4 ms·
The US has a strong inter-city travel network in the airlines. The TSA severely limits its effectiveness, so it could be tempting to build a rail network just
by closeparen 9y ago
The US has a strong inter-city travel network in the airlines.
The TSA severely limits its effectiveness, so it could be tempting to build a rail network just to bypass the TSA, but there's no reason to think the same screening procedures won't apply to HSR after the first incident (or just threat).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smudgymcscmudge 9y agoThis reminds me of the popularity boost various nosql databases got because it allowed devs to sidestep bureaucracy that had built up around schema changes.
- bsder 9y agoThat's the first useful justification I have ever seen for NoSQL. How in the world did I miss such an obvious thing?
- achamayou 9y agoThere is: you can't easily turn a train into a weapon able to take down any large piece of infrastructure in sight. In fact since all high speed trains are electric, you probably can't get very far before the inevitable power cut.
- cylinder 9y agoWhat does the TSA have to do with me sitting on the tarmac for an hour at even secondary city airports waiting for departure?
- closeparen 9y agoCongestion is just what happens when too many people want to use a system and you're not willing to deny travel to some of them. Congestion absolutely happens on trains. Just look at the New York or San Francisco subways during rush hour. The first and most obvious form is that you'll spend the first few train departures in "line" to get to the edge of the platform, then a couple more for a train you can physically squeeze onto. The more insidious one is that public transit operators respond to crowding by increasing frequency beyond what their signaling technology can support. Even after you make it onto the train, you'll spend most of the journey stopped on the track waiting for the train in front of you to move. You can solve congestion in any transportation system by enforcing a low enough number of simultaneous users, forcing the others to not travel, or use some other means. We seem least willing to do this with trains. Transit authorities are seriously thinking about congestion pricing for freeways, airlines raise prices at popular times, but rail systems are working to attract more ridership even as they collapse under the weight of their already-far-too-high ridership.