5 ms·
I feel like articles like this fundamentally miss the point of a peacetime military, which is: 1.) To sit there and look powerful, and ideally dissuade potenti
by nostrademons 9y ago
I feel like articles like this fundamentally miss the point of a peacetime military, which is:
1.) To sit there and look powerful, and ideally dissuade potential adversaries from forcing you to build a wartime military.
2.) To experiment with a bunch of new technologies, so that when you need to go to war, there is some report buried on a bureaucrat's desk detailing precisely the capabilities that the wartime military will have.
3.) To keep military industrial capacity alive, so that you don't have to build new shipyards & tooling from scratch if war breaks up.
4.) To keep military human capital engaged & employed, so that you don't need to train up a generation of engineers to build the tooling to build the war machines that you actually want.
5.) As a form of Keynesian stimulus & political welfare, to redistribute money from wealthy regions of the country to poor regions.
In basically every military conflict since the American revolution, people have found that military doctrine is going to be out-of-date, and all the best tactics & weapon systems you thought you had are largely useless. When Vietnam started, we thought that the war would be conducted through missiles, airplanes, and ICBMS; instead we had a long hard slog of infantry jungle warfare. When Korea started, we thought the next war would be nuclear and over in an hour; instead, jets & amphibious landings had a large place. When WW2 started, we thought we'd have a titanic clash of battleships; instead, the whole naval war was fought by submarines in the Atlantic and aircraft carriers in the Pacific. There's no reason to believe that the next war will be any different; for all we know, it'll be fought with drones in the sky, or hackers in cyberspace, or maybe we'll finally get the nuclear apocalypse that we thought Korea would be.
The point of a peacetime military is to keep options open so that when you find out just how the next war will be fought, there is some low-level engineer, somewhere, who has been experimenting with precisely the technology you need, and can be rapidly promoted and tell everyone else how to do it. Things like the Gerald Ford or F-35 fit right into that strategy. They aren't intended to be fighting machines in their own right; they're floating/flying R&D platforms for developing new technologies, most of which are useless but a couple of which will probably be crucial.
- lambdadmitry 9y agoExactly this. F-35 is a monumental software challenge, it's essentially AR built to military standards on and run on (relatively) weak computers. Throw in a need to invent UI and UX for that to allow the pilot process massive amount of information from the sensor suite. I think the project warrants more respect just for its audacity. It's basically a moonshot project.
- jonknee 9y ago> It's basically a moonshot project. That's good considering it costs several times more than a literal moonshot ($400b vs ~$110b for Apollo in today's dollars). I would describe it as less a moonshot and more a transfer of wealth to military contractors.
- adventured 9y agoThe F35 hasn't cost $400 billion and probably never will (maybe over 40 years with upkeep, spread across all branches and ignoring any foreign sales). The number of planes to be ordered will be cut drastically over the next 10-15 years, as with just about every program from the last few decades. The notion that the US Air Force was ever going to actually purchase ~1700 F35s was a bad joke. They might buy 300 or 400 at a high cost. It's not a great comparison to Apollo anyway, as most of the cost of the F35 program will be spread over decades of maintaining the planes, Apollo's cost was far more concentrated to a short period of time. If we had to keep the Apollo program up to those former levels on a perpetual basis, adjusted to today's costs, the cost would be running in the trillions.
- jonknee 9y ago> It's not a great comparison to Apollo anyway, as most of the cost of the F35 program will be spread over decades of maintaining the planes, Apollo's cost was far more concentrated to a short period of time. FWIW the $400b figure is to buy the planes, the Pentagon estimates a further $1 trillion to maintain them.
- adventured 9y agoI understand. I'm saying that will never occur. They're not going to ever actually buy all of those planes, and the maintenance cost will be far lower accordingly. All you have to do is look at the F22 program to understand what's actually going to happen; there are numerous other recent examples of how they tend to slash & burn on ordering however. Ten years out they'll be on to the new new thing, and they'll be slashing the purchase program toward zero accordingly. The planes are costing $93 million per unit currently, they'll buy less than 500-600 of them across all branches of the military, that's ~$60 billion, give or take $10-$15 billion on cost inflation over 10 years. Then reduce the maintenance cost accordingly for that number versus the laughable former numbers (thousands? ha ha ha).
- mayneack 9y agoIn what definition is this peacetime?
- valuearb 9y agoWe have more aircraft carriers than the rest of the world combined. Russia has one decrepit carrier, China has only one too. Our 10 biggest carriers are all twice the size of the next largest carriers in the rest of the world Spending money on the military isn't a "stimulus", it's very a very damaging drain on the economy. The workers and engineers building those carriers and planes could be building commercial ships, cars, buildings, airliners, and developing new technologies for commercial use. We are sacrificing all those things to fund a military that is nearly irrelevant when we have the largest nuclear deterrent in the world.
- nostrademons 9y agoDo we actually need more of any of the above? (Now, if you'd said roads, bridges, dams, and basic research, you might have a point...ostensibly there is bipartisan interest in infrastructure repairs this term, we'll see if they get it done.) The point of Keynesian spending is that as productivity increases, markets tend to saturate, and money ends up in the hands of those with a lower marginal propensity to consume. Redistribution - by any means, whether it's welfare, infrastructure, basic income, or defense spending - puts money back in the hands of those with a higher propensity to consume, which then raises aggregate demand and raises total economic output.
- valuearb 9y agoKeynesian spending is a myth. It all gets spent, even savings.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt's not so much a myth as that the saving/spending dichotomy is an oversimplification; the real distinction relevant to national policy is the velocity of spending induced in the domestic economy. While even saving induces spending, it does so at a lower domestic velocity, on average, than consumer spending.
- lambdadmitry 9y agoIt's not about the number of carriers, it's about the ability to project enough power to reach political goals. In most cases you are not competing with other countries' carries, you are competing with land-based assets (airbases, railways, etc.). For that you may need a lot of very big carriers