21 ms·
A Slow-Motion Trainwreck Facing the Meal-Kit Industry
- ghaff 9y agoIt seems that there's more potential for meaningful differentiation than in the case of the Groupon-type services but the rush to be one of the few winners who IPO and damn the customer acquisition costs seem like valid points. These services just seem very niche-y to me. I'm not really the target market but, for any given service, there's a pretty narrow profile of cost-sensitivity, interest in prepping/cooking but not just buying ingredients, ability to plan a week out, etc. Finally, if there were a real clamor for meal kits, what's to keep Whole Foods or whoever from just assembling their own meal kits?
- snarf21 9y agoI agree. It seems like these will eventually lose to just normal automated grocery delivery. You will always need other food than just the kits even if they are cost competitive in NYC, etc.
- marssaxman 9y agoIt's not just acquiring the ingredients; there's value in having someone else plan the menu for you. Deciding what to cook can be a challenge! I host an ~8 person dinner party roughly once a week, and it is not unusual for me to spend as much time digging through recipes, trying to decide what to cook, as I put into actually preparing the meal. Yes, of course you need other groceries beyond the meal kit itself, but that's not the point - the point is that you've paid the meal service to deal with all the boring parts of the process, which often includes the decision-making, so you can just enjoy the cooking and eating.
- ashark 9y agoI think too much ambition to be able to home-cook every kind of food under the sun leads to much of this trouble. Focus on a narrower set of things—say, 2-3 national/regional/ethnic cuisines, and/or cooking techniques—and most of the difficulty, expense, and even planning of home cooking goes away. The wildly globe-hopping table of the home cook is a recent, and kinda silly, development. You can get plenty of variety without trying to prepare meals from every continent. (this goes out the window if it's a major hobby, obviously, but in that case so should complaints about its difficulty/inconvenience, which are entirely self-imposed)
- ghaff 9y agoFor me it's a hobby and I do like to try new recipes/styles (while recognizing that there are some things I don't do enough to get good at or that just take more work than I'm willing to put in). But I mostly agree with you. I keep an admittedly fairly thick binder of recipes that I probably use a good 75% of the time I even need a recipe. And there are lots of simple things I can throw together in 15 minutes given the ingredients.
- digikata 9y agoSo where's the moat for the meal service vs something like a recipe pick + shopping list service directly linked to the delivering grocery? That seems like something Amazon or some other grocery delivery service could rapidly expand into. On the other hand, perhaps the quality of the curation and customer relationship does count for something here too.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoConvienience. Imagine the following smartphone app workflow: On first use answer some questions that provide information about dietary needs. Drag some sliders around to indicate preferences for simplicity, cost, ,quality, convenience. Some people want beans and rice because they're cheap, some people want fancier meals and care less about price. Some people are cooking for four and want meals that scale well. Some people Each wee checkbox the meals you want to eat in accordance with your schedule for the upcoming week. Press go and get a bunch of meals paired with a shopping list click on the meals to revise as necessary (e.g regenerate on you don't like or mark an item on the list of required items as "I'll source this myself") Add to cart, press go, wait for brown truck. Something like that could be a hit with single men and college students.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>It's not just acquiring the ingredients; there's value in having someone else plan the menu for you. That's where I see the value. People spend a lot of effort figuring out how to eat a balanced diet while optimizing for low (enough) cost or just close enough. Offloading the work of planning a balanced diet on a weekly level is something many people would pay a small premium for.
- luckydata 9y agoThe kits have a value beyond the food, they teach you how to be more confident about your cooking. Americans are terrible cooks on average, they don't learn good cooking skills at home because their parents are not very good cooks either (gross generalization but accurate if you compare the US with for example Italy). My wife now can cook a much wider variety of meals after a few months of meal kits. It also has reduced dramatically the thinking it required to plan meals in advance. If grocery stores want to compete they will have to work with their providers to create smaller packages of items to assemble and a team to design and forecast demand for different types of meals. Not impossible but definitely not easy, I see acquisitions happening in this space.
