10 ms·
Blue Apron May Need to Raise More Money Soon After Shrunken IPO
- ithinkinstereo 9y agoBlue Apron believes its cash and borrowing capacity will be sufficient for at least a year, it said in its revised deal prospectus after lowering its IPO price range. That's crazy they only have a year's worth of runway. I'd imagine that today's tepid IPO is going to make it that much harder to raise additional private capital. Looks like they'll have to take on additional debt financing just to keep the lights on, let alone fuel more growth. That seems to be backed up by the final paragraph: With its reduced IPO, Blue Apron no longer intends to pay down existing debt with the proceeds, according to its deal filing. Instead, the funds will all go toward working capital, capital expenditures and general corporate purposes. If you didn't catch it, there was an excellent discussion about Blue Apron the other day: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14646679 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14646679
- M_PatrickCPA 9y agoI wouldn't necessarily conclude that they only have one year's worth of runway. Many companies state that they are funded for the next 12 months. It can be pretty boilerplate. See comparison of Blue Apron vs. Apple below. Blue Apron (1): We believe that our existing cash and cash equivalents, together with cash generated from operations and available borrowing capacity under our revolving credit facility, will be sufficient to meet our anticipated cash needs for at least the next 12 months. Apple (2): The Company believes its existing balances of cash, cash equivalents and marketable securities will be sufficient to satisfy its working capital needs, capital asset purchases, outstanding commitments and other liquidity requirements associated with its existing operations over the next 12 months. (1) https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917004316/a2232581z424b4.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917... (2) https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/000162828016020309/a201610-k9242016.htm#s312F59D5215853C98A92CF2CB1813E50 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/0001628280160...
- code4tee 9y agoThis is a big shot across the bow to startups looking to go public. Message: You're not ready to float if you're not floating, i.e. have a viable business model and can fund operations with revenues. Also, having a down round after going public likely rained hard on a lot of people's options situations.
- kevmo 9y ago> can fund operations with revenues I trust you mean currently existing ops, if frozen as is. Lots of companies go public while still taking on debt because their ROI in expanding operations is significantly higher than the interest rates. Amazon wasn't profitable for years because of this.
- adrenalinelol 9y agoCall me a cynic, but I get the feeling this IPO is more of an early investor/founder cash out?
- ProAm 9y agoThat's most IPO's
- wweidendorf 9y agoIn this case, none of the IPO proceeds went to existing shareholders. Based on the prospectus, it would appear that all insiders are subject to either a 120-day or 180-day lock-up post IPO. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917004316/a2232581z424b4.htm#eo16601_shares_eligible_for_future_sale https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917... This seems more like a liquidity raise to fund future growth that just happened to be timed incorrectly with respect to the Amazon / Whole Foods announcement.
- kgwgk 9y agoI may be mistaken, but I think existing shareholders are not selling as part of the IPO. The company really needs the money...
- aresant 9y agoWe are in an age of the "hurry let's IPO before they realize our customer acquisition costs are unsustainable" IPO. Take Blue Apron, for instance. They stated their blended Cost Per Customer is $94 in their prospectus, this # has been parroted all over the place. This little piece of "hope the Analysts dont dig in" masks their most recent quarter costs which exploded to $460 per customer. (1) This is a classic, groupon-like example of somebody figuring out a really profitable niche that's easily duplicate and relies almost entirely on paid media to drive acquisition. The efficiency and sheer scale of todays' online advertising market means that if you're armed with a shit ton of cash you can buy your way into public-market growth. Sustainable it is not. No wonder they don't bother reporting a pesky little detail like "churn" in their prospectus (2) I wonder how much longer companies will be able to get away with this game. (1) https://www.recode.net/2017/6/1/15727182/blue-apron-ipo-s1-analysis-customer-acquisition-marketing-churn https://www.recode.net/2017/6/1/15727182/blue-apron-ipo-s1-a... (2) https://www.forbes.com/sites/neilstern/2017/06/05/meal-prep-pioneer-blue-apron-preps-for-an-ipo/#760d979313ef https://www.forbes.com/sites/neilstern/2017/06/05/meal-prep-...
- Mizza 9y agoEven $94 seems high to me, but $460?! I don't have any context for those figures though, does anybody know of a common cost per customer acquisition across industries/products? Maybe my intuition as a humble programmer is way off, but that seems incredibly high.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe only way you can evaluate customer acquisition costs is to have the other number their lifetime value (LTV). In a 'goods' business it costs you $X to make the good and sell it (COGS) and people who buy it (after averaging sales, incentives, etc) as the average selling price (ASP), so to the extent that ASP > COGS you make money selling your widgets. A service business like this (or cable TV or whatever) has a customer acquisition cost (CAC), or the cost to get someone to sign up. and a life time value (LTV) which is the amount that customer will spend with you over the lifetime of their relationship with you. To the extent that LTV > CAC it tells you whether or not the business is viable. In both cases, when the ratios are wrong, the company loses money faster by either selling more widgets or getting more customers.
