4 ms·
That isn't a bus, that is car hire. Busses and other public transport work well because you have a route which makes it predictable people know when and where t
by dogma1138 9y ago
That isn't a bus, that is car hire.
Busses and other public transport work well because you have a route which makes it predictable people know when and where they can get onto a bus, and where they can get off and how long the ride will take.
There is no point of using 50+ people bus as an Uber.
A small car service would be better for that, it's also the reason why taxis do not use larger vehicles unless you book a special ride upfront.
Even with ride sharing it's often more efficient to have point to point transport when you are not using a route, or at best have only 1-2 stops on the way; in such case a bus is unnecessarily wasteful.
But yet again this isn't anything that cannot be done now without a driverless bus, you have GPS nothing stops public transport companies from implementing dynamic routes now the driver isn't the problem.
Most bus lines do have "dynamic" dispatching already BTW, peak hours tend to have more busses on a given route than off-peak hours, what you are suggesting is to have dynamic routes, which is basically Uber.
- marcosdumay 9y agoIf you put 20 people on that "car", it's a bus. Small buses can adjust their route to get you reasonably quick point to point transport while still being collective transportation. I do agree that is something that could be done today, if only governments let people do it. No need for self driving buses.
- dogma1138 9y agoThere are plenty of places that allow for small (van sized) private bus/shuttles to operate, they however do not seem want to go that route and usually either shadow existing bus route or have their own routes where buses do not usually go (and usually a mix of both). The problem is that when you turn busses into cars for hire you end up in a situation where you'll get a lot of people pissed all the time. Ride sharing with even 5 people that are not bound to the same destination is a nightmare. Think about what happen when you have a bus with 18 people that is diverted because someone called it and then cancels it? How do you plan stops? Uber can stop nearly anywhere a bus usually needs bus stop not just to not block traffic but because people need to be able to safely get on and off the bus which is much harder to do than with a car as a bus blocks the view much more than a smaller sedan. Sorry; I'll buy a Tesla that works for Uber while you are at work all day long, I will not buy ridesharing with on-demand hailing and bespoke routes and destinations with 20 people on board. The best thing you can do get working is a fixed route without fixed stops, and this works today it's called hop-on-hop-off busses and it works in many places including London.
- inopinatus 9y agoThis really sounds like a galloping case of "I can't imagine how it can work, so it can't work".
- dogma1138 9y agoNo that is we have models that work and models that do not.
- inopinatus 9y agoSure. Neither are bounded sets.
- inopinatus 9y ago> Busses and other public transport work well because you have a route which makes it predictable people know when and where they can get onto a bus, and where they can get off and how long the ride will take This is exactly the issue I'm referring to: the assumption that to be sufficiently usable, the route and frequency has to be pre-ordained, and that this is a necessary condition for acceptable mass transit. That's the antithesis of on-demand. > nothing stops public transport companies from implementing dynamic routes Plenty of factors restrain an incumbent from innovating. Internally, their established processes, values, technology. Externally, the regulatory environment, existing infrastructure, market structure. Sounds like a ripe candidate for disruption to me.