33 ms·
Seattle’s higher minimum wage is actually working fine
- ABCLAW 9y agoOh boy. Time to read another page of comments written by people who think that price elasticity is always linear and that markets are always efficient!
- WillPostForFood 9y agoPrices elasticity doesn't need to be linear, nor do markets need to be perfectly efficient for higher labor costs to lead to lower employment. If you want to make an honest argument for higher minimum wage, you need to address the cost of lower levels of employments for the very poor.
- wonder_bread 9y ago^preach
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lumberjack 9y agoSeems like otherwise objective open minded people find it hard to admit ignorance and humility when the topic is political. Climate change and economics are always so hotly debated by engineers.
- CalChris 9y agoI'm in SV and I've never met an engineer here who was a climate science denier. I've met conservatives (not many) but not a full on earth is cooling denier. On the interweb, sure.
- trendia 9y agoThere are studies that avoid assuming perfect, instantaneous markets. They, too, show nuanced but negative long term effects of min wages. http://voxeu.org/article/long-run-employment-effects-minimum-wage http://voxeu.org/article/long-run-employment-effects-minimum...
- tdb7893 9y agoHow good is the model they are using? They are making all of the conclusions based on a model but data on the model doesn't seem in the scope of the article
- trendia 9y agoThe article is a summary of the paper. The full paper is available here: https://www.chicagofed.org/~/media/publications/working-papers/2013/wp2013-26-pdf.pdf https://www.chicagofed.org/~/media/publications/working-pape...
- crdoconnor 9y ago"More recently, some researchers (e.g. Dube et al. 2010) exploit differences between counties sitting on each side of a state border where one state raised their minimum wage and another did not. Many, but certainly not all, studies that use these approaches deliver SMALL disemployment effects." Daniel Aaronson, Eric French, Isaac Sorkin from your article ^^^ Dube et al 2010's ACTUAL result: "We compare all contiguous county-pairs in the United States that straddle a state border and find NO adverse employment effects" This a pathetic piece of weasel wording, although not something I'm terribly surprised to see from them specifically.
- trendia 9y agoThe paper itself is much more nuanced. Their model predicts the results of Dube, especially in industries where few of the employees receive salaries near min wage. It also predicts the minimal disemployment effects (or non-existent disemployment effects, as in Dube) in the short run. Where it differs is in the long-run in industries where 1) many employees receive near min wage, and 2) capital can easily replace labor. So, Aaronson finds disemployment in low cost / fast food restaurants in the long run, but not in expensive sit down restaurants (which can absorb additional labor costs).
- rsync 9y ago"Oh boy. Time to read another page of comments written by people who think that price elasticity is always linear and that markets are always efficient!" I'll take that over a page of comments from people that are not aware that price elasticity exists. Progress, yes ?
- jackweirdy 9y agoDidn't realise so many HN commenters were anti-minimum-wage
- exclusiv 9y agoI don't think that's an accurate statement. I think it's more about what level is optimal for an area and how we determine it.
- sparkling 9y ago"You cannot make a man worth a given amount by making it illegal for anyone to offer him anything less. You merely deprive him of the right to earn the amount that his abilities and situation would permit him to earn, while you deprive the community even of the moderate services that he is capable of rendering. In brief, for a low wage you substitute unemployment. You do harm all around, with no comparable compensation." - Henry Hazlitt
- handojin 9y agoYou should attribute your quotes.
- sparkling 9y agoA mis-paste ;)
- michaelmrose 9y agoExcept for the part where this doesn't seem to be actually happening
- elif 9y agoin a fictional world with unresponsive labor markets
- pjmorris 9y agoOn the other hand, you can make a man worth much more than any given amount by making it legal to create new bank balances out of thin air (central banking). This, too, deprives him of the right to earn the amount that his abilities and situation would permit him to earn, while forcing his community to continue to be subject to the services he did not earn on his own. In brief, for a high wage you substitute over-employment. You do harm all around, with no comparable compensation (though it will be pitched otherwise). Interesting disparities we have at opposite ends of the income scale.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoI think you'd find that many people who would agree with the quote at the top of this thread will also agree that this is a bad idea as well (at the least, when used as you describe); your comment is an accurate description of an additional problem to be addressed.
- bedhead 9y agoThe minimum wage is always $0
- lordnacho 9y agoUnpaid interns effectively pay transportation and other associated costs. I've always insisted on paying a little bit to kids who come in to shadow us, and something a bit more substantial for kids who actually sit and do useful work.
- mywittyname 9y agoThere are companies that pay negative wages. Most notably MLMs.
