental. Oh you don't want that? Too bad, beach is covered in them, no room for your towel unless you wanna invade people's personal space I'm afraid. Maybe you should find a different beach eh buddy?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djsumdog 9y ago> communism socialism. Socialism is when the state provides something for the people. Fire, police, roads, buses/public transport, parks, the post office .. all that is socialism. Communism is buying a round of beers and the next person in your group buying a round of beers. It's the understood unspoken agreement between your flatmates to keep the place clean. It's the communal aspect of humanity and we all practice it every day.
- eevilspock 9y ago> Communism is... the communal aspect of humanity and we all practice it every day. So well put. Most families practice "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." Evil communist pigs!
- tomjakubowski 9y ago> Socialism is when the state provides something for the people No, socialism has nothing to do with the state. It just describes a social-economic system where workers collectively own the capital goods they use to produce value, rather than members of the capitalist class. This is why kibbutzes could be described as "socialist" despite being entirely private and not related to the Israeli state. Social democracy and "welfare states" are what you're thinking of.
- eigenvector 9y agoYou don't need communism to have the concept of public lands and public rights-of-way across private land. A huge part of the western USA and Alaska, after all, is public lands. The UK: https://www.gov.uk/right-of-way-open-access-land/use-your-right-to-roam https://www.gov.uk/right-of-way-open-access-land/use-your-ri... Scotland, which has even broader rights than the rest of the UK: http://www.ramblers.org.uk/advice/paths-and-access/england/what-is-the-right-to-roam.aspx http://www.ramblers.org.uk/advice/paths-and-access/england/w... Sweden: http://www.swedishepa.se/Environmental-objectives-and-cooperation/Swedish-environmental-work/Work-areas/This-is-the-Right-of-Public-Access/ http://www.swedishepa.se/Environmental-objectives-and-cooper... Norway: https://www.visitnorway.com/plan-your-trip/travel-tips-a-z/right-of-access/ https://www.visitnorway.com/plan-your-trip/travel-tips-a-z/r... Public access is absolutely compatible with private land titles and liberal democracy - we just need the government to step up and implement it over the objections of the privileged few.
- komali2 9y agoSpain
- benjohnson 9y agoThe rights to to beach access can also be traced to the Code of Justinian in the 6th century: 1. By the law of nature these things are common to mankind, the air, running water, the sea, and consequently the shores of the sea. No one, therefore, is forbidden to approach the seashore, provided that he respects habitationes, monuments, and buildings which are not, like the sea, subject only to the law of nations. 2. All rivers and ports are public; hence the right of fishing in a port, or in rivers, is common to all men. 3. The seashore extends as far as the greatest winter flood runs up. 4. The public use of the banks of a river is part of the law of nations, just as is that of the river itself. All persons, therefore, are as much at liberty to bring their vessels to the bank, to fasten ropes to the trees growing there, and to place any part of their cargo there, as to navigate the river itself But the banks of a river are the property of those whose land they adjoin; and consequently the trees growing on them are also the property of the same persons. 5. The public use of the seashore, too, is part of the law of nations, as is that of the sea itself; and, therefore, any person is at liberty to place on it a cottage, to which he may retreat, or to dry his nets there, and haul them from the sea; for the shores may be said to be the property of no man, but are subject to the same law as the sea itself, and the sand or ground beneath it. TLDR: Really old Roman dude said watery stuff is public.
- option 9y agoSo the court ruled he must restore the access and he just ignores the ruling. Can someone explain again why? And, of course, as a surfer and computer scientist I find Mr. Khosla disgusting because of this.
