8 ms·
What Chinese bosses think of American workers
- mc32 9y agoThere is lots of cultural adjustment on both sides. However Chinese bosses have to know that there are some things which cannot adjust to their expectations like labor laws as well as what they express as work ethic. It's good for the local economies that the larger companies (GM, etc) create the effect where foreign investors see opportunity in these feeder companies as labor costs back home begin to rise making these investments attractive. It speaks to their commitment to making their investment work that they are only 15% behind in productivity given the "handicaps" of different work ethic, skills, pay and regulation.
- geezerjay 9y ago> There is lots of cultural adjustment on both sides. However Chinese bosses have to know that there are some things which cannot adjust to their expectations like labor laws as well as what they express as work ethic. I don't believe this assumption is correct. There are plenty of cases where US bosses are fully capable of adjusting to inexistent labor laws and abusive labor practices. If US bosses are quite capable of adjusting to other jurisdictions, why do you assume that Chinese bosses aren't?
- yazaddaruvala 9y agoWhy do we use this word "boss"? The connotations associated with it are about obedience and slavery. Similarly "work for" should be changed to "work with". Words matter. Why do we actively choose to use poor ones?
- mikeash 9y agoOur culture worships business. Naturally the language reflects this. See the use of "poaching" to describe companies hiring employees of other companies for a prominent example in the tech community.
- thanksgiving 9y agoOr just human resource: we are just property of our employers. I'll say this again for any employer who thinks they care about their employees: please make all salary and benefits information for everyone public. Until you do so, you may not criticize Travis (of Uber) or anyone else when it comes to treating employees well. Put your money where your mouth is!
- sokoloff 9y agoWho's to say that our employees want their salary information made public? Why would I need to work at a company where all salary is transparent in order to have an opinion on whether Walmart/Amazon treat their employees fairly, whether there should be no, a lower, or a higher minimum wage, or whether Uber's culture is one that should be celebrated and modeled or reviled?
- thanksgiving 9y agoThe point is you and I don't have a say either way. Jim, congrats on being a VP but you and I are just pawns. We have no leverage. If you don't believe me, try bringing this up in a board meeting and see how far it flies. Employers benefit tremendously from the I formation assymetry which to me is a much bigger crime than some idiots who can't keep their junk in their pants. I'm just an idiot on the Internet and you've actually made it. I'd like to apologize if this sounds condescending because it is absolutely not (in part because I'm so far below you that it is physically impossible but regardless of my fortune it is not meant to be). Mind you, i have no original thoughts and this is something i stole from buffer. I think buffer is a great example on how to do things. I wish all the sjw's in silicon valley would direct their attention to something that actually benefits the world for a change. https://open.buffer.com/introducing-open-salaries-at-buffer-including-our-transparent-formula-and-all-individual-salaries/ https://open.buffer.com/introducing-open-salaries-at-buffer-... I encourage you to keep an open mind about this. Thank you for your time. Sincerely yours,
- owebmaster 9y agoIt is because companies behave like communist states and are allowed to have dictators, most of the times with power over life and death issues of their citizens/employees.
- kmicklas 9y agoIronically, this is exactly what communism exists to fight.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoAdvertising is not always entirely truthful.
- zanny 9y agoFight dictatorial control with dictatorial control. Or maybe try moving away from corporations and towards cooperatives. Problem is, making coops popular requires ambition and dedication from the workers, because there will no capitalist looking to make a profit to jumpstart the business.
- pikzen 9y ago>Fight dictatorial control with dictatorial control. ...You do know that communism advocates for a society where control is something done in collaboration with others? Because China, or the USSR calls itself communist does not mean it is. A simple reading of Marx & Engels' work would clarify that.
- louithethrid 9y agoEverything eventually degrades into a dictatorship. Thus we invented advanced concepts to avoid this- like - everyone holds there breath- taxes to milk corroding power accumulating back into the system as a whole - and parliament democracy, which basically consists out of a bonemill for wanna-be dictators, grinding one another to dust in a weapon less fight for power.
- sametmax 9y agoI work for. I don't care. There are more important fights. Nit picking on words only happens with people that don't have enough problems.
- mrob 9y agoThe boss has the power to give orders. The worker obeys or the worker gets fired. There are limits to what orders the boss can give, but it almost certainly includes things the worker would rather not do. Pretending it's a collaboration of equals only increases exploitation of workers, because it helps bosses pressure them into doing things they have no legal obligation to do by framing it as a favor for a friend.
- sithadmin 9y agoFurther, there are many cases where the 'collaboration of equals' model is fundamentally incompatible with the organization being able to function. One example: regulatory compliance and internal audit departments (and by extension, employees working within those groups) generally trump nearly every other department in terms of dictating processes and procedures, because ensuring that the company isn't sanctioned/fined into oblivion by regulators is an imperative for continued operation of the company. This is a necessary power structure because employees specializing in product delivery or other internal operations don't have the domain knowledge to effectively self-regulate to compliance standards, nor understand the legal and fiscal implications of non-compliance.
- zxv 9y agoYour examples, compliance and audit, can be powerful in helping distill risk management issues and communicate them; however, also consider that, in high risk environments that doesn't make it incompatible with other forms of collaboration on risk. Consider safety on oil rigs. There, collaboration on safety is a focal point of all-hands meetings every 12 hours. Both top-down and bottom-up management can be effective, and a combination can be even more so.
