6 ms·
Carnot Efficient Dyson Spheres Are Undetectable by Infrared Surveys (2016)
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoNot sure my mathematics is up to the task but "using a relatively small increase in resources and time." A sphere with 99% efficiency would need 25 larger radius according to the article, which is 625x more material assuming the thickness can be the same and doesn't need to be more be be structurally working. 625x to me doesn't sound like a "relatively small increase in resources". But it looks like some people consider an increase of 62400% in resources a "small increase".
- danieltillett 9y agoWhere you are going wrong is assuming the outer layer has to be the same thickness as the inner layers. The outer layer only needs to capture the long infrared radiation emitted by the inner shells. In theory it only needs to be 1 atom thick and can contain gaps half the wavelength to be captured.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoWhy does the 1 AU Dyson sphere needs to be that much thicker (more than 625x thicker to be precise)?
- danieltillett 9y agoThe inner shells need to be thicker for three reasons - photon pressure, they are at a higher temperature, and the wavelengths they are capturing are shorter. Having said this they would not need to be much thicker than the outer layers.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoSo a.) The inner layer is thicker than the outer layer, but not much b.) The outer layer has a surface area 625x larger than the inner layer c.) The outer layer needs only a "small increase in resources" I still don't get it.
- danieltillett 9y agoThe only thing we get to observe is the outer layer. We really have no way of knowing what is going on inside or what structures are present. The relative small increase is not in reference to a smaller sphere, but to the material resources of the stellar system. If you only need 0.00000001% of the material resources of the system to build an inefficient sphere then using 625x more is not a significant increase.
- tboughen 9y agoWe tend to assume that one would want to be able to walk and live inside a 1AU Dyson sphere, so structurally it would have to be sufficiently strong to support such uses.
- neals 9y agoSo, just musing here, no actual knowledge on any of this: what if a Dyson sphere was 100% efficient and feed its energy back into it's power-source. Could this sphere exists for all of eternity? Trapping all energy inside and recycling it?
- TheCoreh 9y agoThat would be equivalent to a perpetual motion machine, so I don't think it's possible for thermodynamical reasons.
- danieltillett 9y agoThe second law of thermodynamics makes 100% efficiency impossible. The Carnot efficiency is just a measure of how close you can get to 100%. It must be a slow day on HN for this post of mine to make the front page :)
- neals 9y agoIs there any way you could explain to the uninformed, like myself, where the energy would leak? Is it impossible to make a 100% isolated sphere? Would radiation or other kind of waves always pass through?
- danieltillett 9y agoThe energy is converted from short wavelength (visble light) to longer wavelengths (infrared). A Dyson sphere would act as a black body [1] and radiates energy at the temperature of the sphere outer surface. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation
- jonlawlor 9y agoIf it was 100% isolated, the heat from the sun would continually increase the internal temperature, which would probably be bad. They're looking for a steady state dyson sphere.
- leni536 9y ago
- woofyman 9y agoA civilization capable of building a Dyson Sphere wouldn't need to.
- danieltillett 9y agoPossibly, but stars are a huge waste of energy. A civilisation capable of building a Dyson sphere should be able to come up with a better use for a star than just lighting up the universe.
- cryoshon 9y agoyeah. antimatter, dude.
- taneq 9y agoMy guess is that by the time any civilisation gets advanced enough to build a Dyson sphere, ennui has set in to the point where they don't bother.
- korussian 9y agoAny civilization advanced enough to build a Dyson Sphere would by definition be one capable of extreme, long term focus. Since ennui is the enemy of long term focus, they'd probably have conquered it.
- amelius 9y agoSo any candidate locations where such Dyson Spheres may currently exist? Can we detect them based on their gravity (i.e. objects orbiting it without the centripetal force accounted for)?
- pilsetnieks 9y agoThere's this thing: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/dyson-megastructure-mystery-deepens http://www.wired.co.uk/article/dyson-megastructure-mystery-d... Though who knows what it actually is.
- danieltillett 9y agoYes - distant galaxies. This was to be a follow up post that I have just not got around to writing as I have been so busy.
