69 ms·
Social Cooling – How big data is increasing pressure to conform
- dredmorbius 9y agoA related question: can privacy be quantified? And if so, how? On what bases? Thoughts I've had: Total quantity of data available? Ability to define boundaries? Ability to enforce those boundaries? Knowledge of what boundaries to even define? Who knows what about a person? How many agents know what? How aware is the subject of actual knowlesdgee? How rapidly can that knowledge be further transferred? Does the surveillor know more of the subject than the subject? Can the subject access that knowledge? Can others? What level of benefit (or harm) can be transacted on the basis of surveillance? Does this accrue to the subject or others?
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoWhat is the goal in asking these questions?
- dredmorbius 9y agoAnswers. Or possibly just better questions.
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoWhat would you do with those answers?
- dredmorbius 9y agoWhat suggestions might you have? Or perhaps, what possiblities occur to you?
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoNefarious ones.
- tpeo 9y ago"Knowlesdgee"? Anyway, I think you're forgetting one important dimension: whether the person in question would like that particular piece of information to be known.
- dredmorbius 9y agoSigh. Soft keyboard keeps duping and misregistering ketstrokes. That dimension is the setting of boundaries. E.g., "I don't wan't you to know, or share, or seek, or ask of some X." Or if it's acquired, not to share it except as specifically specified -- only with notice, on request, within a given grroup, for (or not for) a specific time, etc., etc.
- bicubic 9y agoI was going to write at length about my concerns on this topic, and then I decided not to. Because it's entirely possible that one day many years from now, a prospective employer/insurer/whatever finds such a comment and flags me for it. That's the cooling effect in a nutshell.
- bottled_poe 9y agoFuture employer can blow me.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DougN7 9y agoI understand the sentiment, but future you might be pissed at your current cavalier attitude.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 9y agoIf the situation reach that toxic point it's time to revolve.
- kirykl 9y ago"Thank you for applying to ProfitCorp. While you have excellent credentials and passed all levels of interviews, your web sentiment analysis score does not meet the threshold for hire. Best of luck in future endeavors"
- f_allwein 9y agoof course, "social credit systems" to rate citizens are already being tested in China: http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21711902-worrying-implications-its-social-credit-project-china-invents-digital-totalitarian http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21711902-worrying-imp...
- aerique 9y agoEveryone is generally playing catch up with China in these matters so I expect this will show up all over the world in five to ten years as well. And with "show up" I mean as blatantly as in China. I'm actually fully expecting these things to happen below the water already.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>It is planning what it calls a “social-credit system”. This aims to score not only the financial creditworthiness of citizens, as happens everywhere, but also their social and possibly political behaviour. This already exists across the world in the form of credit rating agencies and social media. It's merely an issue of data integration
- elefanten 9y agoExcept its: 1. Centrally regulated and collected 2. Mandatory 3. Explicitly includes matters of ideology and opinion So, it's hardly comparable to what is extant under the surface in other countries.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago1. So is Facebook and the credit rating agencies in the US 2. No it's not, it was unsuccessfully tested in a single county 3. So do the judgments of employers on whether or not to hire or fire someone based on publicly expressed political ideology It may make us feel better to point the finger over there to distract from the parallels of what is going on locally but doing so is hardly practical.
- Fuxy 9y agoAnd this is why Facebook has become my go to place for contacting old friends I haven't talked to in years and relatives I speak too even less. If it's people I interact with all the time there's other ways of contact that are less data mined like a good old text message or phone call. Oh yeah and my last Facebook post is well over a year ago. There's no way in hell I will post random pictures it that will show me in bad light. It's basically a slightly less official business profile.
- andreasgonewild 9y agoForget about posting. Even visiting that stupid site will mess with your mind and others in unseen ways. All parties are at all times interacting with a set of algorithms optimized for profit/integrity intrusions/behavioral changes/god knows. You might think you're smart enough, but then why are they spending so much money on something that doesn't work. Just say no. https://github.com/andreas-gone-wild/snackis https://github.com/andreas-gone-wild/snackis
- fibbidd 9y agoI am not saying there is nothing to this, but this is just a catchy concept with a convincing narrative. The sources are news articles and YouTube videos, not scientific papers specifically addressing the issues mentioned, for example showing a link between self-censorship and online monitoring or quantifying that effect.
