10 ms·
Anatomy of a Noob - Why your Mom Suck at Computers
- tkahn6 16y agoIt would help me a lot if you defined what you mean by 'holistic' since you use it frequently in your article. I'm not familiar with this term used in other contexts besides medicine. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/holistic http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/holistic isn't very helpful and the term remains rather opaque.
- someone_here 16y agoI think someone did a find-and-replace for the word "Naturally".
- ThomPete 16y agoHmm thought that expression was well known also outside medicine? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holism
- tkahn6 16y agoI guess that would make me ignorant in that respect. The first paragraph of the wiki article clears it up for me. Thanks.
- elblanco 16y agoholistic is generally used to mean "in its entirety" or "across the whole".
- adambard 16y agoIf it was spelled "wholistic" it would be a bit more intuitive, if more confusing phonetically.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoI like 'Bablefish'.
- kiba 16y agoWell, some people like to say that there is nothing "intuitive" about User Interface whatsoever, even for Mac systems. I don't know if it is true, but it does seem to have some air of truth around it.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoOf course it's true. I mean, why would it be "intuitive" to drag the floppy disk into the trash-can to eject it? As the article points out, we're trying to rely on metaphors to ease the learning curve for users, but metaphors, like all abstractions, are leaky. When we call a UI "intuitive", what we are really saying is that the metaphors chosen enable those who understand the metaphor to leverage this understanding to intuit how to operate the UI. EDIT: added final para.
- Xurinos 16y agoThat was a long way to say that when we call a UI "intuitive", we really mean that it is "familiar". Hopefully this comment clarifies for others what was meant by the metaphors. http://www.asktog.com/papers/raskinintuit.html http://www.asktog.com/papers/raskinintuit.html
- michael_dorfman 16y agoBut the use of the term "familiar" here is, alley oop, a metaphor. Which is what Raskin takes the long way to say in the article you reference. My point is: this problematic does not only apply to UI design. In general, whenever we use abstraction (which we do all the time, often in the name of brevity) we are taking a risk-- and one of those risks, to extend Raskin's metaphor, is uncanniness.
- stcredzero 16y agoAnother thing to note is that many truly intuitive things are not necessarily easy at least at first. Riding a bicycle is in fact intuitive, but many find it difficult in the beginning. Snowboarding and skiing are also intuitive, but people often experience a significant learning curve. Heck, flying a plane is definitely intuitive, but it takes a large number of hours to be considered good enough to do it on your own. EDIT: The ultimate example is flying a helicopter. All of the parts of a helicopter are so dynamically linked, a simply described operation like "move to the right" is going to take a bunch of simultaneous adjustments on several controls at once. There is actually no way to fly a helicopter, except intuitively, and it's definitely not easy at first.
- stcredzero 16y agoWhen I was a TA in grad school, I had one student who couldn't double click. To double click, she'd take her hand off of the mouse, hover her palm a few inches above the mouse, then stab down twice with her finger. Doing this, she'd move the mouse while clicking the button, so her double clicks never registered. I kept telling her to leave her hand on the mouse and just press twice with her finger, but to my knowledge, she never tried it. This was the same class where I tried to use the theory of evolution as an example, and about half the class laughed, because to them the theory was just a ridiculous idea. Gotta love the Bible belt! EDIT: I think there's two keys to the true intuitiveness of an interface that many people overlook. It's easier to make an intuitive interface if you narrow the domain of an interface. It's also easier if you narrow the effective bandwidth of the interface -- show the user more data and they tend to be more confused, show the user less data and they tend to be less confused. Apple seems to apply this in Front Row and in iOS.
- thaumaturgy 16y ago> When I was a TA in grad school, I had one student who couldn't double click. This isn't at all uncommon actually, especially among adults age 50+. Double-clicking a mouse requires a certain amount of manual dexterity, but we've all forgotten that because we developed it a long time ago and to such an extent that it's become effortless.