- Symbiote 9y agoWhen I was a student, the local Sainsbury's supermarket had a selection of recipe cards by the entrance. Here's the front of a newer version [1], the back is presumably something like this [2]. I wouldn't say they taught me to cook, I didn't learn any new techniques. But, I did get a lot of ideas from them, and it led us to eating a wider variety of food. I'm now curious -- what do typical American university students eat? Do they cook, or are all meals provided? (Surely not at weekends?) [1] http://laurenmclean.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/01_Sharwoods_Chicken-Tikka.jpg http://laurenmclean.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/01_Sharwo... [2] https://recipes.sainsburys.co.uk/recipes/main-courses/easy-chicken-tikka-with-zesty-rice https://recipes.sainsburys.co.uk/recipes/main-courses/easy-c...
- jpindar 9y agoThere's cooking and there's cooking. Most Americans, including students, cook standard American food such as hamburgers, hot dogs, eggs, spaghetti, roast chicken, ramen, steak etc., as well as a lot of canned soups, frozen vegetables, and boxed casserole mixes. But these kits are for people who want to eat something novel every meal, and certainly not mundane working class food. I mean, you don't need a recipe for a hamburger.
- ghaff 9y ago
- wrsh07 9y agoWhat if they become automated grocery delivery? It's an interesting leverage point, since there's obviously a [possibly smaller-than-they-want] market. But the expansion into automated grocery will be a matter of luck & timing. Unless you're Amazon [in which case it's persistence]
- sgs1370 9y agoThis. Amazon Fresh already lets local markets sell their raw ingredients, cooked foods, half-cooked, or just prepped stuff. Those markets could (might already) just include some instructions on the package. The familiar search/browse UI and "no subscription" factor will be a huge AF advantage IMO. (I have used AF about 5 times, all good experiences so far, but just for ingredients, not prepared foods)
- kentosi 9y ago> Finally, if there were a real clamor for meal kits, what's to keep Whole Foods or whoever from just assembling their own meal kits? Home delivery seems to be one of the key factors, so as long as Whole Foods/etc can offer home delivery, then yeah there's nothing stopping them.
- jonknee 9y ago> so as long as Whole Foods/etc can offer home delivery, then yeah there's nothing stopping them If only a company with a battle tested home delivery network would acquire them...
- urethrafranklin 9y agoWhole Foods themselves do home delivery. Amazon do not.
- dragonwriter 9y agoAmazon Prime Fresh is a thing; they absolutely do home delivery.
- urethrafranklin 9y agoThe delivery is outsourced and not handled directly by Amazon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- detaro 9y agoWhy is it relevant if the delivery is done by contractors of some kind or by the company directly? Amazon probably even has closer control over their network than WF over Instacart, which isn't exclusive to them.
- aeorgnoieang 9y ago
- YesProcrast 9y agoKroger is trialing meal kits. CEO sounded positive on the quarterly phone call. http://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/hamilton-county/cincinnati/kroger-adds-ready-made-meal-kits-at-4-stores-to-compete-with-online-options-like-blue-apron http://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/hamilton-county/cincinna... Edit: Disclosure -- I own a small amount of Kroger stock.
- eli 9y agoGiant/Peapod has had them for a year.
- madcaptenor 9y agoPublix has had them for a while, too, which means that in the Publix/Kroger borderlands of Atlanta (where I live) there are two supermarket meal kit choices.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Finally, if there were a real clamor for meal kits, what's to keep Whole Foods or whoever from just assembling their own meal kits? Pre-portioned, pre-prepped,low-cooking-effort packaged food products are already a big item in various forms for supermarkets. As are fully cooked meals. No doubt meal packs will be too, of they are popular. OTOH, Grocery stores selling fully-cooked meals haven't killed restaurants (not even takeout-focussed restaurants).
- draw_down 9y agoSwitching is different in this business though. In the group deal business, as a customer you're buying individual deals all the time. As soon as not-Groupon has a better deal than Groupon, you switch. In meal-kit business, you're a subscriber of one service. Switching to a new one means entering all your info again, choosing from the list of options, and waiting for the kits to start shipping to you.
