11 ms·
Soccer and the law of large numbers
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoPeople seem to be assuming that the point of the game is to determine which is the better team. It isn't. The point of the game is to get the fans interested, excited, vocal and voluble. The best teams tend to float to the top over the course of a season, and the best teams are more likely to win, but the excitement would be lessened if the result became more predictable. If I play Kasparov at chess I'll lose and the game will be completely uninteresting, but if I play backgammon against the world's best there is a chance I'll win. That creates more interest. I agree that howlers such as the "ghost goal" from England, and the offside goal for Argentina are blots and shouldn't happen, and I don't argue that technology should remain prohibited, but I do think that meddling with the rules to try to make the game less "chancey" are mis-guided.
- edanm 16y agoI completely agree. I made pretty much the same point on the last "change Soccer's rules" thread: "One of the reasons Poker is so popular is that even a terrible player can beat a pro by chance, some of the time. I've always suspected the same is true of Football. Any attempt to "fix" the game by making refereeing better makes the game more fair. While that might seem like a good thing, I don't think anyone is qualified to decide whether that will make the game more or less popular. And considering it's the world's most popular sport, tinkering with the games in unpredictable ways is stupid."
- jules 16y agoThere would still be a comparatively huge variance in soccer if refereeing were perfect. Would chess be better if a random piece is removed at the start of the game? Perhaps it would if a grandmaster is playing against a newbie. But in a match between two top players? I don't think so.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- edanm 16y agoI may be misunderstanding something, but isn't Chess exactly the opposite of what we're talking about? Take two players, one ranked extremely well, and one a little below him. Chances are, the higher ranked player will beat the lower ranked player almost every time. That's exactly the opposite of what I think makes soccer so appealing: almost no one can predict which team will take a World Cup, and every World Cup has its own team which does far better than predicted. This rarely happens in Chess.
- jules 16y agoThat depends on how big the difference between the two chess players is. But the question is, would it make grandmaster chess matches more interesting if we removed a random piece from the board? This is essentially what the current refereeing system is doing with soccer. I am baffled that anyone could think that introducing random unfair judgement by a referee improves a sport.
- edanm 16y agoI think I haven't explained myself properly. It's not that I think the bad refereeing makes the sport better. I don't, and I wish it were fixed. What I do think is that, with something so obviously successful, it's pretty hard to know what kind of changes might break it. To use a simple analogy, assume you're a new programmer going over some very old financial software at a bank. The thing is written in 30-year-old COBOL code (and written badly at that). I'm guessing most programmers would cringe at such a system, not understanding why it isn't being "improved" by rewriting it in a better language (and there are good reasons too, like being able to easily add new features, etc.). But as you and I both know, it's probably not a good idea to change it. Not because COBOL doesn't suck, not because there are good reasons to rewrite (there are some good reasons), but because it already works, and no one wants to mess with that. P.S. Having said that, I personally do wish they'll change something to make the refereeing more solid. I don't think it will make Soccer any worse, even though I can't be sure. More importantly, I'm pretty sure that Fifa is going to cave on this issue withing 10-20 years, because of public pressure, and allow some form of instant replay.
- jpd 16y agoYes, but what's happening in soccer right now, is that the dealer saw a full house, but decided to only count it as a high-card 5.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoI don't disagree, but that's not the point. There are two things being debated. One is that the errors by the officials are unaccaptable and they must introduce technology to reduce them. I'm not discussing that. The other is that somehow the game is flawed because there aren't enough goals, and hence chance plays a large part. I'm arguing that such claims are misguided. In some sense the two are not entirely orthogonal because a single error by an official that leads to, or prevents, a goal has an enormous effect on the game. Nevertheless, there are two issues, I'm talking about one, and you are talking about the other. I'm discussing the point raised in the original submission. You aren't, except insofar as they are not entirely unrelated, as I remark above.
- jules 16y ago> I'm talking about one, and you are talking about the other. I'm discussing the point raised in the original submission. You aren't, except insofar as they are not entirely unrelated, as I remark above. He is not responding to your comment. He is responding to edanm, who is discussing exactly what jpd is discussing.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoNoted - you are right - I should've read more carefully. Mea Culpa
- edanm 16y agoFunny analogy. And you've got a point. But it doesn't really matter what the method is that makes soccer so unpredictable. Part of it is that there are few goals, so tiny mistakes are often decisive. Part of it is that referees often make mistakes. Should it be this way? I don't know. I'm sure that part of the appeal of Soccer is the randomness. I'm also pretty sure that part of the appeal is the frustration people feel towards referees. It makes everyone upset, but it keeps people talking, keeps people caring. At the end of the day, what matters (to Fifa, at least) is to keep Soccer as popular as it is now. And since no one really knows if "fixing" the refereeing will help or hurt Soccer, I don't think anyone is willing to risk the change (and rightfully so).
