2 ms·
[IANAL corrections encouraged] The court can't usually just make up international sanctions, it would be enshrined in the law passed by parliament. Fines, pris
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
[IANAL corrections encouraged]
The court can't usually just make up international sanctions, it would be enshrined in the law passed by parliament. Fines, prison, material seizure, cease & desist, and other remediations are usually given in schedules.
Usually courts can't order action by third-parties in other countries - if that is available to then it would be bizarre in the extreme that it wasn't in s law passed by Canadian Parliament.
So I was hoping for details of that particular legislation; or an explanation of how Canadian law doesn't have a notion of ultra vires and allows it's courts to demand international actions from third-parties, in order to punish display of a SERP.
Perhaps there some legislation at http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/ http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/ that will shed light on this?
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe decision itself explains it's reasoning and cites (though less directly then I am used to in US appellate decisions) the relevant precedent. https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16701/index.do https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csc/scc-csc/en/item/16701/inde...
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThanks, Fenlon J sets out the specious reasoning inadvertently in his analogy quoted in para 30: >". . . a non-party corporation that warehouses and ships goods for a defendant manufacturing company might be ordered on an interim injunction to freeze the defendants’ goods and refrain from shipping them." The Canadian courts wouldn't make an order to a Lithuanian warehouse to hold goods being sold by a company in Moldova who happened to have the same name as a company previously the subject of a lawsuit in Canada, would they?! As part of an interlocutory injunction the stated aim of which is to close down that foreign business (it's said [albeit potentially erroneously] that without a Google listing the foreign seller won't be able to continue business) prior to a court judgement on the full facts of the case? It's good to see that 2 of the judges agreed this was beyond the pale. At para 53 Abella drops this clanger: >"It does, however, make Google the determinative player in allowing the harm to occur." The original harm was twofold. Reselling re-badged products and an allegation of reverse engineering, the selling of the new product "unfairly" leeching from Equustek's sales. The first part is dealt with by the litigant not selling the product to Datalink to resell. The second part is accomplished by Datalink (incorporated in Canada) no longer existing. >"Equustek’s claims were supported by a good prima facie case, but it was not established that Datalink designed and sold counterfeit versions of its product, or that this resulted in trademark infringement and unlawful appropriation of trade secrets." Equustek could proceed and have Datalink closed down by the courts; but apparently haven't bothered to do this for 5 years. It strikes me the media companies have jumped on this in order to get a judgement allowing them to get interlocutory injunctions (with permanent effects) that force Google to, in effect, close down businesses/websites (by de-indexing) rather than having to get an actual court judgement on the full facts of a case. [See para 66] Datalink have yet to be shown to be guilty, the intended receiver of the Google Order is to shut then down completely - that seems like a loss for the rule of law.