- sithadmin 9y agoLike it or not, obedience, to a supervisor and/or ultimately corporate policy, is absolutely necessary to maintain stable and consistent operations at scale. Further, there are plenty of situations, especially involving so-called "blue collar" labor, where the collaborative approach of "working with" others in a relatively flat org structure just isn't tenable, especially where definition of the product design and QA processes require high levels of technical expertise and specialization.
- goodcanadian 9y agoThe word "boss" holds no such connotations for me. It means roughly "employer" or "supervisor."
- sithadmin 9y agoTo be fair, it's a loanword from Dutch's baas, which is 'master'. It's just been part of the English lexicon for so long that the original connotation has largely been lost for most English speakers.
- goodcanadian 9y agoFair enough, but "master" also has no negative connotations for me. It roughly means "in charge of." The postmaster is in charge of running the post office. The ship's master is in charge of the day to day running of the ship (though he takes his orders from the commander). And so on.
- WaxProlix 9y ago...and a slavemaster is in charge of slaves and a dog's master is in charge of the dog.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- prodmerc 9y agoWell, how does your community owned and operated business work? Oh right, it doesn't. It would work if everyone was equally educated and motivated, but for most human purposes, a hierarchical command structure always works better. The most important part is the ones with power giving more attention and care to the ones without - so everyone can be happy with their lives.
- dragonbonheur 9y agoThe title of the article is "Will China Save the American Economy?"
- jessaustin 9y agoHere on HN, we try not to invoke the wrath of Betteridge.
- dyim 9y agoI thought the aside about NUMMI was interesting [1]. Though the difference between Dayton culture and Chinese culture might be bigger than the difference between Fremont culture and Japanese culture, it's been done successfully before. [1] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/561/nummi-2015 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/561/..., https://hbr.org/2009/09/nummi-what-toyota-learned https://hbr.org/2009/09/nummi-what-toyota-learned, https://consumercal.org/toyatanummi-blue-ribbon-commission-white-paper/ https://consumercal.org/toyatanummi-blue-ribbon-commission-w...
- grokotron 9y agoHaving lived in both Dayton and the bay area for many years, the cultural differences in those places are fewer than many in either place would likely assume. This is probably especially true of those most likely to work in production at one of these two plants.
- dyim 9y agoWord, thanks for the input!
- norikki 9y agoThe differences between any two Americans are going to be much smaller than the differences between two Chinese people from different regions of China, or two Indians from different regions of India. We often take for granted that Native born Americans are drastically more united culturally than people living in more conflict ridden parts of the world.
- naravara 9y agoI think you must have a pretty narrow view of "Americans" if you believe that. Do you think a Shanghaier and a Beijiger have less in common than an Ethiopian refugee in Virginia does with a Hmong in Missouri?
- tacostakohashi 9y ago
- norikki 9y ago"Globalization helped bolster economies around the world, including China’s, and is now allowing a class of wealthy people and companies from those economies to invest in the United States, creating jobs in depressed regions like Ohio." So instead of Americans owning American companies, and employing 100% American labor, most of the factories have shut down, and the ones that are left are owned and operated by the Chinese and employ a large fraction of foreign workers, although not a majority. How on Earth is this better? The globalists at The Atlantic have clearly outdone themselves with this backwards logic.
- zionic 9y agoIt's not about what's better, but about systematically weakening western powers.
- scottLobster 9y agoIt is fair by the laws of Capitalism. China is roughly 3x the US population. If everything is distributed "fairly" by the invisible hand, they should end up with a larger piece of the economic pie. Whether we as Americans want that or should want that is another issue.
- ams6110 9y agoDistributing "fairly" (as in equally) is not what capitalism does.
- geezerjay 9y agoCapitalism is all about fairness, because income depends on competition. Ceteris paribus, China's size means it has a larger market, more competitors and therefore a larger market share.
- scottLobster 9y agoWhich is why I'm using the invisible hand definition of "fair". The principle of the invisible hand, a cornerstone of modern capitalism, is that when everyone does what is in their own best interest things are distributed most fairly. Not saying I agree with it, but that's the moral theory.
- walshemj 9y agoyou don't improve efficiency by working your staff longer hours
- apozem 9y agoAn article that is simultaneously interesting and unsurprising. Cultural differences can be hard to navigate in the workplace, especially if you can't communicate without Google Translate. The learning and adjustment curve will be difficult, but I hope both parties can navigate it well and prosper.
- dlwdlw 9y agoAmericans, for the most part desire sinecures. In fact they believe sinecures are a human right. This is because the US has been able to provide these types of jobs for the majority of the population for many generations. What is a sinecure from the global perspective is normal from the US perspective. Being able to consistently trade time for money is the core sinecure belief, the lack of risk is key. This is only possible in highly controlled almost game like situations. The "real world" requires proof of value and often a lot of risk. A pet theory if mine is that many American companies use off shoring to continue to provide sinecure benefits for their important workers while lowering costs. Those workers don't see it as such as they already have sinecures in this model. The offshoring is necessary for company survival.