- fhars 16y agoAnd not to forget that today's referee errors are tomorrow's legends. I mean, people are still agonizing about the "Wembley Goal", a referee error that made England win a world cup game against Germany (in 1966). So in the long run, the law of large numbers does still apply...
- pkulak 16y agoI think there's just too much luck. With basketball or American football, any team can still beat any other team on any given day, and the Celtics made it to the finals instead of Orlando or Cleveland, but LA still won the championship (but still needed 7 games to do it). It's a good blend of giving you hope for your small-market team, but also making wins actually mean something. I watched all the US games in the World Cup this year, and I never came away thinking that the US was actually better (or as good, yay ties!) as the teams they played. And, in fact, they seemed to be the better team against Ghana.
- kscaldef 16y ago"And, in fact, they seemed to be the better team against Ghana." Hardly. The US was utterly out-classed in the first half. They didn't push their attacks as hard as the Ghanans, and they couldn't get their defense in place reliably. Things evened up in the second half and overtimes, but it never felt to me like there was a point where the US dominated the game.
- sdfx 16y agoLuck is a big part of the appeal of soccer. As with most sports, you usually start rooting for the team that is popular in your area. With a significant reduction of this luck-component, strong teams would dominate the leagues which would in turn reduce the appeal for supporters of smaller clubs. Under the current rules, it's not unusual for a smaller team to win against a much stronger opponent from time to time. To tilt the probability towards the favorite reduces the appeal for supporters of the underdog. It seems that people who grew up with high scoring games, exact time-taking and video referees often times feel the urge to "fix" the perceived flaws of soccer. I don't want to be snotty, but a lot of people love the game in it's current form. If you don't get what's fun about a good game that ends in a 1:0 that's fine, but please don't ruin it for the rest of us.
- mbubb 16y agoExcept that this would make a qualitative change to the game. This would be a version of that most hated of results - the shootout. People who truly understand the game (I am not in that subset) speak in terms of flow and touches and the setup. The qualities which makes a Dutch or Brasilian or German or etc style distinctive. True fans do not watch for scoring alone. People who watch American football do not do so for the scoring alone. High scoring games are often very sloppy and boring. The classic defensive-minded battles of the Giants or Bears are the games I remember from youth (or more recently Pittsburg or Baltimore). The well played American football game is fought at the unglamorous point of the two lines each trying to wear the other down. The tension builds and one side cracks - a defensive lapse, a fumble, botched pass - and the game turns on a few such plays. There are versions of American football that emphasize scoring - Arena league etc. There have been indoor soccer leagues that have rules for higher scoring. But these are different games. A good soccer game is a game of flow and of concentrated effort. Multiple failed attempts - small adjustments - perhaps a lapse or two and a goal. One of the interesting graphics I noted in the online coverage of this world cup (in the NYTimes I think) is a slider bar showing the preponderance of the ball location over time. Things like this can get the casual or new fan to begin to understand what there is about the game - there than scoring - which is mesmerizing.
- whyenot 16y agoI'm not a big football fan, but it's hard to live outside the US and not be exposed to it. Part of football's unique character is how rare goals are. When a team scores a goal, it is a big occasion (GOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL![1]). If you change that, you fundamentally change the game, a game that is the most watched, most popular sport in the world. Also, the assumption that the only purpose of a match is to pick the better team is probably wrong. An important additional factor, perhaps the most important factor, is to make the game exciting for the fans. Here, I think the unpredictability of goals helps. [1] When I lived in Panama, the announcers had a really funny ability to turn a goal eventually into a pitch for Goldstar Consumer Eclectronics -- "GOOOOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLDDDDDSSSSTTTAAARRRR!"
- patrickk 16y agoThis guy should have stopped typing this article after the first line: I am not a soccer fan. It seems by writing this, he is jumping on the 'every-four-years' soccer bandwagon that goes on in the US (or so it seems to a non-American). I don't say this to be nasty, but because of his limited knowledge of the game, he doesn't realise that in a league competition, such as the English Premiership (or MLS in America), luck plays a much lesser factor in deciding who lifts the trophy (in other words, over 38 games, the cream will rise to the top. And penalty shootouts aren't a factor). As the cliche goes, "the league table doesn't lie". In 2005 when Liverpool won the Champions League (World Cup-style competition, group stages and knockout stages hence luck can play a factor) I argued with many Liverpool fans that their team was still fairly crap as that year they only managed to finish fifth in the Premiership (league competition, hence luck doesn't really come into play). ps. The Champions League is the best soccer competition on the planet, the World Cup is second rate by comparison. Most of the best players in the world play in this competition, which is between Europe's elite club teams. Generally, top players play far better for club rather than country as they are more familiar with their club teammates, as they play with them, week-in, week-out, rather than just once in a blue moon. Also, by the time the World up comes around, many players are tired after a long club season - see England yesterday, for example. Not to mention you get a set of really top players all concentrated in a single team (Real Madrid, Barcelona, Manchester United) not unlike an outperforming startup.
