3 ms·
"from calculations we see that the total capacity of the satellite component is, for Europe, 100 Megabits per second" That doesn't sound like it's going to imp
by tyingq 9y ago
"from calculations we see that the total capacity of the satellite component is, for Europe, 100 Megabits per second"
That doesn't sound like it's going to improve inflight WiFi much. They do mention also downward connectivity to cell towers, so hopefully the satellite link isn't used much. There's not much info on how many spots over Europe won't be covered by the ground cell towers.
Edit: I do find the grumbling about inflight WiFi performance funny. You're in a metal tube that twists and turns, 5+ miles high in the sky, going 500mph. Installing the system means cutting a huge hole in the plane and detailed certification testing down to every wire connector...and thus nothing can be upgraded at a normal pace. Isn't being able to check your email novel enough? Why are you surprised that YouTube doesn't work well?
- vidarh 9y ago> Isn't being able to check your email novel enough? It was novel a few years ago. It's not any more. At least not for regular travellers.
- tyingq 9y agoPerhaps. The physics and economics of these systems, and the regulatory barriers to keeping them current means they will never work as well as what you have at home though.
- nolok 9y agoMaybe, but as someone who use them regularly we've moved far beyond "hopefully check my emails sometime in the next five minutes". It's still not good enough for something like youtube, or even javascript application with a need for low latency, but it's definitely good and reliable enough to "use the internet". I've used it on both Qatar Airways and Emirates, and would recommand it if you like to work during flight and your work needs the internet (eg emails, your task trackers to follow/answer your team, code reviews, ...), it's also been cheap enough that it fitted into my needs (paying it and getting myself up to date was worth more to me than not paying and then having to catch up after landing).
- tyingq 9y agoAhh, got it. I was including "regular web surfing" along with "check your email". Just saying that higher bandwidth things like videos, spotify, etc, weren't feasible.
- ghaff 9y agoSometimes I feel as if I'm the only person who genuinely doesn't care if I'm disconnected for some number of hours while I'm in a plane. I have reading material, downloaded video, and various apps. I almost appreciate flying time as an opportunity to catch up on various things without distraction.
- tyingq 9y agoYou're not. The take rate on these services is pretty low. Single digit percentages of the passengers. That's part of the reason they aren't better.
- kogepathic 9y ago> The take rate on these services is pretty low. Single digit percentages of the passengers. In-flight WiFi and cellular were available on my last Etihad flight (Europe -> Bangkok via Abu Dhabi). The charge was something like 25 EUR to share the 1MBit/128Kbit link with the rest of the plane. So no wonder the uptake on this service is slow low. Business passengers will probably take it because the company pays (or it's included in the cost of their ticket) and for economy passengers it's too much to pay for a handicapped internet connection where they can't even Skype friends or browse Facebook because it's so slow.
- tyingq 9y agoThey've all done experiments with different price points. The 25 EUR rate isn't likely an accident...it's what gains them the most revenue. The installation costs are very high (certification, aircraft downtime, etc), and for satellite based solutions, the bandwidth cost is high. I don't even think they are trying to make money, just offset as much cost as they can.
- gsnedders 9y agoAs far as I'm aware, they make most of the money on business jets; the commercial side, as far as I'm aware, operates more or less at marginal cost with lower QoS guarantees than the business jets get as a marketing exercise.