9 ms·
Berkeley’s Attack on Housing
- aphextron 9y agoCan anyone seriously use the term "Affordable housing" in Berkeley with a straight face? The median home value has just crossed 1 million dollars, which buys you a single floor 2 bedroom bungalow. It is very clear that the current homeowners of Berkeley are just fine with the way things are.
- osdiab 9y agoUnfortunately, the young people who are subject to the rental market are also very politically inactive when it comes to local politics. Berkeley residents - how about next time you protest, focus not only on national politics but also on your own city's issues!!
- jstalin 9y agoIt's a lot more fun to dress in all black, scream at people, and riot.
- aphextron 9y agoAnd thus we are left to renting out a baby boomer's garden shack for the cost of a mortgage.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThis is their retirement plan.
- seanp2k2 9y agoThis is, for those unfamiliar with the situation there, not actually an exaggeration, but literally what one of my friends was doing. It had been converted to a "cottage" and it was one room with a bathroom in the corner. FWIW it was pretty cute, but it was about $2k a month and had no dedicated parking. Climate control was "it gets hot in the sun, open the windows to cool it down" plus a space heater she had. The people living there bought the house decades ago and paid less on the mortgage for the entire property than what they rented out the cottage for. How do we fix this?
- zipfle 9y agoWe could try to regulate away the good fortune of the people who bought the house, or we could try to convince the tech industry that they actually don't all need to be colocated, alleviating competition for resources in that area. What I've observed about human nature suggests that neither would be very popular.
- justin 9y agoOr we could build more housing
- WillPostForFood 9y agoOr you could move somewhere cheaper
- Decade 9y agoThat actually does happen. And then we have the twisted situation where the economists say the economy is great, practically zero unemployment, even construction workers are scarce in California; and at the same time workforce participation rates for working-age males is the lowest it has ever been. Given how terrible idle males tend to be, this is worrisome. http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-labor-force-men-20161121-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-labor-force-men-201611... People used to move to cities for the opportunities. Now it's increasingly difficult to do so. For lots of reasons we need to make it possible for people to move to the cities and thrive.
- seanp2k2 9y agoSuburbs in most places = medium-low pay but fairly cheap housing country = cheap housing, no [tech] jobs Metro areas (more dense than suburbs, less dense than cities...e.g. most of the Bay Area) = expensive housing, medium or high pay Cities = extremely expensive, high pay (for tech jobs) Pretty much every scenario seems to be "optimized" to have techies paying 30-50% of their monthly income to housing. You can't really win, but you can attempt to maximize the real dollar amount you end up left over with with each month. Working remotely is "cheating the system" and is therefore largely disallowed, or "work from home" is allowed only to quell some degree of outrage. Literally the industry that invented video chat doesn't [want to] understand how to use it to work remotely.
- Mz 9y agoBut then when they fail, they would have to feel incompetent. It is generally more gratifying to rage against the machine in a way that is unlikely to accomplish something so you don't have to take it personally when it doesn't work, because no one expected it to anyway.
- mjevans 9y agoHow are you supposed to gain representation within an area that you literally cannot live within (even though you work / receive education there) due to a lack of (affordable) housing?
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoTake a look at drivers license address requirements [1], and figure out how to game it. Or some other form of identification. The system generally assumes that if you can reliably receive mail address to you at a particular residential address and you tell institutions that you live there, then you live there - at least until more detailed probing happens. [1] https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/dl/residency_requirement https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/dl/residency_requir...
- mjevans 9y agoMy point was more that in the modern world people's interests likely cover a span or several spans of regions. Not just one single locality. Sometimes (near state lines in the US) not even /state/ level laws would provide adequate representational coverage. A more accurate way of providing representation might be to identify areas of major expenditure. Employment, Education, Living, etc. Aside from residency should be either by some absolute threshold of transaction value or possibly by percentage of income. A significant economic interest in an area should be related to representation in that area (as you are being taxed for your activity there). Corridors that connect those areas should also apply (you do have to traverse them for your interests); transit and transit related laws should thus probably be at a major metro or higher level.
- yonran 9y agoYou can get involved in regional planning (such as Plan Bay Area and the RHNA) and support state bills (such as Scott Wiener’s SB-35) that put more power in regional commissions that have more equal representation. Some Berkeley NIMBYs actually have the gall to claim that cities’ rights over zoning is pro-democratic (such as Zelda Bronstein (https://48hills.org/2016/11/28/17209/ https://48hills.org/2016/11/28/17209/) and Thomas Lord (http://48hills.org/2017/05/19/why-housing-quotas-lead-to-displacement/) http://48hills.org/2017/05/19/why-housing-quotas-lead-to-dis...), whereas as you point out it, hyper-local zoning disenfranchises commuters (https://pedestrianobservations.com/2016/06/18/a-theory-of-zoning-and-local-decisionmaking/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2016/06/18/a-theory-of-zo...). When people say that cities’ rights are pro-democracy, call them out on it. Edit: Also add public comment on zoning decisions that affect you even if you cannot vote.
