15 ms·
Tesla is a pretty expensive car, so when the buyers no longer got a discount on the purchase of an electric car less people could afford them. The Electric car
by mrweasel 9y ago
Tesla is a pretty expensive car, so when the buyers no longer got a discount on the purchase of an electric car less people could afford them.
The Electric cars aren't selling because only a few people can afford spending $110.000 car, more than a house in some parts of the country. Even when the subsidy was in place most of the buyers were relatively wealthy people.
You can question the Danish taxation of cars if you want, but what's killing Tesla and others is the high price. The best selling car in Denmark in 2016 was the Peugeot 208 at $20.000. If electric cars are to take of they need to hit the $20.000 - $40.000 price range.
Tesla is a luxury which sold well among the well of segment of the population, when they were given a discount on the taxes, by the government.
- ebbv 9y agoThere are a number of EVs available in the $20-40k price range. A majority of them in fact. In the US we have the Nissan Leaf and Chevrolet Bolt. In Europe the two have a number of other options available as well. The Renault Zoe is like a more affordable Leaf. I'm not sure what the VW eGolf clocks in at over there but it's probably in the neighborhood. So yeah, just because the Model S is a luxury car, don't make the mistake of assuming all other EVs are too. Here in the US if you can find a used Nissan Leaf you can get a really good deal.
- _pmf_ 9y ago> I'm not sure what the VW eGolf clocks in at over there Ca. 35 000 EUR in Germany (which means less in the rest of the world, for whatever reason).
- mrweasel 9y agoThe Leaf is $40 - 45.000 in Denmark, so that's within range of most I would think, it's just that you can get bigger/better cars for the price. The Bolt isn't available in Denmark, it's under the Opel brand here and Opel won't sell it in Denmark because they priorities countries with an "ambitious policy".
- ebbv 9y agoIf it makes you feel any better, the Bolt was designed here in Michigan and won't be on sale here until later this year because they're targeting California and other markets first.
- coredog64 9y agoGM has opened up orders nationwide with delivery dates starting in August. https://electrek.co/2017/06/09/gm-chevy-bolt-orders-nationwide-deliveries-august/ https://electrek.co/2017/06/09/gm-chevy-bolt-orders-nationwi...
- robotresearcher 9y ago> $40 - 45.000 in Denmark, so that's within range of most I would think Wikipedia says $42K is the mean after-tax annual income in Denmark. Median will be a bit lower. So maybe not as many Danes are in that market as you think.
- dagw 9y agoI'm not sure what the VW eGolf clocks in at over there but it's probably in the neighborhood. In Sweden the eGolf is about SEK 400k ($45k) compared to about SEK 220k ($25k) for the Zoe.
- tovkal 9y agoThat's why they are doing the Model 3.
- baldfat 9y agoModel 3 is $35,000 before incentives. https://www.tesla.com/model3 https://www.tesla.com/model3
- Trafz 9y agoRight. Now add the 180% taxation: $98,000. Not THAT far off the 110k you're replying to.
- NuDinNou 9y agoWhere is that 180% taxation on EVs? In Denmark?
- Spare_account 9y agoYes, as per the article
- mrweasel 9y agoOn all cars, not just electric cars. That's sort of the point of the whole thing. Electric cars were taxed less than diesel or petrol powered cars, the law changed and electric vehicles started to be taxed as any other car and sales dropped like rock.
- battlebot 9y agoThat's insane. I know that taxes are used to create disincentives, but that's why Americans think Europeans are insane--you let them rule you like that? Insane. Sorry.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoOh wow. So, to get the figure after tax, you're multiplying by 2.8, not by 1.8? That's even worse than I imagined. I suppose that when we talk about a 6% registration tax in my state, that's unambiguously multiplying the end cost by 1.06, or 106% - but I'd assumed that they were inflating the figure by using the multiplier directly. That's astonishing! Still, doesn't this also apply to the cheaper cars? You're getting a Pugeot 208 for not $20k but $56k. While the difference between sticker price and post-tax price is smaller in proportion with the cost of the cars - $63k vs $36k - that's still $56k... for a Pugeot.
