4 ms·
Well I won't add anything on whether this particular study is flawed, though I recognise the same doubts as you. What I can say is it seems like an awfully tir
by lordnacho 9y ago
Well I won't add anything on whether this particular study is flawed, though I recognise the same doubts as you.
What I can say is it seems like an awfully tiresome drudge to replicate someone's statistical analysis. Where's the raw data? How did you clean it? What tests did you run? With what parameters? And what library? It's different in R / Numpy, oh no, another week of sorting the haystack.
It would be easier if there were a GitHub for each study where you could just pull the exact same analysis that the authors did.
Also, I get the feeling most experts see themselves as experts in their particular field. Not surprising, given how people start by studying some subject and then get more and more degrees in it. But actually, the more I read papers from various fields, the more it seems statistics is the critical skill. Domain knowledge is necessary, but it means very little without stats.
Now it would be nice if researchers in every field were also experts in statistics, but I happen to have a friend whose post-doc is to assist biomedical researchers with their stats. So he's a biochem domain expert, but also a stats expert, and the other researchers come to his little group to make sure things are statistically well reasoned.