- doktrin 9y agoCatchy concepts and convincing narratives sometimes precede more rigorous studies. As you yourself cautiously indicated, there might be something to this. I can't satisfy anyone's need for a thorough scientific paper offhand, but I can certainly add anecdotal evidence : I regularly self censor online precisely because I know I'm being tracked in some fashion (and probably in ways I haven't even thought of : retroactive big data analysis 20 years from now is likely to be more sophisticated than it is today). I doubt I'm the only one.
- socialcooling 9y agoAuthor of the website here: The website does link to a lot of scientific studies actually. Both throughout the page and at the bottom. But I purposefully didn't want to link directly to the PDF's of those studies too much. By pointing to accessible news articles about those studies in the "further reading" section I was hoping to keep things accessible to a wider audience. This article that appeared in The Guardian today about Social Cooling has some more sources you may like. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/18/google-not-gchq--truly-chilling-spy-network https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/18/google... And you may also like "Postscript op societies of Control" by philosopher Deleuze, that greatly inspired this view. https://www.qwant.com/?q=Postscript+op+societies+of+Control https://www.qwant.com/?q=Postscript+op+societies+of+Control We need catchy concepts to reach a wider audience.
- joekrill 9y agoThe first thing I thought of was the "Nosedive" episode of Black Mirror this season. Seems more and more plausible every day.
- zeotroph 9y agoWhat is missing is a government actively pushing this scheme - which China is doing with their "social credit score". An intermediate step would be selling of derived data to anyone, not just companies interested in hiring you but really anybody.
- vlasev 9y agoIt is never mentioned how things came to be in that episode. I'm sure there was a lot of government in it, as is in all the episodes of the series.
- nippples 9y ago> People are starting to realize that this 'digital reputation' could limit their opportunities. Thanks to the moral police and keyboard warriors out there normalizing contacting employers over an internet argument.
- creepydata 9y agoI think you meant to say "hiring managers Googling potential employees."
- Bartweiss 9y agoSurely this is a case of "why not both?" Campaigns to get people fired when their online posts are revealed are well-attested from all parts of the political spectrum, and generally come out of doxxing efforts that hiring managers don't undertake. There are even campaigns that boil down to "this person said X, harass/troll their employer so that even if the employer doesn't object to X it becomes too costly to keep them employed". But at the same time, hiring managers have Google and all kinds of tools random harassers don't, like the ability to check criminal records and credit scores. (And there's a great example of an opaque and inaccurate tool governing people's lives - just read about the people sharing a name and birthdate with someone who has bad credit or legal issues!) So yeah, hiring managers with Google. But I wouldn't discount the other issue either, since it can cause people problems even for comments that don't violate any general social standard.
- jgh 9y agoThere are definitely people out there who email screenshots of social media conversations to employers.
- voidhorse 9y agoI think the creator may be better off conducting a through philosophical investigation in efforts of pinning down the concept. You would be much better off giving full citations to Foucault and Deleuze, and full analysis into the Snowden incident and the fallout rather than a sort of half nod to, what I think, are the foundation beams of this concept. This page kind of assumes the audience is already willing to admit social cooling as a legitimate phenomena, and if not, will be convinced to do so after a few short bullets and very little in the way of actual analysis (ironically, this sort of approach leverages one of the modern patterns the piece could tackle--short bursts of information, instant delivery, decreased skepticism and amounts of reflective thought). Also, I'd highly recommend avoiding the global warming comparison. It does a disservice to your cause. It basically comes off, at least to me, as saying "our problem isn't a substantial thing in its own right so lets compare it to this other big problem people already care about and hope the very loose and forced analogy strings them along" All this being stated, ya'll should check out Horkheimer's essay "The Concept of Man." He wrote it in ~1952(might've been 53 or 57, I'm forgetting the exact date)--and it's crazy how prophetic that essay turned out to be. It shows how all our innovation really just led to an amplification of social structures and patterns that were already emerging during the dawn of automation and mechanization. I think it's relevant to your project.
- socialcooling 9y agoAuthor here: Being trained as a media theorist I understand your criticism (and am going to check out Horkheimer's essay, thanks for the tip!). But this website purposefully tries to keep things accessible in order to reach a wider audience. I often see how academics have a deep understanding of what's going on, but just aren't as good at spreading that insight to a wider audience, like the startup community.