- Karunamon 9y agoUntil you start seeing low-income people in Seattle and around the country taking to the streets to demand lower minimum wages, don’t listen to anyone who tries to tell you otherwise. The article ending on this note kind of soured the whole thing. The average person will be perfectly okay with higher wages so long as they don't take into account things like inflation and other knock-on effects - and most won't, because those effects are subtle over time. The money's gotta come from somewhere at the end of the day. And if the company doesn't want to or can't raise prices (franchises are especially hit by this, since a lot of their pricing flexibility is dictated by a corporate office), the next thing to be cut will always be labor.
- MaysonL 9y agoRemember reading an article in Forbes back in the '80s that cited a study comparing the profitability of McDonalds franchises that paid minimum wage, and those that paid somewhat higher. Guess which were more profitable? The ones who paid higher wages.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoAt what point does the law of diminishing returns kick in, though? McDonalds fries are good, but not THAT good, so at some point it's just not worth going there any more.
- mmmpop 9y agoI like to think this is because the workers are more inspired to work harder to "earn their keep". I'd say it's more likely the boss is keeping a closer eye on the workers' productivity and insists upon a bit more effort. I think it's a win-win but my lack of faith in humanity (read: cynicism) causes me to worry about those not interested in putting that much effort into a "minimum wage job". I understand the perceived need for something like a $15 minimum wage but as a guy who has always considered himself quite benevolent when paying subcontractors their actual value, I have a hard time swallowing the whole deal. Again, probably my own shortcomings but it would be interesting to understand how this might affect the attitudes of your typical "minimum wage worker".
- 9y ago
- randomfool 9y agoThrilled that Seattle is giving this a try. Great that it's being analyzed so other areas can learn from and improve upon.
- pasquinelli 9y agoi'm dismayed at how thrilled i am to see such an attitude as yours, as if i never expected to see such a thing.
- dlp211 9y agoI just want to point out something that I heard on NPR/Public Radio on my drive home the other night. Essentially the studies that have been done around Seattle show that $15 was probably too high, but when it was raised to $11 it had no noticeable effect. Now of course, confidence in the studies matter, and I am going to assume the worst and that these studies weren't conducted in the same manner. But if the above holds true, the implications are immense.
- aetherson 9y agoIt hasn't hit $15 yet. The current studies are on the increase to $13. The studies when it was $11 didn't show no noticeable effect, they showed mixed effects. Basically, at $11, the studies suggested that it produced losers and winners, and the winners slightly outweighed the losers.
- lordnacho 9y agoMy thought as well. There needs to be experimentation for us to learn anything. That goes especially for economics, where you often get ideology instead of evidence.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIt is incredibly difficult to experiment in economics because you can't control for a single variable. If I like minimum wage, I'll look for employment data during a boom to mask the negative effects. If I dislike it, I'll look for data during a bust. That's over simplifying, but it is why we have multiple studies both showing minimum wage helped and hurt.
- wonder_bread 9y agoWelcome to the modern news cycle, where alternative realities are only a click away! Sit back and enjoy your daily deluge into the fantasies of some revenue-pressured writer seeking to capitalize on the latest zeitgeists us citizens consume each day as if they are fact.
- dailyrorschach 9y agoIt's a column/opinion not an article, an not from someone on staff at the Washington Post.
- alacombe 9y agoWaPo is being contradicted by a recent report from the National Bureau of Economic Research... https://evans.uw.edu/sites/default/files/NBER%20Working%20Paper.pdf https://evans.uw.edu/sites/default/files/NBER%20Working%20Pa... "Using a variety of methods to analyze employment in all sectors paying below a specified real hourly rate, we conclude that the second wage increase to $13 reduced hours worked in low-wage jobs by around 9 percent, while hourly wages in such jobs increased by around 3 percent. Consequently, total payroll fell for such jobs, implying that the minimum wage ordinance lowered low-wage employees’ earnings by an average of $125 per month in 2016"
- akl 9y agoDid you read the article? They are literally responding to this study.
- coldpie 9y agoIt's not a contradiction, they are responding directly to that report.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DiggityDug7 9y agoYou should try actually reading the WaPo article. They spend about half the article discussing that exact report.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- exclusiv 9y agoMakes sense. I have a contractor for one of my companies that I pay $20/hr for doing mostly CMS edits. She's been pressuring me for more hours. We asked her to get more acquainted with Snapchat and other things to get more hours but she pushed back. We gave her a way to get more hours but she only wanted the easy ones that she already knew. If her rate was less, I'd have her do more things. Time to part ways unfortunately.
- mmmpop 9y agoThe existence of this Washington Post article was determined yesterday by the existence of an article critical of Seattle's minimum wage in the Wall Street Journal. Andrey Markov is sleeping soundly in his grave.
- MegaButts 9y agoAnd don't forget the Washington Post is owned by Jeff Bezos, who owns Amazon, which is in Seattle.
