4 ms·
That doesn't mean you're not rich, that just means that you're spending your income on immediate comfort and flashy toys rather than security. If you lived furt
by taneq 9y ago
That doesn't mean you're not rich, that just means that you're spending your income on immediate comfort and flashy toys rather than security. If you lived further within your means and invested the difference wisely, within a year or two you would have far more security than the $30k household will ever have.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoMedical issues (maybe legal too) seem to be the game changer. Millions can go just like that, assuming you want the best available (and who doesn't for loved ones?)
- taneq 9y ago"The best available" goes far beyond the point of diminishing returns. If you're willing to settle for merely 'top tier', you'd spend a small fraction of the amount for essentially the same level of care. And that's even in a place with medical costs as insane as the U.S. Anyway, there's no such thing as perfectly impervious to risk - even ultra-wealthy families sometimes topple. That doesn't change the fact that with careful management, a $300k/year income can rapidly feather a rather nice, rather secure nest. $30k/year cannot.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoI'd like to think that there are diminishing returns, but in my experience, the biggest complaint about doctors (and from doctors) is the lack of time they get to spend on a patient. It would stand to reason that a doctor that can spend an hour talking to you, researching your condition and history, collaborate with colleagues across disciplines is going to have a much greater impact than one who sees you for 5 minutes. And it costs quite a lot to get that level of care. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/03/business/economy/high-end-medical-care.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/03/business/economy/high-end...
- kbutler 9y ago> in my experience, the biggest complaint about doctors (and from doctors) is the lack of time they get to spend on a patient. If you talk to someone with significant health issues, it rapidly becomes, "The doctors don't have the answer". Nobody wants to spend longer with the doctor - they want healthy, productive life outside the doctor's office.
- FussyZeus 9y agoAs I understand it, medical expenses are the fastest route from "stable" as OP defines to the street. If you blew your millions on a yacht only to crumble under the load of the debt that would be one thing, but for the majority of people who lose everything they have, it was due to one disease or another, traffic accident, some other kind of ailment that they played little to no role in getting. That's not right.
- miguelrochefort 9y ago> due to one disease or another, traffic accident, some other kind of ailment that they played little to no role in getting. How do you feel about kids born in Africa?
- Cthulhu_ 9y ago> implying all African kids live in shit conditions Can we please not generalize Africa? It's the biggest continent of the world, not a giant 3rd world country plagued by famine and poverty. Some countries are, but if you mean those, please name them specifically. (I dislike phrases like "asians" and "europeans" too, much as Americans should dislike the moniker "American")
- thatwebdude 9y agoI always liked the ring of "United Statesian".
- FussyZeus 9y agoI'm not certain if you're trying to imply that people in the US shouldn't complain because they have it better than "kids born in Africa" or if you're implying that healthcare shouldn't be a basic human right for everyone, in the US or not. If it's the former: Suffering isn't a contest, just because you aren't the MOST impoverished person on the face of the planet does not make your problems less real, nor does it make you less deserving of help when you do need it. If it's the latter, I'm all for getting those kids healthcare (and food) and whatever else they might need. That's a damn sight better use of my tax dollars than numerous Government programs currently sucking up actual trillions of dollars here in the States.
- korrachs 9y agoI work in a wholesale brokerage. I try and manage the risk exposure so we won't go bankrupt tomorrow because someone couldn't tell the difference between 0 and O on their screen. I have seen trades worth hundreds of millions fail and bankrupt the people making them. The problem isn't people not saving or investing the problem is an insane system kept afloat by greed, ignorance and fear. "Security"? what good is having paper when no one wants to buy it? October 29, 1929 is a day my grandmother remembers well and one I dread we will see again. Government is the only insurance scheme large enough to protect us from ourselves.
- charlesdm 9y agoNo one says you need to invest it in the stock market though. There are plenty of assets one can acquire, that are not directly connected to the stock market. Use some debt to acquire them, and good returns can be made, even in small(er) deals.
- thjan 9y agoWhat investments are you suggesting?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoTreasuries, CDs, et cetera. You should be able to build, over a few years, a decent rainy-day fund on $300,000 a year. Disclaimer: this is not investment advice. Do not take investment advice from Internet comments.
- icedchai 9y agoThe return on treasuries and CDs is ridiculously low, less than 3%. Bond funds are not much better. Unless you're talking short term, put it in a total stock market index fund and forget about it.
- brookside 9y agoThe one option is real estate (which isn't feasible for some who aren't staying in a place for long to manage). What else do you have in mind?
- naiveattack 9y agoSecurity is defined by some assumptions. The stability of society and the ability of the government to enforce that through the military and police. Very fragile the things we take for granted. When there systems fall, only those with either high enough walls around them with ability to sustain independently within those walls, or at least the ability to escape to another currently stable situation will be secure. When a Gotham'esque hell breaks loose, where is your security then?
- adrianN 9y agoWell yeah, if society collapses you'd better be a prepper. Most reasonable people however think that you're very secure financially once you have saved enough for ~30 years of average spending. Barring major market disaster you could then continue living from your capital gains indefinitely.
- naiveattack 9y agoSure, but this is the precariat. Most excellently pointed out be korrachs. This autonomy is the line. It doesn't have to be total anarchy or civil war either. Imagine food shortages or media propaganda or government policy changes. Again, all very fragile. The distinction is what controls you, and what autonomy you retain. Categories: every day is a living fuck all, I depends on the systems around me, I have autonomy myself, I have autonomy over others as well.
- i_cant_speel 9y agoHow does that have anything to do with the current discussion?
- naiveattack 9y agoBecause this is one way of seeing security. If I have a private jet and runway, I can fly away when war breaks loose. Can you see the line?
- 9y ago
- vacri 9y ago> within a year or two you would have far more security than the $30k household will ever have. Within a year or two? I think you mean "after your first paycheck". The ability to have a grand or two 'cushion' money in the bank is an incredible difference between the haves and have-nots. And I don't mean "money in my day-to-day account", I mean emergency money of any kind. It's bizarre that a 300k/yr household can even contemplate being similar to a 30k/yr one.
- geggam 9y agoDepends on where you live. 30k in the Midwest compared to 300K in San Francisco is actually not too far apart. 2 Beds 1 Bath -- 650 Jackson MO or 7800 a year or 25% of the income gross $4940 - $5160 /mo 2 beds / 2 bath 979 sqft say 5000 a month or 60000 a year or 20% of the income add the huge differences in effective tax rate of CA to MO combined with the jump in federal tax rates and it is arguable that 30k in MO would actually be better off
- mikesickler 9y agoYeah but look at the different in what you're left with after rent and taxes. It's not even close.
- mindways 9y ago...even if we take this not-quite-equivalence at face value (note: 650 < 979 and 20% < 25%), most life expenses don't scale linearly with housing values - not even close. Groceries may be more expensive in the big city, but not 10x more expensive. You're not paying 10x more for a car, or a plane flight. And insurance premiums / deductibles sure aren't 10x cheaper in a less expensive part of the country. Plus, the "$300K in expensive place" household has the option of moving to the less expensive place. The reverse is hardly true. > it is arguable that 30k in MO would actually be better off 1. No. 2. Even if we were to accept that $30K in one place went just as far as $300K in another, "better off" ignores that higher property costs are likely to indicate a more desirable place to live. (For whatever reason: access to jobs, lower crime rates, pleasant to live in, what-have-you.)
- 9y ago