- voidhorse 9y agoAh, that is a fair concern, and this approach makes sense if that is your goal. Still, I think it's useful to point to some of the academic backing--like you already do with Foucault, just perhaps in greater depth. Maybe add some of that academic/conceptual source material to the further reading section--then again, might just distract from the main point. You know your target audience better than I do, I only have my particular reaction (which is probably a bit idiosyncratic and outside of the scope of your intended audience). In any case this is a cool project and a noble effort. Hope you stick with it.
- golemotron 9y agoIn one model of human behavior we all just become better people because we self-censor. I think that may be true for the first generation of people experiencing these effects in a society. Later generations will have more of a problem. The problem comes when they repress negative emotions and other status detractors because the cost of even being aware of them is too high. Then you have people who, in psychological terms, are prisoners of their shadow selves. They become anxious and depressed because they fear confronting it.
- socialcooling 9y agoAuthor here: I also worry about Learned Helplessness, where we believe that there is nothing we can do about it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learned_helplessness In Silicon Valley the Technological Determinist view that technology has it's own will, that it is some unstoppable force, is the dominant but dangerous viewpoint. That idea is only creating a self-fulfilling prophesy. The reality is that we as a society have always taken the rough edges of new technologies through the creation of laws and new norms. For example, we pretty much put a halt to nuclear energy. We can and we must regulate the Big Data world much more. And the first step is that we must help people understand the problem.
- golemotron 9y agoI agree. We need to be more conscious of the Precautionary Principle, but having said that it is easy to see how technological determinism is an accurate view regardless of whether we like it or not. As an example, no one quite knew how much cars, television, or the ready availability of cameras on cellphones would impact society. But consumers were so excited by the upsides that there couldn't ever be debate about any downsides or call for regulatory frameworks until the downsides manifested themselves. The trick that we use is to hook the consumer faster than law can react. Uber did this successfully. Segway flubbed it. With Segway Kamen wanted a big rollout. It attracted attention and municipalities started passing legislation restricting Segways before they were off the assembly line.
- api 9y ago
- bem94 9y agoI really feel that engineers need to wake up to this kind of thing. I'm not saying we should stop (although that's what might happen), just that we pause and consider what this is doing to the world. It is the undercurrent for so many profound changes going on right now. Are we really comfortable as individuals building systems which predict someones mental (ill) health, personality traits or ethnicity just so we can sell them things, or worse, not sell them things?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- inanutshellus 9y agoIt's like any other thing in capitalism. You'll have a contingent of folk that won't do the work, based on ethical reasons, and you have folk that will, for financial reasons. Anecdotally, the few folks I know that work for data collection companies are all "tinfoil hat" types. They have flip-phones, they have no online presence, they smile like a Cheshire Cat when you ask them about it and you generally get the impression they've just decided to categorize it as "us" and "them". :-\
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bem94 9y ago> It's like any other thing in capitalism. You'll have a contingent of folk that won't do the work, based on ethical reasons, and you have folk that will, for financial reasons. That is true, but going on my peers (especially the ones fresh from university), I think a dangerous proportion of people simply aren't aware on any level of the ethical implications of what they do. It's that which worries me.
- sixstringtheory 9y agoI don't think I've ever seen as much apathy in a classroom as my fellow CS majors displayed in our society and ethics course.
- dalbasal 9y agoHmmm... There's one side of this which is straightforward. Companies and governments are compiling data for their own purposes, which range from modeling user behaviour to profiling you so that they can sell you stuff or arrest you for dissidence. The lines we previously defended for privacy, freedoms of conscience, affiliation and speech have been disturbed, to say the least. This has generaly been done under the surface, without involving users. It is increasingly felt on the surface, via the ads you see on FB or the recomendations youtube feeds you. The other side of this is what I think of as a "post-history" problem. We're now transitioning into a period where reality is simply recorded. Your comment on Chelsea Manning's release is now a matter of public record. Your next Tinder date might see it and so might the HR manager reviewing your application for senior talent accumulator in 2032. There are all sorts of implications to that, but mostly people just feel weird about it for now. Anxious and uncertain. So... FB (HN, whatever) is a space for casual discussion. Casual generally meant private in the past. Now, some of the most casual discussions mean an extreme opposite of private. This inevitably comes with stress. Calling it a hilling (or cooling) effect is evoking a political dimension, one that speaks to the first part of the issue. The second issue, that's more of a social issue. It's political too, but I don't think that's where the centre of mass is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jxramos 9y agoWe should start compiling data on the government and turn the tables.