- OrwellianChild 9y agoConspiracy theories aside, WaPo published the initial release of the working paper yesterday (June 26) with a favorable headline: A ‘very credible’ new study on Seattle’s $15 minimum wage has bad news for liberals [1] [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-study-casts-doubt-on-whether-a-15-minimum-wage-really-helps-workers/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-s...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- awinter-py 9y agowords missing from this article: 'delivery', 'outsource', 'manufacturing', 'offshore', 'manual labor'. Seattle is the headquarters of starbucks (low-wage high-labor coffee shipped from overseas) and amazon (manufactured goods shipped from wherever). They can raise the minimum wage because a big piece of their economy is already happening elsewhere.
- jhall1468 9y agoThat's true of almost all extremely large companies, so I'm not sure I understand your point. Those two companies still only represent a small portion of the entire Seattle workforce.
- awinter-py 9y agoI'm not talking about the people who work at sbux/amzn, I'm talking about the people who don't work in seattle because of import/export activity: factory workers and coffee growers.
- chillwaves 9y agoYes, but we all buy from markets that benefit from the lower cost of other labor markets or technology (or regulation).
- awinter-py 9y agoAgreed. And that's the reason Seattle was able to raise their minimum wage without major disruption -- not because their economy doesn't rely on cheaper labor, but because they've outsourced it. I'm not assigning a moral value to outsourcing, though I agree with intel founder Andy Grove that outsourcing high tech like chip fabs can backfire after a generation. Just making the point that raising wages is easy if cost of living / labor deltas has already offshored part of your economy.
- jhall1468 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ared38 9y agoConvenient of this article to ignore that the Berkley study only looked at food service workers while the UW study looked at a much wider range of jobs than previous studies. I'm sickened by my "pro science" party rushing to ignore results that don't agree with our ideological intuitions. Obviously the UW study has flaws. Let's give economists a little time to figure out WHY the results are so different from previous studies before we draw any conclusions.
- peterjlee 9y ago*Berkeley
- ender7 9y agoIf both studies are so flawed, it seems indefensible to draw _any_ conclusions right now.
- thehardsphere 9y agoMaybe if you limit your scope to this single event. There is a large body of prior evidence and theory to suggest that disemployment was likely to occur from such a large increase in the minimum wage, so I don't think it's really proper to act as though two studies represents our entire universe of human knowledge about these sorts of policy changes.
- surfmike 9y agoThe studies on that are mixed (see Card/Kreuger). But it's worth noting that the UW study was able to explain the results of previous studies that showed no effect on employment: those studies did not have access to info about hourly wages and hours/week.
- cwyers 9y agoThe UW study was actually able to duplicate the results of previous studies, and had an explanation of why the results were different -- previous studies haven't actually known what wages people were getting and what hours they were working. This study did. Much better data gives you the ability to ask better questions. There are still possible flaws with the UW study, but the UW study addresses many criticisms in advance, and is much more worth a read than this WaPo article.
- eagsalazar2 9y agoWhat do the models say? I'm not an economist but I always feel like decisions and debates like this are based mostly on people's limited ability to reason about a very complex system (and probably more so, their biases and personal interests). A minimum wage is likely to have a complex and unexpected impact. So what can be modelled? What experiments have been done where we can simply observe the impact? Also what are the goals and how are they prioritized? Do the rights of wealthy individuals to keep every penny of their earnings outweigh (I hate that I can't use 'trump' anymore) a societal goal of eliminating poverty or making sure the poor have a decent standard of living (health care, education, safety, etc)? Obviously everyone wants both these things (right?) but how are the weighted? Aaagghhh!! (Our world is so far away from anything sane I just can't stand it this morning.)
- Mikeb85 9y agoThe models say that a rising minimum wage would decrease demand for labour. Of course, how much it affects actual unemployment depends on how much labour was previously demanded and supplied. The thinking of course is that aggregate income among low earners makes up for the increased unemployment, and the extra spending power they have improves the economy as a whole, leading to less unemployment than a linear relationship between minimum wage and unemployment would suggest. Edit - at the very end I should add, "assuming the demand for labour actually increases aggregate income for those workers affected". If a min wage hike is too severe or unemployment already too high, you might not be better off in the end.
- eagsalazar2 9y agoMore fundamentally, I wonder if this just boils down to an oversupply of inexpensive labor (or shortage of low skill work depending on your perspective)? Would be interesting to see what the models predicted if we removed a huge portion of cheap latino laborers that currently occupy almost all minimum wage jobs in every state I've lived in (CA and WA) in service and agriculture. BTW, for people who are economists, are there models out there that are freely available where people can tweak variables like that? Would be fun as hell to play around with. (Just to be clear, I am not a Trump supporter in general. Heh.)