- option 9y agoBtw, if you care, contact your elected official. Surfrider foundation has a link to do so http://www.surfrider.org http://www.surfrider.org
- pmoriarty 9y agoI'm not sure if you're asking why he ignores the ruling or why he's allowed to get away with it. Regarding why he ignores the ruling, the article says he does it on "principle". Presumably, he feels it's his land and he can do whatever he wants with it. But it would be interesting to hear him defend his position himself rather than having to put words in his mouth. As to why he gets away with it, presumably the penalties for ignoring the courts are not severe enough. Maybe he's just rich enough to pay whatever fine has been levied on him and keep access closed. It reminds me of when Microsoft was fined by the courts something like a million dollars a day for violating antitrust regulations, and they just paid and kept violating (if I'm remembering this right). Some companies prefer to just get the law changed in their favor instead, or maybe get people elected who will defund regulating bodies or put their cronies in control, etc. When you're rich enough you have many options for evading the law.
- option 9y ago>> "the penalties for ignoring the courts are not severe enough" - This seems to violate state's constitution. How can this be something anyone can regularly get away with?!
- FireBeyond 9y ago> presumably the penalties for ignoring the courts are not severe enough And this is the crux of it. Khosla is a multi billionaire. He could afford to pay a fine of $10,000 a day for the rest of his life. At what point does this become contempt of court and lead to jail time? Unfortunately, in the US, the answer is likely "never, because he has too much net worth".
- Camillo 9y agoWhy can't they go to the gate with the court order and a sheriff and cut the lock?
- just4themoney 9y agoBecause he appealed the order and the appeal hasn't been decided yet.
- SwellJoe 9y agoI've ranted about this here before, and I'll rant again. Up and down the coast of CA there's a tremendous amount of public beach made inaccessible by wealthy property owners. Malibu is awful in this regard, with (bogus) no trespassing signs and gates everywhere. I spent a month there, for a conference in LA, and made a point of stomping around on every "no trespassing" beach I could get to, and some of them are hard to get to. But Malibu is not alone. The thing I don't understand is why police don't simply cut the lock every time Khosla locks the damned thing. It's gone to court, he lost (as he should have), and now he continues to blatantly violate the law. Petty criminals have been shot and killed (thousands of times) over less blatant disregard of a legal order, but a rich guy can get away with a massive theft of a public resource for years without any consequences. Money may not buy happiness, but it certainly buys the right to be a truly awful human being without consequence. Why can't a citizen simply call the police every time a gate is closed and locked? Send Khosla the bill for a locksmith or whatever it takes to restore access. Cities do it for overgrown lawns (which is harmless, IMHO), and this is causing actual harm to the public good.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> The thing I don't understand is why police don't simply cut the lock every time Khosla locks the damned thing. It's gone to court, he lost (as he should have), and now he continues to blatantly violate the law. I'm happy to pay for someone to get bolt cutters and put them somewhere nearby for the public to use when needed. "Break glass in case of affluenza"
- jayd16 9y agoYeah, chain the bolt cutters to the fence...er wait. Hmm.
- Animats 9y agoSome years ago, in Los Altos Hills, a new landowner built a fence across a horse trail easement. The mayor and police chief went to the site and cut the fence open. It can be done.
- atomical 9y agoThis man does not have the personality of Warren Buffet or Charlie Munger.
- bsg75 9y agoIf the gate and trespass warnings are invalid, what happens to citizens who ignore them, and cut the lock themselves?
- s73ver 9y agoIdeally nothing, but I’m sure he tries to harass them.
- hyperliner 9y agoIf they are valid, and he shots and kills an intruder, would that be trespassing and he fearing for his life be a valid legal defense?
- wavefunction 9y agoIt's public access, Khosla doesn't get to decide if it's trespassing. That would be a complaint lodged by the local authorities against someone if they were accessing the land in prohibited hours. So it would be murder. Who knows, maybe Khosla wants to hunt humans for the sport of it but probably he just wants to keep paying miniscule fines hoping to wear the public down. I'd lodge the fines in the form of the land he owns abutting the easement.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sbov 9y agoWrong state.
- s73ver 9y agoThe state of California has the common sense to not allow you to execute someone just because you believe they may be trespassing.