- ghaff 9y agoMaybe. Signing up for a new account is maybe five minutes work. I might equally be inclined to argue that the switching effort is more than justified by the variety gained by trying a different service.
- canada_dry 9y agoIt's true that churn will be slightly lower in comparison to Groupon et al (due to the subscription aspect)... but the barrier-to-entry is very low and it's likely the subscription part will dissolve to being effortless as competition heats up.
- Mz 9y agoI feel like the real problem with meal-in-a-box delivery services is that they are trying to fill the empty shoes of a missing full-time wife and mom because there are more two career couples and both spouses now "need a wife" and it can't be found. The problem is that such a service has no real hope of taking the place of someone with actual cooking skill who knows you well and will tweak the recipe to your preferences, possibly without you even having to explicitly ask or remind her. If you can afford a meal-in-a-box service, why would you not just go to a restaurant where the wait staff will do a decent job as a substitute for your own live-in cook previously known as The Wife? I mean, this seems like the worst of all worlds. Someone else decides what you will be eating and you have to do the cooking. I can't imagine buying this.
- 123e1daAdfafsdf 9y agoThese services allow you to pick the meals you want, and you can tweak the recipes as you cook them. I have tried a few to get my sweet sweet VC subsidized healthy meals, but in the end, I agree with you: I'd rather go to a restaurant.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> If you can afford a meal-in-a-box service, why would you not just go to a restaurant where the wait staff will do a decent job as a substitute for your own live-in cook previously known as The Wife? I always say that these are for people with more money than time. The reason they don't go to a restaurant is because you like cooking - or at least, you like the idea of being someone who cooks. But the ad copy is right - shopping sucks, finding recipes sucks, throwing away food because you bought too much kale sucks. (Not to mention, cooking a meal and eating it takes 45 minutes - depending on the restaurant, you might be in there for an hour, plus travel time. And remember, time is what they're short on.) Even if you find four interesting recipes and buy all the ingredients, and cook them - this takes 3x the time than just using Blue Apron, at minimum - on Friday you've got a bunch of assorted ingredients and no idea what to do with them. (Because you're not a wifemom, and you don't know how to combine those things into a meal.) But the person they're targeting doesn't want to learn to do that. They just want to buy a pre-configured lego set, and build a spaceship they can eat. You are not their target audience. Neither am I. But it definitely, definitely exists.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoIsn't this sort of issue faced by 99% of any new business that sells a service or a product? Unless your idea is something patentable, or you have a trade secret that's locked up tight, or you control your product vertically (e.g., you own the only Unobtainium mine on the planet) - can't your business be copied fairly trivially? (Quick edit: who else remembers everyone and their nephew offering website hosting/colocation at ludicrously low prices in the early-to-mid 2000's?)
- moomin 9y agoNot really, no. When Dropbox applied to YC, they had to fill in a section that specifically dealt with how hard it would be to enter their space. It was much harder than it looks, and they convinced YC of that. Groupon always suffered from being easy to copy and having no appreciable network effects.
- eli 9y agoWere any of the Groupon copycats successful? Maybe it just wasn't that good an idea.
- pchristensen 9y agoNo. Living Social was the most successful runner up to Groupon. The problem was that "email deal-based marketing for small businesses" was going to be worth something, but there would only be one valuable winner and no one knew how much that would be worth. So Groupon, Living Social, FB, Google, Yelp, and hundreds of clones all threw in tons of money, slogged it out, and now they're all gone and GRPN is worth $2B, 1/8th of its IPO price. Exactly the same thing is happening with ride-hailing now. It's harder to copy, but there's too much investment subsidizing it so no one knows what the market will be worth once riders have to pay sustainable rates. But they know being 2nd place will suck. Citation: I worked at Groupon before and after the IPO.
- puranjay 9y agoWerent a lot of these acquired by Groupon/LivingSocial? In theory, that would make them "successful" since they had good exits.
