9 ms·
Fractal planting patterns yield optimal harvests, without central control
- chriswarbo 9y agoThis looks very interesting from a regulation point of view, as a potential way to bring greedy self-interest into alignment with national/international social interest. I wonder what scenarios could be given a "pest tax", to alter the dynamic from a tradgedy of the commons to a cooperative/competitive optimum?
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThere's plenty of science against (20th century) top heavy / top down control. The issue seems to be: the current power holders admitting their model is flawed; and those being managed realized they'd be better off without "leadership."
- chriswarbo 9y ago> top heavy / top down control Could you characterise what is meant by this? I know that achieving some objective 'X' may not be amenable to regulation which says 'you must do X'; but regulation may (in some circumstances, with sufficient thought) alter the situation's dynamics such that greedy self-interest in that environment just-so-happens to coincide with causing 'X'. What better alternatives are there to "top down control"; do you mean a "vote with your wallet" sort of 'bottom up' pressure?
- chiefalchemist 9y agoCentralized, as opposed to decentralized. I would say these farms/farmers are decentralized. There's no gov agency, with some academia pencil pusher in some removed city overseaing them. They've figured it out. And they will continue to do so. p.s. Team of Teams (book) does a great job flying to decentralized flag.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoNot quite. There's plenty of examples in nature of automatons executing simple behaviors without an overseer that lead to tremendous complexity and efficiency. However, we only see the successful emergent phenomenon, not the failed ones. Also, to this day we can not make accurate predictions of inherently chaotic systems. So, while a bottom up sysytem may optimize, exactly whatt it optimizes is impossible to discern.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWell. Yes. But I didn't say always. Only that it is (often?) very possible to find solutions in a local decentralized sort of way.
- scalio 9y agoI believe ecology has to be turned into a strong economic factor if we want anything to happen in its favor. Assuming political cooperation, the easiest way I see is to just slap a tax on any and all polluting emissions. That's very much top-down and seems very useful.
- danharaj 9y agoPrivate property and profit motive are obstacles.
- chriswarbo 9y agoNot really; they're exactly what I meant by "greedy self-interest".
- IslaDeEncanta 9y agoIf you don't support neoliberal fantasies, your comments probably aren't welcome here.
- dnautics 9y agoThe classical solution to the tragedy of the commons for rivalrous goods is propertization. It's the logic behind contemporary land rights, some very successful commercial fisheries management (north west Atlantic), and emissions auctions in the US (SOx and NOx implementation - but notably not the proposed carbon, which has other wierd factors bolted on)
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat's terribly limited though, since it basically relies on a land grab, and people who come along later are out of luck.
- dnautics 9y agoHow does that apply to rolling auctions?
- ende 9y agoThat's why you introduce a land value tax. As the supply of interested parties increases, so too does the demand and therefore the value of the land. This has several effects: 1) incentivizes unproductive land owners to sell 2) incentivizes productive land owners to seek tenants 3) generates public revenues to offset negative externalities
- danieltillett 9y agoYes but the rentier class (our overlords) don’t like LVT.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat never seems to get mentioned at the time the commons are privatized, only in salons later on. Also, it's rather hard to build capital improvements on fisheries, and correspondingly this does nothing for the preservation of wilderness. which is a problem that privatization is supposed to solve but frequently doesn't.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoIs this a form of emergence?
- rubidium 9y agoYes... both profs are external sante fe institute members. That's kindof their chorus.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoCan you recommend a book or two on emergence? I've seen it mentioned. It intrigues me. But I haven't been able to find anything sold for going deeper. TIA
- rubidium 9y agoFirst read "more is different". Solid state physicists were first to pioneer in this field: http://robotics.cs.tamu.edu/dshell/cs689/papers/anderson72more_is_different.pdf http://robotics.cs.tamu.edu/dshell/cs689/papers/anderson72mo... There's a very light book by some modern author that's not terrible: Emergence: The Connected Lives of Ants, Brains, Cities, and Software https://www.amazon.com/dp/0684868768/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_3WxpzbP55A6WW https://www.amazon.com/dp/0684868768/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_3Wxp... If you want to really dig in though you need some math: Emergence of Dynamical Order: Synchronization Phenomena in Complex Systems (World Scientific Lecture Notes in Complex Systems, Vol. 2) https://www.amazon.com/dp/9812388036/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_.Yxpzb925HPYX https://www.amazon.com/dp/9812388036/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_.Yxp... Final suggestion is most of the stuff is online at different professors websites. Warning: the field is full of meaningless fluff too, and there's a lot of qucks mixed in with genuinely interesting science.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThanks.
- aetherspawn 9y agoI didn't understand: 1. how they didn't have pest problems if they planted in fractal patterns 2. but they did have pest problems if they didn't plant at the same time Could someone kindly explain that in a little more depth?
- livingparadox 9y agoIts actually that planting "in synchrony" reduced pests. Balancing that with limited water supplies resulted in the fractal pattern, which created close to an optimal yield.
- oelmekki 9y ago> When farmers are planting at different times, pests can move from one field to another, but when farmers plant in synchrony, pests drown and the pest load is reduced. The strategy is that if there are several fields planted for the same amount of bugs, each field receive less bugs than if it was the only one planted (on the contrary, if they were planted one after an other, the whole bug population would just jump from field to field).
- aetherspawn 9y agoThanks, I thought when it said drown it literally meant something to do with water but this makes a lot of sense now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mamon 9y agoYes, they meant literal drowning of bugs when the field is flooded with water, which is one of the stages of growing rice. Bigger the area flooded at once, lower the chance for the average bug to escape. Fractal pattern arises as a trade-off because water supply is limited - if it wasn't for that they would probably just flood ALL the fields at once.