- thangalin 16y agoRecommend they get a trackball; a big, beefy beast that can be slowed to a crawl. Better for the neck, better for double-clicking, and easier for positioning the cursor (especially if they have Parkinson's). http://cil614.files.wordpress.com/2007/11/kensington_trackball.jpg http://cil614.files.wordpress.com/2007/11/kensington_trackba...
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>To double click, she'd take her hand off of the mouse, hover her palm a few inches above the mouse, then stab down twice with her finger. Perhaps she was dyspraxic? Presumably you (or the person responsible) set the middle button to double click or used some other mouse accessibility fix?
- patio11 16y agoOne quick tip for describing things to non-technical customers: tell them everything three times. Don't tell them to click the "sign in link". (Don't ever use the word link. You'll regret it. "Button that says...", "picture that says...", "underlined blue text that says...") Tell them to click the + purple button + which says Sign In + near the top-right corner of their screen. You will be amazed how much more effective that makes them at carrying out directions. (If you can only pick one, go for color or similar visual distinctiveness. Your users have long-since stopped reading everything on their computer because "none of it makes sense anyhow.") In my experience it is worth overruling your designer's desire for visual continuity and having your most important button(s) be uniquely identifiable by color. (Strictly speaking I use purple for two things, but if they try to sign in by signing up for the free trial they'll be signed in like they intended.)
- ori_b 16y agoIt's even easier to walk someone through with a command line. I've done it, reciting the magic incantations for the Windows recovery command line to a relative who didn't even know the difference between Windows and Office. It was painful, but I relish the idea of walking someone through a GUI to do it even less.
- Jach 16y agoHow did you get the person to understand the concept of "what the command printed out"? I don't know how many times I had to say "Yeah, but look above the dollar sign, was there any text printed out between the current dollar sign and the last one?" The person I was talking to always would complain "IT DID NOTHING I'M BACK TO THE SAME THING." I eventually got through it by getting them on IM and giving them text to copy-paste, and sometimes they'd send me screenshots.
- ori_b 16y ago"Can you read back the last three or four lines on the screen, please?"
- cypherdog 16y agoI don't think this applies to my Mom. She is 50 years old and has installed harddrives (both scsi & ide), memory, formated and installed Windows 98,XP,ME (blah) and 7. Set up her own wireless. She calls me every-now-and-then for tech support, though honestly, the level of questions she asks have shot ahead of me, since I've been on a Mac since 05' and hate messing with hardware now. You'd be surprised how much a game like the Sim's can motivate a person to pick this stuff up.
- trafficlight 16y agoShe is definitely an outlier.
- hy3lxs 16y agoUser interfaces my mother doesn't understand: - Running multiple applications at the same time is too confusing. She doesn't understand/notice the taskbar. She always tries to close one thing before starting another. Also, she doesn't notice that she has four copies of gmail open in the same browser -- since she doesn't understand what tabs are either. - Window geometry is never manipulated. She has never maximized, minimized, or resized a window. - As a result of the first two problems, inter-window operations such as drag and drop, cut and paste are often impossible. - She doesn't know when it's correct to left click, right click, or double left click to do what she wants. So she opts for double-clicking on everything: links, buttons, menus, credit card purchases... - She used to have 10 different "toolbars" activated in word 2003 because she couldn't find the button she needed, and they are randomly positioned everywhere because of accidental dragging (probably from overzealous double-clicking). Then one day she accidentally dragged the main toolbar offscreen, and was no longer able to open, save, or print... - Corollary to above -- she avoids menus, since they appear to her as a hierarchical wall of text full of jargon. Also, they are difficult to use when you tend to over-double-click, since they close themselves... - Activating Chinese UI in i18n-enabled programs it is often detrimental, as she doesn't have the tech vocabulary in Chinese either, and it just makes it harder for me to help her remotely. - She clicks on a word doc attachment in gmail, spends hours editing it, and can never find the file again, because it's really called "C:\Documents and Settings\Username\Temp\awq2a393.doc" - She will click OK on any dialog box to make it go away, because she is trained to close dialog boxes that way. Even if the dialog box is a security popup warning for a sketchy activeX control. - She calls firefox "the google" because it was installed by google pack, and opens to the google homepage. She doesn't know the difference between the browser and the internet. - She doesn't understand why she can't print a web page and have it look nice, without all the extra columns of ad junk. + Okay, one thing that does work well for her -- hitting control key twice accesses google desktop search popup to find anything -- even those annoying files in TEMP. She can remember that shortcut. Once ipad gets traditional chinese support -- I'm going to get her one, and cut my tech support calls by 90%...