- eru 16y agoDoes the Champions League have finals where you get knocked out after losing one match?
- patrickk 16y agoYes - in the knockout stages (same as World Cup, there's group stages, then second round, quarter finals, semis and the final). See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Champions_League#Format http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Champions_League#Format If you have never seen it, I highly advise watching the Champions League as the standard is very high.
- CoryMathews 16y agoThe main thing that football(soccer) needs is another official to use technology such as a replay camera to overrule the officials on the field, on obviously large mistakes that any ref could make. This way events such as the first goal in the mexico game should not happen. (in case you missed it, Argentina scored making it 1-0 however a player was clearly off sides and the goal should not have counted. They showed the replay over and over to the viewers, But the officials stuck with their call and counted the illegal goal. This really took a toll on Mexico's moral. )
- naz 16y agoThe low scores are the reason why football is so exciting. Both teams know a single goal could change the course of the game. In American sports when it is 52-11 who cares if the losing team scores?
- jimbokun 16y agoAlso, after watching a little more football, I can now watch a 2-0 match and see how that result can be just as decisive as a 35 - 7 victory. (One more tip for the Amercian Football fan: multiplying every score by 7 is a good way to convert to something more familiar, kind of like converting Celcius to Fahrenheit.)
- tshtf 16y ago7 is a very close approximation. In 2006, the average world cup combined score was 2.3 goals: http://www.insidescience.org/current_affairs/best_team_not_guaranteed_world_cup_success http://www.insidescience.org/current_affairs/best_team_not_g... In 2006, the average NFL combined score was 20.7 points: http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_average_score_for_one_team_in_an_NFL_game http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_average_score_for_one_... 20.7/2.3 = 9
- sandipagr 16y agoIs it really? How about the US comeback after going 2-0 down? And it does happens a lot.
- mrkurt 16y agoThere's plenty of "luck" based drama in other sports. I can think of numerous games in American Football that were decided by a moment of extreme luck or a single bad refereeing decision. If you want to eliminate that, you need to try and maximise score differential (rather than just total score).
- akie 16y agoNeither of the games he mentions were won by luck alone. True, there was some luck involved (and some bad decisions), and his argument in general still holds, but to the games he mentions it doesn't apply.
- WorkerBee 16y agoIt seems as though every game I read about, including Germany-England and Argentina-Mexico yesterday, is decided by a lucky goal or a wrongly-allowed goal or a wrongly-disallowed goal. Except that it wasn't. Germany 4, England 1. The wrongly-disallowed goal would have given England 2. And Argentina 3, Mexico 1.
- chegra 16y agoPsychological effect of having the first goal affects future performance.
- ovi256 16y agoExcept if you were French during the '90s, they had a tradition of the opposing team scoring first, and then the French team would rally and play way better. Well, not anymore, unfortunately.
- forinti 16y agoBut the goals in question happened at critical stages of the game. England would have tied 2-2 and Mexico was tied but playing better than Argentina. When your only option is to win, you have to open up your game, and your defence becomes vunerable. You can't know what would've happened, but you can't deny that these mistakes altered the dynamics of the games.
- fname 16y ago
- jimbokun 16y agoThe group stage handles this quite well. If you play conservatively and accept ties, you most likely will need a win in the final game to have a chance to advance. Furthermore, tie breakers going by goal differential then goals scored also encourages more aggressive play. Taken over the course of three games, it is very likely that teams will end up in their rightful position. Take the U.S., for example. Even on the wrong end of multiple calls in close matches, they won their group, and deservedly so. I believe at one point a group play system was used all the way through the end of the World Cup. This is probably a more statistically sound way of determining the best side, but with less fan appeal, I think.
- brazzy 16y agoYou're right, the 1950 FIFA world cup had a second (final) group stage. Ironically, the last match ended up being the decisive one anyway.
- miguelpais 16y agoFootball (sorry, Soccer) is not the kind of sport which enables high scores, it never was. Actually, in the past, goals seemed to occur more often, but that was mostly because of the huge discrepancies between the opposing teams. I think it would be much more easier to embrace what Rugby does, and get a referee analyzing TV footage to help the field referees when doubts arise, than changing the one thing that makes soccer what it is, the act of scoring a goal and what it represents, reducing it to nothing, turning Soccer into one of those sports where in each attack there is a point taken for the attacking team, being the game decided by those few attacks that weren't successful.