- jedberg 9y ago> Unfortunately, the young people who are subject to the rental market are also very politically inactive when it comes to local politics. Quite true. Also, they don't actually care all that much, because most of them have their housing subsidized by federal loans or their wealthy parents or both.
- taysic 9y agoFrom what I understand, they are squeezed like sardines to a room though. I would imagine they care - or maybe they don't know how good it can be. I was lucky to have easy access to a single room in college in the middle of an east coast city.
- jedberg 9y ago> they are squeezed like sardines to a room though Yeah but that's been true for a long time. When I attended I had a friend who rented a piece of wood suspended above the laundry room of a frat house for $150/mo (while I paid $400/mo to share a one bedroom unit).
- Decade 9y agoThere's affordable housing, and then there's Affordable Housing. Some of the restricted Affordable Housing actually is pretty expensive, while still being too scarce for the demand. https://medium.com/@Scott_Wiener/market-rate-housing-isnt-a-bad-word-and-we-won-t-solve-the-housing-crisis-without-it-ce67c06aff4d https://medium.com/@Scott_Wiener/market-rate-housing-isnt-a-...
- inostia 9y agoAnother example of how "progressives" in Berkeley are all for progressive policies (and driving a Prius) until they conflict with their NIMBY attitude towards their home values. Holdovers from the 60's and 70's who have seen their home values skyrocket and now want to prevent building of newer rental units (the "Missing Middle", 3-8 unit, smaller apartment buildings).
- orblivion 9y agoMy favorite was seeing a "Bernie Sanders: breaking the class ceiling" sign in front of someone's house in the damn hills.
- zhemao 9y agoDuring the primary season, I saw a Bernie Sanders sign in a window (I think it was their local campaign HQ) and a homeless man sleeping in front of it.
- unclesaamm 9y agoThere is a broad coalition of people who are excited about socialist ideas. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- orblivion 9y agoFine, but if they're honest, it should be the "class floor" coming from them.
- davidw 9y agoVery relevant: http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-liberal-aspirations-and-liberal-housing-policy-is-killing-coastal-u-s-cities/ http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-...
- inostia 9y agoThanks for this. Also relevant, recent article about this issue in Oakland: http://www.oaklandmagazine.com/May-2017/The-Real-Cause-of-Gentrification/ http://www.oaklandmagazine.com/May-2017/The-Real-Cause-of-Ge...
- api 9y agoI've always seen this kind of unhinged NIMBYism as a backdoor passive aggressive way to implement housing discrimination, though more based on class than race. It's a way of making sure the "wrong people" (poor people, usually minorities) can't live there. I almost have more respect for all the neo-fascists who are just openly racist and elitist. At least they're being honest about how they feel.
- lstyls 9y agoClass is often backdoor racism too. Structural racism is a huge driver of class division in the US.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoIs there a good place to read more about that? I haven't seen a good study on teasing apart cultural, class, and racial discrimination in terms of contribution to outcomes.
- lstyls 9y agoTa-Nehisi Coates covered it in both depth and breadth in this article: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-cas.... Class divisions due to race were cemented by slavery, jim crow, redlining, and the criminal justice system. Nimbyism parallels redlining in certain ways now that I think about it.
- exclusiv 9y agoThis hidden racism is rampant among the leftists. They start their policy-making by assuming that minorities can't do certain things. They make themselves feel better by telling themselves they are helping out the disadvantaged. But they really have a disdain for minorities. They don't see them as capable citizens, even when those things are basic. Example: they think Voter ID laws are racist because they think black people and other minorities can't find or get to a DMV or don't have internet [1] They want artisanal-everything, Whole Foods and similar which is also a way to push out those that can't afford those things. I hear them talk about moving to these hipster places that are "up and coming". I know what they really mean. A gentrifying place where they can be surrounded by people just like them, with the same views, the same interests, similar occupations and similar social status. [1] https://pjmedia.com/video/what-berkeley-liberals-think-of-voter-id-laws-vs-what-actual-harlem-black-people-think/#comments https://pjmedia.com/video/what-berkeley-liberals-think-of-vo...