- loganfrederick 9y agoOnly two years ago, Hortonworks IPO'd and then had to do a secondary offering one year later as well: http://www.businessinsider.com/hortonworks-shares-tanking-after-news-of-secondary-ipo-2016-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/hortonworks-shares-tanking-af...
- erdle 9y agoTesla/SolarCity will be raising by the end of the year. It happens, a lot. But how/why is a big deal.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoCongratulations on getting to the IPO, that is a huge amount of work and worth celebrating. That said, it pretty much defines squeaking through the exit. Interested to read the reorganization they did last year in the S-1 [1] presumably to normalize all of the various rights clauses from previous funding rounds and to dump some otherwise undesirable baggage on what was left, aka "Opco". That they had a 1:10 and 1:5 splits on their early stock and have not done a reverse split prior to the IPO suggests the employees will do ok, assuming they can sell their stock at some point. It seems healthier than the Silverspring Networks IPO (SSNI) which was anemic at best and just got worse over time. Let's hope that they keep their expenses in line and can crack the nut of acquiring new customers more cheaply than their competitors. [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917003765/a2232259zs-1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1701114/000104746917...
- benmanns 9y agoWhy would a reverse split affect employees? Is it only in the case that an employee thinks: • I have 10,000 shares • GOOG is $1,000 • We're going to be the next GOOG • 10,000 * $1,000 • I'm worth $10m I don't see how anything related to % of ownership or intrinsic value would change with a reverse split.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt is simpler than that. If you have 50,000 share option of a tradeable stock and it goes up $1[1] you feel great you just made $50,000! If just prior to the IPO your company does a reverse 50:1 split and you now have options for 1,000 shares of stock and it goes up $1 you, gee, that's nice and all but really it isn't enough to get a new Macbook Pro. The other thing that happens is your strike price goes up in proportion. So if it cost you $1/share to exercise your 50,000 share option its going to cost you $50 a share to exercise your 1,000 share option. [1] of course it has to be above water.
- consz 9y agoUnless you're in an egregiously unfavorable options contract (do these even exist?), an options contract should have the underlying number of shares it pays out adjusted in such a way that a stock split has no effect on your payout in USD.
- alistproducer2 9y ago"In its IPO prospectus, the company warned that it may never be profitable, adding that it anticipates that “operating expenses and capital expenditures will increase substantially in the foreseeable future.” Wait, what? Between the ICO craze, the amazing levitating stock market, and things like a company that admits it probably won't ever make a dime of profit being able to IPO, I've been feeling like nothing in the financial world has made any sense for so long that I barely remember when it did.
- slapshot 9y agoThat's the one thing that's probably pretty standard. Here's Amazon's S-1 from 1997, or over 20 years ago: [T]he Company believes that it will incur substantial operating losses for the foreseeable future, and that the rate at which such losses will be incurred will increase significantly from current levels. Although the Company has experienced significant revenue growth in recent periods, such growth rates are not sustainable and will decrease in the future. In view of the rapidly evolving nature of the Company's business and its limited operating history, the Company believes that period-to-period comparisons of its operating results are not necessarily meaningful and should not be relied upon as an indication of future performance. http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/filing.ashx?filingid=384706 http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/filing.ashx?filingid=3847... (edit:format)
- dragonwriter 9y ago“may never” is substantially different “probably won't ever”. The former is fairly common for companies to acknowledge in IPO documents, the latter would be noteworthy, but isn't the issue here
- icedchai 9y agoThis is normal language. Were you around in the late 90's / early 2000's? Things were even worse.
- timdierks 9y agoThere's little to no reason to downplay risks in the prospectus, so the statements of material risk are always doom-filled. (Prospective investors don't take such statements as final, but failure to disclose a possible risk has a big downside.)
- jdubs 9y agoI don't understand how they will improve their numbers with the scrutiny of the public demanding more share holder value. I'm having blue apron tonight and I think it's a great product. Add salt and pepper to taste.
- WheelsAtLarge 9y agoCompanies go public for 2 reasons: 1) as a way for funders and investors to cash out or 2) to raise money since their other sources have dried out. If the ipo was not enough, I doubt they will be able to raise any more money at any reasonable valuation. They have a tough road ahead.
- eldavido 9y agoYou're forgetting a major third reason: to have a currency to do acquisitions. If your stock isn't publicly traded, you can't issue shares to buy new companies. Most acquisitions aren't all cash, they're a mix of cash and stock.
- adrr 9y agoOr to supplement capital investments beyond getting loans. Building out a logistics chain for any food company is very expensive.
- mychael 9y agoI would rather run a sustainable & profitable 100M company than a unicorn billion dollar company with 12 months of runway.
