11 ms·
Windows 10 Without the Cruft: Windows 10 LTSB (Long Term Servicing Branch)
- MadSax 9y agoThe only version of Windows 10 which prosumers want, they can't have.
- douche 9y agoI've rarely been so happy that my employer has an MSDN subscription.
- cwyers 9y agoThere are plenty of prosumers who don't want to serve as a functional IT department in addition to everything else they have to do, who want features like Bash on Windows, and who are generally fine with Pro.
- na85 9y ago>Windows 10 LTSB omits a lot of the new stuff in Windows 10. It doesn’t come with the Windows Store, Cortana, or Microsoft Edge browser. It also omits other Microsoft apps like Calendar, Camera, Clock, Mail, Money, Music, News, OneNote, Sports, and Weather. >In fact, the default Start menu on Windows 10 LTSB doesn’t even include a single tile. You won’t find any of those new Windows 10 apps installed, aside from the Settings app. That sounds fantastic. I use absolutely none of those "features" and would love to be able to remove them from my copy of windows 10.
- Dylan16807 9y agoIs it really better to have IE11 and only IE11? And the ability to use the store is not a bad thing.
- Scarbutt 9y agoYou install firefox or chrome ;)
- ovao 9y agoFor which you'll ordinarily use the pre-installed browser to grab the installer. It's not clear to me why using IE11 to do that versus using Edge is an actual win.
- CamperBob2 9y agoHow about endless nags from the OS about how you're wasting battery power running that boring old Firefox, and how you really should upgrade to the latest Edge experience for whiter teeth, better gas mileage, and more bedroom endurance? Microsoft brought every last bit of this criticism on themselves.
- drdaeman 9y agoEndless? I think I saw it only once. Said "nope" and it was gone. The whole marketing mess still sucks (they sure try their chances every once in a while), but it's not that bad - and at least it's different every time (not sure if this is good or bad, though). I think the only repeated warnings I even saw with W10 were from Windows Defender discontent with me telling that I don't want automated uploads of whatever it thinks it should.
- Pica_soO 9y agoI love also how the settings amnesia sets in with every update- if this "forgetfulness" sets in on something that Microsoft could benefit from. Throwing away User Works- wasn't that as the Ultimate Insult to the User in some legendary book? Same goes for the registry rip, you have to redo to undo- "repairs" on the Cortana...
- na85 9y agoThe actual win is avoiding bloatware like Cortana
- 9y ago
- na85 9y agoI saw nothing in the article that implied LTSB lacked the ability to run binary installers. The same capability to install your company's application to the machine can surely be used to install Firefox.
- iaml 9y agoI have a local account and while store is there, I can't use it without signing in with ms account. I'm not going to, so it's basically just wasting space. I would rather it wasn't there completely.
- techload 9y agoYou could run this script: Make Windows 10 Great Again. https://gist.github.com/IntergalacticApps/675339c2b805b4c9c6e9a442e0121b1d https://gist.github.com/IntergalacticApps/675339c2b805b4c9c6...
- drdaeman 9y agoDoes that break Skype and parts of Azure portal and online Office suite? Most of such scripts break things. And I see the usual suspects, like DNS blocking client-s.gateway.messenger.live.com etc, so I think this one isn't an exception.
- techload 9y agoYou can edit the script to remove what you don't want disabled/blocked.
- Ezhik 9y agoWhat a fun way to cripple your OS and disable important stuff like Windows Defender.
- ferongr 9y agoI personally have disabled Windows Defender consciously since it tends to perceptibly affect system responsiveness.
- Dylan16807 9y agoThat's strange. The store seems to work fine on my local-only account.
- drdaeman 9y agoIn my opinion, good thing about Store apps is that they're are isolated. I'm not sure how robust this isolation is, but it seems that apps can't just access random files, etc, without a specifically granted permission. The permission model seems to be immature (no prompts at all, not even at install time - not sure how upgrades work; and everything requested is granted by default but can be revoked later), but the very idea of app sandboxes sounds right. A random document-editing app shouldn't be able to do mess with any parts of user profile, except for the files it was explicitly provided access to. (I wonder if there's a way to somehow hack things and re-use this sandboxing with non-Store apps...)