- TulliusCicero 9y agoBeing anti-housing in urban areas doesn't just hurt the poor and middle class. It's also definitively anti-environment. The people who would've ended up in new housing don't just disappear into the ether; they end up living in some further out suburb, where they contribute to encroaching on nature, and where they have longer, more energy-intensive commutes. To be an environmentalist and a NIMBY is a contradiction in terms. The bay area, unfortunately, is chock full of hypocrites of this sort.
- ScottBurson 9y agoSomeone else posted this link in response to another comment, but I think it's more relevant to yours: http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-liberal-aspirations-and-liberal-housing-policy-is-killing-coastal-u-s-cities/ http://marketurbanism.com/2017/01/27/the-disconnect-between-... Here's a quote: In many metro areas, household emissions in the suburbs are roughly double those of city households.
- santaclaus 9y ago> The bay area, unfortunately, is chock full of hypocrites of this sort. Cough San Francisco Sierra Club Cough
- davidw 9y agoRelevant links about SF Sierra Club: https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/05/31/san-franciscos-sierra-club-is-a-bastion-of-faux-environmentalism/#4e52b1527c34 https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/05/31/san-franc... They're fighting to preserve a.... car garage. http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-fights-to-savea-parking-garage http://thebaycitybeacon.com/32740/282282/a/the-sierra-club-f...
- Spooky23 9y agoGeorge Washington had his oil changed there!
- kevinburke 9y ago
- jedberg 9y agoAs a previous student and renter, and a current landlord in Berkeley, I can tell you exactly why this happens. Students don't vote in city elections for the most part. The city council represents the homeowners and long time residents. The homeowners want their property values to go up, so most of them oppose more housing. The long time residents inexplicably hate students and "what the students do to this city" despite the fact that the University was there before every single person who live there now. So the city council does everything it can to keep those property values high, since the students are a captive audience and will rent no matter what, and for the most part don't care what the cost is because their upper middle class parents and/or the federal government is picking up the bill until they graduate. I personally do my small part by keeping the rent on our place below market, as close to our actual costs as possible. The appreciation on the property value is nice, but the steady income is really what Berkeley property is good for. In 19 years I've had three months of vacancy, and two of those were because I was renovating and one was because my tenants left in a odd month.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI'm confused by these two statements: "as close to our actual costs as possible." "but the steady income is really what Berkeley property is good for" Wouldn't 'as close to costs as possible' be exactly what it costs to maintain the property (insurance, maintenance / upgradtes, rates, etc) thereby eating all the steady income.
- maxsilver 9y agoThere's a big difference between self-imposing a 15% profit margin, or taking the "market rate" 150%+ profit margin.
- jedberg 9y ago> Wouldn't 'as close to costs as possible' be exactly what it costs to maintain the property (insurance, maintenance / upgradtes, rates, etc) thereby eating all the steady income. Yes. We basically break even, including the cost of the mortgage. The idea is to own the property outright in 30 years, and then slowly ramping up the profits but still staying below market rate. Or simply sell the property. But the point is it's a long term investment and savings account, that doesn't depend on the value to go up. If I wanted to be more rational I would add in a small return on capital as a cost, which would still have me be below market, just less so.
- fiter 9y agoI hope "Ecocity Berkeley"[0] (written 1987!) can become a reality. It's exactly the idea that many have commented about: increase density, increase parks, and reduce sprawl. This is a vision to strive for instead of just preserving whatever state we're currently in. [0] https://books.google.com/books/about/Ecocity_Berkeley.html?id=QYE-Q8MAF3MC https://books.google.com/books/about/Ecocity_Berkeley.html?i...
- natrius 9y agoYou're going to read a page full of comments that agree with this, which is great. But you need to change it. You need to join an organization that will show you how to fight for policies that make our cities open to all. Find your local pro-housing organization and join it. Let people live where they want.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI'm coming to suspect a common trait of goods whose primary or significant function is as an asset that there are built-in incentives to seek the value inflation of those assets. This happens across asset classes, but there are at least two significant distinctions: * Purely financial assets: money, stocks, bonds, etc. * Productive assets, most especially Maslovian assets: those which provide necessities of life. Purely financial assets can absorb inflation without inherently creating dislocations in the productive economy. This isn't to say that they don't risk bubbles or other issues, only that there's no inherent need for a person to have, say, a specific quantity of stock or money (excepting ongoing expenses for the latter). Pricing up productive assets is another story -- two roles, wealth preservation, and productive use, are in conflict. The problem is, from a rational perspective, it makes sense for the owners of such goods to seek value appreciation. This doesn't translate to an increase in real economic growth, but it does increase the owner's claims to such growth. Through leverage, debt, and lending collateral, there are knock-on effects to other agents as well: a bank whose core asset (and lending reserve) is the market value of its real-estate portfolio benefits by increased valuation of that portfolio. I'm not entirely sure what if any solutions might exist, though I'm partial to the concept of a land tax (or more generally: a held-asset tax), which increases ongoing carrying costs, and encourges more intensive utilisation of high-value property. I'm also interested in what areas don't have this problem, and what policies or other conditions tend away from it.