- DavidWoof 9y agoI'm more or less sympathetic to the idea that the Seattle minimum wage experiment can be having negative effects. Card/Krueger has to have a limit somewhere, and I suspect certain jurisdictions are approaching or exceeding that limit. That said, excluding multi-location employers from a minimum wage study just seems to me to be so obviously flawed as to border on pure dishonesty. I'm truly curious how things like this happen. Did UW publish this as a reasonable study with limited findings only to find the press massively misreported it? Or did the desire for media coverage lead the researchers to overstate the findings just to get in the press? I personally don't think political bias drove this. It looks like researchers at UW made a perfectly reasonable small limited study that added a small amount to our knowledge, but then either the researchers or the university or the press advertised it as an exhaustive answer to a complex question.
- john_horton 9y agoIt wasn't dishonest - they didn't have the data for those multi-site employers b/c of how Washington state keeps records. The authors are upfront about this and try to address the limitation by adding a a survey component---they talked to these employers to see if their responses to the MW were different.
- DavidWoof 9y agoI agree with that, so maybe my post wasn't as clear as it could be. I would say that in the transmission between the study and the mainstream press, something happened that is best described as "dishonest", or at the very least a reckless disregard for nuance. As you point out, and I agree, the study itself doesn't have that problem. The study itself is quite clear on its limitations. So where's the issue? Is it just the general incompetency of the mainstream press (I could absolutely believe that). Is it the authors crossing every 't' in the study, but then overstating the findings and dropping the caveats in their interviews with the media? Is it the UW PR staff overstating the findings in a way PR staffs are wont to do? A combination of all of these. I could believe any of those things. But when this study came out a few days ago, I had to read the study itself to have even a remote awareness of what it actually said (and remember, I think the findings are probably correct). And yes, I think that process is best described with the word "dishonest".
- 0xbear 9y agoIf I'm not mistaken the new minimum wage is not yet fully implemented and small businesses got a temporary reprieve. As to WaPo: the new release of Google News finally lets you ban the news sources you don't like. After removing WaPo, HuffPo, CNN and NY Times, my news feed is borderline useful again. Thank you, Google!
- s73ver 9y agoSo what's the difference now between getting your news from there or from Facebook? It sounds like Google News is going to be the same kind of echo chamber that other news sources become :( Please don't take this as a criticism of your chosen (or dischosen) news sources, as I'm sure I can find someone replying to this thread who is removing the sources you like as well.
- 0xbear 9y agoI don't use Facebook, so I wouldn't know. I've come to the conclusion that the function of the media has shifted over time from reporting news to just peddling narratives, all while also showing me irrelevant ads. So I shut off those news sources for which narrative peddling is the primary function. I would shut off Fox, but Google seems to not show anything from them even if they're not in block list. My news feed now mostly consists of science/tech and local news. I like it that way.
- kartD 9y agoFrankly, I'll be happy when the US gets out of this mandatory tipping culture BS.
- alacombe 9y agoOOTH, it's not as if one of the Berkeley author, Michael Reich, was a long time socialist. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Reich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Reich: In 1968, while in graduate school, Reich was a founding member of the Union for Radical Political Economics (URPE).[5] In doing so, as Reich describes in a biographical compilation piece (A Biographical Dictionary of Dissenting Economists),[3] he helped "to organize an influential circle of radical economists." URPE’s agenda, as described by a spokesperson for the group, is to: "support an American version of socialism, with public ownership of production and a government-planned economy to meet social needs rather than the needs of private profit." So he's very clearly biased toward proving minimum wage increase's success.
- fsloth 9y agoPeople change. I think you need proof of current ideology to make a case. Soviet propaganda pre 1980:s managed to convince a lot of smart people to go ultra left. For instance, one of the most prominent bankers in nordic countries, Bjorn Wahlroos, was originally at far left in his political leanings.[0] [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Björn_Wahlroos https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Björn_Wahlroos
- alacombe 9y agoFrom the wikipedia article: "Controversy Reich's analyses on the effects of minimum wage increases in his capacity at IRLE have generated controversy and accusations of bias from Los Angeles city legislators. Addressing IRLE's selection to analyze a proposed minimum wage hike in Los Angeles to $15.25, Democratic City Councilman Felipe Fuentes argued that "the selection of U.C. Berkeley, by perception, compromises the possibility of a fair and balanced discussion." Fuentes and fellow Democratic Councilman Mitch O'Farrell asked to reopen the selection process for a research team "so that we can engage in a process that is worthy of our employers, workers and their families, and the well-being of our economy."[14] In March 2016, the Albany Times Union reported on hundreds of pages of emails from Reich’s research team that showed a close collaboration between the research team and labor union groups that fund the movement to raise the minimum wage. According to the article, “the relationship between academic and funder seemed explicit” with one uncovered email showing that the research team was seeking grant money to support its research "for local groups engaged in work to raise the minimum wage" and “testimony/media work” in California.[15]" When you are getting accused of bias by Democrats, things are pretty bad.
