13 ms·
Pop-up bike lanes show that demand exists
- cbhl 9y agoWhat was the temporary bike lane made of? Chalk?
- IshKebab 9y agoRoad marking paint, looks like. Normal white lines etc are made by melting plastic onto the road. They're very thick.
- jeron 9y agoFrom the picture, it looks like spray paint. For permanent road markings, the paint would have to be DOT approved, professionally painted by the transit authority, etc. Spray paint would go away a lot sooner than the paint for road markings.
- sideshowb 9y agoIn my day job I have simulated the effects of segregated cycle infrastructure on demand http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0966692316307256 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0966692316... (above is out of date, more recent work under review: http://www.cardiff.ac.uk/sdna/european-transport-conference-2016/ http://www.cardiff.ac.uk/sdna/european-transport-conference-... ) So far I have shied away from simulating on-road cycle lanes, e.g. where motor vehicles and bikes are separated by a line of paint. Firstly because the quality is so variable - hilarious examples about on the internet, and many cyclists would argue that a bad cycle lane is worse than none at all as it creates an expectation they should be riding in it rather than sharing the road. Secondly because data on what's there - width, quality, obstructions - is so thin on the ground. (any time anyone wants to use deep learning to harvest this from streetview please go right ahead!) Where am I going with all this? It's heartening to see a case where lines painted on the road actually made a tangible difference. I wonder how much came down to the temporary nature though - like some kind of campaign - as cultural effects are known to have a huge impact on cycling as well.
- proactivesvcs 9y agoI noticed that the lane itself is a safe distance from the door zone and has a sensible, safe boundary marker between the cycle lane and standard highway. A cycle lane done properly - ironically, with some spray paint!
- wiredfool 9y agoThere have been a lot of lanes going in around Dublin, and frankly, most of them are useless. Some of them are grade separated from the main road by a inch high curb. Just high enough to catch a wheel and cause a wreck. Most of them just collect road debris like the shoulders. Some of them are de-facto parking lanes. Some of them are confusing enough that it's seriously unclear what the lane actually means. (I say this as someone who had to go through the whole driver licensing scheme here after 20 yrs driving in the US, so I've seen all the rules from the POV of an experienced driver.) For example: https://www.google.com/maps/@53.6089878,-6.1934201,90m/data=!3m1!1e3 https://www.google.com/maps/@53.6089878,-6.1934201,90m/data=... What the hell are those cycle turn boxes in the middle of the car lanes? They have a solid border, so they're 'mandatory'. They're unavoidable by cars. And if you're in one, you better have right of way already, because squishy. (and fwiw, the one other cyclist I saw at that junction was using the crosswalk). And then there's the cycle lanes near Greystone where they exist for one block, then there's something that looks like a crosswalk for bikes, and they dissappear for a block, then they reappear again. At some point, you just have to assume that some one with a can of paint is taking the piss and you just ride in a straight line like any other vehicle.
- eecc 9y agoThat's how bicycles came to the Netherlands. Many think bikes always existed since the beginning of time but that's not true: during the rebuild in the immediate post-war cities were designed around car-based transportation. Only after a couple decades, raised awareness about street safety , accidents causing death of children, the first Oil-shock and general tree-hugging '60s eco-friendliness did the country evolve into the cycling paradise it is now. That is to say: anyone can do the same, anywhere. So get on with it.. :)
- cdnsteve 9y agoAmsterdam has figured it out for sure. They even have parking garages for bikes only and they're full. The city is a great reference for others looking to go a similar route. Painting lines on streets can showcase demand, which is smart because you need to validate your product/project with minimal cost. Long term, dedicated lanes are needed, for safety, and someone has to pay for them.
- flippyhead 9y ago> anyone can do the same, anywhere. I love Holland and I love biking but you guys have it easy compared to, say, Seattle where I live part-time. The hills make it a very different problem. I bike a lot but will still drive/uber when I can't deal with being crazy sweaty for a meeting or something. I was very disappointed when they decided NOT to install electric bikes in the bike share system here. Electric bikes are the only way you'll get the ridership numbers needed in a place with the topography of Seattle. I also suspect it rains more in Seattle than Holland.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoAFAICT Seattle has fewer hills than Aarhus, Denmark. 47% of commutes in Aarhus are done by bicycle.