- mmagin 9y agoAnd I thought this was going to be about the companies that produce military rations.
- redmalang 9y agoWhilst I'm not the target market (I enjoy cooking from scratch way too much), I think there are a few things wrong with the analysis: - Surely this isn't the first business to make a loss on acquisition in expectation of breakeven. That in of itself doesn't make this untenable. I also feel that the Groupon analogy is a bit underbaked: Groupon (and the ilk) were also I suspect totally unsustainable for the end businesses. - There is substantial scope for curation. This in & of itself may not not be enough of course, but this doesn't seem like total commodity land either. Also it isn't just about getting the ingredients bundled together. It is harder than you'd think making sure standard measures of stuff in the supermarket doesn't go to waste from spoilage when trying to cook whilst keeping repetition low. Optimising for this is probably an interesting and not super simple problem. I've only been exposed to the UK variants. The above may not hold true for other places though.
- mr_tristan 9y agoThe long term trend for "meal kits" is very likely just going to have massive local and regional competition. I'm already seeing this in Portland with several meal delivery services that cater to different lifestyles: gluten free, whole 30, extra protein, etc. These are successful "complete meal delivery" businesses. I see no reason why there can't be "meal kit" variations in the future. The cost of starting up a local meal kit business is only going to go down. In fact, I see a reason local variations will become stronger. A lot of these customers have money and are interested in "farm to table" and "buy local" ideas. So, I'd expect that they could find meal kits that fit whatever diet they want, prepared by a local chef, using ingredients from local farms. This is a great potential avenue for local chefs to promote their brand, in addition to appearances on shows like Top Chef, etc. So... why would a large company with a national brand matter at all? I could easily see business like Blue Apron just fold overnight, but the meal kit concept shift entirely to, well, small business. Sure seems like the big investment dollars are basically paving the way for local competition, by planting the idea of "meal kits" as a viable option in people's minds.
- kbenson 9y agoNot to mention, if you're really local, you can beat out the competition in freshness and probably delivery costs as well (beyond a certain critical threshold of local customers at least). It's the resurgence of the milkman.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoThat's the best idea I've seen in this thread so far. Taken one step further with the farm-to-table concept, I can see suburban delivery of local meal kits directly from nearby farms on a subscription basis. It becomes a value-add on the CSA concept. In my area we have a pretty big concentration of high-income earners in relatively close proximity to small farms. It could probably be made to work in a situation like that.
- qqg3 9y agoDelivery from local farms like https://www.farmdrop.com/ https://www.farmdrop.com/
- stevewillows 9y agoA little off topic, but with the acquisition of Whole Foods, Amazon should pick up one of these services to get people into cooking at home. With the complaints about the estimated v real time for prep and cleaning, they should also include a bunch of videos like ChefSteps that show how to effectively cook and clean at the same time. They should also sell knives and other kitchen tools. Lastly, these meal providers should have an app with a running timer that gives directions while you cook. For instance, 'while onions are sauteing, wipe cutting board and crush garlic' --- just like a GPS but for cooking. The major hurdle for these services is that there is still a certain level of skill assumed -- but if they aren't teaching these skills, the consumer doesn't really come off any better.
- mothers 9y agogenerally people who do meal-kits just aren't good at shopping. it isn't cheaper, healthier or faster to cook than regular food. the only thing it might be better at is faster at preparation, an advantage that is negated if you buy a sufficiently large amount of food each time you purchase and pre-prepare (cutting chicken into slices and freezing them, etc.). tldr: only lazy people with more time than money would be interested in this. if anyone disagrees go ahead and post your cooking schedule and workflow. i'll point out the glaring inefficiencies (e.g. buying small amounts of food frequently for preparing and then complaining it takes too long to eat; cooking small amounts of food; not preslicing meat upon purchase, etc) the one thing i'll give meal kits is that you can get a large variety of food.
- aeorgnoieang 9y ago> only lazy people with more time than money would be interested in this. Opportunity costs are real, people's preferences are heterogeneous, and also I'm pretty sure you're 'lazy' too – using a computer to perform all of those arithmetic calculations it's doing!