- cptskippy 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abhinai 9y agoTLDR; Locally collaborative greedy planting strategy leads to globally optimal results and looks like a fractal from above. Mind == Blown.
- havella 9y agothis is very interesting, wondering the principle applies to societal organization and current reversal trends on globalization (mono-culture) and weakening of international 'controlling' organizations.
- gumby 9y agoActually this depends on a monoculture as it is an adaptation to the life cycle of the rice (paddy) plant and its water requirements. If different farmers were growing different crops the requirements would vary.
- kakarot 9y agoNow how can I apply this to Dwarf Fortress?
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat's an absolutely valid question that doesn't deserve to be downvoted. Generalizing these insights for deployment is absolutely a problem worth solving.
- kakarot 9y agoHaha, people can be such assholes sometimes. Dwarf Fortress doesn't currently have crop pests, but it's reasonable to assume it will within a decade. Tarn plans to spend the rest of his life working on it. Dwarf Fortress is a game about decentralized, organized planning so once pests are added we'll see pages and pages of discussion about the best way to plan your fractal farm. Sure, I was being half serious but c'mon people have a sense of humor.
- Polarity 9y agoso: monolithic frameworks vs loose coupled components?
- chrismealy 9y agoThis reminds me of something from Sam Bowles's "Microeconomics": Like the overnight train that left me in an empty field some distance from the settlement, the process of economic development has for the most part bypassed the two hundred or so families that make up the village of Palanpur. They have remained poor, even by Indian standards: less than a third of the adults are literate, and most have endured the loss of a child to malnutrition or to illnesses that are long forgotten in other parts of the world. But for the occasional wristwatch, bicycle, or irrigation pump, Palanpur appears to be a timeless backwater, untouched by India’s cutting edge software industry and booming agricultural regions. Seeking to understand why, I approached a sharecropper and his three daughters weeding a small plot. The conversation eventually turned to the fact that Palanpur farmers sow their winter crops several weeks after the date at which yields would be maximized. The farmers do not doubt that earlier planting would give them larger harvests, but no one the farmer explained, is willing to be the first to plant, as the seeds on any lone plot would be quickly eaten by birds. I asked if a large group of farmers, perhaps relatives, had ever agreed to sow earlier, all planting on the same day to minimize losses. “If we knew how to do that,” he said, looking up from his hoe at me, “we would not be poor.”
- std_throwaway 9y agoThis is how visitors from other planets look at us in regard to resource distribution on earth and space exploration.
- jcoffland 9y agoI fail to see how the planting patterns are fractal. A fractal pattern is one which repeats itself at different scales. I realize that the repetition does not need to be exact but I don't see how there is any at all in this situation.
- jon_richards 9y agoSomething as simple as a contour map could be thought of as intrinsically fractal. It isn't as mathematically rigorous as the fractals we are used to seeing described as such, but it fulfils the criteria.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoActually, that is only one type of fractals. Perfectly self similar patterns like the Triforce or Sierpensky triangle are used as toy models for learning . Typically, fractals in nature are not self similar(Branching of your blood vessels for example) . Mandelbrot developed fractal geometry as a way to model nature that captures roughness. It was kind of a rebellion against calculus, where if you zoom in eventually you get smoothness. It's funny that many people think that only self similar patterns are fractals when his desire was to get away from idealized models towards more pragmatic ones EDIT: I'm actually just learning about fractals, so I'm certainly no expert, but I'm excited to share what I've learned so far. Look at a line, square, and cube in 1, 2, and 3 dimensions respectively. If you scale down each by 1/2 in all its dimensions, you need to look at how much of the "mass" (for lack of a better term is scaled down If you cut a line in 1/2, it's mass is scaled by 1/2 as it takes 2 one-half length lines to make the original line. If you scale a square down 1/2 along all its dimensions, you break into/scale it down into 4 smaller squares, it's mass scaling factor is 1/4....scaling a cube down 1/2 along all its dimensions (1/2)^2 breaks it into 8 smaller cubes...it's scaling factor is 1/8 and you can see the progression here. (1/2)^3. (I imagine a tesseract/hypercube has a scaling of 1/16 as it is the 4D analogue of a cube) The exponent represents the concept of dimension and this is how you can have non-integer dimensions. So, back to the Sierpenski triangle or triforce example. Let's scale it down 1/2. When we do that, we know we get 1/3 the "mass" of the original since there are 3 triangles contained in the larger triangle at each level. The dimensionality is then (1/2)^x = 1/3 where x is the dimensionality. We rewrite this as log 3 base 2 which gives it a dimensionality of ~1.585. And that is the definition of a fractal, a shape with a non-integer dimension which gives the shape roughness at every scale. I don't quite understand the more technical definition, but hopefully this helps! Note, you cannot use length or area as a measurment for a scaling factor, as the length would be infinite and area would be 0. Also, I say mass because the more correct concept is difficult for me to explain without a whiteboard, but basically, it has to do with putting the fractal on a 2d grid, scaling it, and seeing what the ratio of boxes touched is. See, told you I'm bad at explaining it :D
- anigbrowl 9y agoThese insights will be useful for my political project.
- marmshallow 9y agoCan anyone find sample satellite imagery that illustrates the fractal patterns? I didn't see any in the article or with a quick google search.
- DanBC 9y agoFractal doesn't appear in the paper. I'm not sure where phys.org gets the word fractal from. Here's some figures which might help with satellite image searches. http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2017/05/31/1605369114.figures-only http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2017/05/31/1605369114.figu...
- ggrothendieck 9y agoThere is an agent-based model of Balinese irrigation written in NetLogo here: https://www.openabm.org/model/2221/version/3/view https://www.openabm.org/model/2221/version/3/view