- peter_retief 9y agoWe are in the age of "virtue signalling" people pretend to hold what they believe are popular virtues. Is it possible to mention "Donald Trump" and not cause an uproar of virtue signalling?
- jerf 9y agoVirtue signalling is only a subset of this problem. It's an important one because of the way it interacts with human psychology, but it's not the whole story. This goes into things like "not being able to post those photos of me getting blasted last weekend", being unable to partition one's identity such that you might be able to keep your sexual orientation details away from people you may not want to know them, and all sorts of other things well beyond the political issues of the day. (Sexual orientation may be a "big political issue" too, but in this case I'm referring to the personal dimensions of those issues.)
- peter_retief 9y agoI absolutely agree with you about the subset however the fear of being different is huge and I believe that plays into what people say online. People have lost jobs with inappropriate online rants, sometimes racial or religious discrimination sometimes being negative toward an employer or even looking for another job. Wrong signals can cost you a lot. I am really glad it is been debated/discussed
- api 9y agoI agree but I must also point out that in some parts of the country not being a Trump supporter could have serious social consequences. The entire country is not San Francisco.
- bussierem 9y agoAs much as I love this site and what it provides, the last sentence of your comment should be an all-caps sticky message on the front page at all times... :)
- ptero 9y agoI agree with the general premise, but I think privacy is not the perfect weapon here: if someone is making a public statement (e.g., a personal view expressed on a weblog) they cannot claim that it is a private statement. The goal (I think) is to prevent them being hounded for it outside the channel where it was expressed. One option is to bring back anonymity so people can make public, anonymous comments. Anonymity has been sharply curtailed (because terrorism) and this is, IMO, bad for society. Another is to mandate short term limitations on use. For example if the employer wants to look at your online presence they can only look at last week of your posts and only for initial employment consideration. IMO employers should not look there at all, but maybe this may be a palatable compromise. The chap in HR is not itching to dig dirt on employees -- he just has a distorted notion of due diligence forced on him. If he has a clear, legal definition of what he can and he cannot look into I suspect he will gladly comply. My 2c.
- bradmwalker 9y agoWhat stops hiring managers and potential colleagues?
- nachocode 9y agoThis is a very delicate topic indeed. On one hand, users are not willing to pay to use the services of platforms such as Youtube or Facebook so they need to find ways to monetize. On the other hand, As a user, you feel that your trust in platforms has been betrayed by knowing that platforms are selling the data that you willfully post to the public.
- socialcooling 9y agoYes, it's becoming more difficult to argue that users are giving 'informed consent' when they sign up to 'free' services. In the EU the new GDPR law is already making the 'informed consent' requirement more strict. http://www.eudataprotectionlaw.com/consent-under-the-general-data-protection-regulation/ http://www.eudataprotectionlaw.com/consent-under-the-general...
- avip 9y agoDomainistication - How inventing a quite meaningless term, made of N words, then registering the domain made of these words glued together, and uploading a single page thingy, became a thing. More on that in https://domainisticationofngrams.com https://domainisticationofngrams.com
- zeteo 9y ago> People are starting to realize that this 'digital reputation' could limit their opportunities. (And that these algorithms are often biased, and built on poor data.) That's interesting of itself, but the bigger underlying issue is that opportunities are becoming more concentrated. When only a few companies dominate hiring in many fields, their mistakes get seriously amplified. Back in the day you were fine if Google's hiring process misjudged you - you could work for Excite or Altavista instead. Nowadays if some ML algo decides that people wearing blue sneakers are worse job performers you can get screwed (without even knowing why). And even worse, the major companies (where the jobs are) often share algorithms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- api 9y agoWorse still-- past employment at the majors is seen as a strong "social proof" indicator by many including other employers and investors. I saw an angel.co drinking game once. I think you had to chug two drinks for "worked at X" (where X is any major) being put forward as the sole qualification of a founder or key early employee. This is starting to edge out "went to X" where X is a top-tier school. China is supposedly deploying their own horrific state-sponsored "social credit score" system, but we're doing it too. We're just doing it in a less centralized way. In a way that's worse. In China everyone will know of this system and its existence and I'm sure people will figure out so many ways to game it it'll become irrelevant. In the West people will remain blissfully ignorant as ours has no name or formal identity. Ultimately I am still more creeped out by what our private sector is doing than what our NSA and CIA are doing. Neither is good, but the latter has some oversight and regulation. The former has absolutely no regulation or oversight whatsoever, and in any case the private sector is very often better at such things than the public sector is. I wouldn't be at all surprised if Facebook's data analytics are far superior to the NSA's.