- mothers 9y agoi've never claimed i'm not lazy. i'm super lazy. if i had unlimited money i wouldn't cook or order from a restaurant. i'd have people literally feed me with a spoon. this fact, however, is irrelevant from my point.
- ericlewis 9y agovariety is incredibly important to us, but I'm curious, do you have resources I could read about improving our efficiency when we do buy? I purchase many raw ingredients but struggle to use them effectively for a 2 person household.
- mothers 9y agohard to give you one source, but /r/cooking, /r/mealprep led to some interesting discoveries.
- thedangler 9y agoI feel like they should have Meal-Kits at grocery stores. They could make them with all the extra food they have. That way you can go pick up 3 of them and then grab more groceries if need be. It would be way better than all the frozen meals they have.
- knieveltech 9y agoIsn't the grocery store already basically one large meal kit?
- fanpuns 9y agoLove this comment so much I just had to comment and tell you :))
- ghaff 9y agoIt's not like grocery stores keep a bunch of extra food on hand that they don't expect to sell. But, to your main point, a number of chains and other stores have started doing this. I'm a little surprised it's not more common though, of course, there's a lot of pre-chopped vegetables etc. so once you're in the store, gathering up the ingredients for a quick meal is pretty straightforward.
- dbot 9y agoCooking involves 3 steps: (1) recipe selection, (2) ingredient acquisition, and (3) cooking. Blue Apron takes care of the first two, which I don't enjoy, and let's me do (3), which I very much enjoy. A grocery store doesn't solve (1) and only partially solves (2) (often has item availability, too much quantity issues, and then I have to measure it, too).
- ghaff 9y agoI'd argue prep and cleanup are in there too which I enjoy less. Some kits help with the first and none help with the second :-) But that's a good way of looking at it. Personally I like selecting (and modifying) recipes. I agree that getting the ingredients is often a pain--especially to the degree they invalidate the first step. My general philosophy is that if any of these services get people cooking rather than eating fast food that's a good thing.
- ambrice 9y agoWe tried Blue Apron but stopped for two reasons: - We have toddlers, and the menu was too "fancy". It's difficult to get a 4 year old to eat squid ink pasta. - I felt bad about all that wasted packing material and giant ice packs. We switched to Dream Dinners, which is a local place. My wife goes once a month, picks out a bunch of dinners for the month, and we throw them in the freezer. Each of the dinners fits in a gallon ziploc bag. They were generally easier and faster to cook (pre-chopped vegetables, pre-marinated meat, etc) and there is more choice to it and no shipping containers. Highly recommend.
- dredmorbius 9y agoOT: When did Medium start showing bottom-feeding Taboola ad content? That's a massive disappointment. Update: Oh, that waas content. My error.
- gdulli 9y agoThat was part of the content of the article, not an ad slot.
- dredmorbius 9y agoDoh! My error. Thanks. I ... cannot say how absolutely abhorrent I find that stuff. Even when pointed out in articles. I'm sensitised to it in part because I've taken extreme pains to block as much of that as possible. A harder task than it should be.
- deathanatos 9y agoWhen I first saw it, with the lead of, > the ones responsible for, say, this: I thought that was the end of the article, and a very cleverly placed transition into the ad content. I almost wish the sites that run these ads would do this now; it would be more entertaining.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- agentgt 9y agoBeen to a Wholefoods lately?... seen the prepared foods section or any grocery store prepared foods lately.... seen how many people buy prepared foods? Ever see a family eat the same thing. I mean a family of say five and not DINKs. Amazon acquiring WFM will just make it worse if instacart wasn't already.
- mattnewport 9y ago> Ever see a family eat the same thing. I mean a family of say five What do you mean by this? When I was growing up the whole family (of 4, plus dog eating leftovers) ate the same meal. Is that not the norm? Is it an American thing?