- chroma 9y agoIt's important to notice that any argument in favor of public access to beaches can be applied to any kind of desirable land. One could make an isomorphic argument about mountaintops: "The concept of a private mountaintop is backwards and unethical. Why should rich people be able to restrict others from hiking to the top and enjoying scenic views?" Should we ban private ownership of mountaintops? Public beaches are a good thing, but it's wasteful to ban ownership of all 840 miles of California coastline. Some people want private beaches, even if the law doesn't allow for it. They'll lock gates, block roads, and otherwise shirk the law to get what they want. The state then must then expend significant resources discovering and sanctioning these people. A better solution would be for the state to tax private beaches. That would collect significant revenue from people like Khosla while still allowing only a small fraction of the coast to be privately-owned. Edit: I'm not saying we should ban public beaches. I'm saying allow something like 20 miles of private coastline and auction off the rights every year. The other 820 miles of coastline would remain public, and the state would collect millions in revenue to be used for social welfare.
- rebootthesystem 9y agoI think you missed this part: "Public access to Martins Beach, and to all land seaward of the mean high tide line in California, is guaranteed in the state’s constitution and mandated within the Coastal Act of 1976."
- hyperliner 9y agoSo it's the right to bear arms in the US Constitution, but that does not stop us from wondering whether it is archaic and whether it should be changed. Or is there a difference?
- mnglkhn2 9y agoIf we are of the opinion that everything should be private, then why not privatize Central Park?! What could go wrong if some poor kids will never get to see the beach? It makes it even more of an incentive to work hard, am I right? /sarcasm The truth is that the bigger the disparities between rich and poor the more violent the environment gets. So, let those poor kids access to the beach and you'll be able to enjoy your wealth.
- la6470 9y agoWhat about the private beaches for resorts and hotels?
- option 9y agoI wonder if the public opinion (in SV) can be turned enough against Khosla for this. To the point it'll hurt his businesses. Much like it was (deservedly) turned against Uber for their behavior.
- xxSparkleSxx 9y agoI bet it can, so let's get started! Here's a list of companies that Khosla ventures invested in: http://www.khoslaventures.com/portfolio/all-companies http://www.khoslaventures.com/portfolio/all-companies Is anyone who works for or owns these companies reading this? Would you be willing to quit your job or return funding so as not to support a sociopath and to help make the world a better place? Anyone know people who work for these companies? It would be great if you could (kindly) remind them of the types of people they are working to enrich every day and how those people are using their riches to abuse society. Bet we can change a few minds!
- komali2 9y agoEh, I'd rather just drive out to the gate and cut the lock. Where is it exactly? I'll do it next week.
- randycupertino 9y agoSomeone should facebook organize some sort of protest there where we all march across the gates.
- rocky1138 9y agoThere is definitely a need for organization here. Probably a Google spreadsheet with location and "most recent lock cut" date.
- SwellJoe 9y agoYou'll likely need an angle grinder with a metal cutoff blade (bolt cutters can't handle a good lock, though if it's on a chain, the chain might be a weak link). The article said there's security on the premises, so be prepared for that sort of trouble (make sure you've got an emergency number and people who know what's going on in case you're arrested). Though, I have a hard time seeing how restoring legal public access could be considered a crime. Maybe just bringing witnesses and cameras will be enough to protect you from security.
- hyperliner 9y agoYou mean trespassing into private property without a warrant?
- gokhan 9y ago"court order"
- cylinder 9y agoAre you dense? It's not private property, that's the whole point!
- dang 9y agoPlease don't respond to bad comments by making the thread even worse. We ban accounts that make personal attacks.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679294 and marked it off-topic.
- hyperliner 9y agoIt's funny to see people here trying to protect something "because the Constitution" when the right to bear arms in the US Cobstitution is "archaic and should be changed."