- dhebenudr 9y agoHaha, I'd rather run a sustainable $1m company! Frankly, I'd rather try to get an actual (horsie) unicorn to take off from an airplane runway!
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoI would never invest in this company. My Mom gave me some extra meals of this type and they are great but you still have to cook them, so they pile up, so you cancel... I don't know anyone that has stuck with the program long term but boy do I hear about how great it is on the ads on all my podcasts.
- increment_i 9y agoThis IPO is getting absolutely torched, and for good reason. However, there is a TON of money in foodie culture and food fandom. There's a reason half of your relatives watch the Food Network non-stop. Perhaps once this IPO brings in much needed capital, Blue Apron can start bringing aboard celebrity chefs in promotional deals. Get Gordon Ramsay or Bobby Flay to contribute a recipe, ingredients and a couple YouTube videos and you might have something people will pay for. I'm sure they've thought of this already.
- ryanx435 9y agoI watch the food network all the time. You know why? Because food is non-political. It's a positive vibe only type of programming: every place guy ferrari goes to is delicious, every dish Gianni cooks is wonderful, and I don't have to deal with the fear mongering that permeates literally every other channel
- ghaff 9y agoI generally agree with this. Put another way there's a lot to foodie culture and interest in the Food Network that doesn't involve cooking pre-kitted but relatively complicated meals on weeknights. I suppose there's an argument to be made that none of these services have really broken out because no one has wrapped sexy celebrity-based marketing around their offering. (Added: And some of them have paired with celebrity chefs.) But I'm skeptical. Most of them do the localvore farm to table thing in spades. I doubt that celebrity chef endorsements and videos and a major missing ingredient.
- Zarath 9y agoMeh, you see identity politics creep into a lot of the competition shows nowadays. You're right though that it is a good escape.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago"Blue Apron's executives and venture investors own Class B stock, which gets 10 votes per share and gives them control of the company. It sold Class A stock, with one vote per share, to the public in the IPO. It is keeping around Class C stock, with zero votes, to use as acquisition currency and avoid diluting its insiders in the future. Dual-class stock, triple-class stock, nonvoting stock, entrenched insider voting power: All of these are things that investors profess to hate. But in hot IPOs like the one for Snap Inc., which sold nonvoting stock to the public, priced above its offering range, and then jumped on the first day of trading, investors seemed perfectly willing to ignore the governance issues and pay up for startups. And then in ice-cold IPOs like Blue Apron's ... what? Blue Apron cut its valuation by a billion dollars -- and cut the amount of money it was raising by $100 million -- when it repriced this IPO from $15-$17 down to $10. What do you think the discussions were around the voting rights? Did any investor say "I'll pay $10, or $12 if you scrap the triple-class structure"? Did any banker say to the company "this deal is not going well, and we'll need to reprice, but you might get a better price without the triple-class structure"? Or is there just no tradeoff at all between governance and economics: Hot deals get done with bad governance, and cold deals get done with bad governance, but no one can just move a slider to increase valuations by improving governance?" https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-06-29/stress-tests-and-meal-deliveries https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-06-29/stress-te...
- jeffdavis 9y agoBlue apron is tasty and fun. I hope they sicceed in some fashion. Seems like the kind of thing young couples would do for a year, and would be a great alternative to spending money and time at restaurants. But they need to get the customer acquisition costs down enough that they make good profit in that first year. After that, people will either lose interest in cooking or get so interested that they do their own shopping and recipes. To get a lot of long-term customers would require a cultural shift. They are probably a bit early, but it might happen.
- speedplane 9y agoBlue Apron is a great company with a solid product that could easily make a good profit. The problem is that they can't sell themselves to VCs as a fun way for couples to cook and spend time with each other. They have to disrupt the dinner market, and convince VCs that they have sky-high evaluations.
- ghaff 9y agoPresumably there are some economies of scale, startup costs, and minimum volume to make all this work. But, yeah, with some clever PR and promotion you'd think you could get a business of this type to the point where it's a fairly attractive niche business. With less pressure to max out revenue per customer now it could even be a more attractive product that could more easily survive alongside grocery delivery. But, as you say, there's all this growth pressure to win the land grab and dominate the category which puts customer acquisition costs through the roof. [Added: Having said that, I think churn is always going to be a problem with a business like this once the novelty wears off.]
- intoverflow2 9y ago> a great alternative to spending money and time at restaurants You realise that isn't a chore, right? It's supposed to be fun.
- alikoneko 9y agoI don't see the value prop in things like Blue Apron. It seems overpriced for what it is. Between my roommate and myself, we cook every night (trading off nights), and take the leftovers for lunches the next day. $60 for a curated box of groceries for 3 meals just doesn't seem worth it. I spend half that weekly, snacks included.