- falcolas 9y agoSo, for that additional 4% efficiency, the radius must be increased by 25x; making the total surface area somewhere around 650x bigger? An exponential increase in size is not "a relatively small increase in resources and time." It goes from "something that could be built with all the mass in the solar system" to "something that requires the mass from an additional couple of hundred solar systems to construct". I'm also curious about whether a Dyson sphere which would roughly equal Neptune's orbit would have sufficient sunlight at any given point to sustain life (at least, life as we know it). I'm not a member of an alien civilization with the technology to create a Dyson sphere, but as a lowly human engineer, the costs don't seem worth the benefits, especially without some other form of energy to supplement the 650x increase in energy needs.
- danieltillett 9y agoYou don't need to make a single sphere (swarm more likely). If you arrange the shells in layers the outer layers can efficiently capture the long wavelength radiation using relatively little matter. The question is if you could capture the energy and you had the material resources would you let it escape into the universe at 290K?
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoOr do something else with the 625x more resources you need? I'd probably let the 4% escape and do something nice with the 625x more resources.
- danieltillett 9y agoYou don't need 625x the material resources to capture the last 4%. Think multiple shells with the outermost shell being 1 atom thick.
- falcolas 9y agoWhat atoms - when arranged in a single-atom-thickness structure - could collect, transform, and transfer radiant energy back towards the inner shells, while also remaining rigid enough to not deform under the pressure of that radiant energy (not to mention the energy emitted by other stellar phenomena)? For better or worse, we have to assume the alien civilizations have the same physics that we do, otherwise the civilization simply has to build their 1au sphere out of artificially created unobtainium to achieve 99% efficiency.
- xenophonf 9y ago...put simply, the emission signal from efficient Dyson spheres will be swamped by infrared noise in any wide-field infrared surveys. I am also not a member of an alien civilization with the technology to create a Dyson sphere, but this strikes me as being very good from the standpoint of such a civilization's operational security.
- schiffern 9y agoI've seen mention before of the Carnot efficiency of Dyson spheres, but what about Landauer efficiency? Assuming the DS is powering a bunch of computers, and assuming sufficiently advanced technology that these computers approach the limits of physics (reasonable for a Type 2 civilization imo), then their computers will use power proportional to kT. The colder the computer, the less power it uses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle This provides another thermodynamic reason to make a Dyson sphere as large as possible.
- O5vYtytb 9y agoDoesn't this also assume a computer similar to our own? How would this principle apply to a biological computer for example?
- lann 9y ago> Doesn't this also assume a computer similar to our own? No. It is about abstract computation, which is based on (our best understanding of) theoretical physics.
- Armisael16 9y agoThe Landauer limit applies to all non-thermodynamically reversible changes of state in a system. I don't know how your biological computer works, so I can't say 100% that it applies - but it probably does.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoThe Landauer principle applies to any computer made of matter utilizing energy (in a non-thermodynamically reversible fashion). So it applies just fine to biological computers, quantum computers, and even mechanical computers! It's a result in quantum information theory, and doesn't have anything to do with the overall type of computer used. It just determines how much energy it takes to change the state of a quantum (particle), at a minimum. Things like changing the polarization of a photon or the spin of an electron.
- pmoriarty 9y ago
- dynofuz 9y agomaybe all the black holes are dyson spheres?!
- zeroer 9y agoThe article posits that maybe advanced alien civilizations may be motivated to build larger (and hence harder to to detect) Dyson spheres for the efficiency gains. While that's a possibility, it's also possible that being harder to detect is an end unto itself for safety reasons.
- outsidetheparty 9y ago"The good news there is a different approach for finding efficient Dyson sphere, but that is another post." Tease! Did he ever write that other post? If so it must have a high Carnot efficiency because I can't find it /rimshot
- abecedarius 9y agoI'd guess: survey for sources at stellar brightness and low temperature. Dunno if it's been done.
- danieltillett 9y agoSorry I haven’t got around to writing it yet as I have been too busy with work - actually I have not written an article on anything this year.
- mrfusion 9y agoI'm thinking what's remarkable about this is it could be a potential explanation of dark matter. It had always been ruled out previously because astronomers said they'd be easily detectable.