- patrickk 16y agoYou only have to look at Real Madrid to see what happens when you think only of attacking. The thought process of their president Florentino Perez (who makes new signing decisions, not the manager) must look like this: 1. Get a €300million loan from a bank. 2. Go out and buy as many attacking, 'flair-players' as possible. (Ronaldo, Kaka, Benzema). 3. Sell lots and lots of Real Madrid shirts. Notice that winning trophies does not enter the equation. Indeed, Real Madrid got dumped out of the Champions League by a fairly ordinary Lyon side.
- miguelpais 16y agoI think Mourinho will finally give that club the stability it needs either by bringing new players, not particularly the big stars, but those who are able to play in the context of a team, or he will just take the big stars out of their pedestal and make them work if they really want a place in the team.
- unwantedLetters 16y agoDoes anyone have any ideas on what exactly can be done to improve scoring? I think increasing scoring would take something away from football (soccer) rather than add to it, but it will be interesting to hear how exactly people think the rules should be changed.
- patrickk 16y agoThe only changes that should be made are in relation to video technology. FIFA should experiment with every refereeing decision possible being able to be analysed/scrutinized/affirmed by a Television Match Official (similar to rugby) and then scale back as necessary. FIFA don't have the wisdom or foresight to do this, sadly. It's badly needed to stamp out cheating, diving, off-the-ball fouls not spotted by the ref, Thierry Henry handball-type incidents, incorrect disallowed goal incidents etc. EDIT: They (FIFA) did try to increase the likelihood of goals being scored in this World Cup and the last World Cup also, by messing with the ball design, making it's flight path unpredictable and therefore more difficult for keepers to save a shot at goal.
- miguelpais 16y agoProbably making the goalkeeper unable to save with his hands. To avoid injuries for the goalkeepers you could then reduce the height of the goal to something like 0.7 meters, so that saves would be done with the legs and knees. Then you could bring back the old heavy balls. And then it wouldn't be Football anymore...
- SkyMarshal 16y agoVery interesting take on the problem. While everyone is clamoring for goal-line refs or technical solutions, he proposes changing the rules somehow to enable more scoring, which would reduce the consequences of wrongfully allowed or disallowed goals. I've always wondered what the game would be like if you simplified it even more and removed goal keepers, so that no player on the field could touch the ball with their hands. Replace goalies with another defender, or not. That would likely open up scoring, as long-range shots would have a realistic chance to score, and short-range shots would be almost guaranteed if they were on-goal. I'm sure there would be cons as well, but can't think what they might be. Edit: One con would be more breaks in play, though they could probably mitigate that by allowing the scored-on team to restart with a quick goal-kick instead of a center kick-off. Center kick-offs often end up pushed back to the defensive line anyway, to open up the other team.
- barrkel 16y agoRemoving goalkeepers wouldn't have the kind of effect you think it would, I feel. I can see two possible dynamics: * The game would turn into a boring series of attempted long-distance lobs. You'd probably have to reduce the goal size significantly to prevent scoring from anywhere on the pitch. * Teams with very good defenses actually have goalkeepers that don't see a lot of action. This change would promote even stronger defense, with a more negative outlook, and still result in low-scoring games - possibly even lower scoring than is currently the case. The goalkeeper is key to what gives back-line players the confidence and permission to move forward and help with attacks.
- GFischer 16y agoThere are already casual variants with no goalie. This variant is called "Richard" over here, it's played on a 5-football field(1), and you can't shoot from after the midfield (otherwise it would be far too easy). The thing is, it's far less skill-challenging than having to beat a goalie. If you've never played football/soccer, you can't know the thrill of having just that one chance (unless you're a striker), the frustration of missing it (more often than not), and the pure bliss of making it. As a defender (most of the time) I'd say that football is more frustrating if you're a defender or goalie than as a forward, since you get so few chances to show off (and strikers are the heroes more often than not). As an example, the best player on the field for Uruguay's win over Korea was defensive midfielder Diego Pérez, but the most lauded player is striker Luis Suárez (which made two goals with a huge level of difficulty to be fair), since goals are so hard to come by. (1): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-a-side_football http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Five-a-side_football
- sandipagr 16y agothis is what I called twisted logic. Like seriously? how does using technology not solve the problem that you need to change the way it is played. The author forgets that it is still the world's most watched and popular game and there is a reason it is so.
- brazzy 16y agoI suspect that arguing about wrong referee decision or how close games could have ended is a major factor in what makes football so popular and emotional. No spectator sport is really about watching the better team win predictably.
- lookACamel 16y agoThe simplest way to increase the effect of the law of large numbers without compromising the play of the game would be to have teams play multiple games. Best out of 15 anyone?