- stcredzero 16y agoRunning multiple applications at the same time is too confusing. She doesn't understand/notice the taskbar. She always tries to close one thing before starting another. Machines with multiple functions/modes/uses are a generational thing. Up until the late 70's hardly anyone ever encountered a profoundly multi-function device before. Multitasking devices didn't come into mainstream use until later. Think about it, isn't it weird to have something that can be one kind of appliance, then after activating one control, have it change into a different kind of thing altogether? That would be like a fruit that resembles a pear when you peel it one way but an orange when you peel it another. One can buy an actual crowbar/plier/wirecutter/hammer/wrench/screwdriver. A lot of people probably find it easier to have 1 tool for each purpose and grab the right one. Does anyone remember the 1970's? Just how well would a TV/typewriter/stereo/VCR/telephone/phonograph/answering machine have sold? I think most people's eyes would've glazed over. Well, the personal computer has functions that subsume all of those devices, and the eyes of a lot of adults who were alive back then do glaze over when they encounter one.
- kscaldef 16y agoMy mother has been a practicing computer scientist for 40 years and doesn't particularly appreciate your stereotypes.
- freakwit 16y agoBut isn't it interesting that she gets her child to make a comment on HN instead of writing it herself?
- alnayyir 16y agoI don't usually say things like this, but... `hahahaha, buuuuuurn` That said, we're the kids of the world by most standards (median age). You think Thompson or Pike chill on here?
- kenjackson 16y agoDidn't his mom notice that the cursor moved the opposite direction? That's the first thing my mom would've said: "This mouse is broken".
- ThomPete 16y agoNo she didn't unfortunately. Mind you the mouse is an abstraction, which means it can be interpreted in many ways. Inverted mouse used to be natural in fps games and still is in flight simulators. A touch screen on the other hand that don't register where you click but just randomly chose coordinates now that would be noticed.
- arghnoname 16y agoOne of my aunts got my grandmother a computer 10 years ago or so. She had actually operated old IBM machines for accounting back many moons ago, but hadn't used a computer otherwise. When I went to her house I got on her computer and said, "where's the mouse?" She didn't know what I was talking about, of course. She sewed a lot, so when I discovered that she thought it was some kind of foot pedal, I guess that makes sense. These things are always illuminating. "Scroll up" gets a confused expression. She initially just tried moving the mouse. Click the scrollbar. What's that? How do you click? The button on the mouse? Which one? Do I click and release or hold the click? etc... It's amazing how many minor details we can't help but take for granted.
- LiveTheDream 16y agoI learned long ago to never do family tech support over the phone. Use screensharing -- TeamViewer FTW. Even the most non-technical person can open up a teamviewer session and you can take it from there.
- danudey 16y agoDespite my parents asking me what kind of computer they should get, and me telling them they should get a Mac, they keep getting Windows machines. They don't call me for tech support that often (they're pretty clever folk), but usually when they do I'm out hiking or at the mall or something, so I offer a few suggestions, then honestly say 'Well I dunno, I don't use Windows so I've never encountered that.' The only real problems they've called with recently though are 'suddenly I can't get on the internet' problems, which is usually solved by saying "look in the Add/Remove Programs control panel for anything that says 'Norton' or 'Symantec', then uninstall it and reboot" TL;DR: After a few weeks/months/years of Mac use, you can disclaim all knowledge of Windows to family members. Symantec sucks.
- listic 16y agoSo, why does my Mom actually suck at computers? Is it because computer interface designers suck at design?