- sveme 9y agoI just bought a VW Caddy, but was also struggling with the decision as I thought about going electric. However, what I personally need is a minibus form factor to sleep in the back, 500km range to go to the alps and back and preferably at less than 30k Euros. Like many other city dwellers in Europe, I don't need a car in the city, prefer to take my bike or public transport, I only need it for weekend trips and vacations. I guess quite a lot of people in my part of town act similarly, even though we should be the most interested in electric cars, all being eco-minded and such.
- mrweasel 9y agoPersonally I ran into the issues that to save on weight many manufacturers compromised on leg room behind the wheel. It's not physically possible for me to drive something like the Renault Zoe.
- pmarreck 9y agoI'm 6'3" (1.923m), get a used model S if you can, it's plenty roomy
- amelius 9y agoI'm curious: why not simply rent a van whenever you go on a trip?
- pjmlp 9y agoSpeaking for German prices, because it eventually adds up, specially taking into consideration that to be on the safe side it is better to have full coverage insurance. With own car one pays insurance once, while renting the insurance gets payed every single time it gets rented. Not going full coverage is an open game as they will charge for any little new scratch the car might get, no matter how tiny. Meanwhile, I have been in countries where the only thing that matters is that the car is returned in one piece still.
- willyt 9y ago
- donquichotte 9y agoAlso, giving tax breaks on luxury cars means shiftig wealth from the poor to the rich.
- mseebach 9y agoYes, rolling back the tax discount on EVs should remove the last fragment of the fig leaf that those taxes have any environmental purpose whatsoever.
- Decade 9y agoCars in general are bad for the environment. The discount was about being quite a bit less bad, but EVs are still bad. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14536854 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14536854
- mseebach 9y agoThat may be the case, but the Danish vehicle tax has not made a meaningful dent in neither car ownership nor usage.
- watter 9y agoThis is why I like to remind people of Tesla's true innovation: finding government tax credits and giving consumers a way to spend them on Tesla.
- dmode 9y agoThis comment makes no sense. Tesla doesn't find government credits and build a car accordingly. Tesla makes an electric car. Government, which represents their tax base, had decided to provide tax incentives to encourage EV sales. These are mutually exclusive. No one is stopping GM from converting their entire fleet to electric and take advantage. If this is the only innovation, it should also be relatively easy for anyone to start electric car company and start making money. I would encourage you to start one
- 9y ago
- pmarreck 9y agoSo the cost of electric cars tripled (due to a near-200% import tax imposition) and it only dropped sales to 1/3 what they were? The fact that this didn't wipe them out entirely is telling
- hammock 9y agoTriple price and 1/3 quantity directly follows the linear demand curves they teach in Economics 101.. not sure what else you were expecting.
- jackcarter 9y agoLinear doesn't mean slope = -1, though.
- gibberfish 9y agoAlso, you can fit just about anything to two points.
- JBReefer 9y agoHey, that's an interesting question: is there anything you can't fit to two arbitrary points? Seems like with compression, x/y offsets, and rotation you could fit just about curve.
- tonmoy 9y agoThere's Nissan Leaf
- ClassyJacket 9y agoUnfortunately a garbage car in every sense. Tiny range around half that of a Model 3 - at 172km I can't drive to the airport and back without charing - no supercharging equivalent, ugly, no autopilot or equivalent, tiny, and cheaper than a Tesla Model 3 but not by much. Oh and it's been withdrawn from sale entirely in Australia.
- robotresearcher 9y agoIt has an important advantage over the Telsa Model 3, if you need to go anywhere anytime soon.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoWhat's that? Like I said, it's been withdrawn from sale entirely in my country and they imply it's never coming back. At least the Model 3 is confirmed to be available next year if you preordered.