- option 9y agoIt is amazing how people "just don't get it". Laws can (and ocassionaly) should be changed. They should not be violated. The discussion here is about a person constantly violating the law, court order and just getting away with it.
- forkLding 9y agoThe difference is that one's actually on the paper and one's not
- SwellJoe 9y agoWhat does this conversation have to do with the second amendment? Who has brought up guns here, except you? Are you intentionally trolling?
- refurb 9y agoI think it's a fair comment. I would expect everyone who supports the constitution to just as vigorously support the 2nd Amendment. Or is it a pick and choose document?
- SwellJoe 9y agoWe're talking about the California Constitution, and no one has mentioned guns or the second amendment of the United States Constitution, except for the above nonsequitur. WTF are you talking about?
- s73ver 9y agoBecause there's a HUGE difference between access to nature, and access to devices who's sole purpose is for killing.
- hyperliner 9y agoIs the question here not that Public Access if guaranteed constitutionally, but whether a single citizen should bear the cost of the public having to go through his property to access the beach? I can't tell what the Constitution says about which path the public must use to access a beach. Is it the case that the State or municipalities failed to secure or purchase property to build a path, and now want a single citizen to pay for this path?
- johnmarcus 9y ago"e had been warned by San Mateo County and the California Coastal Commission – before and after buying the property – that he would be required to keep the public access open. Public access to Martins Beach, and to all land seaward of the mean high tide line in California, is guaranteed in the state’s constitution and mandated within the Coastal Act of 1976."
- hyperliner 9y agoI had read that too. It's clear that the beaches are public. But I would not trust a government employee. It's unclear to me that the Constitution guarantees my right to cross anybody's private property to access the public beach. Why can't people go through other properties doors, climb fences, etc. to enjoy the right to use a public beach? Why is this path considered public property, when it is clearly private? I think this is the issue.
- djrogers 9y agoIt’s a simple easement issue. If he wanted to create a new path for he public to access the beach, then nobody would care if he closed this one. It’s not as if this was an after-the-fact decision, the public access path existed when he bought the property, as did the existing law and state constitution. His responsibility as a property owner there is to maintain that public access.
- ScottBurson 9y ago"An easement is a non-possessory right to use and/or enter onto the real property of another without possessing it." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easement
- hanoz 9y agoIs there no scope to prosecute someone who illegally locks up public land under false imprisonment laws, i.e. I am being falsely imprisoned in the part of the world which doesn't include the locked up bit?
- blackbagboys 9y agoWhile it's heartening to see a vigorous reaction to the utter contempt for the law demonstrated by Khosla and his ilk, it's also understandably discouraging to see the ease with which people with virtually unlimited resources can abuse and exploit the public. That's why it's important to remember that civil disobedience is perfectly justified to combat this kind of criminality; e.g. sit-ins occupation of the land in question, a 'March to the Sea' through the disputed access-ways, and/or direct action against the gates, locks, and signs.
- lovemenot 9y agoThe 1932 civil disobediance in the moors near Manchester had long-lasting social impact. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_trespass_of_Kinder_Scout https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_trespass_of_Kinder_Scou...
- randycupertino 9y agoIf someone organized something like that, I'd happily go!
- all_usernames 9y agoSame.
- pasbesoin 9y agoWish judges would/could find contempt of court and toss these selfish recalcitrants in jail. No release until public access is (re)secured. After all, that was the court's finding -- that public access was/is required.
- hyperliner 9y agoSo if I did the same for people to do that in your house you would be ok too? If not, what's the difference?
- pmoriarty 9y agoThe article says Khosla doesn't even live there. As someone else in this thread pointed out, his whole motivation for doing this is probably just to get the state to buy the disputed part of the property from him for millions of dollars. Comparing this to someone breaking in to your your house is ridiculous.
