3 ms·
"According to polling performed by the Pew Research Center, Republicans who are college graduates are considerably less likely to accept the scientific consensu
by timr 16y ago
"According to polling performed by the Pew Research Center, Republicans who are college graduates are considerably less likely to accept the scientific consensus on climate change than those who have less education. These better-educated Republicans probably aren't ignorant; a more likely explanation is that they are politically driven consumers of climate science information. Among Democrats and independents, the relationship between education and beliefs about global warming is precisely the opposite -- more education leads to greater acceptance of the consensus climate science."
I object to the terminology. Just because someone is cherry-picking information to support their chosen ideology doesn't make them "not ignorant". It makes them willfully ignorant.
Part of the problem with American political discourse is that we don't do enough to marginalize non-factual arguments -- from both sides of the political spectrum. Pretending that people aren't "ignorant" if they're filtering facts through a political sieve doesn't address this problem. Everyone has freedom of expression in the US, but we should all be doing more to make it plainly clear that some types of content are inferior to others.
- spamizbad 16y agoThe best terminology for this phenomena would probably be (neo-)Lysenkoism, where you have a field of science under attack for conflicting with political orthodoxy. I agree completely with your point that a college degree has limited impact on your scientific literacy. Taking baby-bio or physics for poets isn't going to give you the tools necessary to churn through scientific papers, nor will it give you perfect objectivity when evaluating scientific arguments, particularly volatile ones that challenge your own core beliefs.
- brandnewlow 16y agoOr maybe these Republicans went to college, saw how politicized the science departments were on their campuses, and instead of shrugging it off, realized that scientists are prone to mistakes and misleading just like everyone else, and so their claims should be taken with a grain of salt, just like those of everyone else. I fall into that camp. My time in college impressed upon me how human and fallible the academy is. I went in thinking "professors" had all the answers. Then I met enough people who were stealing funds, sleeping with students, lazily grading papers, exploiting free labor and jealously hording grant money, that I realized these were just people, prone to the same errors in judgment that everyone else deals with.
- anthonyb 16y agoOr maybe these Republicans are personally invested in a particular ideology, and anything which threatens that ideology triggers the monkey brain's fear-of-other and must be destroyed. Much like you're trying to do by insinuating that all scientists/professors are lazy, greedy, exploitative thieves who shag their students.
- MichaelSalib 16y agoI realized these were just people, prone to the same errors in judgment that everyone else deals with. I don't understand how this is relevant to the discussion. No one has ever claimed that scientists are all-knowing or super-human or somehow not subject to the cognitive defects endemic to all human brains. But just because scientists are human and make mistakes does not mean that their claims about scientific matters are wrong. I mean, my attorney is a human guy who makes typical human mistakes, but when it comes to giving me legal advice, he's a hell of a lot better than the average person. His expertise is beneficial even though he sometimes forgets things or gets confused or gets angry or suffers from status quo bias. All those problems mean that I should exercise some judgment while considering his advice, but statistically, his advice is still much better than what I could come up with on my own.