- fivestar 9y agoOne reason why I think management in the US is so bad is because the entire corpus of managers went to the same few groupthink institutions and that is why they are so bad--no real risk takers, no real anything. It's like that in politics, too. We aren't promoting the right ideals, but merely conformity, risk-aversion, and foregone conclusions accepted as fact.
- Pigo 9y agoIt's been depressing to think about the (mostly harmless) fun I used to have on the Internet in years past. I miss the wild-west with bizarre magazine, 4chan when it full of anon and battle-toad threads, bandedup.com, Kazaa, and downloading crazy anarchist cookbooks from mIRC. At this point myspace was more fun than our facebook filled with grandmothers. I've been wondering if I'm just old now and don't know where the fun is anymore, but IRC seems dead, and everything else is reserved for masturbation purposes.
- DanielBMarkham 9y agoOur species is hardwired to mix among multiple social groups, each having different norms and hierarchies. We have positively proven that we evolve over time by allowing repugnant minorities the ability to publicly speak. Out of 100 reprehensible social opinions, one turns out to be the next Martin Luther King, Jr. Our perception of something as being "good" or "bad" for public discourse is notoriously fallible and broken. The things I say in a social group of former college buddies and the things I say in a group of the local clergy are two different things. That doesn't make me two-faced: it makes me human. In fact, the ability to converse and trade with drastically different social groups is probably the essence of humanity. Yet our current overlords that program the internet are convinced that the entire world should run as if it were just a huge version of their favorite social group. Joe tells racist jokes? Maybe we let Joe continue, but we definitely ought to score that. After all, Joe could offend somebody -- and then they would be mad at our platform, not Joe. We are instrumenting a terrible evil on our species, even more evil than the security and surveillance state, if such a thing could be possible. SkyNet has finally attacked, and because there are no T-1000s leading the way the vast majority of the population doesn't even know it's at war.
- imron 9y agoYou better watch out You better not cry Better not pout I'm telling you why Big Data is coming to town It knows when you are sleeping [0] It knows when you're awake It knows if you've been bad or good So be good for goodness sake. 0: https://medium.com/@sqrendk/how-you-can-use-facebook-to-track-your-friends-sleeping-habits-505ace7fffb6 https://medium.com/@sqrendk/how-you-can-use-facebook-to-trac...
- vladf 9y agoI might be misunderstanding the point being made here, but at one part doesn't make sense to me. The digital reputation argument seems to be saying "big data is bad because your reputation (i.e., people's valuations of your past actions) is now more accessible to people." Such an argument can hold two ways: 1. Giving anyone access to your reputation is inherently bad. 2. Giving some amount of people access to your reputation is OK, but the amount of people big data gives it access to is now magically worse. (1) is definitely untrue, at least to most people. We all definitely use our knowledge of other's reputations to make judgements, and apply social pressure to make them conform. For instance, if someone you know is a rich snob, or a vehement racist, you won't hang out with them. (2) seems ad hoc. Why would letting more people know about your reputation magically be worse? Whether someone knows about your reputation should either be bad or not -- it's not dependent on how many other people are aware of your reputation.
- bem94 9y agoI got the impression it was more to do with gaining access to the various pieces of information which make up your online (and offline) reputation, out of their original context. That lack of context then means the otherwise benign info suddenly makes you look awful. That's the big thing here, the internet strips context and nuance from everything you post unless you take a lot of time and thought over exactly what you say. It's proably fair to say most people on the internet don't do that.
- vladf 9y agoStill, why is that distinct from offline reputation (hence my original question still holds)? All second-hand information about another person's reputation is just as out-of-context when repeated by another person. Consider (1) your friends, who might have their own political agendas, bad-mouthing a politician who disagrees with them or (2) someone recommending their friend for a job you have. It seems to me that it's even worse off-line: people actually intentionally select evidence to influence a person's reputation when trying to relay reputation about a person you don't know directly. At least when a machine does it there's code you can look at to verify whether it has an agenda.
- michaelcampbell 9y agoHow is this not the well documented Hawthorne Effect? That being watched digitally and with more ubiquity seems to be a distinction without a (real) difference. Calling something new does not make it so.