- hyperliner 9y agoHe does not need to live there to want to protect his property. It seems that he owns a property that has a path that the public thinks is public property. It seems legally the property is private. At least, I have not been able to find an easement description. In a state and country where the notion of private property constitutes a sacred principle, it seems to me he deserves compensation from the public. If this happened to me, I certainly would demand it, but I am glad a rich person with resources can fight this for me. Otherwise, who is to stop people onme neighborhood to cut through my property to access the park behind my house?
- notyourwork 9y ago> He does not need to live there to want to protect his property. Did you read the article? It is not his property, it is public access to a public beach. He deserves compensation for losing in court and continue to break the law with which the court upheld? I'm confused, did we read the same article?
- hyperliner 9y ago"So the coastal commission tried to broker a compromise, chief of enforcement Lisa Haage said. Officials offered to consider moving the access road, to find a nonprofit to operate the entry and to close on rainy days when the beach was muddy. But the talks went nowhere." If it was clear cut, why is the Chief of Enforcement accommodating alternatives?
- Animats 9y agoMalibu’s Zonker Harris beach accessway is "closed for repair". Again. Since summer 2016.
- jedmeyers 9y agoPolice chief? Los Altos Hills does not have a police department.
- randycupertino 9y agoProbably was a county sheriff. Why is it necessary to split hairs?
- 80211 9y agoBecause it's never ok to be sloppy with facts.
- khazhoux 9y agoYes, society MUST be protected.
- honestoHeminway 9y agoCaptain Nitpick, he arrived just in time to save us all! <BAM> Im so sorry for forgetting about the quotation marks - Captain Nitpick! <WHAM!> AND NOW FOR THE VILLIANS!
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to HN?
- 80211 9y agoBecause it's never ok to be sloppy with facts.
- hkmurakami 9y agoThey definitely have a vehicle or two that says Los Altos Hills Sheriff.
- Mz 9y agoWe used to have a concept of "outlawry." What it meant varied over time, but it was rooted in the reality that the court system and law enforcement had limits on how much they could do. So, they would declare someone an "outlaw" as a means to deal with this. In some times and places, this meant anyone could murder them. They were not protected by the laws of the land. I don't know what the solution is today and I am not suggesting that we should make it legal to murder someone like Khosla, but we need a mechanism for addressing the fact that our legal system cannot control everything. Someone this rich winds up being beyond the law in far too many ways and they don't care. I think one of the things wrong with modern life is the delusion that the legal system is in control to a greater degree than it is. This has all kinds of problematic side effects. There are far too few rules for what to do when someone is breaking all the rules and it means that rule followers are routinely crapped on by certain classes of rule breakers in a way for which there is no real remedy.
- zanny 9y agoSounds like a bandage on a more general issue of the police not representing the will of the people. There are many ways to fix that, that have been discussed a thousand times in forums across the Internet. But really, if your police are acting in the will of the general citizenry, they would be arresting anyone repeatedly breaking the law to such a large degree as this, no matter what. If they aren't you can tell the police are not loyal to the people, especially when instead they spend their time bloodying or killing people taking recreational drugs instead.
- Mz 9y agoSometimes, putting a bandage on it yourself is the correct answer. Imagine a world in which we could do nothing medical for ourselves at all and could ONLY call an ambulance any time we had a problem. I am fine with the courts and legal system trying to come up with solutions that say, in essence, "for little things, you are allowed to bandage it yourself and here is the list of approved remedies."
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoAllowing people to murder him is going way too far. There is already a simple legal solution to people who willfully defy court orders: put him in jail for contempt until he complies with the order. This is simply a failure of the legal system to apply the law equally to the rich and powerful as it does to the poor and powerless.
- hyperliner 9y agoMayor cutting fences? Hmmm, what is this, some banana republic?
- khazhoux 9y agoIIRC, the official Los Altos Hills fence-cutter was on holiday that week, and so the Mayor had to step in. Believe me, this was all above board.
- greglindahl 9y agoThis is California. California has a court system, and the property owner has access to the courts. Given the price of land in Los Altos, I suspect money to go to court is not a problem. So, where exactly is the banana republic?