- Freak_NL 9y agoIt also does not appear to rain more in Seattle than in, say, Amsterdam: https://weather-and-climate.com/average-monthly-Rainfall-Temperature-Sunshine,seattle,United-States-of-America https://weather-and-climate.com/average-monthly-Rainfall-Tem... https://weather-and-climate.com/average-monthly-Rainfall-Temperature-Sunshine,Amsterdam,Netherlands https://weather-and-climate.com/average-monthly-Rainfall-Tem... This is a cultural and legacy infrastructure problem mostly.
- awjr 9y agoThe arguments for segregated cycle tracks (physical barriers) rather than cycle lanes (paint) can be answered by one question: "Would you let your child cycle here?" https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/jun/15/urban-planners-let-child-cycle-here-denmark https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/jun/15/urban-planner... However the argument against cycle tracks focuses on resident car parking and becomes extremely political. So a key part of developing a good end to end cycle network, given that a network is only as good as its weakest link, is parking control. This is where paint fails and you create these bitty networks where drivers feel happy to park their cars in the cycle lanes, because they can. A more interesting approach is to look at road capacity. A typical road consists of: footpath|parking|lane|lane|parking|footpath = 19,000 pedestrians + 2000 drivers per hour => 21,000 people. Converting this to: footpath|cycle track|lane|lane|cycle track|footpath = additional 14,000 cyclists per hour = 35,000 people Providing a 67% increase in road capacity while protecting pedestrians, reducing congestion, and making a population healthier is a big win for any urban environment. Politcally this is finally becoming easier, but it is a fundemental recognition that our roads are not there to store private property. More interstingly is that many cities are focusing on routes to centres of employment. The focus needs to be more on connecting schools to communities. An immense amount of congestion is caused by parents dropping their fat little kids off at school. Analysis I did on UK Census 2011 data looking at range traveled across 112 towns and cities in England and Wales indicate 6 million residents drive to work in the city/town they live in. 1 million live within a 20 minute (2km) walk of work 3.5 million live within a 20 minute cycle ride of work. Looking at Bath,UK that's about 20,000 local car journeys in a city that is 3miles in diameter. Add in the 5,000 kids being dropped off at school and you end up with 40,000 local car journeys. BUT unless people feel there is a safe alternative choice this is not going to change and for some reason the UK seems fixated on strategic networks and hub centric public transport systems. Not actually fixing local journeys.
- michaelt 9y agoThe arguments for segregated cycle tracks (physical barriers) rather than cycle lanes (paint) can be answered by one question: "Would you let your child cycle here?" Where I live, when segregated cycle tracks meet T junctions the layout is often like so: | C | ----------------------------------| a |-------- Cycles ◅ | r | ▷ ----------------------------------| s |-------- divider | | ----------------------------------- Δ --------- Cars ------------------------------------------------- This means cyclists using the segregated path have to stop to give way to cars at every T junction - whereas cyclists who don't use the segregated path can maintain a constant speed, with joining cars giving way to them. This leads to a demographic split in cyclist behaviour. For children and cyclists who aren't in a hurry, the segregated path is more friendly - but for 'serious' cyclists and people in a hurry, staying on the road makes more sense. Especially if there's a high density of T junctions, which isn't unusual in some urban areas. Fortunately, in my country there aren't any laws that force cyclists into bike lanes, so it generally isn't a problem. But any urban planner who wants 100% of cyclists segregated from traffic is going to have a difficult time on their hands :)
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoOne of the problems with more bicycle infrastructure I see is the current regulatory environment promotes the extremes only. A nice intermediate step would be if states would make moped registration less onerous. As it stands most states require a motorcycle license ($), insurance ($) and registration ($) for anything more than a bicycle with an engine kit. If more people rode those parking would be less of an issue and it would be easier to get support for bike infrastructure since bike infrastructure is common with moped infrastructure in many cases. Edit: I don't care how the moped is powered. I'm just pointing out that a moped that can keep up with 30mph traffic is a huge increase in utility over a bicycle while not taking up appreciably more space.
- Theodores 9y agoElectric bicycles are here we do not need any more dangerous and noisy mopeds.
- saiya-jin 9y agoFast(=powerful) electric bikes are much more dangerous than mopeds, since you don't hear them coming at all, which is a big issue especially for kids which always run around. They are super expensive compared to normal bikes, plus battery will fade away in couple of years. Just ask about honest opinion in some good bike shops, if they don't sell them/won't sell them to you, they will be honest and things I heard were not so favoring. + Depending on where you live, but my place has a fair amount of aggressive/outright crazy bikers that must have proper color blindness for red, because they just don't stop, even with plenty of people on pedestrian crossing, riding fast on pedestrian paths etc.