- agentgt 9y ago>> Ever see a family eat the same thing. I mean a family of say five >What do you mean by this? When I was growing up the whole family (of 4, plus dog eating leftovers) ate the same meal. Is that not the norm? Is it an American thing? Yes most likely (American Thing). I'll give you a rough anecdotal example I have seen: A 13 year old that is a vegan, A father who is a pseudo body builder (eats lots of meat), a picky 8 year old that will not eat certain colors and of course a gluten, organic mommy. And of course there is the toddler/infant age where god forbid you don't follow the pediatricians recommendations (despite that humans have survived this far and produce 8 billion people). Oh and I haven't even got into timing considerations (ie some individuals eat earlier and others later). Yep its probably an American thing :)
- fludlight 9y ago> Really, if you wanted proof that there was a bubble, you’d look for a refrigerated warehouse REIT. I know someone working on a roll up of refrigerated warehouses. A REIT might be part of their exit plan but I don't think these meal-in-a-box companies even register on their radar.
- nailer 9y agoFor anyone else: http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/reit.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/reit.asp
- dsr_ 9y agoThere are businesses with network effects: the more people using them, the better off everyone using it is. There are businesses with scale advantages: doing it bigger makes it much cheaper. There are businesses with required huge capital investments: if you don't have the $25 billion silicon foundry, you don't make CPUs. There are businesses where a national brand is a big advantage, and businesses where local is a selling point. The meal-kit industry looks like it's halfway between grocery stores and delivery restaurants, and that means economies of scale aren't hugely important, but a reputation for quality is. Local/national can go either way, but most people are willing to experiment every so often and have strong preferences about what they like -- which means that having a lot of players in the market is to their advantage, and long-term contracts are not.
- sarreph 9y agoIs there anything we can learn from 'daily-deal' pivots that were successful, and apply them to meal-box ideas in order to beat the curve?
- eresing 9y agoHere's what my family does: We hired an older woman (from thumbtack.com) to come to our house once a week for 4 hours and cook whatever is in the fridge. I make sure to have plenty of food in the fridge, spices, canned goods, etc. Then she cooks enough food for my 4 person family for about 5 - 6 days (excluding breakfast). She knows our preferences and takes requests. We pay her $25/hr ($100 week). I feel like everyone interested in these meal services should really just have a personal chef. Way better than these pre-made meal services because you have complete control over ingredients and meal types.
- maxander 9y agoI guess I respect having the intestinal fortitude to do the responsible thing, but at least in the U.S., seeing any service position with obvious privilege connotations makes people uncomfortable. The meal-in-a-box industry is another clever way to work around this taboo, by hiding the lower-class service workers behind a clean user interface. Similarly, what's the value-add of Github? Primarily, it's not having to talk on the phone to some guy with a thick foreign accent with kitchen noise in the background. Dealing with a website, even if it's slow sometimes, is a much less socially complicated experience.
- neuronexmachina 9y agoI... assume you meant Grubhub instead of Github? ;)
- munin 9y ago> Similarly, what's the value-add of Grubhub? The value of grubhub is that I can send written instructions to the restaurant instead of spoken ones, which will be understood more clearly, so my order is done the way I prefer it. It also helps with discoverability, instead of having to keep an assortment of paper menus in my kitchen up to date, I can just go to the website. It's not about avoiding poor people.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThere's a simpler reason it won't work over the long term: as people get better at cooking, they don't need things like meal kits any more and just make smarter grocery shopping choices.
- mstaoru 9y ago...in the US. We do a similar, but very different, thing here in China, Shanghai. Not only building the meal plans but also cooking and delivering it every day. The city is flat and dense, 10000+ people per sqmi dense. Every day local food delivery companies jump on their electric scooters and deliver over 2,300,000 meals (2016 data, now probably more). In one city. I can choose from 2,980 restaurants near me. If I add ¥5 (~$0.8) extra delivery fee, a bit farther, making it 8,600 restaurants. Decision fatigue multiplied by "I'm hungry just get me that deep fried chicken NOW" thing. The food is very meh. Mid- to high-end restaurants don't do it. Good restaurants have enough business to skip deliveries at all. Meal kits tried and failed here, because people are just too busy and stressed to cook. Average rent is 140% of average salary. Overtime is a norm. So we figured, why don't we take customer data + preferences, make a feedback loop and build FULL meal plans for them that they will 1) be happy to eat, 2) reach their fitness goals with, 3) be able to afford? By "full" I mean including healthy drinks and snacks. Lots of meal kit companies, food deliveries, and meal plan builders forget this. We're in stealth mode so far, but I believe this will work in China.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vitaminbandit 9y agoUh, what exactly is your competitive edge? You've framed the problem but haven't provided any details on how using customer data and preferences solves it. Isn't the most accurate customer preference data the actual real-time decision that the customer makes at the time of order?