- rjurney 9y agoNo, it's a jerk on Hacker News.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679492 and marked it off-topic.
- jondubois 9y agoI think eventually we'll have to push the reset button on capitalism. The government should repossess all shares of public and large private companies and redistribute them to everyone based on some formula. I don't understand why this hasn't happened yet. Probably 95% of us would be better off and it would make things interesting again. It would open up many new opportunities for everyone. Why do the majority of people who are not wealthy vote for things which benefit wealthy people? Those same wealthy people who only care about themselves. The fact that this comment will probably get down-voted by lower and middle-class people is mind-boggling to me.
- usaphp 9y agoBecause media is owned by rich people and they trick regular people into believing that what they are doing is for their own good
- jondubois 9y ago...Or maybe for some higher principle. Though it's ironic given that the majority of wealthy people have no principles themselves; yet they are very good at teaching them to other people.
- weirdstuff 9y agoThe rich have principles. They're just more sociopathic principles, IMO.
- hyperliner 9y ago"Joan Gallo, a former San Jose city attorney who represents the land owner, agreed that the courts should weigh in. The Deeneys had run a private business, she said, allowing invitees of their choosing onto the property, and that hadn't changed. "It seems to us that it's an important issue to be litigated," Gallo said. "I have a strong belief that the Constitution doesn't require you to give up property rights or conduct a business you don't want to conduct." Mark Massara — a surfer and attorney who is working with McClosky and the law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy on the case — said he believed the constitutional arguments have merit. But since that approach could drag on for years (think Geffen), his team opted for "a very narrow strike to the heart of this thing."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dang 9y agoYou've done staggering damage to this thread, posting something like 20 comments, most of which were inflammatory and several of which were copied and pasted. If you behave like this again on HN we're going to have to ban you. It leads straight to flamewars and this one was particularly wretched. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679391 and marked it off-topic.
- hyperliner 9y agoThe Denney's (previous owners) used to charge for people using their property to go into the beach. Maybe you should read instead of calling names and getting bent out of shape? "Joan Gallo, a former San Jose city attorney who represents the land owner, agreed that the courts should weigh in. The Deeneys had run a private business, she said, allowing invitees of their choosing onto the property, and that hadn't changed. "It seems to us that it's an important issue to be litigated," Gallo said. "I have a strong belief that the Constitution doesn't require you to give up property rights or conduct a business you don't want to conduct." Mark Massara — a surfer and attorney who is working with McClosky and the law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy on the case — said he believed the constitutional arguments have merit. But since that approach could drag on for years (think Geffen), his team opted for "a very narrow strike to the heart of this thing."
- cjensen 9y agoSorry, but you are wrong. Khosla could have maintained the property in the old state where he charged admission and made no changes to the property. He was warned about this when he bought the property. California law is extremely clear about this, and a cursor check of case law would have confirmed this. Khosla knowingly violated the law in an attempt to remove public access using thin and unlikely legal excuses involving pre-US law. He had his day in court and lost. He has received a court order and continues to be defiant. This isn't the "property rights" hill you want to die on. This is an utter jerk being an utter jerk. This is a rich man trying to use money as a substitute for following clear Law. This is such extreme lawless behavior that every time that every time I see a company take investment from Khosla it stains that company in my mind forever.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679505 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679505 and marked it off-topic.
- hyperliner 9y agoIt's not public Joan Gallo, a former San Jose city attorney who represents the land owner, agreed that the courts should weigh in. The Deeneys had run a private business, she said, allowing invitees of their choosing onto the property, and that hadn't changed. "It seems to us that it's an important issue to be litigated," Gallo said. "I have a strong belief that the Constitution doesn't require you to give up property rights or conduct a business you don't want to conduct." Mark Massara — a surfer and attorney who is working with McClosky and the law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy on the case — said he believed the constitutional arguments have merit. But since that approach could drag on for years (think Geffen), his team opted for "a very narrow strike to the heart of this thing."
