4 ms·
The analogy with electricity is pretty good. When the electricity goes out, most people are pretty screwed: it powers our lighting, air conditioning, household
by nostrademons 9y ago
The analogy with electricity is pretty good. When the electricity goes out, most people are pretty screwed: it powers our lighting, air conditioning, household appliances, refrigeration, gasoline pumps, Internet access, point-of-sale systems, and in many places, cooking and running water too.
However, when the electricity goes out, it usually comes back on within a day or so, because a power outage is viewed as a top priority to fix, simply because so many aspects of modern life depend on it. And really critical businesses (supermarkets, hospitals, etc.) invest in generators so that they can run independently of the power grid.
The Internet will likely follow that path. It'll become indispensable to modern life, which means that when there's a threat against it, a lot of experts will be mobilized to put it back in service. And really critical businesses will invest in making sure their systems work even when offline.
- adrianN 9y agoAren't we already at that point? I haven't experienced any "internet outages" that lasted more than a couple of hours. Critical services are highly redundant.
- digi_owl 9y agoKinda. Thing is that with PCs and smartphone it is really the first time that the smarts are at the edges. With electricity it is in the transformers and the power stations. The kit at the individual home and office is downright dumb in comparison (and can be operated via local generators in a pinch). Similarly the analog phone network has its smarts in the switches. Not in the phones in homes and offices.
- natrius 9y agoIt's not like a power outage. It's more like a power surge that's somehow crafted to exploit every engineering flaw in every surge protector that well-funded state actors have piled up over the years. We would not recover from that in days.
- achamayou 9y agoNot even Google, in all their might and splendour, can reliably deliver software to all the versions of a platform they themselves created. I find it hard to believe that even the most competent villain will work out a way to hit 10% of the devices out there, let alone everything.
- marcosdumay 9y agoGoogle doesn't use their client's bandwidth and connectivity to help them.
- aaron_m04 9y agoIs bandwidth really the limiting factor for Google?
- rocqua 9y agoThe scary case isn't the internet going down. The scary thing is the internet becoming to hostile a place. When I can't reach the internet, all it takes is a new cable. When anything I connect to the internet is going to be infected and DDosed to oblivion, the fix is a lot harder. The other scare is that some critical infrastructure is exposed but not widely known. This allows the infrastructure to develop resilience to unintended failures, but not malicious failures. When this finally gets found, carnage may happen. An interesting example of this is BGP.
- nostrademons 9y agoThe same concerns were expressed about electricity [1] when it was first invented. The usage of the electric chair for executions was sponsored by Edison Electric [2] (now GE) as a way to link rival alternating current (and specifically Westinghouse; Thomas Edison made sure that the first executions were conducted with Westinghouse machines) with death in the public's mind. The solution wasn't to give up on electricity, it was to adopt basic safety precautions like step-down transformers to household voltage, elevated power lines, and insulated couplings. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_Currents#Safety_concerns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_of_Currents#Safety_concern... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_chair#The_Medico-Legal_commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_chair#The_Medico-Lega...
- Nomentatus 9y agoThe three-letter agencies haven't changed their minds. They still think that every computer being insecure makes us all more secure, and they will and they have acted to create this situation. That's the difference between now and a century ago. The govt back then didn't feel it was in their interest for electricity to be fundamentally unsafe for consumers. Until the agencies genuinely reverse course, inventions to promote safety can't move forward. We'd have basic safety now, as you describe, had room been made for it. But instead, they played past the edge - way past the edge, and have no profound regrets about that that I've heard.
- lucaspiller 9y agoI've never heard about this part of history before. I wonder if a dentist inventing the electric chair has something to do with why people don't like them :-)
- digi_owl 9y agoKinda. Electricity is pretty darn dumb. You can get cheap-ish 2-stroke generators with a typical outlet or two that is enough to drive anything short of a refrigerator or freezer. Similarly analog phone lines are pretty darn dumb. Vibrations registrered by one membrane is replicated in another by inducing changes in an electric current connecting the two. The complexity is in the switch boards that construct the circuit over distances. A proper POTS setup can actually handle loss of long distance lines without losing local connectivity, as long as the local switchboards are powered. And for that we are back at generators. Computers on the other hand are complex. Your typical Windows install have a buch of processes going in the background, talking to various pieces or hardware, and that is just a clean install sitting idle. Frankly the old microcomputers were more reliable. At worst a crypto attack would take out whatever floppy was in the drive at the time, and would be gone the second a power switch was flipped.
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Necessity is the daughter of invention." That is: the things we invent, out of necessity or otherwise being irrellevant, often become of themselves necessities. Part of our collective dependency tree.