- rorykoehler 9y agoHaving been in Taipei where mopeds were illegal until ~20 years ago and then unleashed on the city like a plague I can only hope that if any city were to do this they would add the caveat that the mopeds must be electric.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago
- pmontra 9y agoThis in Milan, Italy three weeks ago: https://www.wired.it/lifestyle/mobilita/2017/06/01/milano-pista-ciclabile-attivisti-guerrilla-biking/ https://www.wired.it/lifestyle/mobilita/2017/06/01/milano-pi... It's on a narrow bridge quite dangerous for cyclists as cars tend to cut the turn to the left. After years of asking somebody decided to help themselves.
- zwp 9y ago> i milanesi hanno percorso in media 18,6 miglia > in bici per andare al lavoro... > velocità media a Milano 14,8 miglia all’ora "The Milanese cyclist averages 18.7 miles per day to go to work... at an average speed of 14.8 mph". Is my translation okay? That seems improbable [time & distance, not speed]: the _average_ Milanese cyclo-commuter takes over an hour each way? Currently 36C/97F in Milan. Or is this per week? Is it current to talk in "miglia" in modern Italian? (though even km would be high IMHO).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JamesMcMinn 9y agoThe "miles per day" would suggest 9.35miles each way, so ~40 minutes each way, which seems more likely.
- throwawayjava 9y agoThe average speed is kinda fast but not insane, especially if most of the ride is on a stretch without many intersections (which you'd expect to be true of a 9 mile ride). I average around 15 mph in a mostly flat area where I stop every few blocks. TBF I'm probably riding a bit more aggressively than a typical Milanese bike commuter. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the average American bike commuter averages 15 mph. But I'd also expect the average American bike commuter to be much faster than the average Milanese bike commuter because in the USA most bike commuters are dedicated enthusiasts. 18.7 miles per day seems like a really high average, but is entirely believable. I used to do something close to that, and our summers were also hot.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoEasily the biggest problem in the US with biking is that the infrastructure is, nearly without exception, absolutely atrocious. Nobody would accept having only 'painted walk lanes' on busy streets to get around, much less having them appear and disappear from the road seemingly at random, and yet that's the default state of bike lanes in nearly all US cities. If biking had as much infrastructure as even walking -- meaning, physically protected lanes on most streets -- Americans would bike in enormous numbers.
- bluejekyll 9y agoBike lanes are a step in that direction. SF is starting to gain more protected bike lanes, it would definitely be nice to have more. The bike lane itself is a great initial way to measure bike interest. Though honestly, nearly every street in the city should have at least a painted bike lane.
- rocqua 9y agoHere in the netherlands, cyclist paradise, we don't even have a painted bike lane on nearly every street. There are also streets where biking isn't allowed. These are mostly major car arteries. It is imperative to realize there are places where cyclists don't belong. Just like it is imperative to realize that in most places in the city, cyclists do belong.
- saiya-jin 9y agoEvery single road I ever saw in Netherlands (true, been only in Amsterdam & around for daily cycling) had a corresponding separate bike lane running along with it, in many cases on both sides. Maybe you mean roads only for motorized vehicles (not sure about proper name), usually with multiple lanes? Maybe some roads at the beginning/end of highway? In many not only European cities this is impossible to build since streets are as narrow as possible, you would have to remove pedestrian paths or tear down many buildings.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoIt was my understanding that major car arteries in the Netherlands usually had adjacent bike paths that were slightly set apart from the road, ala: https://www.google.de/maps/@52.1084742,5.0647,3a,75y,172.64h,74.24t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sQlTJOWPoMf60id13qdZuFA!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo0.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DQlTJOWPoMf60id13qdZuFA%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D58.057777%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i13312!8i6656!5m1!1e3 https://www.google.de/maps/@52.1084742,5.0647,3a,75y,172.64h... > Here in the netherlands, cyclist paradise, we don't even have a painted bike lane on nearly every street. With narrow streets and low speeds, cyclists and cars can effectively mix. It's just that in the US, politically that's an even harder sell than protected bike lanes, most of the time.
- mvitorino 9y agoThat hypothesis does not seem to apply to Lisbon, Portugal so far. We have now around 60km of dedicated bicycle paths in Lisbon (not just cycle lanes, but actual separated paths) all built in recent years (and plans to double that very soon). But, simply put, they are barely used. A few things are different in Lisbon from a lot of Northern Europe cities: it's very hilly and windy, it has temperatures close to 40 degrees in the summer (we have AC throughout the tube network) and in the winter, when it rains it really pours (not that drizzle that you get in London for example). I may be too early to call it, but not all cities are alike and many people here are very skeptic about whether general adoption will ever be reached.