- socialcooling 9y agoSocial Cooling is related to a number of concepts, including Foucault's panopticon. But Social Cooling is about much more than "individuals change their behavior when observed"(the Hawthorne effect). That's only the starting point. Social cooling aims to cover the large scale societal consequences of that effect, and makes a comparison to Global Warming to point to the scale of the problem as well as the possible path that leads us out of the problem.
- randommm 9y agoI sincerely doubt that anything that places the 'panopticon' in the center of the analysis will be able to point us the path that leads us out of the problem. The discourse of ubiquitous surveillance (or less political: observation) is a discourse of weakness, a discourse of lacking alternatives. The only normative proposal they make is: watch us less!
- Katastrophial 9y agoIt's a great presentation of facts into an infographic form that is easily digested by lots of people. It could use some serious fine tuning for grammar though, likely as a result of English being a secondary language. If the guy who owns the website is on here, I'd be happy to help out with the syntax and grammar. PM me, I'd love to help out with this - it's really well laid out.
- vlasev 9y agoSerious question - how viable would it be to implement some sort of data decay? I don't know how it would be implemented, on what schedule, and to what extent.
- jellicle 9y agoIf even one person that has access to it makes a non-decaying copy, the decay has failed...
- dredmorbius 9y agoThat depends on the person and their capabilities. It's more a probability distribution.
- randommm 9y agoIt is obviously bogus that Foucault raised that issue in 1975. For example Erving Goffman introduced the term "Total Institution", which implies total surveillance already in 1961. Subsequently, there have been many public reports concerning the information society and the problem of data bases. For a legal assessment see Westin, Columbia Law Review 1966, pp. 1003ff.
- socialcooling 9y agoIt's not 'obvious'. The goal of that chart is not to be a perfect representation of history. It's to show 'greatest hits'. Foucault was a superstar-philosopher who was a regular TV guest. His panopticon analysis is way more widely know than Goffman's analysis (as much as I love Goffman).
- randommm 9y agoSure. But why this urge to rewrite history then? Just because Foucault is the grandfather or surveillance studies? Why forget all these older and more fruitful discourses?
- dmartinez 9y agoIn the future, the right to anonymity is a right that will become worth fighting for.
- bballer 9y agoThat future is now.
- Symmetry 9y agoRegardless of current issues, I figure that in 30 years everybody will have access to AIs capable of trawling the internet and correlating all my online identities. At least barring things like nuclear war, global draconian censorship, etc. I've taken to just using my real name in most places online to remind me of this. If I'd created this HN account a few years later I'd be AndrewClough rather than Symmetry.
- njarboe 9y agoI had a high school teacher once tell me, "Never write anything down you would not want published in the local paper". This was before the internet and smart phones. It seemed like good and not very restrictive advice that I used as a heuristic for many years. Maybe at that time there was a better balance between personal privacy and society's right to know things about you. Equivalent advice today might be, "Never say or do anything within 100ft of a smart phone or put into a computer anything that you would not want everyone in the world to be able to see now and at all times in the future." That is quite a bit of change and I would feel unjustly controlled following this heuristic.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lithos 9y agoAll of this with 4, different share buttons. Just to flag everyone who visits the site.
- kakarot 9y agoThat's the saddest part. Social beacons are so entrenched in the internet at this point, I don't think we'll ever be able to get rid of the majority of them.
- socialcooling 9y agoThose buttons are privacy-friendly (as stated right above them). They don't load any tracking scripts.
- sn41 9y agoI guess it's time for Samizdat all over again.
- sn41 9y agoIt's like we need Samizdat all over again.
- syphilis2 9y agoIt seems to me we need to write 'privacy in public' into our laws. We've reached a time where government possesses the power to track most citizens simultaneously. Businesses can do the same with everyone they come in contact with, and technology is cheap enough I believe an individual could do a decent job tracking people in his community. We all have to exist in public to some extent, I believe it's reasonable to demand more privacy be extended into public space.
- ika_ 9y agoIt's funny to see this on such a site that shadowbans people who don't confirm.
