3 ms·
Isn't this sort of issue faced by 99% of any new business that sells a service or a product? Unless your idea is something patentable, or you have a trade secre
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
Isn't this sort of issue faced by 99% of any new business that sells a service or a product? Unless your idea is something patentable, or you have a trade secret that's locked up tight, or you control your product vertically (e.g., you own the only Unobtainium mine on the planet) - can't your business be copied fairly trivially?
(Quick edit: who else remembers everyone and their nephew offering website hosting/colocation at ludicrously low prices in the early-to-mid 2000's?)
- moomin 9y agoNot really, no. When Dropbox applied to YC, they had to fill in a section that specifically dealt with how hard it would be to enter their space. It was much harder than it looks, and they convinced YC of that. Groupon always suffered from being easy to copy and having no appreciable network effects.
- eli 9y agoWere any of the Groupon copycats successful? Maybe it just wasn't that good an idea.
- pchristensen 9y agoNo. Living Social was the most successful runner up to Groupon. The problem was that "email deal-based marketing for small businesses" was going to be worth something, but there would only be one valuable winner and no one knew how much that would be worth. So Groupon, Living Social, FB, Google, Yelp, and hundreds of clones all threw in tons of money, slogged it out, and now they're all gone and GRPN is worth $2B, 1/8th of its IPO price. Exactly the same thing is happening with ride-hailing now. It's harder to copy, but there's too much investment subsidizing it so no one knows what the market will be worth once riders have to pay sustainable rates. But they know being 2nd place will suck. Citation: I worked at Groupon before and after the IPO.
- imjk 9y agoI think that's the point of the article (although I doubt it's anyway near 99%). The article is enforcing the importance of building an "economic moat" in business: http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/economicmoat.asp http://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/economicmoat.asp In the case of the meal-kit industry, the author's suggesting there is no moat, or none has been identified/built yet.
- wrsh07 9y agoNot really. Ben Thompson [Stratechery] talks about this in his update regarding Blue Apron's IPO [1]. Now to quote him: > ... the first customers a company gains are those for whom the product has the best possible fit; by definition they cost less to acquire. Growing beyond that initial base, though, costs more and more. > This is why network effects are so important. What differentiates services that are actually sustainable businesses is that the larger they grow the more their utility increases, and it is this increased utility that drives new customer acquisition (as opposed to simply spending more marketing dollars). > Ride-sharing services are a perfect example... So patents and vertical integration aren't the only type of moat. Network effects shouldn't be overlooked. However, it's hard to see what network effects [besides just economies of scale] Blue Apron will be able to leverage. [In their ads they try to talk up their relationships, eg with farmers. If Blue Apron were trying to be a farm-goods marketplace, ie the Uber of produce, then that would be an effective moat. In the current case, I'm not sure I buy it] [1]: Subscription needed :( https://stratechery.com/2017/blue-apron-files-for-ipo-network-effects-and-customer-acquisition-costs-uber-concerns/ https://stratechery.com/2017/blue-apron-files-for-ipo-networ... Edit: - I am, however, a happy subscriber of Blue Apron. [fixed the above bullet] - Thompson also gives Netflix as an example. The bigger it gets, the larger its backlog of [hopefully timeless] shows -- increasing its value for late subscribers.