- cpursley 9y agoI was just in Lisbon (lovely city). Hills aside, the metro is so good, it seems like a bike is just unnecessary (you have to store a bike, can't easily walk into shops, etc etc).
- kristofferR 9y agoThat's a problem that can be solved easily just by having a good and cheap city bike system. Oslo is also really hilly and the weather isn't the best, but since the city bike system was revamped in 2016 biking has exploded here. https://oslobysykkel.no/en https://oslobysykkel.no/en One thing I really like about the Oslo system is how startup-like it is, unlike a lot of other systems which feel arcane. The apps are flawless (there's no card), the design profile is fantastic [1], the bikes are good and light and they do a good job of communication [2]. [1] http://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo_and_identity_for_oslo_bysykkel_by_heydays.php http://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_logo... [2] https://www.facebook.com/bysykkeloslo/videos/1448346241855498/ https://www.facebook.com/bysykkeloslo/videos/144834624185549...
- rorykoehler 9y agoCheap bike sharing schemes usually don't have gears. If you've ever been to Lisbon you'll know that will be an issue. Lisbon needs electric assist bike for a bike sharing scheme to work.
- mattnewport 9y agoThis doesn't really prove anything. My observations from Vancouver where a lot of time and money has been spent on bike lanes over the last few years: (I'm a non car owner, mostly pedestrian) - Pilot projects are not representative of actual long term use. When Burrard bridge lost a footpath to a temporary cycle lane, as a regular pedestrian commuter I saw a brief spike in cycle traffic but then a big drop off again. - Cycle lanes have a negative impact on both car and foot traffic. The Burrard cycle lanes increased the length of my commute on foot (footpaths were converted to cycle lanes that went empty much of the time) and disrupted car traffic causing delays to drivers. - Expensive but poorly thought out physically separated bike lanes made intersections more dangerous for cyclists (who would go faster and slow down less for cars) and pedestrians (cyclists are silent and frequently ignore traffic lights) - On street parking is frequently lost to new cycle lanes that frequently sit unused. - There are a lot of 'fair weather cyclists' who only ride in good weather. Pedestrian traffic seems much less weather dependent. A pilot project like this doesn't necessarily reflect actual long term usage and also ignores the many negative effects and costs associated with cycle lanes. Existing cities that grew up around mixed pedestrian and car traffic are not necessarily well suited to increased bike traffic. Bikes are dramatically more dangerous to both cyclists and pedestrians and take up disproportionate space relative to their contribution to transport options.
- jnty 9y agoSounds like Vancouver is seeing fastest growing number of cycling trips in the world - do you think it's possible your experiences might not have been representative, or is there an effect you believe the stats aren't capturing? http://www.vancitybuzz.com/2016/02/eco-counter-cycling-index-vancouver-biking/ http://www.vancitybuzz.com/2016/02/eco-counter-cycling-index...
- mattnewport 9y agoLots of effects yes. I never suggested that bike lanes don't increase bike traffic however, I think it's pretty obvious that they will to some extent. I merely suggested that the large increase that might be observed in a temporary and well publicised pilot project likely greatly overrepresents the actual sustained usage. Questions I would ask that I haven't seen addressed as part of Vancouver's bike lane push: - Given the higher risks of cycling relative to driving or walking, how many extra deaths and injuries are associated with increased cycle use substituting for other forms of transport? - How many people are switching to cycling from driving because you have made things worse for drivers, pedestrians and transit users by installing cycle lanes (less parking space available, fewer car lanes, dramatically more congestion during the construction process) - Are pedestrians at greater risk due to the increased cycle use? (anecdotally it appears to me they are) - Given all the other ways the transport budget could be spent and road space used, is building cycle lanes the best bang for the buck? - What exactly are the goals of transport policy (hopefully not just 'increase the number of cyclists') and how are you measuring your success?
- Piccollo 9y agoThat cheeky Field of Dreams reference
- rorykoehler 9y agoAnecdotal I know however my wife only learnt to cycle properly this year. She is (rightly) terrified of riding on the road. If we had a better dedicated cycle road network (not paths but actual bicycle dedicated roads) she would be able to use it as a mode of transport. She has expressed interest however the network, while pretty good in Singapore (the park connector network is a good safe cycling option), is not continuous enough to allow commuting as an option.