- enoch_r 9y agoThis reminds me of: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refuted/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refut... There's a complicated issue where theoretical predictions go one way and empirical evidence is mixed. Result: everyone looks at the studies that suggest they're right, and claims that they "debunk" the studies that suggest they're wrong. You get to look at all the weaknesses of the studies you don't like, and ignore the weaknesses of the studies you do like. In this case of course the UW study was commissioned several years ago by the city of Seattle. Then, apparently, in mid-June, after seeing the results of the UW study (but before they were publicly released), the mayor of Seattle commissioned this second study, this time from UC Berkeley's IRLE. (Why the IRLE? It certainly couldn't be because their previous work suggests that they very strongly believe the minimum wage has no disemployment effect.) The IRLE's study said the minimum wage increase had no disemployment effect. Whew. Debunked and well refuted! Just for fun, you can use this handy guide to see which study has been refuted: - if you want the minimum wage to increase, then excluding multi-location businesses from their analysis obviously damns the UW study, and proves that their results can be ignored. - if you don't want the minimum wage to increase, then including only food-service jobs in their analysis obviously damns the Berkeley study, and proves that their results can be ignored.
- cwyers 9y ago> In this case of course the UW study was commissioned several years ago by the city of Seattle. Then, apparently, in mid-June, after seeing the results of the UW study (but before they were publicly released), the mayor of Seattle commissioned this second study, this time from UC Berkeley's IRLE. That's what really bugs me. They commission the UW study, they see the results, and then they commission this other study hurriedly to release six days before the UW study. If you keep asking the question until you get the results you want, you're going to get the results you want.
- haberman 9y ago> This reminds me of: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refuted/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/13/debunked-and-well-refut... What an excellent essay. I especially liked: > There are many “questions” that are pretty much settled – evolution, global warming, homeopathy. But taking these as representative closes your mind and gives you a skewed picture of academia. On many issues, academics are just as divided as anyone else, and their arguments can be just as acrimonious as anyone else’s. The arguments usually take the form of one side publishing a study, the other side ripping the study apart and publishing their own study which they say is better, and the first side ripping the second study apart and arguing that their study was better all along.
- TimJYoung 9y agoWe need to make the EITC (Earned Income Tax Credit) much more generous, removing the necessity for higher minimum wages to fix our demand issues. The EITC has better knock-on effects in terms of increasing competition for labor and serves as an employment subsidy for many small businesses that would, otherwise, not employ anyone. Plus, it is much, much easier to get a "10,000ft view" of the employment/demand situation at the Federal level, as opposed to a hodge-podge of local initiatives. The EITC is a great tool for efficient re-distribution of resources to working Americans on the lower rungs of the economic ladder. It's efficient and we can turn the knobs to adjust it as necessary to fit our needs, such as not being as generous to teenagers that live in an existing household (something that minimum wage increases do not account for). The only downside to the EITC is the once-a-year aspect to the distribution. It would probably be wise for us to develop a more reliable distribution of the money so that it provides a more even boost to the worker's regular paycheck.
- greedo 9y agoEITC has a massive downside that you're ignoring. The ability of municipalities to act as laboratories in social policy is essential to effective governance. Seattle can raise their minimum wage far easier than having Congress change the Federal minimum wage. And then we can see how it works in Seattle. Expanding EITC has a huge affect, and is both harder to enact, and if needed, harder to rollback.
- davidw 9y agoThe minimum wage affects both high school students looking for some extra cash, and people desperately trying to support a family. The latter is where an effective policy would concentrate its help. I'm not sure what the best answer is.
- TimJYoung 9y agoThat's absolutely true for most new Federal economic/tax policies that are relatively untested. But, the EITC has been around since the mid-to-late 70s. We've got loads of data on its effects under all sorts of different economic scenarios, some of which are included here: http://www.epi.org/publication/ib370-earned-income-tax-credit-and-the-child-tax-credit-history-purpose-goals-and-effectiveness/ http://www.epi.org/publication/ib370-earned-income-tax-credi...
- cowpig 9y ago> It’s not entirely clear why the University of Washington team gets such a weird result — since their data isn’t public, we can’t check it — but it’s worth noting at least two important issues with their study. I cannot understand how economic studies are supposed to be credible when the data they use is not provided along with their methodology. Is this for privacy reasons? If so, surely we can come up with obfuscation standards?