- grillvogel 9y agothe formatting of this site is truly awful
- captainmuon 9y agoThis sounds like a self-fulfulling prophecy. Tell people that having data of them out there will change their behavior, and then they'll become aware of that idea, and will change their behavior. If they don't know about the concept, they might not. You could even say that this page, and people trying to raise awareness for this issue, are harmful! Imagine a few important people stepping up and saying, no, we will not disadvantage applicants because of their "unprofessional" facebook profiles. In fact, we value authentic, unintimidated people. The act of saying so will make it a little bit so! We need to shift the blame from people expressing themselves, to those people punishing them for it, or even to people giving well-meaning advice like this. (Just a crazy thought I just had. Didn't want to be to harsh with the creator, who raises an important discussion.)
- gedrap 9y ago>>> people trying to raise awareness for this issue, are harmful Harmful for who? If, let's say, they make people actually aware of this, that might lead to change towards privacy. But if people are unaware, and they remain unaware, the probability of change is smaller.
- captainmuon 9y agoThat's what I'm wondering - maybe "privacy" is the chilled state. Maybe what we should be aiming for is not "privacy", but rather being at ease with modern communication. The following is a kind of evil comparison, and I'm sorry, but I can't come up with a better one right now - it's a bit like saying: "If 'chubby' people were aware that they should wear flattering clothes, then this might lead to other people liking them better." - Maybe well-indended advice, but WTF no! You shouldn't tell somebody to hide their body, and likewise you shouldn't tell somebody to hide their emotions, political ideas, drinking pictures, social moments, and so on.
- socialcooling 9y agoIgnorance is not a way out. In 2015 the databroker market was already worth 150 billion dollars in the US alone. (source: FCC report on databrokers)
- SamBoogieNYC 9y agoIf public expression of a thought MAY result in more sophisticated communal understanding revealed by discourse, then it follows that self-censoring said thought MAY result in eliminating more advanced thoughts. That is a real concern to me.
- Mz 9y agoOh. My. God. Fearmongering is everywhere. We also might conclude that "meh, teens getting drunk occasionally" or "meh, people actually having a sex life" is pretty goddamn normal and get over a bunch of nonsense. No matter what goes on around us, we still have a choice in how we interpret things and what kind of world we choose to build. There is zero inevitability here. When Demi Moore posed naked on the cover of a magazine while pregnant, this was some sort of shocking dramatic thing. Now, it seems like every pregnant celebrity does the exact same pose and posts it somewhere. It has become prosaic. Seriously, we can choose to be more humane to people. Things going to hell is not some inevitability. Edit: Maybe a better example is that when 24 hour news channels became a thing, it changed the news. Before that, people were very straight laced and serious for the 30 minutes that they reported the news. This was not sustainable when reporters had to talk live all day, every day. They became less stiff and formal, more able to crack a joke and be human. They still had to treat some subjects with appropriate respect, but 24/7 news channels caused news to lighten up some. Geez.
- gedrap 9y agoI think that one of the reasons why awareness is still relatively low, is that it is often hard to imagine the implications of this for the casual internet user as HN is quite a bubble in this regard. And by implications I mean something more than not seeing job ads, or not getting a loan. Fortunately, there are no such cases that I am aware of. Unfortunately, it might be just a matter of time.
- bogomipz 9y agoI see this chilling effect manifested sometimes on HN as well. People will create throwaway accounts to comment on certain subjects. An example - there was a discussion a couple of days ago about FB and I questioned why a commenter felt the need to create a fake account simply to comment on FB. It turned out they weren't even a current employee but an ex-employee.
- 20170619-2 9y agoon HN, the mods are directly responsible for the chilling effect. they censor anyone who doesn't tow the company line, or has any kind of strong dissenting opinion. this is achieved by shadow bans, single-IP bans, and then finally by flagging every single IP they've ever logged in under as blacklisted for new account creation. i cycled through 3 or 4 accounts with multiple-thousand-points of karma, but in the end i just stopped giving a shit. this sort of amateur-level banning may work against your typical troll, but on HN, the end result is you're wiping out diversity of opinion, because although the people on here are smart and resourceful enough to get around any ban that happens over the internet, at some point it just becomes not worth it just to express your opinion -- that's how censorship actually works in the real world. at the end of the day, YC is a VC and has interests to protect.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"on HN, the mods are directly responsible for the chilling effect. they censor anyone who doesn't tow the company line, or has any kind of strong dissenting opinion ..." What is the company line exactly? Is it just maintaing agreement with YC-backed companies? I hadn't heard about the shadow bans, are they only on submissions or commenting too?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 20170620-5 9y agoI was wondering why no-one was voting or commenting my highly dissenting replies here. Now I have the answer.