- mstaoru 9y agoHey! Didn't want to provide details that aren't relevant to the parent topic. We built a system to calculate science-backed meal plans based on customer data. Calories, macronutrients, micronutrients, vitamins, probiotics, fiber. Water. We have over 5000 cookbooks from all over the World from which we curate our recipes, input them and get full nutritional breakdowns. It is probably THE most important part of any diet — the ability to actually stick to it and enjoy it. What we want to do is to completely take away the decision fatigue, and provide diverse food that is tailored to your body. Nutrition is complicated, and things that work for some people may not work for the other. The feedback loop is important. If a customer wants to lose fat or gain muscle, we track the progress and adjust their diets accordingly. PS: "Real-time decision that the customer makes at the time of order" is fueled by ghrelin and stress, decision fatigue and availability, and is most often poor.
- motles 9y agoThe one difference between Groupon and meal kit services to me is that the meal kit services actually provide value over and over for something I actually need to do every day, 3 times a day: Eat. If I don't use the meal kits, that's fine, but I'm just going elsewhere - restaurants, delivery, take-out, grocery store. I don't need discount yoga classes or buy one get one froyo coupons every day. You don't need discounts to survive. You can just buy less. Discounts are not a commodity that I wish to purchase often. I have used groupon once, and have been innundated ever since with constant spam about new deals for things which sound like good deals but probably I wouldn't even give them a second look at full price. So I don't bother. I don't need half that stuff anyway. I hope meal kit services continue to thrive, despite negativity from investors. They are a service that I truly value and will probably keep my subscription to BA going until BA service quality drops or the food stops being as good. So far, they haven't done either. But for god sakes BA, EASY ON THE GARLIC. You don't need to send me a whole bulb every time when the recipe just needs 2 cloves.
- upvotinglurker 9y agoMaybe sending the whole bulb is cheaper than the labor and packaging to send separate cloves?
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThere is clearly some value to the meal kits, but when all of the alternatives (restaurants, grocery stores, etc) are very low margin businesses why would you expect meal kits to have the kind of margins that would justify the high customer acquisition costs that the current incarnations of meal kit companies have?
- shalmanese 9y agoLocal services are the penny auctions of the VC industry. Since your margins are so dependent on achieving scale, there's a strong push to win customers at any possible cost. Each VC is forced to dump in increasing amounts of money due to sunk cost fallacy for a fixed prize at the end of the rainbow. At the end of the day, the prize won isn't worth the collective investment and the entire industry represents a net subsidy to the consumer in the form of discounted services and referral bonuses. It's one of the few things that make living in San Francisco bearable as it tends to be ground zero for these kind of gigantic customer acquisition battles.
- Paul_S 9y agoI tried hello fresh back when they were promoting it aggressively. The only good thing about it were the neat recipe booklets. I actually kept them and made the meals again later. Everything else was bad. The produce quality was worse than from my supermarket, missing ingredients, stupidly expensive (outside of promotion). I'm amazed they still exist, I assume it's running on investors' money.
- kschmit90 9y agoNo where else can I find a group of people cost benefit analyzing to death one of the purest, simplest, and most fulfilling aspects of life. The general consensus here seems to be that, "My time is not well spent preparing and consuming, by my own hand, the life giving meals I will eat." But, of course, I've misspoken. And, now prepare for the assault of many pedantic, infuriated, hacker news commentators.