- ghaff 9y agoAs someone who didn't bike as a child and won't bike on a road, I suspect that there isn't just about anywhere one can commute on a bike and totally avoid roads with cars on them. Including places like Amsterdam or other cities with a lot of dedicated lanes.
- Tommyixi 9y agoI'm a biker in Boston; I cycle 5 miles to work and 5 miles home on a daily basis. I think the city is doing an amazing job with what they are given but so many of the roads are just too narrow for dedicated bike lanes. Most streets have "sharrows" which is great but honestly what it comes down to is a lack of understanding on how to share the road. I'm constantly honked and shouted at for commanding full use of the driving lane when no bike lane is present, which is perfectly legal but often results in aggression from drivers. I've even had cars tailgate me and hit my back tire with their car.
- coldpie 9y agoIt is pretty frustrating to be forced to go 10 MPH on a 30 MPH road. The roads also aren't designed for traffic to go 20 MPH slower than it ought to be, traffic starts to build up, causing more delays and frustration. I think we should be more accommodating of bikers, but asking them to share the road and be treated the same as cars is not the answer.
- Tommyixi 9y agoI mean, if we're talking about Boston then the roads weren't originally designed for cars either: they were created for horse drawn carriages. http://www.mass.gov/eea/docs/dcr/pe/historic-parkways/4d72bd01.pdf http://www.mass.gov/eea/docs/dcr/pe/historic-parkways/4d72bd... They have been engineered to accommodate cars, so now they're undergoing a renovation for bikes.
- coldpie 9y ago> so now they're undergoing a renovation for bikes. Good! Renovate them to accommodate bikes. That's great, do more of that. But "sharing the road" is a terrible solution, which leads to the honks and dangerous situations the OP described. Neither the biker nor the drivers in the OP's post are in the wrong. It's just a really terrible situation that really should not happen.
- Jacqued 9y ago
- maaaats 9y agoMVP-infrastructure, interesting. There are always pilot-projects, but they cost a lot of money, takes a lot of time, and are set in stone.
- kennydude 9y agoThey could have at least made a better effort to keep cyclists and cars separate. In the photo a cyclist is still on the road which should not happen. I also remember seeing a video where a guy got some kind of ticket for not cycling in a cycle lane, so he made a point by cycling only in the cycle lane and deliberately crashes into a police car because they were parked in the cycle lane...
- jblok 9y agoLondon has been doing a great job lately at improving cycle infrastructure. There is a new concept of a "cycle superhighway" - sometimes that means a segregated bike path, like CS3 that goes from The Tower Of London, straight through to Westminster, sometimes it is paint on the ground. However it is much clearer to motorists as they paint the entire line bright blue. What I've noticed too is you get increasing returns the more you build. Given a scenario where a chosen route is covered 50% by acceptable infrastructure, it makes you think if it's worth taking a bike. Improve some strategic junctions and roads, and the coverage of acceptable infrastructure may increase to 90%, at which point it's a no brainer taking the bike.
- sidlls 9y agoIn SF there are plenty of bike lanes that are painted a vivid green (the whole lane, with a white lane marker line). I think it's fantastic. It's really very difficult to not notice that the bike lane exists.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoIronically (perhaps?) I think in the US the cities are often doing a good job but suburbs are awful. At least where I live, I can bike in my own neighborhood but to get from my neighborhood to the commercial districts where the actual jobs are I need to essentially go on a highway and share the road with 40 MPH cars. When neighborhoods are spread out it makes biking hard. Where I am at least, neighborhoods tend to be connected to main (high speed) roads like Christmas lights. Thing is they aren't even far away... work to my house is 5 miles. An easy bike ride. Except part of that ride is a highway that I'd need a death wish to bike on and there are no back roads.