- digi_owl 9y agoThe FS access is not so much a permission, as the user picking a folder or drive that the app is allowed to access. Sadly doing the picking is done via the age old Win32 file picker UI, making it a royal pain to do on touch screens.
- contextfree 9y agoIt is both. There are install-time capabilities for certain known folders (e.g., music and videos libraries), and then access to arbitrary folders has to be granted by the user via the file picker. The shell provides the file picker UI so it's dependent on what edition of Windows you're using.
- cm2187 9y agoIt's not Edge or IE11. It's Edge or Chrome or Firefox. I don't mind Edge, not because I like just, just because once I switch the default browser to chrome it doesn't bug me. Just some dead bytes on a large SSD. I mind a lot more the other features that bug me all the time.
- tjalfi 9y agoBetter is really the wrong word. It's certainly cheaper to only support IE11 than IE11 and Edge. IE11 is my employer's officially supported browser. We have some dusty decks ahem legacy websites that require it. The legal industry is generally behind the times - there are still many court and government websites that require Java. We have two types of end users. People who care use Chrome and people who don't use IE. Here is some of the additional work that Edge required. Testing all of the internal web applications with Edge. Testing hundreds of business critical websites with Edge. Testing our intranet with Edge. We use Enterprise Mode to redirect sites that are not compatible with Edge. The results of all of this work is a browsing experience that is more confusing than IE on our Windows 7 image. It is easy for users to confuse Edge for IE and I expect that to cause support tickets for the foreseeable future.
- intopieces 9y agoA simple checkbox list at install would be nice. Hide it under "Install Windows 10 (Advanced)" Even.
- intopieces 9y agoI would be okay with a pay-as-you-go Windows 10 Enteprise subscription for this LTSB. My use of Windows is very sporadic. If I could log in and pay $7 for the next 30 days official access then let it expire till I need it again, I would be giving MSFT more money than I do now but would consider a fair exchange for ongoing security updates.
- jt2190 9y agoHave you tried their free virtual machines for browser testing? https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/tools/vms/ https://developer.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-edge/tools/v...
- mschuster91 9y ago> And Windows 10 Enterprise is only available to an organization with a volume licensing agreement, or through a new $7 per month subscription program Given that it's basically free to register as a commercial entity (in Germany it costs 40-50€, and iirc a British LLC can be formed for less), can one do so, and then apply for said subscription program? edit: are offerings like https://www.lizengo.de/microsoft/windows-10-enterprise https://www.lizengo.de/microsoft/windows-10-enterprise actually legit, and can these be used to activate a LTSB installation?
- dom0 9y ago> (in Germany it costs 40-50€ Less, in most cities. Sometimes, free.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoNot sure if it's worth the hassle of setting up a company IRL just to use a piece of software.
- gambiting 9y agoin the UK it takes 10 minutes online to open a company and if you don't do anything with it the only thing you need to do is add it on your annual tax return, with all fields as zero since you are not actually trading. It's almost zero effort.
- maccard 9y ago> add it on your annual tax return That's not doing nothing. That requires filling in a Self Assessment which most people aren't doing
- drdaeman 9y agoI think it's all messed up, just as usual. I have a business entity registered, and $7/mo sounded like a good price, so I went to look up for a form where I can sign up, set up a subscription, pay the invoice and get a product key. The CSP program seems to be this: https://partner.microsoft.com/en-us/cloud-solution-provider https://partner.microsoft.com/en-us/cloud-solution-provider but it seems that they don't directly sell it but do so through some resellers (and the whole page is dedicated to those). I found this link: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windowsforbusiness/buy https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windowsforbusiness/buy that mentions Windows 10 Enterprise E3 and E5 ("coming Oct 2016" says something about how the page's up to date) but after clicking "find a license solution provider" I'm basically lost. Filters helped a little, but everyone there still wants to sell me all sorts of most enterprise cloud solutions (Azure stuff, SharePoint, telephony, whatever), but not those $7/mo licenses. (Or maybe I've just looked at all the wrong partners, I don't know). And of course they're still all-enterprise "call our sales for any details". No surprise probably no one uses that for personal desktop.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoI noticed that when I had Windows 8.1 installed on my PC earlier this year, the version string mentioned LTSB. Does 8.1 use the kernel of 10's LTSB?