- Aloha 9y agoYou've posted this at least 4 times in this thread. Why? This is a clearly established matter of both state law, and the common law, and every time a property owner has fought, they've lost, at considerable expense to both them, and the taxpayer.
- dang 9y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14679544 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SSLy 9y agoWhy is this on hackernews?
- greglindahl 9y agoBecause the landowner discussed in the article is a part of the SV tech community.
- SSLy 9y agoSigh. I guess flagging and going on my merry way is the only thing to do here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rjurney 9y agoI wouldn't take Khosla's money if they offered it to me, so terrible is his behavior regarding public access to the beach at his house. He has thugs chasing people off from public access.
- chasing 9y agoThis is one of those situations that can be summed up rather succinctly: Christ, what an asshole.
- Judgmentality 9y agoThe thing I find most fascinating about Khosla is that he is so obsessed with limiting access to public property, that he will be remembered years later for that instead of anything else he has done. He already has a reputation as an asshole in the VC community (which is saying something), this just cinches it to permanently tarnish his reputation. Of course he obviously doesn't care - he just wants that beach.
- jsemrau 9y ago> he just wants that beach. He wants to win the principle to control the access to the beach. Sorry to be pedantic, but if he would be living there full-time, he might have an argument, but he doesn't.
- all_usernames 9y ago> He wants to win the principle to control the access to the beach. Which is much worse than just wanting the beach, because he's fighting a battle to set a precedent that is directly contrary to the public good.
- valuearb 9y agoCalifornia's beaches are publicly owned. Which is also why they are toilets.
- rdiddly 9y agoThe "principle" he's adhering to is property rights, with a healthy dose of welching on your agreements. All we need here is 5,000 people to show up at the same time, 4,999 of them carrying beach towels, and one of them carrying bolt-cutters and a beach towel, and then they enjoy a day at the beach. Or several days, resupplied occasionally with food and so forth by the GoFundMe campaign.
- greggman 9y agoIf you want an example of providing access across private property in the bay area drive up to Genentech. You can drive right through their campus to access the public beach and there are several public parking spaces provided here. https://goo.gl/maps/hAyPMsWvJV52 https://goo.gl/maps/hAyPMsWvJV52 I'd be curious if there's a story there. If Genentech knew they needed to do this and just did it or if it was settled after. Either way it would be good to know. On the other hand, I tried walking in the Dogpatch area of San Francisco near the end of 25th street along the water and was warned off. When I called the government to check why that wasn't public I was told not all coastline is public. https://goo.gl/maps/VVRNoHyKkSk https://goo.gl/maps/VVRNoHyKkSk A better example of that I'm pretty sure you can't access the shoreline around SFO.
- codezero 9y agoToday I found the Ritz Carleton hotel in half moon bay provided access and free parking! I was having trouble finding even paid beachside parking today and stumbled on this.
- tajen 9y agoSometimes I write emails to tell corporations that they are famous because they did a positive thing. I believe it encourages them, even if the email is eaten by the receptionist, if you can somehow demonstrate in the email that it brings them customers ("I always recommend XYZCorp because of that thing you did for the community").
- dmode 9y agoYes, I regularly park there to access the beach. Very well kept secret
- pmoriarty 9y agoThis reminds me of the Privately Owned Public Open Spaces (POPOS) in San Francisco.[1] "Scattered throughout Downtown San Francisco are public plazas, atriums, and roof gardens. Privately Owned Public Open Spaces (POPOS) hide behind secret elevators, security guards, and stairs. Their elusive trait raises the question: if they are public, then why are they hidden? In a city where land is scarce, POPOS allocate open space to prevent overdevelopment. The 1985 Downtown Plan mandates developers build and maintain 1 sq ft of public space for each 50 sq ft of commercial space. Yet, developers hide them from the public to keep cost of maintenance low..." [1] - https://medium.com/sf-popos/the-21-secret-parks-of-san-francisco-192e6d88ea0a https://medium.com/sf-popos/the-21-secret-parks-of-san-franc...