- Asooka 9y agoOk, but isn't this the system working as intended? Yes, to me this is absolutely awful, a new form of Gestapo with similar awful consequences, but isn't this exactly what Big Data is supposed to do? Make everyone conform and punish those who step out of line. Just raising awareness won't change anything - the system is working as intended for the people who were sold on it and the people who implemented it (bar a few unfortunate engineers who had to do it for the money). History is rife with examples of people trying to enforce a more rigid social order with varying degrees of success. Letting people different from you have freedom is not something that many people want. Think hard about the last time you thought "the world would be a better place if everyone thought like me". Then realise how many people don't follow that with "but enforcing a mind-police on society is awful".
- rdrey 9y agoHN can help us investigate this phenomenon by tracking how often users click on 'reply' but then shy away from submitting it.
- nxc18 9y agoI've done this multiple times over the last 2ish months, and every time it has been because I don't want to create the wrong perception of myself. In fact, I almost did that with this comment, but decided the irony was too much.
- rdrey 9y agoThen HN can sell the "self-censorship index" data to data brokers... oh, wait. :P
- rXoX 9y agoOnce upon a time, the curator of each projected 'self' was biologically centralized and understood that each version of who we were had to be carefully parsed. There was 'out with the gang at the softball game' Joe, 'straight shooter at the office' Joe, and 'devil may care boyfriend' Joe, and each version understood their self expression within very specific contexts. Now, we have devices in which each version sits alongside the others. So deeply Personal Joe sees no harm in texting naughty messages to his girlfriend one moment, reaming out a coworker for their sloppy reports in an email and then instagramming April's great diving grab at the weekend game a few minutes later. So here we sit, curating the real self, for our new and mysterious friend, "third party". How ya'll liking it?
- mncharity 9y agoHarvard Rescinds Acceptances for At Least Ten Students for Obscene Memes[1]: "Harvard College rescinded admissions offers to at least ten prospective members of the Class of 2021 after the students traded sexually explicit memes and messages that sometimes targeted minority groups in a private Facebook group chat." (June 5) A related NYTimes opinion piece [2] encourages "help young social media users realize that their online and real-life experiences are more intertwined than they may think. Parents might, for example, cite current events, like the Harvard episode, to remind them that nothing online is ever completely private". Which is true, good advice, and social cooling. And the nytimes/reuters version [3] is currently "Page No Longer Available". How does that affect your confidence that "if it was going on, you would know about it"? :) [1] http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2017/6/5/2021-offers-rescinded-memes/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2017/6/5/2021-offers-resci... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/07/well/family/the-secret-social-media-lives-of-teenagers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/07/well/family/the-secret-so... [3] https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2017/06/05/business/05reuters-usa-harvard.html https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2017/06/05/business/05reuter...
- mhh__ 9y agoI know that it's crazy I know that it's nowhere But there is no denying that It's hip to be square ?
- jxramos 9y agowow, this is a huge question and a huge distinction "If they say they don't sell your data, ask if they are selling theirs." I've never even contemplated the ramifications of derived data. Can anyone enlighten the gang about what risks reside along this derived data surface?
- chicob 9y agoI would add that, in an age where old values fade away, people seem to be caught in a strange economy of visible virtue. By reducing moral relativism to the self and ignoring its role in relationships at large, individuality overcomes any collective moral system (be it religious, political or philosophical), and so self-righteousness assumes a form that values spontaneity and originality - the tools of personal promotion - above ethical soundness. This seems to be, in my opinion, the hummus of the most visible social outcry. Social media outrage took the place of discussion, just like opinion articles are taking the place of news reports. Uncritical adherence to this logic harms us all. And the chilling effect strengthens it. In the past, people fought against a static, conservative religious or political moral, in order to make room for individuality, liberty and democracy. Now we have an agglomerate of individual perspectives fighting for visibility in social media, where popularity (by any shallow measure) took the place of reasoning. The chilling effect makes public virtue even more black and white, and conformity (or social cooling) is just settling in either side. Living in the fringe that is refusal of conformity (social heating?) has become more difficult and exhausting than ever... I don't know. Maybe I'm wrong and things were like this for ages. Maybe there is an answer in all the valuable teachings of the past that we simply choose to ignore for the sake of the here and now.