4 ms·
How is Google beholden to the Canadian court to perform actions outside it's jurisdiction? Surely the response from Google should be something like "Google.ca c
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
How is Google beholden to the Canadian court to perform actions outside it's jurisdiction? Surely the response from Google should be something like "Google.ca can comply in removing links from all web pages and databases it legally controls in the jurisdiction of the court but as this court has no jurisdiction over foreign partner corporations will not comply with ultra vires demands against third-party legal entities in other countries"?
I guess Google can choose to comply, what benefit is there for Google in that?
Aside OP lacks detail: it sounds naively like a company was butt-hurt because someone did marketing better than them and sold more re-branded product? Anyone got analysis of the actual harm committed?
- phkahler 9y ago>> it sounds naively like a company was butt-hurt because someone did marketing better than them and sold more re-branded product? Anyone got analysis of the actual harm committed? I noticed there is a potential debate around IP law in this case, but I think it's best to leave that for another day. The use of Google to enforce the wishes of the legal system is prominent here.
- mtgx 9y agoGoogle will comply for the same reason it has built the overly-abused (and extra-legal) automated-takedown tools for its search engine and YouTube in order to cater to Hollywood's wishes and to get the content contracts they were hoping to get from Hollywood.
- qb45 9y agoTo that end, the music industry backed Equustek in its case against Google, and widely welcomed yesterday’s Supreme Court judgement. I'll put my tinfoil hat on and ask if maybe this could solve the mystery of some Canadian court ordering American companies around?
- mabub24 9y agoGoogle will comply because it is an intermediary and does not lose power from this decision. It comes out of this decision with more power: the ability to pick and choose which laws it wishes to follow. See this part: > “Google’s argument that a global injunction violates international comity because it is possible that the order could not have been obtained in a foreign jurisdiction, or that to comply with it would result in Google violating the laws of that jurisdiction is, with respect, theoretical. As Fenlon J. noted, “Google acknowledges that most countries will likely recognize intellectual property rights and view the selling of pirated products as a legal wrong” > In the absence of an evidentiary foundation, and given Google’s right to seek a rectifying order, it hardly seems equitable to deny Equustek the extraterritorial scope it needs to make the remedy effective, or even to put the onus on it to demonstrate, country by country, where such an order is legally permissible. We are dealing with the Internet after all, and the balance of convenience test has to take full account of its inevitable extraterritorial reach when injunctive relief is being sought against an entity like Google.” And see Micheal Geist's opinion in relation to that section: > "This is a key aspect of the decision as the court has effectively concluded that those seeking global takedown orders do not need to canvass the laws in other countries to consider the potential for conflicts with their request. In doing so, it places the obligation on intermediaries such as Google and increases the likelihood that those companies will pick and choose among the orders they are willing to follow." http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2017/06/global-internet-takedown-orders-come-canada-supreme-court-upholds-international-removal-google-search-results/ http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2017/06/global-internet-takedown-...
- qb45 9y ago> Google will comply because it is an intermediary and does not lose power from this decision. Why did they oppose this ruling, then? They will comply because Canada would fine them or block their operations in the country if they didn't. > It comes out of this decision with more power: the ability to pick and choose which laws it wishes to follow. They come out of this with more obligations: to globally filter some silly thing that somebody somewhere considered illegal, and possibly in the future to globally filter every silly thing that anybody considers illegal anywhere. That's a lot of mess for sure. If they really get to pick which laws to follow, they should give the finger to Canada in accordance with the position they held in court. We will see if they have such freedom.
- mabub24 9y ago> They come out of this with more obligations: to globally filter some silly thing that somebody somewhere considered illegal, and possibly in the future to globally filter every silly thing that anybody considers illegal anywhere. That's a lot of mess for sure. They don't have to do this. The ruling is very finely worded. See Michael Geist's immediately following article that replies to the music industries comments about monitoring. http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2017/06/no-monitoring-no-liability-supreme-courts-google-v-equustek-decision-not/ http://www.michaelgeist.ca/2017/06/no-monitoring-no-liabilit... The choice quote is here: > In fact, the majority stated precisely the opposite, emphasizing that there was no obligation to monitor content and no liability for facilitating access. The court states at paragraph 49: > The injunction does not require Google to monitor content on the Internet, nor is it a finding of any sort of liability against Google for facilitating access to the impugned websites. > The music industry may have wanted the Supreme Court of Canada to establish an affirmative duty on Google to monitor content, but the ruling is unequivocal that there is no such requirement as a result of the Equustek decision. The music industry representatives are basically lying. There are negative consequences to this law, but it's important to fully understand the written ruling and the limits it imposes and what it could impose. Google is an intermediary in this case so there were limits as to what the SCC could impose on Google.
- 9y ago
- dragonwriter 9y ago> How is Google beholden to the Canadian court to perform actions outside it's jurisdiction? Jurisdiction doesn't work the way you think it does, so the premise of your questions is false, but Google is “beholden to” the court because the court has the legal and practical power to impose further sanctions which do not rely on Google's cooperation if it's orders are not obeyed.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSanctions under what law? I'm interested in the construction of the law here. Does Canadian law prevent Nestle from operating because they employ child (and slave) labour in West Africa for example. If not then why does Canada care more about a foreign SERP listing for re-branded products than for exploited children in the chocolate industry, why push their jurisdictional area of action to the globe in one case but not the other?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Sanctions under what law? Canadian law regarding contempt of court.
- pbhjpbhj 9y ago[IANAL corrections encouraged] The court can't usually just make up international sanctions, it would be enshrined in the law passed by parliament. Fines, prison, material seizure, cease & desist, and other remediations are usually given in schedules. Usually courts can't order action by third-parties in other countries - if that is available to then it would be bizarre in the extreme that it wasn't in s law passed by Canadian Parliament. So I was hoping for details of that particular legislation; or an explanation of how Canadian law doesn't have a notion of ultra vires and allows it's courts to demand international actions from third-parties, in order to punish display of a SERP. Perhaps there some legislation at http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/ http://laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/ that will shed light on this?
- 9y ago
- sfifs 9y ago> I guess Google can choose to comply, what benefit is there for Google in that? Because the court can impose sanctions that restrict Google's ability to earn revenue in Canada?