- dragontamer 9y agoThe Leaf exists, and it existed for years. Since its existed for years, we pretty much know exactly what we're gonna get. In contrast, as of today, the Model 3 doesn't even exist. Personally speaking, I don't buy the first model of any car anyway. If I were seriously considering the Model 3, I wouldn't plan on buying it till 2019 at the earliest. That would give Tesla enough time to work out the issues that the first batch of cars will inevitably have. No car company has ever launched a new model line without issues. The issues may be major, or minor (like doors or windows not closing properly... rattles and that sort of thing). Inevitably, the first year or two are basically a public beta-test. For what basically amounts to a dozens-of-thousands of dollars investment, I want to make sure the car manufacturing company gets it right.
- R_haterade 9y agoNail on the head. When your concern is cost, electric vehicles just don't make sense. I drive 5-10 thousands miles a year, and at $2/gallon gas, I'm looking at a total expense of 4-500 dollars per year. To illustrate, I recently spec'd out a honda civic, with the base model costing $19k USD, and looking at even hybrids like the chevy volt and prius, I'm basically paying a premium of $4k to $15k for what amounts to a nominal gain in mileage. It just doesn't make sense when the civic is cheaper and more fun to drive (huge consideration when you spend more than 10 minutes commuting every day.) Drop the honda to a fit, and the straight IC is even more of a hands-down winner. Mileage standards are probably the most effective tool at reducing automobile emissions, and I wish more people costed that out and understood the economic impact, especially on poor people, before coming to any debate on the subject. Edit: I realize this is more of an american perspective on an article about a european problem. I wish I could bike safely where I live, but the infrastructure costs would probably be tremendous given how spread out everything is here.
- gambiting 9y ago>> I drive 5-10 thousands miles a year, and at $2/gallon gas I assure you that even at nearly $8/gallon over here, an electric vehicle still didn't make much sense when we were buying a new car last year. Even the cheapest Leaf was so much more expensive than a well specced VW Polo that it made no sense to go electric, we did the calculation and the difference in price would not be returned in the savings over the time we are likely to keep the car for.
- dpark 9y ago> Nail on the head. When your concern is cost, electric vehicles just don't make sense. I agree with this. Electric cars are still affordable only to the affluent. Even a Nissan Leaf costs over $30k. > I drive 5-10 thousands miles a year, and at $2/gallon gas, I'm looking at a total expense of 4-500 dollars per year. This, however, seems really optimistic. 10k miles for $500 in gas assumes $2/gallon and 40 mpg, which is the EPA rating for highway miles in a Civic. Most people are driving >10k miles/year. Most people don't spend 100% of their miles on open highway at optimal speed, nor do most people drive a new car with max efficiency. And most people don't have $2/gallon gas even in the US (the average is closer to $2.50 currently). Driving 12-15k/year, getting 25mpg, paying $2.50/gallon, you'd be looking at $1200-$1500/year for gas. That's still not enough to offset the difference in an electric car unless you assume long ownership and no major costs to, say, replace the battery pack at 5 years.
- sh87 9y agoTesla is the stairway to cheaper fully electric cars. Just needs some time.
- alacombe 9y agoFor how long have people been saying this ?
- vhhhggv 9y agoPlease use a comma to separate thousands. Thanks.
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoBut Denmark is special, cars are taxed insanely high [0]. For cheap cars (~11.000 EUR) its double the price, for more expensive cars its 150% now and used to be 180%. [0] https://www.thelocal.dk/20151120/whats-the-deal-with-denmarks-car-registration-tax https://www.thelocal.dk/20151120/whats-the-deal-with-denmark...
- mvindahl 9y agoDane here as well. We own a Peugeot iOn which we bought for $15,000 a few years back. At the time it was about two years old but hadn't driven very far. The price and size is about the same that you'd pay for very low-end gasoline driven cars in Denmark. I don't regret buying it as it's very fun to drive. On the flip side, the range isn't that far, only about 60 miles, so it's nice for commuting and short trips, but we need our MPV as a fallback for longer trips. Anyway, I guess the point I was trying to make was that there are electrical cars in a lot of different price ranges these days. The old car manufacturers are trying to board the train as well, with varying commercial success. It's not all Tesla.