- my123 9y agowinblue_ltsb means that it's the long term support branch, with no new features and securuty updates only.
- alkonaut 9y agoI'm on ltsb for my business laptop and it stinks. Id rather have random issues with a few upgrades than be stuck without new features and get almost no bug fixes. New features I get for my home machine are missing on my job laptop. New dpi handling improvements coming Nope, not in ltsb. It appears to get security fixes only - few bug fixes. For example, the LTSB start menu is completely broken - there is no search on it and it takes 3-4 seconds to show. Presumably related to the lack of Cortana, but who knows. In any case, it's been a widely reported bug in ltsb for a long time and it's a pretty fundamental feature in windows. I could see the point in being on the LTSB branch of windows 7 because that OS is done. But windows 10 isn't nearly finished yet and very rough around the edges. Being on LTSB of such an old Win10 release is like being on the release day version of a AAA game while everyone else runs the fixed version that came out 3 months later.
- problems 9y ago> It appears to get security fixes only - few bug fixes. For example, the LTSB start menu is completely broken - there is no search on it and it takes 3-4 seconds to show Install Classic Shell. Practically mandatory to run Windows since 8.
- billforsternz 9y agoSeconding this. I was reluctant since I prefer vanilla installations if at all possible. But my concerns vanished immediately after install - it just works and the start button actually becomes useful again. I used ninite.com. Of course.
- xpclient 9y agoYes, Classic Shell highly recommended.
- cm2187 9y agoThe way you describe your start menu pretty much accurately describes my full patched windows 10 pro. Not sure LTSB is the problem.
- Animats 9y agoNow that's useful. I have a Windows 7 machine for the few things that don't run on Linux. Windows 10 LTSB would be great for that. I wonder if I can get Windows 10 LTSB preloaded by Central Computer, the retailer. They installed Windows 7 with no bloatware for me. (I asked for that, and the invoice actually reads "no bloatware")
- unicornporn 9y agoI was about to switch to this about a month ago but realized WSL does not work with LTSB. So no BASH for Windows. It will probably be more than a year too...
- FireBeyond 9y agoI'd be surprised if WSL ever made it to LTSB. Especially if you read the article and MS's definitive of what the intended use case is.
- pas 9y agoThe Bash that comes with Git (which uses msys AFAIK) works pretty well.
- symlinkk 9y agoIt uses MSYS2 actually, which is a completely different project.
- mappu 9y agoTo expand on that: MSYS was a fork of Cygwin 1.3, and MSYS2 is a fork of Cygwin 1.7. (Babun is a distro of Cygwin, and Git-bash is a distro of MSYS2.)
- dingo_bat 9y agoCan it run executables compiled for Ubuntu?
- ams6110 9y agoIs Cygwin still maintained? It was the first thing I installed on Windows going back over a decade.
- milcron 9y agoYes, but I prefer MSYS2 these days. It's a lot like Cygwin, but uses pacman as a package manager instead of Cygwin's setup.exe.
- fsiefken 9y agoI also want the Classic Theme back, Classic like in NT4 classic, with the old school minimize, maximize and close buttons.
- Ezhik 9y agoClassic theme, classic explorer, classic task manager, classic everything. Just admit it, you want to use NT4.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago...yes, that sounds nice. With security patches and drivers for modern hardware.
- chungy 9y agoThere are hacks available to disable DWM and regain the classic theme. I do not know of a reputable source, however, so I cannot recommend one.
- mqatrombone 9y agoLTSB = Embedded
- omgtehlion 9y agoMore like Server 2016. In embedded version you have more fine-grained pick of components to install, and you do this before even storing your image to installation media.
- itsoggy 9y agoI have deployed LTSB in a few schools I look after, it's far easier because of the minimal feature set especially in smaller environments where full enterprise management tools like System Centre and WSUS are not installed. Go old school and customise the default profile in the build for best results! The best part is that if you have education volume License You get both EDU and Ent LTSB editions!
- Filter 9y agoTwo changes made a big difference for me in using Windows 10: 1. Turning off Cortana using these instructions: https://www.howtogeek.com/265027/how-to-disable-cortana-in-windows-10/ https://www.howtogeek.com/265027/how-to-disable-cortana-in-w... 2. Turning off most of the visual effects under "Adjust the appearance and performance of Windows." (I left "Smooth edges of screen fonts" and "Enable Peek" checked) The combination of these two change feels like a whole new computer.