- pc86 9y agoIn my state it is illegal for anything but a motorized vehicle to be on the highway (and rightfully so as most traffic is 70 mph+ outside of rush hour). With rare exception I've seen cyclists on most of the busy multi-lane surface streets where it is 45+ and traffic is going 10-15 faster than that. What metro area are you in? It seems odd that there are no surface streets at all between two points just a few miles away.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoI'm in New Hampshire. Part of the Manchester-Nashua metro region or the Boston metro depending on which survey you use. I think the word highway might have some regional nuance. Around here there are often open highways (highways with stop lights and connected side roads) and bikes are allowed to go on them. Although I wouldn't feel safe doing it. Bikes are not allowed on the kind of highway you are thinking of here either. The speed limit on those roads tends to be 35 or 40 MPH. Not 65 like it would be on a large highway. Edit: Here's an example from Nashua, NH (for privacy I found a place similar to where I live but not actually where I live). Notice how the residential on the left is completely separated from the commercial on the right by "Daniel Webster Highway"... one could easily bike on that road if there were bike lanes but it is an extremely busy road and there is no safe way for a bike to take a left hand turn to get to the other side. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Daniel+Webster+Hwy,+Nashua,+03060/@42.7293831,-71.4611499,2521m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m13!1m7!3m6!1s0x89e3ba75d16d96f7:0x261a0b96112fbe5b!2sDaniel+Webster+Hwy,+Nashua,+NH!3b1!8m2!3d42.7225921!4d-71.4440401!3m4!1s0x89e3ba75d16d96f7:0x261a0b96112fbe5b!8m2!3d42.7225921!4d-71.4440401 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Daniel+Webster+Hwy,+Nashua...
- yourapostasy 9y agoInteresting. For the cyclists out there, would you pay out of pocket for a bi-directional elevated bike/walk-run track, with access from every street intersection, Japanese-style underground bike garages and automatically-cleaning showers/toilets at public transit intersections? If so, how much? I would, at $0.25-0.50 per mile, $0.25 per hour storage, and $2 per use of showers. I don't know if that would pencil out even in heavy cyclist commuter traffic, though. I envision a high-tech track that uses redox batteries around its foundations, replaceable solar panels around the sides, is very brightly-lit, uses every 10 meters PTZ lenses on fiber optics leading back to a centralized, multiplexed bank of 2K and 4K video cameras backed by a deep-learning vision system, and easily-accessible emergency boxes every 20 meters to put female customers at ease. Emergency boxes vend bike repair kits (tire, chain, hex wrench, etc.), vend first aid kits, have an omnidirectional microphone listening for calls for aid, and of course a Big Red Button. Water is captured, filtered and stored for a cleaning robot to use later to maintain the track, solar panels, and awnings. Clear awnings automatically come out of housings, then raise and lower to shield from excessively-hot sun and inclement weather. Cleaning robot runs along a high-speed rail hanging on outside of track, multi-purposed to perform simpler replacement-style maintenance duties (replace vending supplies, replace awning, etc.).
- tbihl 9y agoWhat are you talking about? Can you define some of the problems you're trying to solve? It feels like you're writing a parody of something. The post is about keeping bike lanes simple and cheap so we'll just build them already. Yours is the opposite, no?
- yourapostasy 9y agoIn the US, obtaining right-of-way to build bike lanes in metropolitan areas is infeasible. I've sat in neighborhood meetings with my state's Department of Transportation engineers and planners discussing main artery expansions, and they explained that there isn't sufficient demand for bike paths to include them in any new planning funded by taxpayers; whenever they've tried to include dedicated bike lanes in the past, they were shot down first by politicians looking to curry the fiscal conservative votes, then by special interest groups protecting a car-based culture (housing developers, chambers of commerce, etc. all see dedicated bike lanes as yielding less traffic to their planned projects). However, obtaining right-of-way to privately build an elevated path, they conceded, while not easy, was more feasible because someone else foots the bill. The problem is no one has figured out a design that can feasibly pay off. If you can obtain the right-of-way for an elevated path, then what would you design for it that makes it pay off at least a little above break-even? Generally, I take this as a sign that in the US, unless you deliberately attract a demographic to a specific concentrated area that consciously chooses biking as a major transportation mode, namely, a master-planned community/town built around biking and public transit, cyclists are SOL to comprehensively expand biking for the foreseeable future in most US metro areas outside of "bike ghettos" where there is a strong cycling culture. I'd love to see as much biking for normal daily activities as we saw in mainland China before they opened up to the West, but in the US in many areas it is legitimately risky to bike (despite the actual risk of fatality on a bike gradually dropping over the past three decades). So a related hypothetical is, if you were in a high-density (say, 30K per square mile scale density) city designed from the beginning for walk/run/bike/public-transit transportation, what kind of bike paths would you want? The article describes intra- and inter-neighborhood scale at best, but doesn't address efforts to solve US commuter distances, which invariably involve highways. That seems an insoluble challenge at the moment in the US.
- BigIQ 9y agoFor anyone who has even read a bit on infrastructure, this is a no brainer. The problem with alternative transportation is you have to go all in to see the benefits. Half assing it won't work. But half assing it is what a lot of places do, and then they say "see, ridership didn't increase, going further is just a waste of money."