14 ms·
For anyone interested in the molecular process of DNA replication, here's a pretty cool video that explains what happens at the protein level. It's always amazi
by ekianjo 9y ago
For anyone interested in the molecular process of DNA replication, here's a pretty cool video that explains what happens at the protein level. It's always amazing to watch what is in practice a molecular-sized machine:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjPcT1uUZiE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjPcT1uUZiE
- haskman 9y agoThat was amazing! Especially the machinery of the second part where the DNA strand is replicated backwards!
- im3w1l 9y agoThat looks more error-prone, wonder if that copy has more mutations...
- ekianjo 9y agoyeah I am wondering if there is any research on that particular matter.
- Palomides 9y agoyes, e.g. [1], but there are specialized repair mechanisms that operate at the same time, so the 'final' error rate is much lower than the 'initial' rate. [1]: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v518/n7540/abs/nature14183.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v518/n7540/abs/nature14...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pfd1986 9y agoHave a look at this lecture. It's really well explained, at a undergrad level, how the cell keeps the error rate low. Quite impressive, imo. https://youtu.be/DRBREvFL19g https://youtu.be/DRBREvFL19g
- rwmj 9y agoI can also recommend an undergrad text book called "The Molecular Biology of the Cell". New editions are expensive, but second hand or older editions can be had relatively cheaply. https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/0815341067 https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/0815341067
- agumonkey 9y agoIt's very nice to grab 2nd hand books for cheap. Saved me in linear algebra 2 years ago.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI think it's safe to say more has changed in our understanding of biology (compared to linear algebra) in the last twenty years, though.
- agumonkey 9y agoSure, I realized that old editions were very very cheap but very outdated, the 5th (2012?) is about 20$ that's probably the best compromise
- eternauta3k 9y agoProbably fine for the basics, but you will find some details outdated if you buy a 20-year old copy.
- mk7 9y agoI'm looking at this video and can't stop thinking: "Who created this process?" With all advances in technology and know-how we are not able to put such sophisticated process together... And it is present in EVERY living creature and happens millions of times in every body... So how this process came into existance?
- rapala 9y agoMy understanding is that this process didn't really come into existance but stayed in existance. Countless other arrangements failed to replicate and endure.
- jtbayly 9y agoAnd that seems to require quite a bit of faith.
- yequalsx 9y agoWe both agree the process exists. The overwhelming evidence is that species evolve over time. We can conclude that this is the process that won out evolutionarily or that God did it. I suggest God did it requires the most faith and incidentally more likely leads to a stifling of curiosity. God did it might possibly be true but it is the refuge of the incurious. It can be used at every turn. It can be used to answer all 'why?' questions. And thus it is singularly the most incorrect answer in history. That's why God did it requires the most faith. It has been wrong so often that I wonder why it hasn't been discarded for the intellectual crutch that it is.
- amelius 9y agoI'm always wondering how long the machine just sits there waiting for the building blocks to arive, before it detects them, and uses them. Is the soup of building blocks just swirling so fast that the machine can continue working without interruptions? Or is waiting just part of the game?
- agumonkey 9y agoTalking about dna and machines, Schabanel-Rondelez-Woods of Paris Diderot Univ. did design DNA tiles as building block for turing capable machines. They have demoes of gliders, and even a nanoscopic dna hello world in lab. "program" size limited to 500 tiles IIRC, because the design will break when things get larger. Still amazing, happy googling.
- CuriouslyC 9y agoThe substrates aren't just floating free, in many cases they're collected by binding proteins, which form parts of protein complexes, and these protein complexes are guided around the cell by it's cytoskeleton. In most cases when substrates are unavailable the protein complexes maintain the enzymes in an inactive state. Don't think of cells as disordered bags of water. They're more like highly ordered liquid crystals.