- berkeleyguy 9y agoI've lived in downtown berkeley for five years and pay 1100 per month for a studio apartment. For those arguing that the city could zone and facilitate building affordable non subsidized housing, where exactly would it be built? There isn't an abundance of empty lots AFAIK and it seems enormous highrises would have to be built in large numbers to make any dent in having prices come down. I would love more options but without even mildly specific suggestions articles like these seem to lack any pragmatism.
- inostia 9y agoWhy not relaxing rules for property owners to build units in their own backyards? See https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/16/us/california-today-housing-crisis.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/16/us/california-today-housi...
- berkeleyguy 9y agoCoach house airbnbs and one off rentals could be great or terrible. In either case I think its hard to argue this would get rents to go down. My personal bet is the proliferation of these cute backyard dwellings would actually make rents go higher because these would go for a premium over 50 year old crummy spots.
- taysic 9y ago"She spent about $100,000 to add a cottage in her backyard in Berkeley in 2011, and has been renting it out for between $1,500 and $2,000 a month. It paid for itself in under five years, she said." Why do they need to be relaxed if its already profitable to build one? I wonder what about building such a unit requires too much red tape. Too bad they don't go into it in the article.
- closeparen 9y agoThere is a specific movement to increase the minimum lot size you need to build one, which would remove the possibility of more than 100 such units.
- 9y ago
- berkeleyguy 9y agoActual UC Berkeley dorm prices. http://www.housing.berkeley.edu/rates http://www.housing.berkeley.edu/rates I'm not sure if these are at/over capacity, but how do non students feel about these prices?
- fiter 9y agoNote that this includes 10 meals per week. Maybe that's worth $200/mo.
- berkeleyguy 9y agoIt definitely is if you were to use it. In either case, as a public institution there may be a cap on the cost of these spots, and should be required reading for any critique/support of the Berkeley student impact on housing prices in Berkeley. Typically these articles paint a picture of students rolling in as if they were forced into a 3000/mo condo.
- taysic 9y ago$1500/mo for a single room where you share a bathroom seems like a lot to me. Not $3000 but still a _lot_ for a college student imo. $1000/mo to share a room of 4? Wow!
- somecontext 9y agoAccording to http://www.housing.berkeley.edu/policies http://www.housing.berkeley.edu/policies and other related pages online it appears that a student only receives this room from approximately August 15 to May 14, with a mandatory move-out for three weeks during Christmas break. That is only ~250 days of housing. Thus, the price of a quad room is even more, at ~$1,580/month, disregarding the inconvenience of the move-out. The single room with shared bathroom works out to ~$2,200/month. In-suite is more, at ~$2,400/month.
- csharpminor 9y agoI think it's worth actually reading the piece of legislation for the housing fee: http://www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/Clerk/City_Council/2017/06_June/Documents/2017-06-13_Item_53_Supplemental_Report.aspx http://www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/Clerk/City_Council/2017/06_June... From what I've gathered, the additional fee is designed to incentivize developers to include at least 20% affordable housing units in new projects. If you're building less than 20% affordable housing, you pay a sliding-scale fee. That money goes to supporting staff in the city that monitor and enforce affordable housing regulations. I can definitely see the opposing policy argument here: just remove incentives on developers and let the market figure it out. However, I don't think Item #53 is some kind of scheme to keep housing unaffordable on the part of home owners. I wasn't able to find the de-zoning item in the agenda, if anyone knows which one it is I'd definitely give it a read. Full agenda here: http://www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/Clerk/City_Council/2017/06_June/City_Council__06-13-2017_-__Regular_Meeting_Agenda.aspx http://www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/Clerk/City_Council/2017/06_June...
- Upvoter33 9y agoThere is an answer here: move slowly. Add a little bit of dense housing and show home owners that the price of their housing isn't affected. Continue to do so over many years to allow people who spent a lot of $$$ to get into the housing market to get out w/o losing a lot of investment. Rapid change is the big enemy and what people fear here -- and why liberals end up voting against very progressive policies...