3 ms·
How are they making so much less money than Uber? Simply by paying drivers more? Because if they don't have things like booking, pre-paying via apps etc then o
by alkonaut 9y ago
How are they making so much less money than Uber? Simply by paying drivers more?
Because if they don't have things like booking, pre-paying via apps etc then of course they are losing business - but in that case why don't they?
I don't use Uber over taxis simply because I can get the exact same service from a taxi, but the drivers are better off in terms of pay and schedule (as far as I know).
- shapov 9y agoI don't use Uber over taxis simply because I can get the exact same service from a taxi That's just not true. Just off the top of my head: * 3-4 clicks and I have an Uber on its way vs. Having to talk to a dispatcher. Time saved. * I know ahead of time how much the fair will be vs. at the end of the ride. * I simply get out of the car once I reach my destination. I don't have to deal with paying, calculating tip, etc... * Uber cars tend to be newer and in much better condition. Now, I am not advocating for Uber, but lets not kid ourselves that the two experiences are even comparable from the customer's point of view.
- alkonaut 9y agoI'm talking about where I get a cab where there is app dispatch+ (pre) payment. And no medallions. Obviously taxi companies that still operate like it's 1990 are going to go extinct - my question was why are they operating like it's 1990?
- brianwawok 9y agoAs a monopoly, you usually have no reason to change. You make piles of money with no extra work, why innovate? Uber/Lyft is eating their lunch. Now they need to innovate or die. Very likely they die at this point.
- alkonaut 9y ago> As a monopoly, you usually have no reason to change. But they don't have a monopoly and haven't for several years. I mean changing from phone dispatch to apps has to be done in 6-12 months not 6-12 years otherwise yes they will go under. So what you are saying is that they are too slow to change? What's the reason for that? Is it that the taxi operators are small businesses and they are a too diverse group to be willing to take large risks/investmentst together such as for improving their common dispatch? In that case - the system is almost a perfect storm. So would you agree that at challenges to traditional taxi in medallion-cities include: - Small taxi companies (single car to maybe 100 cars) rather than large operators (1000 cars or more) that would have the money to evolve when needed - Expensive medallions causing overhead compared to Uber/Lyft - Long history of monopoly causing an unfamiliarity with rapid changes - (Possibly) regulative hurdles to overcome before you could e.g. pre-charge for a ride or dispatch with an app rather than phone?
- weberc2 9y ago> I mean changing from phone dispatch to apps has to be done in 6-12 months not 6-12 years otherwise yes they will go under. I think you underestimate the amount of work involved in building a rideshare platform. How are taxi companies going to consolidate and find app developers to build a platform to compete with Lyft and Uber in a tiny fraction of the time, not to mention getting the word out about their platform, when Uber and Lyft are already so good (and cheap). This is to say nothing about disparities in investment and regulation.
- alkonaut 9y agoI mostly have experience of taxi apps from where I live (Stockholm) and basically when one operator had an app, then suddenly all the major companies had apps. The difference is obviously that there are numerous taxi companies (There used to be one monopoly but at that time there were no smartphones) and the big ones are pretty big, like a 1000+ cars each. The apps obviously look almost the same and it wouldn't surprise me if they came from the same developer in many cases. Here are four of the largest for comparison: https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/sverigetaxi/id504540989?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/sverigetaxi/id504540989?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-sthlm/id375988670?l=en&mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-sthlm/id375988670?l=en&... https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-020/id503115316?l=en&mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-020/id503115316?l=en&mt... https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-kurir/id503098740?l=en&mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/se/app/taxi-kurir/id503098740?l=en&... You can see the last 3 just use a skinned standard taxi dispatch app! I appreciate the effort of creating the platform from scratch, but a taxi company shouldn't have to do that. They just license the app. These taxi companies each had dispatches with many dozens of operators, so they save a good amount of money on using an app and cutting back on people) No difference from other commerce. The main difference between Stockholm and Chicago is of course that the "taxi companies" are the large city or nationwide companies battling for market share. A taxi driver or group of drivers can also be a "company" but they just operate under the umbrella of the larger brand - who handles all dispatch, branding etc just like a city wide monopoly usually does. So while it's understandable that a company unlike a monopoly has more incentive to evolve, I don't see any reason why a city taxi monopoly such as Chicago couldn't just make their product more similar to Ubers (regulations aside). I mean - they must also be able to save a ton by getting rid of phone dispatch staff. And anyone with a medallion obviously has an interest in their services not becoming obsolete.
- kasey_junk 9y agoThey have much higher legislative hurdles to overcome?
- alkonaut 9y agoWould they need to pass red tape to have their customers hail with an app rather than call a dispatcher? Sounds like the medallion system isn't the only thing wrong here.
- kasey_junk 9y agoThey have an app. It's also more regulated. Taxis are also horrible so I'm not convinced they could compete in any case but it's not a fair playing field. My bet though is on Lyft/Uber becoming just as horrible once the VC money dries up. It will be interesting to see what legislation will arise between then & now.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoTaxi medallions were being sold for $300k three years ago. Taxis likely didn't buy with cash, but rather financed them, leading to significantly higher operational expenses.
- alkonaut 9y agoYeah but don't those medallion prices tank now, so anyone who got one recently doesn't have that overhead? Obviously those who bought into the pyramid ponzi scheme at the wrong point will go under. The use of medallions where it still exists needs to die - but what better time than when prices reach bottom?
- thephyber 9y ago> so anyone who got one recently doesn't have that overhead If you were a lender and you are aware that the medallion market hasn't bottomed, would you lend $200k-300k? Probably only if the down payment was very significant. The article states that foreclosures on medallions are increasing, so the market hasn't capitulated.
- tlogan 9y agoI do not know about you but I have very low requirement: I just want that when I take my wife on a date to use transportation which does not smell bad and it is not dirty. Nothing else. So I have to chose Lyft or Uber.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI'm curious, is buying a car out of the question? I also face the same problem when going out with my wife and hate hailing taxis on the road. Uber is just so much better, I am even ready to pay more than what they are asking. But every few weeks I think about buying a small car, so I don't have to depend on Uber.