- dpatru 9y agoThe average home price in Seattle is over $670,000.[1] This requires a salary of $182,000 per year [2] or $87.50 dollars per hour. At $15 per hour, a full-time worker cannot afford a house in Seattle. Therefore, to avoid the injustice of a homeless, full-time worker, the minimum wage should raised to at least $87.50 per hour. [1] https://www.zillow.com/seattle-wa/home-values/ https://www.zillow.com/seattle-wa/home-values/ [2] https://www.redfin.com/how-much-house-can-i-afford?utm_source=google&utm_medium=ppc&utm_campaign=1001260&utm_term=kwd-37027506043&utm_content=115419081140&adgid=19054547780 https://www.redfin.com/how-much-house-can-i-afford?utm_sourc...
- epistasis 9y ago$670,000 is the average home price, not the minimum home price, so you're chasing the wrong goal. I would also argue that chasing home ownership for everyone, in a city, is the wrong goal. I don't care about owning a home, I care about saving for retirement, and living in a home that's adequate for my family. Home ownership is great for some, I encourage it, but let's not pretend that it's the only way to live.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoIf you'd like some real criticism of the UW study, the author of the Berkeley one has published a letter which goes over a lot of the methodological problems. http://irle.berkeley.edu/files/2017/Reich-letter-to-Robert-Feldstein.pdf http://irle.berkeley.edu/files/2017/Reich-letter-to-Robert-F... Here's the best points, I'd say the UW study is quite problematic. The UW report excludes multi-site businesses from its dataset, which removes 48 percent of Seattle’s low-paid workforce out of their study.3 This major exclusion raises a big red caution flag about the representativeness of their sample and therefore about the interpretation of their findings. Yet the UW report provides essentially no evidence that their sample is representative of all jobs in Seattle and Washington. In the UW data set, workers who leave a single-site business for a multi-site business to benefit from the higher wage mandate or because they received a better offer are not counted in the wage gains, but are counted in jobs lost. Seattle's policy essentially sets a higher minimum wage for all multi-site businesses, counting them as large employers.4 The exclusion of multi-site businesses, which is not standard in studies that use these data, may therefore create major biases in their results. Of course, some employees may move from multi-site businesses to single site businesses, but this mobility direction is likely to be smaller. It is not possible to estimate the size of this bias without access to the underlying data. The UW report focuses only on jobs that had paid less than $19, which surprisingly is much too low. Table 3 of the UW report indicates that the number of jobs paying under $19 in all single-site businesses fell by about 6000 between 2014 and 2016. Yet the number of single-site jobs at all pay levels in Seattle increased by about 44,000 in the same period. This pattern of average higher pay and more employment appears also in food services: a decline of about 150 jobs paying under $19 from 20014 to 2016 and a simultaneous increase of about 4,500 jobs in all pay levels at single-site food service establishments. These numbers represents very good news: Seattle’s pay levels and job numbers both went up, at least among single-site businesses. We want to know, though, how much of this upgrading in overall pay and employment at all pay levels can be attributed just to the minimum wage policy. The UW report nonetheless finds an unprecedented impact of wage increases on jobs, ten times higher than the average in 942 published minimum wage and non-minimum wage estimates, and triple that of minimum wage critic David Neumark
- surfmike 9y agoIt would be interesting to read how many of those criticisms were addressed in the Berkeley study itself.
- cwyers 9y agoThis is a hack job, an out-and-out piece of propaganda trying to dismiss a study the author doesn't like the conclusions of. > First, their data exclude workers at businesses that have more than one location; in other words, while workers at a standalone mom-and-pop restaurant show up in their results, workers at Starbucks and McDonald’s don’t. The UW report actually discusses this: > Multi-location firms may respond differently to local minimum wage laws. On the one hand, firms with establishments inside and outside of the affected jurisdiction could more easily absorb the added labor costs from their affected locations, and thus would have less incentive to respond by changing their labor demand. On the other hand, such firms would have an easier time relocating work to their existing sites outside of the affected jurisdiction, and thus might reduce labor demand more than single-location businesses. Survey evidence collected in Seattle at the time of the first minimum wage increase, and again one year later, increase suggests that multi-location firms were in fact more likely to plan and implement staff reductions. Our employment results may therefore be biased towards zero. It's irresponsible to criticize the report for not including multi-site employees without mentioning the conclusions of this survey data. > Second, the University of Washington team does not present enough data for us to assess the validity of its “synthetic control” in Washington — that is, the set of areas to which they compare the results they observe in Seattle. The synthetic controls are probably the most complicated part of the report, and the part that seems the most open to criticism. But the UW report used two different controls for for changes in employment, and both of them lead to similar conclusions about the effects of the minimum wage. It's possible that there are other synthetic controls that yield different results. The WaPo article says that the "Berkely researchers take a better approach" to synthetic controls, but doesn't note that the UW study can't use that approach because the data that enabled the UW study isn't collected nationally. Also, saying "the new studys' findings are out of step with a large body of research" ignores that the UW paper duplicated the findings of that large body of research, and discussed how the more expressive dataset they had (being able to actually identify low-income workers instead of using a proxy like "restaraunt workers" or "teenagers" is the biggest difference between this and other studies) leads them to different conclusions. And saying the UW study has "important limitations," but not saying the same thing about the Berkely study, which was only able to look at workers in one sector (restaraunts), is a pretty clear indicator of where the author's sympathies lie.
