4 ms·
> Should all token development stop now that we have ETH? Should ETH never have been created because we had BTC? Should BTC never have been created when the USD
by jstanley 9y ago
> Should all token development stop now that we have ETH? Should ETH never have been created because we had BTC? Should BTC never have been created when the USD was already a liquid medium of exchange?
Bitcoin was created because it isn't possible to do Bitcoin with USD.
Ethereum was created because it isn't possible to do Ethereum with BTC.
Bancor was created because you want to make fat stacks of cash. It would work just as well (or better) if it was using ETH directly instead of having its own token.
Disclaimer: I am almost completely uninformed about Bancor.
- arethuza 9y agoI must admit that my familiarity with the term "Bancor" was only from Yanis Varoufakis explaining about Keynes, Bretton Woods, the Nixon Shock as background explaining the current plight of the Euro and the Eurozone: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancor
- atmosx 9y agoMe too. I got to know the Bancor via proxy (Varoufakis). Te idea is more than intriguing, what I would like to know is if JMK expected the US to go with it or knew it was a dead-end but had to pursue it anyway. I believe that it was one of the most obscure and important mewtings of post WWII.
- hedonistbot 9y agoIf you are referring to Bretton-Woods Conference, it is not obscure at all. It is probably the most important monetary event in modern history and probably everyone with economics background knows about it. Also it was during WWII. But you are right that parts of it (like the international clearing union and its implications) are just mentioned in passing in economic courses and rarely acknowledged nowadays.
- arethuza 9y agoDo economists look at things like Bretton-Woods from a purely "theoretical" perspective (for lack of a better term) or do they also take into account the political and global power level tensions driving that kind of decision making?
- notahacker 9y agoAs a general rule, economists tend to look at theoretical models of how systems are supposed to work and whether those assumptions fit the data and economic historians tend to look at why policies were introduced or recommended and what their proponents and detractors thought about then. They do tend to share departments, students and reading lists though.
- arethuza 9y agoThat would appear to be like someone coming up with a theory of the movement of sailing boats without accounting for the weather! :-)
- hedonistbot 9y agoThat's economics for you. That's why I switched fields some time ago. It is a "science" that consistently gives flawed predictions and it's is often used to provide cover for political ideologies.
- notahacker 9y agoOr evaluating code without intimate familiarity with the internal politics of the dev team that wrote it :-)
- spangry 9y agoIt's only my faint impression, but I think there's some renewed interest in some sort of international financial / monetary framework similar to Bretton-Woods. The governor of the Chinese central bank publicly expressed interest (and explicitly invoked Bretton-Woods) a few months ago. And other 'mainstream' central banking authorities seem to be acknowledging that there are big deficiencies with the current model (e.g http://www.bis.org/speeches/sp160210_slides.pdf http://www.bis.org/speeches/sp160210_slides.pdf) I think the problem is that it's such a huge issue. It makes sense the original agreement was hammered out towards the end of WWII: people were 'thinking big' at the time. I worry that we are only capable of making such big and forward-thinking moves in the wake of some catastrophe or war... EDIT: The 'renewed interest' is actually mentioned in the Wikipedia article on Keynes' Bancor proposal, and it looks like the governor of the Chinese central bank has been talking about this for some time now: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancor#Proposed_revival https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancor#Proposed_revival
- johnnydoebk 9y ago> Ethereum was created because it isn't possible to do Ethereum with BTC. I don't think that is true. You can absolutely reuse BTC for your so called "smart contracts".
- davidgerard 9y agoIn theory, but in practice almost nobody did. I've been looking into this question. Szabo first proposed "smart contracts" in 1994, but Ethereum is basically the first practical smart contracts platform ever - the first one that people actually use a whole lot. (You can squint at things and say "well that's a bit like a smart contract", but that's retrospectively applying a label - like calling Git a "blockchain". I'm speaking of things that were expressly labeled "smart contracts".)
- DonbunEf7 9y agoToo bad it's not the first secure smart-contract platform; that honor probably goes to the folks who developed Joule, E, etc. in the mid-90s. Szabo and his contemporaries were steeped in capability theory, but Ethereum glossed over all of that in favor of hype and cash.
- davidgerard 9y agoWorse is better, yet again.
- rhart92 9y agoThat's not entirely true. Bitcoin's scripting language is not Turing complete, among other limitations that Ethereum addresses. https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/White-Paper#scripting https://github.com/ethereum/wiki/wiki/White-Paper#scripting
- BaronSamedi 9y agoIt is true that Ethereum has a more powerful scripting language. The real question, however, is if that feature has practical value. I think the jury is still out on that question but I personally lean towards no. If and when there are profitable applications of this technology, ones that wouldn't have been possible without ethereum scripts then I will be glad to change my mind.