4 ms·
I'll be the negative Nancy here - you'll never get 1000 people to pay $400 each for any OSS software, no matter the price of the competitor. The reason is a si
by falcolas 9y ago
I'll be the negative Nancy here - you'll never get 1000 people to pay $400 each for any OSS software, no matter the price of the competitor.
The reason is a simple value estimation. It's open source (and so free to get) therefore its price is $0. Any product that is free signals that the product has correspondingly low value. I think it's simply unrealistic to expect people to put forward $400 for something with such low value perception and whose fair market price is $0.
This is especially true when Photoshop has such a high value perception (in part because it is better, and in part as a justification for shelling out the $400).
Ask yourself this - Have you, or will you, paid (donated, ...) $70 for using Vim (atom, neovim, emacs, VSC, ...) to support development? Have you paid $200 to Debian, Ubuntu, or Redhat for your Linux OS? $5,000 for (open|libre)ssl? $13,000 per core for PostgreSQL/MySQL?
- jkeat 9y agoIf I could count on the 999 other people, Kickstarter-style, I just might.
- grogenaut 9y agoWell... Set it up
- falcolas 9y agoHe'd also need the GIMP devs to cooperate: to provide tangible feature sets with timelines, part time PR for updating and managing the Kickstarter campaign, and an part time CFO for managing the sudden influx and management of $360,000 (minus Kickstarter and the payment processor's share), dev salaries, taxes, and such. I would be curious if the GIMP dev team could reach usability parity with Photoshop on only that money. It seems a bit on the low side frankly (about a year's time of a good developer and UX designer, plus support staff).
- masukomi 9y agohe could always fork it and pay for other developers if the core team didn't want to participate in this. You'd rather the core team's approval and participation, but you don't NEED it.
- blunte 9y agoCall it Pimp. I would say that I'm in too, but I also need a quality Illustrator alternative that works well on Mac.
- cacarr 9y agoI assume you've tried Inkscape?
- rhaps0dy 9y agoTo cacarr: Inkscape is not at its best in Mac. It's clunky because you have to use control instead of command, can't zoom with the trackpad, can't go fullscreen. I use it and love it and it's one of my favourite programs, but really it's better in Linux.
- grogenaut 9y agoA key mapping function sounds like one of them more easy things to add into a piece of software
- falcolas 9y agoIf you don't get their support, then that $400,000 has to go a lot further (or you have to work towards a branch reconciliation at the end of the work). Ongoing maintenance is not free.
- ethanwillis 9y agoI'm in.
- e12e 9y agoI think something more limited (like get GEGL out the door, if that isn't done yet) along the lines of the Django migrations kickstarter would be more realistic: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andrewgodwin/schema-migrations-for-django https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andrewgodwin/schema-mig...
- paultopia 9y agoYeah. This is a classic free rider problem. Game theorists have known about it for decades. See Mancur Olson, The Logic of Collective Action.
- GoToRO 9y agoAlso, Free software, creates a large tree at $0 that will kill everything that tries to grow under it, like a $5 decent alternative (nothing grows under large trees).
- adekok 9y ago> you'll never get 1000 people to pay $400 each for any OSS software, no matter the price of the competitor. Yes and no. I'm doing that right now... The key is that I don't charge for the software as such. I charge for services, etc. around the software. People are happy to pay for value-add, even if the underlying software is free. You just need to show value-add...
- justboxing 9y ago> The key is that I don't charge for the software as such. I charge for services, etc. around the software. Yep. Matt Mullenweg & his crew at WordPress have been doing the same thing, and are wildly profitable at it.
- m1sta_ 9y agoIt's not just about profit. It's about lifestyle.
- falcolas 9y agoSure - but then you're not really charging $400 for the software. You're charging $400 for the services associated with that software, and a (typically significant) portion of that money will go towards funding the service, not the OSS software. This change in how the money is allocated is a subtle, but important, distinction. Monetizing a service means you now have a minimum of two products to manage, and from my time at a company which did exactly this I've found that the OSS software development is the product which absorbs any shortfalls. It's hard to watch the budget for OSS development shrink constantly; to watch developers passionate about the OSS software being reassigned to grow the service instead. It's probably still the best way to handle a crummy situation, but it's not what the OP described.
- e12e 9y agoI don't know. 1000 is [ed: not] that large a number of people. But it might be easier to get 40 from 10.000 people, than 400 from a thousand. I'm reminded about the kickstarter for Django migrations: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andrewgodwin/schema-migrations-for-django https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/andrewgodwin/schema-mig... Most backers gave 5 or 10 pounds, but on average ~500 people gave ~35 each. You might be half-right about perceived value though - I think anyone that is a serious Gimp user see value in the software, but might still think 400 is too steep, given that it is free now. But I also think many users would be willing to pay for getting some features in/some polish done - personally I'd say my current limit would be around 100 USD for any one OSS project. Now one one hand, Debian does much more than any small project, but I also think it's more likely that 10 000 USD would do more for something like the Gimp, than for Debian (assuming we had a developer or two on standby that could take the opportunity of devoting a month full time on getting some pain points resolved, say).