- drak0n1c 9y agoThe UW researcher, Jacob Vigdor, whose research is dismissed in this article, has responded to common criticisms in this interview: https://www.seattlemet.com/articles/2017/6/26/what-should-we-make-of-the-uw-minimum-wage-study https://www.seattlemet.com/articles/2017/6/26/what-should-we...
- karl11 9y agoTwo good marginal revolution posts on this: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/06/seattle-minimum-wage-study.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/06/sea... && http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/06/minimum-wage-evidence-danish-discontinuity.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/06/min...
- phezzan 9y agoShort version. A member of the San Jose teacher's association thinks one of two academic studies is wrong, because... we already have a consensus. The one point raised in the article about multi-site employers is acknowledged by the article's favored Berkeley study: "some multi-site businesses report payroll and head counts separately for each of their locations, while others consolidate their data and provide information as if their business operated only at a single location." Oh and by the way: "This report was prepared at the request of the Office of the Mayor of Seattle." http://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2017/06/the-most-surprising-finding-of-seattle.html http://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2017/06/the-most-s...
- theprop 9y ago"There's lies, there's damned lies, and then there's statistics..." Mark Twain
- exclusiv 9y agoSome considerations of the minimum wage movement: 1) The higher it gets the more likely and quicker the minimum wage jobs will be replaced by AI/robots/automation. 2) The cost gets passed on to the consumer. So if everything costs more and everyone is paying more in taxes, that's not good either. Some companies may keep prices the same and take from profits, but the lower the margins, the less attractive creating and running a business becomes. 3) What works in one area like Seattle won't necessarily work across the country. There has to be a sweet spot in each area and we have to be honest with ourselves to say that the feel-goodness of a higher minimum wage does have its limits. And that limit is what we are debating. We don't need to do a study to know that a $50/hr minimum wage is unreasonable. In any given city, what minimum wage provides fairness for individuals, businesses AND the local economy as a whole? And how can we develop a model framework for cities across the country to use?
- openasocket 9y agoExcept it's already like that. If we don't pay workers a living wage they have to use our social safety net programs, such as food stamps. Those programs are funded by the tax payer. So basically the tax payers are already subsidizing companies like Walmart so they don't have to pay a full living wage to their employees. If those companies paid them a full wage the taxpayers would pay less for social welfare programs. I'm also not that sympathetic to the plight of companies like McDonald's when it is earning in excess of $4B in profit in a year. Obviously, what counts as a fair wage will depend on the local cost of living.
- exclusiv 9y agoThat's a good insight. I agree with that point and think every city should propose laws that support a living wage. We just need to understand what that living wage should be in any given city and consider a variety of factors, some short term and some long term. > If those companies paid them a full wage the taxpayers would pay less for social welfare programs. Maybe. That assumes the poverty line stays the same and nothing happens with the price of other goods those minimum wage earners need to buy. It also assumes there's no impact on 1) number of jobs and 2) number of hours and thus total income as the UW study discusses. As long as part time employee is allowed you cannot guarantee an income for any given job. So a min. hourly wage doesn't definitively solve the problem of mandating a fair wage as we are discussing. > I'm also not that sympathetic to the plight of companies like McDonald's when it is earning in excess of $4B in profit in a year. Me either. But McDonalds has already shown a long time ago that they can eliminate min. wage jobs and/or hours by getting consumers to throw away their trash and fill up their own drinks. This is part of the consideration #1 I mentioned.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoNext week there will be a study refuting the MIT study, then another refuting that study, back and forth. It seems no matter the study academia publishes, and how much it is lauded for its clarity, breadth, and quality, another study will come along ripping it to shreds that another group will heap praise upon.
- CobrastanJorji 9y agoYou're saying that like it's a bad thing, but so long as each new study is honest criticism of the previous study or brings new information to the table, that sounds like exactly how big questions like this should be handled.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoFair point. I don't mean it to sound like a bad thing, but I understand and accept that research and science can be bought. For every study supporting something, another study could be done that refutes it. Especially in such a politically charged atmosphere and issue, it gets hard to trust one source over the other. I trust the MIT study more than the UW study, but someone else probably has the completely opposite viewpoint.