- krapp 9y agoI don't want to turn off Cortana, I want Cortana not to exist. How can I accomplish that in Windows 10?
- pjmlp 9y agoThe same way you disable Google Now and Siri.
- Tharre 9y agoRemove "C:\Windows\SystemApps\* cortana* " with something like[0] to get around "File is in use". A fair warning though, [insert standard MIT style disclaimer]. [0] https://gist.github.com/Tharre/d900a5f6ce16701b441c4405abc3634a#file-post-install_win10-ps1-L27 https://gist.github.com/Tharre/d900a5f6ce16701b441c4405abc36...
- nisa 9y agoYes. Also take the time and clean up the default tiles on the start menu. If you drank the anti-av kool-aid also exclude C:/ (or where you have installed Windows 10) from Defender - a nice speed bumb and USB drivers are checked anyway. There is also uBlock Origin for Edge that works pretty well. I find the battery savings when using Edge worthwile.
- garraeth 9y agoI found https://www.oo-software.com/shutup10 https://www.oo-software.com/shutup10 to be really effective.
- 9y ago
- Crontab 9y agoMicrosoft should make this available for everyone. It sounds perfect.
- dsr_ 9y agoIt's the precise opposite of the Extend and Embrace strategy which has worked for them forever. I'm surprised they have it as a named product instead of a set of bizarre Registry tweaks.
- Pica_soO 9y agoThere is a whole Eco-system of tech-bloggers and tool-smiths, whos whole working-life consists of ripping out the "improvements" Microsoft has shoveled towards the users - riding binary rodeo with every update. My assumption is that this Eco-system will rather soon bring the clumsy Microsoft attempt to become google one stack-layer closer to the user to a horrific end.
- cududa 9y agoThis has been going on since I got into the "Windows scene" 15 years ago with Windows XP, slipstreaming and custom install INI's. It's no longer the area I work in, but something tells me your prediction is probably as wrong as it was when people were saying this exact same thing 15 years ago.
- thomasfedb 9y agoI'm a full time Fedora user. I run LTSB in the VM that I run Office 365 in and it's perfect. No fuss, no bells, gets out of my way and just works.
- andreasen 9y agoThis seems to install a pretty 'good' win10 version: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10startfresh https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10s... I had a Lenovo S500 dektop that I just reinstalled. Non-SSd. I was getting a '100% disk usage' issue right of the bat. I installed 'windows10startfresh' and now it's pretty sweet - pc is not slow, and such. The 'windows10startfresh' installs windows without all the lenovo crud apparently.
- andreasen 9y agoI should have emphasized the machine is like a dream right now - without the Lenovo cruft that is usually installed. Runs like a charm - where as the base Lenovo install was slow - i mean really slow. and this is an i7 16gb machine.
- sjellis 9y agoI'm both amused and angry that Windows 10 adopted the same model as the big commercial Linux distributions: a fast-cycle OS that upgrades every 6 months (but might have bugs), and a slow-moving version that they support for a long time but won't suddenly change behavior or stop working with your hardware. It is a proven model in the Linux world. The unpleasant thing is that Microsoft shunted millions of users on to the equivalent of Fedora or non-LTS Ubuntu without bothering to explain this.
- kyberias 9y agoI'm sorry, what didn't they bother to explain? Why are you angry that they adopted a release model that works well?
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoThey pushed everyone from major versions to rolling release.
- sebow 9y agoWorks like a charm on my 1800x system, people who say this OS is mostly for embedded systems probably never even used extensively the other versions of 10 or they're just addicted to some (shit) features of 10 like Cortana, Windows Store and being fine with Microsoft mining their data through their 50 methods of telemetry.(Even though even LTSB versions have telemetry and can only be disabled with some 'extreme' tweaking which would result in no more updates for the OS) It's the exact equivalent of an Ubuntu LTS version for example(though Ubuntu comes with a lot of pre-installed software): it's bare naked and stable, without all the unnecessary features(Specially the N version) and with less telemetry. You can still get all your features out of your hardware, you just got to manually install the drivers, which for the most part is better than letting Windows install them automatically anyways.