- jakelarkin 9y agofrom what I remember, Khosla and his lawyers were real jerks to the county and throughout the trials but I think their biggest problem was he has to pay for a relatively expensive liability insurance policy for public passage on the private access road that runs on his property, the only "easy" access to Martins Beach. The previous owners just sort of let things fly w/o insurance. If the road was owned by the county and he gated it somehow he wouldn't have a leg to stand on but the problem is more nuanced ... Should he personally have to incur a large cost to maintain a public good b/c of proximity? It does seem arbitrary. A better man might sell the road to the county or come to some other compromise but he's become obsessed with the principle of the matter.
- hudibras 9y agoI don't know if what you said about the insurance is correct or not, but if it is then that should have been factored into the price that Khosla paid to get the land (and possibly the government's assessment of the land value). Nobody forced him to buy that property.
- jayd16 9y agoIts what he signed up for when he bought the place.
- michaelchisari 9y agoNot only was this part of the deal when purchasing the land, I'm sure if the insurance costs were an issue, he could work out a compromise with the State of California to donate the access path land.
- all_usernames 9y agoVinod Khosla is clearly a despicable example of a mega-wealthy individual, but is not the problem here the existence of the ultra-rich? Anyone allowed by society to accrue that much wealth will be above the law almost by definition. If we value the rule of law, why do we think it good to produce billionaires?
- robbiemitchell 9y agoGenuinely surprised no one has simply removed the gate or otherwise rendered it useless.
- rdtsc 9y agoThought of that too. But since he built the gate, it might still fall under destruction of property or vandalism. Now what about picking the lock? If the gate or lock is not damaged it might be ok. Since the access is public it wouldn't be breaking in or trespassing? Even more interesting if the only way out is via the gate, and his minions lock the gate there might be case for kidnapping? Call the police and claim you have been kidnapped by Khosla. Too far fetched probably...
- all_usernames 9y agoThere's a FB group for those who might be interested in mobilizing: https://www.facebook.com/groups/friendsofmartinsbeach/ https://www.facebook.com/groups/friendsofmartinsbeach/
- unlmtd 9y agoThat's all nice and fluffy sounding. Anyhow, I'll sell my share of the beaches and take the cash. What? I can't? Then this whole story is one giant bull shit. If you can't sell it, you don't own it.
- banku_brougham 9y agoI really appreciate the direct-action interest on behalf of the public here in these comments. In my commentary however, i just cant get over how selfish someone would have to be. I'd feel terrible if i somehow blocked somebody's family picnic. Yet here is someone doing this to hundreds of people, probably, every weekend. There are possibly thousands who grew up in the region and went to that beach regularly. I simply cant personally imagine being so completely void of consideration.
- CoachRufus87 9y agoParks too? http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/11-a-good-walk-spoiled http://revisionisthistory.com/episodes/11-a-good-walk-spoile...
- handedness 9y agoThe only saving grace is that the gate is low and easily passed: 1. http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/45/63/00/9908283/3/1024x1024.jpg http://ww4.hdnux.com/photos/45/63/00/9908283/3/1024x1024.jpg 2. http://ww2.hdnux.com/photos/32/27/65/6913369/19/rawImage.jpg http://ww2.hdnux.com/photos/32/27/65/6913369/19/rawImage.jpg
- diyseguy 9y agoI wish we had this law in Washington State. Most beaches here are privately owned and many of the few public beaches here are laughably tiny - 150' to 200' wide with threatening signs on either end.
- hi41 9y agoKhosla is from India and people from that region have utter disregard for the law. These rich indians took our jobs and are not taking over our land. (I am a person of Indian origin so I think it okay to have this opinion). Wrest back beaches that belong to the people.