- drostie 9y agoYes. Oh my god yes. So there is this HUGE part of biophysics that we completely isolate all of the undergraduate students from, with these pretty videos where one machine magically swims out to exactly where it's supposed to go and then the next machine magically swims in to do the next thing and then the next machine, and so on, until you've got this perfect assembly line chugging away at this stuff. That is NOT what happens. The reason that we make those "schematic" videos is that if we drew the real video, you could get overwhelmed by detail and miss the actual mechanism that we're talking about. What's actually happening is that this whole activity is happening in one big churning sea of all of these things knocking into each other bouncing around chaotically. That one machine that went to the right place is symbolic of hundreds of machines that happened to bounce off into the wrong one; that straight line is symbolic of an average of a million possible bouncy trajectories which went in all sorts of different directions before getting there. Everything is at a high enough concentration and pulsating and buzzing so much that in short order the "right stuff" happens to bounce together to do whatever is happening. Sometimes, even, the cell makes the "local concentration" of some machine or part even higher, via either containing some structure within a bag or else by producing proteins which attract "the right sort of thing" to them, so that more nucleotides or whatever happen to be nearby. Just to give a more concrete example, in the fertilization of an ovum, we showed you a nice picture of one single solitary spermatozoon which shakes hands nicely with one ovum, and they became best friends. We also tried to scare you with "just one sperm is all it takes!" reasoning, which is technically true but misleading. If we were showing you the absolute truth, you'd see that the ovum is getting beaten down by a bunch of spermatozoa pelting it like a pack of wolves, trying to break down a chink in its shell, called the "corona radiata", until one of them burrows into a thin tear. Then the eggs of most mammals have to chemically shift composition of their borders to actively prevent "polyspermy", getting penetrated by multiple spermatozoa, through that tear. What's really fascinating here is that we're not completely sure how this happens because usually this process is happening during meiosis, another of those things where we separate the story for the textbooks ("meiosis happens, then you store the resulting cells, finally some of them bubble up for fertilization" -- no, meiosis actually has these two long pauses in it; long-term storage happens during the first one (the "dictyate") and fertilization happens during the second one before meiosis is complete). So it's hard to say "this prevention of polyspermy is due to meiosis" vs. "it's due to fertilization." Suddenly it's not so much of a surprise that some of your friends were trying for years to conceive while some teenagers you know of got pregnant too soon -- that "it only takes one" rhetoric makes people very worried very rapidly, "what if I waited too long, what if I'm infertile" and the "there is literally a wall there and it's a matter of luck whether something breaks through it or not" story reveals the real emotional truth: "oh, we have like no real control over this; whatever will be, will be." It's just that at the lowest levels there's a ton of bouncing chaotic pulsating activity, things smashing into each other routinely, and heck, the only reason that your proteins even keep their characteristic lumpy shapes is that they're designed by evolution to take on this shape when water molecules are bouncing against them chaotically enough that they happen to curl up into it. The machines to replicate DNA similarly are sitting in a sea of nucleotides smacking against them, which is why the helicase can't unzip too far ahead of the polymerase; that polymerase might be able to handle the stray nucleotide that binds prematurely to the DNA, but it might have real trouble if an extended sequence gets accidentally bound that way.
- dwighttk 9y agoI'd like to see an updated version of that second part including the new findings from the parent.
- agumonkey 9y agoAm I the only one to see lists and map/reduce here ?
- amelius 9y agoI'd like to see this in a simulator.
- nom 9y agoIf you liked this video, also check out this one: Inner Life of the Cell https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzcTgrxMzZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzcTgrxMzZk And here's a nice TED talk by Drew Berry: Animations of unseeable biology https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFCvkkDSfIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFCvkkDSfIU These kind of visualizations are of course an idealized view on how it works. As others have already mentioned, the processes are hugely chaotic and much more probabilistic than deterministic. On this scale everything is just one huge wobbling soup of things crashing into each other, which makes it even more fascinating that it works as well as it does.
- posterboy 9y agomaybe that's why we need a lot of sleep to grow or recover, then it's not all that wobbly