- thetruthseeker1 9y agoMy take away has been that it is not clear beyond doubt that higher minimum wage is better in the long run. If both the studies had agreed that it is better, yes, it makes sense to enthusiastically adopt it. However if studies have results that dont match, then I think there is a reason for caution. As far as what I understand, only Seattle adopted higher minimum wage, now many people with that minimum wage can get services (may be not directly, but in the supply chain) from other states which don't have the minimum wage which can give the impression that their life has improved. However, if the whole country adopts it, the parameters of that might be different. I hope somebody sheds a light on wage dilution as well. If somebody was incentivized to learn a skill that pays them 20$ an hour, will that incentive still be there?
- cartercole 9y agothe min wage hurts low skilled workers. period.
- cybernytrix 9y agoI feel one of the real issues is incentivizing publicly traded companies to beat pressure from Wall street to keep cutting costs and workers be damned attitude. It might be worthwhile to experiment $30 per hour wages for all publicly listed and big companies, including temp workers. Overall it is better for someone to work 4h at $30 instead of 8h at $15.
- k__ 9y agoI'm more of an UBI fanboi, but it seems MW is working, at least here in Germany. Turns out, most jobs that had wages below MW were still lucrative for the companies even when paying 8,84€/h
- paulMageau 9y agoVery confused wapo published this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-study-casts-doubt-on-whether-a-15-minimum-wage-really-helps-workers/?utm_term=.505244cd285a https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-s...
- paulMageau 9y agoVery confused wapo published this https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-study-casts-doubt-on-whether-a-15-minimum-wage-really-helps-workers/?utm_term=.505244cd285a https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/06/26/new-s...
- dragonwriter 9y agoPublishing analysis/perspective/opinion pieces with different spin on the same underlying news isn't uncommon in publications that aren't simple ideological propaganda mills.
- ableton 9y agoA lot of people are getting fired due to increased minimum wage. The employers will take their money and pay it to you and me to build automated solutions that do what the now-too-expensive people once did. That's what McDonalds is finally doing with self-order kiosks.
- Shivetya 9y ago5000 fewer jobs, not in the article is it?
- dmccunney 9y agoWhether any government mandated minimum wage boost "works", depends upon who you are. Who benefits from it? If you are currently in a minimum wage job, you may benefit. You're making more money, because the government says so! (But your employer might just decide wage costs are too high and lay you off...) If you are unemployed and looking for a minimum wage job, the bar just got raised. The higher the minimum wage is set, the harder employers look at how badly they need the work done. The job they might be willing to pay $10/hour for might not be worth $15/hour to them. Your quest to get a minimum wage job just got harder. And if you are willing to accept less money, because some money is better than none, it doesn't help you, because employers aren't legally permitted to pay you less, even if you would be happy to accept it. So you likely get a substantial underground economy of "off the books" employees, getting paid in cash that doesn't get reported to the government. And those folks may actually take home more than minimum wage employees because taxes don't get deducted from their wages. (I live in the NY metropolitan area. I see a lot of that. And there are employers who would pay the higher minimum wage, but the employees don't want to be on the books. Many are undocumented aliens, and being on the books leaves a trail pointing to them and possible deportation.) If you are the government that mandated the higher minimum wage, you might not benefit financially, because the amount of taxes you see is less than what you might see if minimum wage was lower and more people had minimum wage jobs. (Of course, for government who do this, it's about getting votes, and impact on tax revenue isn't a consideration.) And bear in mind that what the employee gets in a minimum wage job is rather less than what the employer has to spend. The employer must deduct and remit taxes, and must maintain the appropriate records for legal purposes, and that costs money. Ultimately, "it takes two to tango". There must be workers looking for minimum wage jobs, and employers offering them. The government can't require employers to hire workers they don't need, and increases in minimum wage will tend to decrease the number of minimum wage jobs available. Ultimately, minimum wage increases have the effect of decreasing total employment, but this seems to get missed in such discussions. The goal of minimum wage increases is to insure workers can make a survivable income. But value is relative - something is worth what someone else is willing to pay for it, and that includes the worker's labor. Minimum wage jobs are minimum wage for a reason. They are low skilled/unskilled labor, and what the worker does simply isn't worth that much to those who need it done. What the minimum wage folks need is to be able to acquire the knowledge and skills that are worth more to employers and be able to get better jobs. Increases in minimum wage by themselves don't aid that. We are seeing all sorts of commentary elsewhere about job losses to automation. The only reason many minimum wage jobs still exist is because it's more expensive up front to automate them than employers want to spend. At some point, minimum wage boosts might just make it worth the employer's while to spend the money needed to automate those jobs. Then what do the job seekers do?